69 million page views

Tablighee twists and turns

Reader comment on item: Pope Benedict XVI and the Koran
in response to reader comment: Earth is round as accepted by all

Submitted by dhimmi no more (United States), Feb 23, 2015 at 08:08

For the readers notice that our dear Nasr ignores parts of my comments when he has no answer and he hopes that I will not notice right our dear Nasr?

I asked him

[[Our dear Nasr does not seem to be aware that a Saudi Sheikh is telling us that the sun orbits earth. Oh you do not believe me here is the articlehttp://english.alarabiya.net/en/variety/2015/02/16/Saudi-cleric-Sun-revolves-around-stationary-Earth.htmlWhat a disaster and he is not wrong because this is what the Qur'an says that the earth is stationary and the sun runs in an orbit around earthNow go and tell him that he is wrong]]

And this is his answer

Well, that is the opinions the Saudi Sheikh from 50-60 years ago whom you quote, whom was using a source from 11th century.

You did not read the article right? Hint: This ignorant Saudi Sheikh uttered this nonsense this past week

Now you tell me why did you not read the article?

But you dont see the opinion being the same now as the movement of Sun has been made clear.

What movment of the sun? Oh that Bin Baz said that the sun rotates around itself? So does the sun rotate around itself?

Turkey change their solar system from geocentric to heliocentric

Could it be because using the lunar calendar as your Allah orders is idiotic and useless?

and there is no issue since the Quran and hadith did not say specifically about appointed course of Sun by Creator in specific.

How about your Allah's ranting in Q9:37?

Oh the creator: 25% of pregnanies end in abortion because of malformations incompatible with life and you tell us that he is a real creator?

But wait the Qur'an says that Jesus created life which means that he must be God and non of the birds that he created died this means that he is a superior creator when compared with Allah

No trial made by scholars for transition of solar system made.

So? Hint: because even pious Muslims realize that the lunar calendar is useless

As in Islam there is no such thing as Holy Spirit teaching scientific facts towards scholars

Well let us see the holy spirit in Islam is Gabriel right? and he is the one that told prophet Quthm akaq Muahmmad that the earth is flat right? See? sometime silence is golden do you get it?

And so the same applies to Saudi Arabia after the prince of Saudi went to space. The sheikh no longer deny دوران الارض or

Where? You did not read the link from his web site right? He never denied that the earth is stationary he only said that the sun rotates around itself as you can see in the new video by the Saudi Sheikh that you did not even watch! Why the twsits and turns tell me

Then I asked

[[Was Hinduism and was Buddhism the religions of your ancestors part of these "covenants"? And if not then how come your Allah has no clue about neither Hinduism nor Buddhism?]]

And this is his answer

Any religion that worship the Creator came from the same root that is to worship unique and one singular Creator. However innovations have taken place and you see them making partners or equals to Creator.

You did not answer my question how come your Allah is silent about the religions of your ancestors?

Then I asked

[[They do not count right? This means that Allah is only a Semitic deity and he has no clue about India or Malaysia right? Thank you for proving my point]]

And this is his answer

Thats is why you need to study Israelite scripture.

Why should you or I study "Israelite scripture" after all your so called Allah says that the Jews corrupted their books? And if I read them would i find any mention of the religions of your ancestors?

The Creator says the semitic Arab will proclaim His religion for all mankind.

Then you tell me why would not select your ancestors? and how about Q14:4 where your so called Allah (which is by the way a laon word from Syriac) that islam is the religion of the Arabs only? would you like to know more?

And where does it say in the Qur'an that islam is the religion for all of mankind? Hint: The Qur'an says that Islam must be the religion of the Arabs only

In the past covenants were given to regions as Islam is for whole globe.Then

Then how about Q14:4?

Then I asked

[[Really? so your Allah is the ethnic God of the Jews? Says who?]]

And this is his answer

Not just Jews, God of Abraham, Noah, Adam *father of all races). The same one unique God.

Evidence? Hint: because the Qur'an says so will not be accepted as evidence!

Then I asked

[[You did not answer my question so let me ask you again: How come your Allah is silent about your Hindu ancestors? And why was the Qur'an not revealed in let us say Urdu? Well if it was revealed in Urdu then Arabs would have to learn Urdu right? so why was it not revealed in Urdu? why do you regard your ancestors and your mother tongue as inferior to the Arabs and their language?]]

And this is his answer

It has been answered as covenant for mankind sent by Creator will be in new song, new language that is Arab. Ths has been decreed.

I see you do not have an answer but why did Allah not select your people in Malaysia? Any guesses? Could it be because your Allah is an Arab?

Then I asked

[[Well if we read al-Qurtubi's tafseer it says that the word قضى is really a mistake as per no other than Ibn Abbas and in his Mushaf the word قضى is ووصى and very different word then al-Qurtubi that it is due to the fact that it was misread as قضى oh you do not believe me? Here is al-Qurtubi explaining this disaster]]

And this is his answer

Tafseers is talking about variant readings of Quran.

Then we have more than one Qur'an so which one is the correct Qur'an? Any guesses? but most damaging to your case if we have "variant readings" of the Qur'an then which reading one would find in Allah's al-lawh al-Mahfuz? The Caior Qur'an or the Tunisian Qur'an and they are not the same? Enlighten me please!

And this is his answer

Do you not know?

Oh I'm waiting for this one

If they write their opinion of other word being used. How is it edited/corrupted?

Then we really do not know what the Qur'an says and more evidence that the claim that the Qur'an was memorized by early Muslims is a big fat lie! Thank you for proving my point

And here is your bonus question: so which word would we find in Allah's little al-lawh al-mahfuz and it cannot be both unless we have more than one so do we have more than one Lawh mahfuz?

Then I aksed

[[How come you did not know that? Let me guess because you cannot read the Arabic right? and here is the article from his web sitehttp://www.binbaz.org.sa/mat/8640]]

And this is his answer

That is the opinions the Saudi Sheikh from 50-60 years did he correct it? Read http://www.binbaz.org.sa/mat/18030

Then send an e-mail to the web site and tell them that Bin Baz was wrong and let us see what they will say! Hint: You will have a fatwa of takfeer at the blink of an eye and it would serve you right

Then I wrote

[[But here is the real disaster and this is from Bin Baz's web site and it is about an article that was published by Ahamd Baha' el-Din in the Egyptian newspaper al-Musawar that Bin Baz issued a fatwa of takfir for anyone who says that the earth is not flat and that the sun does not orbit earth and here is Bin Baz's response to this disasterhttp://www.binbaz.org.sa/mat/8570And here is a video by Bin Baz where he does not say that the earth is like a ball he only says that this Ibn al-Qayyim says it is like a ball but he does not provide reference which means that he is either a liar or he is making things up then he ends the video by saying but the earth must be flat! What a disaster https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kXFObsF2K_U]]

And this is his answer

That is the opinions the Saudi Sheikh from 50-60 years did he correct it? Read http://www.binbaz.org.sa/mat/18030

Did you read what is posted in the web site? Why the lies?

Then i asked

[[Let me help you again the correct word in Arabic has an alif following the letter hah your Allah could not even spell a perfect Arabic word]]

Look closely. quran.com/79/30 Can you not see? Thats why you need to understand recitation and tajweed

How many times do I have to tell you that your Allah could not spell a perfect Arabic word like Dahaha and this is why al-mufasereen added the alif and your claim that it is because of recitation which is a bogus claim it still means that al-mufasereen added an alif which means that the Que'an is a corrupted book

Then I wrote

[[Big time issue because adding an alif CHANGES THE MEANING OF THE WORD and the word Maaliki means the owner of and the word Maliki means the King of so is it Maalki or is it Malki and it cannot be bothHow come you did not know that?]]

And this is his answer

And so you shall check http://quran.com/1/4 as been post before. There is an aleph. Learn tajweed

Bogus so you tell me is it maaliki or is it maliki?

Then i asked

[[Wrong again if the Qur'an was indeed memorized then we would have had either Maalki as you will find in the Cairo Qur'an or Maliki as you will find in the Tunisian Qur'anThe bogus claim that the Qur'an was memorized is a bogus claim]]

And this is his answer

That is why you have tajweed set of rules for proper pronunciation and recital. Do you not know?

Then prove it to me and only Kutub al-Mufasereen will be used as evidence! And provide the evidence in Arabic! As a matter of fact this was a big deal for al-mufasereen and how come you did not know that?

Then I wrote

[[And al-Qayyim is not one of them]]

And this is his answer

How are you certain?

Mr and you must pardon me I provided you with the quote from his book Oh I forgot you cannot read Arabic right?

Abu Ya'la in his work Tabaqatal-Hanabilah (Biographical Entries of the Hanabali Scholars) quotes the unanimous consensus (ijma) of all Muslim scholars that the earth is round in 10th century.

Oh you gave up on al-Qayyim right? then provide me with the Arabic text or shut up

Spherical earth was notion among the scholars in 12th century. "Fakr Al Razi" pointed to the Sphericity of the earth in his clarifying book "Mafatih Alkaib"

Evidence? IN ARABIC!

And it is al-Ghiab!

For better clarification, readhttp://www.speed-light.info/miracles_of_quran/earth.htm

No I read primary sources in Arabic only!

Then I asked him

[[I will leave this to the readers to judge you and leave islam and be free from all of this nonsenseWhat a disaster the author of the Qur'an says that the earth is flat and fools believe it]]

And this is his answer

The Quran never says it is flat.

How about Q79:30?

Thats why you have scholars in 12th century saying earth is spherical. While if some say earth is flat. That is due to the philosophy of that period.

Evidence in Arabic!

It is for the readers to judge shall your points be taken seriously or not.

Again I will let the readers to judge you and judge your poor education and uncritical thinking

As most of them are merely toying with arab words.

But you can prove me wrong go for it!

Leave islam and be free

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to Tablighee twists and turns by dhimmi no more

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List
eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2020 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)