1 readers online now  |  69 million page views

The tight connection between Islam and Marxism

Reader comment on item: Pope Benedict Criticizes Islam [in Regensburg]
in response to reader comment: Interesting comments... but

Submitted by Ed Melik (United States), Sep 28, 2006 at 03:36


I think your comments need a bit check of reality. I don't know about you but I have lived and worked in the former Soviet Union and I have pretty good knowledge of the Russian Islam. I have visited Uzbekistan whose capital was and still is Tashkent and visited the historical cities like Bukhara, Samarkand etc. Before the Bolshevik revolution and thereafter no religions were allowed specially Islam. Islam was one of the religion is very rigidly monotheist religion that has its entire roots and historical connections with Judeo Christian teachings. If you check about the chronology of Islamic Prophets, you'll be shocked to find out that each and every Prophet of Islam is the same as of Judaism and Christianity. So it's a total fallacy to even remotely connect Islam with Marxism. If you have to look at the right perspective about Marxism regardless of which religious groups sided or help create and promote Marxism then no one can touch the Soviet Jews.

During the time Vladimir Lenin was the Founder and dictator of the Soviet Union, Joseph Stalin had worked himself into the position of General Secretary of the Central Committee. He was greatly assisted in this by the Jews Lev Kamenev (real name Rosenfeld) leading member of the Politburo and Grigori Zinoviev (real name Apfelbaum) head of the Petrograd soviet. In 1925. As a matter of fact history's archives are filled with tens of thousands of pages reflecting the contribution of Jews to Marxism than any other group in Russia. For example: The American Army Intelligence Service had its agents in Russia at the time of the Communist Revolution, and the Jewish nature of that revolution is accurately reflected in those reports.

An American Senate subcommittee investigation into the Russian Revolution heard evidence, put on congressional record, that "(I)n December 1919, under the presidency of a man named Apfelbaum (Zinovieff) . . . out of the 388 members of the Bolshevik central government, only 16 happened to be real Russians, and all the rest (with the exception of a Negro from the U.S.) were Jews" (U.S. Senate Document 62, 1919).

However, none of these authorities quoted above dared to use quite the language of a US Military Intelligence officer, one captain Montgomery Schuyler, who sent two reports to Washington in March and June 1919, describing in graphic detail the Jewish role in the Russian Revolution. Both these reports were only declassified in September 1957 and the originals are still held in the US National Archives in Washington, open for public inspection.

The first report, sent from Omsk on 1 March 1919, contains the following paragraph:

"it is probably unwise to say this loudly in the United States but the Bolshevik movement is and has been since its beginning, guided and controlled by Russian Jews of the greasiest type..."

The second report, dated 9 June 1919, and sent from Vladivostok, said that of the

"384 commissars there were 2 Negroes, 13 Russians, 15 Chinamen, 22 Armenians and more than 300 Jews. Of the latter number 264 had come to Russia from the United States since the downfall of the Imperial Government."

Not one document points such connection with any Muslims in Russia. The reason? Simply that Islamic teaching is totally opposite to Marxism. Islam and Marxism can never exist together due to theological teachings of Islam. Vladimir Ilichiya Lennon once said "Islam and Marxism is like oil and water... they can never mix".

Jews were also behind the American Communist Party, which although politically unsuccessful, was very successful in its espionage and infiltration activities, eventually reaching right into the Civil Rights Movement and that group's leader, Martin Luther King.

According to the Encyclopedia Judaica, published in Jerusalem, Israel (1971), page 804 (extract below) "the list of Jews who played a prominent role in the leadership and factional infighting of the American Communist Party is a long one . . .Many American Jewish authors and intellectuals, some of whom later recanted, were active in editing Communist publications and spreading party propaganda . . among them Micheal Gold, Howard Fast and Bertram Wolfe."

Many of the Soviet spies arrested by the American government during the Cold War have been Jewish, and none have been more damaging than the group of spies who passed the secret of the Atom Bomb to the Soviet Union.

This group of Communist spies was all Jewish, from the ringleaders, Julius and Ethel Rosenberg, to the actual scientists working at the top secret Los Alamos laboratory, namely David Greenglass and Theodore Hallsberg. The latter actually passed the atomic secrets to the Rosenbergs, who then passed it onto their Soviet handlers, via their Jewish courier, Harry Gold. Not a single Muslim was ever remotely connected to any communist/Marxists activities in the United States. Wonder why?

As far as Hitler and his connection with the Muslims world is concerned, it was practically zero. However, the creation of Hitler and his socialist party was exclusively done by the Jews of Germanys.

In 1919 Anton Drexler, Gottfried Feder and Dietrich Eckart formed the German Worker's Party (GPW) in Munich. The German Army was worried that it was a left-wing revolutionary group and sent Adolf Hitler, one of its education officers, to spy on the organization. Hitler discovered that the party's political ideas were similar to his own. He approved of Drexler's German nationalism and anti-Semitism but was unimpressed with the way the party was organized. Although there as a spy, Hitler could not restrain himself when a member made a point he disagreed with, and he stood up and made a passionate speech on the subject.

Anton Drexler was impressed with Hitler's abilities as an orator and invited him to join the party. At first Hitler was reluctant, but urged on by his commanding officer, Captain Karl Mayr, he eventually agreed. He was only the fifty-fourth person to join the German Worker's Party. Hitler was immediately asked to join the executive committee and was later appointed the party's propaganda manager.

In the next few weeks Hitler brought several members of his army into the party, including one of his commanding officers, Captain Ernst Roehm. The arrival of Roehm was an important development as he had access to the army political fund and was able to transfer some of the money into the GWP.

The German Worker's Party used some of this money to advertise their meetings. Adolf Hitler was often the main speaker and it was during this period that he developed the techniques that made him into such a persuasive orator.

One should read "Bryan Mark Rigg. Hitler's Jewish Soldiers: The Untold Story of Nazi Racial Laws and Men of Jewish Descent in the German Military. Modern War Studies Series. Lawrence: University Press of Kansas, 2002. xxi + 433 pp. Index..

So far in any pre or post-Hitler era no Muslim-Marxists existed. Muslims as a matter of fact were always persecuted due to their monotheist faith.

As far as Putin is concerned, I guess facts speak for itself of how pro-Muslim Putin is. In case you have not heard of Chechnya... this speaks volume about Putin and his love of Muslims of the former Soviet Union.

You say "Muslim Brotherhood has tentacles that stretch back to Nazi Germany". How and where did you find any documents on this information? You continue with your remarks by saying "The Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, during the second World War was a known ally of Adolf Hitler. I am sure that a very strong link can be made between Nazi Germany and Islamofacism". What made you so sure that these remarks make Islam a partner of Marxism and Hitler?

Here are some verifiable historical facts for you to ponder on:


GUARDIAN - George Bush's grandfather, the late US senator Prescott Bush, was a director and shareholder of companies that profited from their involvement with the financial backers of Nazi Germany. The Guardian has obtained confirmation from newly discovered files in the US National Archives that a firm of which Prescott Bush was a director was involved with the financial architects of Nazism. His business dealings. . continued until his company's assets were seized in 1942 under the Trading with the Enemy Act. The evidence has also prompted one former US Nazi war crimes prosecutor to argue that the late senator's action should have been grounds for prosecution for giving aid and comfort to the enemy. . .

The new documents . . show that even after America had entered the war and when there was already significant information about the Nazis' plans and policies, he worked for and profited from companies closely involved with the very German businesses that financed Hitler's rise to power. It has also been suggested that the money he made from these dealings helped to establish the Bush family fortune and set up its political dynasty. . .

NEWSWEEK [POLISH EDITION] - Prescott Sheldon Bush, grandfather of George Walker Bush, had financial dealings during World War II with the Nazis, amassing a family fortune as a banker. Prescott Bush was a shareholder of the company United Banking Corporation, working with industrialist Fritz Thyssen from the Nazistowskiego Silesian Consolidated Steel Corporation, where Auschwitz prisoners worked.

JFK's father, Joseph Kennedy, had a reputation of being pro-Nazi or at least pro-Hitler. He was U.S. Ambassador to Britain but was recalled because of his pro-Hitler viewpoint. His code clerk was Tyler Kent, which is a story in itself.

Since its publication in February, Edwin Black's book "IBM and the Holocaust: The Strategic Alliance Between Nazi Germany and America's Most Powerful Corporation"

When Hitler published Mein Kampf in 1924, he held up a foreign law as a model for his program of racial purification: The U.S. Immigration Restriction Act of 1924, which prohibited the immigration of those with hereditary illnesses and entire ethnic groups. When the Nazis took power in 1933, they installed a program of eugenics--the attempted "improvement" of the population through forced sterilization and marriage controls--that consciously drew on the U.S. example. By then, many American states had long had compulsory sterilization laws for "defectives," upheld by the Supreme Court in 1927. Small wonder that the Nazi laws led one eugenics activist in Virginia to complain, "The Germans are beating us at our own game."

The contribution made by American capitalism to German war preparations before 1940 can only be described as phenomenal. It was certainly crucial to German military capabilities. For instance, in 1934 Germany produced domestically only 300,000 tons of natural petroleum products and less than 800,000 tons of synthetic gasoline; the balance was imported. Yet, ten years later in World War II, after transfer of the Standard Oil of New Jersey hydrogenation patents and technology to I. G. Farben (used to produce synthetic gasoline from coal), Germany produced about 6 1/2 million tons of oil — of which 85 percent (5 1/2 million tons) was synthetic oil using the Standard Oil hydrogenation process. Moreover, the control of synthetic oil output in Germany was held by the I. G. Farben subsidiary, Braunkohle-Benzin A. G., and this Farben cartel itself was created in 1926 with Wall Street financial assistance.

If you study the real connection to Hitler, Lennon, Stalin, and others you will not find any Muslims. Why do you think its if? Despite the facts there have been Muslims scientists, writers, professors, engineers, and statesmen but none of them every got bear Hitler and Stalin.

Adolf Hitler & Christian Nationalism:
A popular image of the Nazis is that they were fundamentally anti-Christian while devout Christians were anti-Nazi. The truth is that German Christians supported the Nazis because they believed that Adolf Hitler was a gift to the German people from God. German Christianity was a divinely sanctioned religious movement which combined Christian doctrine and German character in a unique and desirable manner: True Christianity was German and True German-ness was Christian" says Austin Klein of Newsletter. "

Christian anti-Semitism:
Anti-Semitism was an important aspect of the Nazi state, but the Nazis didn't invent it; instead, they drew upon centuries of Christian anti-Semitism and extensive anti-Semitic theology in Germany's Christian community. The Nazis believed that Jewishness was more than just a religion, a position which was supported by religious leaders who supplied the Nazis with baptismal and marriage records to help identify converted Jews.

Christian anti-Communism:
Anti-communism was probably more fundamental to the Nazi ideology than anti-Semitism. Many Germans were frightened of communism and saw Hitler as their Christian salvation. The communist threat appeared very real because communists had taken over Russia at the end of World War I and briefly took control in Bavaria. The Nazi party was also intensely anti-socialist, in the sense that traditional socialism was derided as atheistic and Jewish"

Nowhere there is any connection of Islam or what you labeled " Muslim Brotherhood" and "Islamofascism" with Hitler or Stalin. As a matter of fact it's on the contrary toward your comment"If one was being literal towards the Word of God, then Marxism itself is incompatible with both Judaism and Christianity".

I think you should undertake a serious study into the history of facts. I have given but a very few examples of so called "Judeo-Christian" harmony on the subject of Hitler and Stalin.

Keep the constructive research and its criticism going for it certainly is very educational, at least for me.




Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to The tight connection between Islam and Marxism by Ed Melik

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List
eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2021 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)