ı give in
Reader comment on item: Does Turkey Still Belong in NATO?
Submitted by berk akk (Turkey), May 14, 2009 at 04:23
"What a shift in tactics ! A while ago [Apr 22, 2009 at 14:50] you wrote about me : "You seems to me well educated and researcher personal". Now you say the opposite. Have you ever suffered from memory disturbances"
I dont make tactics to you.I dont say you are not well ducated and bad searcher..But pay attention"never to trust a Turk ",Ataturkistan","Turks will never tell anything wrong about Turkey " are examples of auto generated words.There are thousands of turks who say bad about turkey.
"But what do I say "Kemal's crimes" ? If Turks jail other Turks for chewing gum during a public ceremony, what can one expect for expressing loud doubts about his alleged sanctity ? " First ,ataturk is not responsible for the arrestment of gum chewer.In all countries official ceremonies there are similiar rules.But you may not be aware of a fact.That is chewing gum not only in official ceremonies but in any serious publical actions not neceseraly be official is regarded a disrespect in turkey.This is a tradition.Not a fault of Ataturk.
"Contrary to you I build my world on external documents and resources"I am also bulding my world on external sources.what i am doing here? are not you an external source.?
"..............the Braveheart" (Scots against the English).........." Does that film a support to IRA.? a terrorist organisation? or not? I am talking about banning terror supporting...
""Without these words my crticisms would be impossible" It is posibble.No need to use such words if you can try.but you choosed your way
"What a fine Moslem apologist you are. One might think, not an enginner but a fully-fledged imam!"I am a good engineer.You asked me an explanaion about 9.29 verse.And i answered.I say finaly jews and christ are not my enemy.didnt you like this answer ? i am liar? how about my answer?
"..Ragip Zarakolu... and the other" Enmity feeding books between people should be banned in all countries. what is the goal of that books? why do they provake people? To increase fight between them?Enmity feeding is a freedom?
"Do you think I am an idiot ? Where does Allah give us kafirs any right to defend ourselves against Moslem aggression ? He demands we be true to Moslems, but forbids a Moslem to make friends with kafirs (5.51)."
I will not explain long .5.51 is again war situation suggestion .With an integrity of 5th verse ,Take a look at 5.69 for daily life ."Surely those who believe and those who are Jews and the Sabians and the Christians whoever believes in god and the last day and does good-- they shall have no fear nor shall they grieve. "Zaprawde, ci, którzy wierza, ci, którzy wyznaja judaizm, sabejczycy i chrzescijanie, ci, którzy wierza w Boga i w Dzien Ostatni i którzy czynia dobro - niech sie niczego nie obawiaja; oni nie beda zasmuceni!" "i just assume you know polish."
Remember I had told you that anatolian islamic understanding does not have enmity background.I dont know if i had succes in my explanation.Someone ermeni ,christ,jew , japan ,english who does good ,is my friend....I dont defend any islamic understanding of enmity feeding..I feel you inside does good.But that doest mean all you say is a fact like how you say ".Turkish sensitivities" ="Liars' sensitivities".But again, i could think same as you how you regard 5.51.I just wanted to take pay attention to make distinction of war situation,indivuduals at peace sitaution etc.
"I notice that you have problems with memory. Your profound knowledge of the Quran may help you to tackle the issues raised by my anwer to your insidious comment : "Insulting other religions is primitive behaviour" , won't it?" I am open to all critisim.but please words like" liers"arabian allah" are what type of critisim.?Critisms like 5.51 is not this type of course.
"We have nothing to agree upon as far as principal matters are concerned. You are a Moslem and a Turk in the full sense of both of these terms." remember 5.51 alone .same almost isnt?
"Say some bad things about Turkey (we are too often told how sweet and good she is) and I'll tell you more." say some good things 1,i will say bad things 5
"If they did , why the Turkic word for "iron" (demir) has a Chinese etymology ?" I didnt claim.i just said why not?There are many words exchanged between asians.Nobody knows demir is a chinase word. i never teached such turkish invention.iron usage was widely used all parts of world.
">court and jails for them ?<
Many in Turkey do deserve them and more ." Will you behave like a turk??? if there are potential who want to send us to jails and how will we forward spending a larger part of the inflated military budge on social and cultural programs ....?
"Ataturk said something to this effect. He even found Niagara was a Turkic word too, and so the Turks were native to America , weren't they ?" There are many words in turkish and native americans .Migration of native americans from asia is known .isnt? This is a part of homosapiens migration. There are also words used in china and in turkish.I regard this similiarities in terms of human brothership..But thats not a superrace claim.
"- factual emptiness and jingoistic Turkish arrogance ." One can't expect humanity from barbarians"T impudent claims"so brainwashed"old barbarity refined"""A Turk is a Turk just like a crocodile is a crocodile "
AFTER THIS COMMENT i have nothing to say.You finished me.I give in...........
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
Reader comments (526) on this item
Comment on this item
You can help support Daniel Pipes' work by making a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum. Daniel J. Pipes