69 million page views

Translations of this item:

en

Submit a comment on this item

Reader comments (527) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
A-Priori [120 words]SoundDocDec 20, 2008 09:16145497
2no wonder, muslims are upset [142 words]Phil GreendDec 29, 2007 23:55117103
1very appalled [138 words]saher khanOct 8, 2008 13:43117103
2Read the Hadiths [39 words]SalmanJan 3, 2010 00:12117103
4why sex scandals in churches around the world [315 words]mikeOct 19, 2010 23:12117103
mohammed [44 words]RichardMar 14, 2011 11:30117103
Little has changed [41 words]StasSep 10, 2012 00:26117103
addiction to islam [154 words]joe kafirAug 14, 2006 14:3852753
There's a drift, but it doesn't run between countries... [346 words]Farid H.May 13, 2006 15:1245523
Why most Arabs, Most Muslims are guilty. [908 words]G.A.May 12, 2006 14:3345429
Knowing the Enemy [281 words]Precious OneMar 2, 2006 18:4338699
Congratulations, For the West [47 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 28, 2006 10:4238341
To Octavio, Europe and hope [378 words]LisaFeb 27, 2006 17:5238245
1Europe and the Muslims [125 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 27, 2006 15:0638229
2Tenis vs. Tennis [543 words]RashidFeb 26, 2006 23:3938140
The problem is not Harrak, it is Militant Islam [40 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 27, 2006 14:5638140
To Rashid [207 words]faqiFeb 27, 2006 16:1638140
tenis or tennis --the proverb of the monkey- Richard or Rashid [137 words]HARRAKFeb 28, 2006 11:2138140
Representative of ISLAMIC views in this forum [125 words]Jeremy MattilFeb 28, 2006 23:2938140
Islam isnt to blame [281 words]halimaApr 19, 2006 06:1438140
Don't blame Islam? Blame Mohammed? [278 words]John BastileMay 25, 2006 12:0338140
halima you are going to hell turn back to true islam [100 words]g-dogSep 29, 2006 08:4938140
please be studious [31 words]mahbubFeb 21, 2008 09:0538140
Generalizing ??? [90 words]Linda HaslamFeb 21, 2008 11:2838140
To Harrak, GODs plans and journey with us [553 words]LisaFeb 26, 2006 15:4138093
HARRAK :Discuss Saudi Arabia's non-muslims [734 words]ForTheWestFeb 25, 2006 20:5138035
'for the west' and the mad cowboy desease and the proverb of the chicken giving an egg [389 words]HARRAKFeb 26, 2006 22:1238035
Thanks For the West [60 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 27, 2006 03:4338035
Harrak's blood pressure climbing over questions [210 words]ForTheWestFeb 27, 2006 23:5138035
Britain [16 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 25, 2006 18:1438028
Finally we agree Britain and Canada [138 words]HARRAKFeb 25, 2006 23:2438028
Liberalism [46 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 26, 2006 09:1838028
Harrak on Britain [14 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 26, 2006 16:2438028
Western culture: a contradiction in terms [254 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 25, 2006 14:3438007
I would hope for separation...but it is highly improbable and unlikely [239 words]J.S.Feb 24, 2006 15:5437930
Our way of life [85 words]faqiFeb 25, 2006 16:4737930
Different Ways to Respond to Insults [306 words]ihavejcFeb 25, 2006 18:1237930
To Harrak [150 words]LisaFeb 24, 2006 15:2437928
Lisa, no I was not answered, I bypassed the non-convincing answers out of respect [407 words]HARRAKFeb 24, 2006 20:2837928
To Harrak, God almighty journey with us and his plans to us [569 words]LisaFeb 25, 2006 16:5437928
Lisa, we agree on something at least [172 words]HARRAKFeb 26, 2006 13:2937928
To Lisa [458 words]FaqiFeb 26, 2006 14:1437928
Harrak, you make our point [151 words]RashidFeb 26, 2006 15:1837928
To Harrak: You have to clearly explain your opinion [202 words]Richard Lion heartFeb 26, 2006 15:2637928
Harrak - the good friend of Christians and Jews! [113 words]PDMFeb 26, 2006 17:4537928
To Harrak, interesting answers [495 words]LisaFeb 27, 2006 00:1037928
Thank you Richard [67 words]LisaFeb 24, 2006 12:5237916
Muslims cannot be integrated into European society [123 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 24, 2006 06:3037885
1To Octavio: immigrants who refuse to assimilate are the problem [196 words]Richard Lion heartFeb 24, 2006 16:4837885
Danger ahead !!!! [138 words]ForTheWestFeb 24, 2006 16:5137885
I don't feel guilty for the things I said [153 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 25, 2006 08:1537885
Illegal Immigration and Octavio Johanson [225 words]John Anonymous SmithFeb 25, 2006 16:4637885
I wasn't talking about Mexicans [261 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 26, 2006 07:0837885
one quibble with John Anonymous Smith [201 words]SullyFeb 26, 2006 13:0037885
For the West [116 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 26, 2006 17:4537885
Response to Octavio [201 words]John Anonymous SmithFeb 27, 2006 21:1237885
Response to sully [143 words]John Anonymous SmithFeb 27, 2006 21:4137885
To John Anonymous Smith [208 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 28, 2006 06:1037885
Response to Octavio [136 words]John Anonymous SmithMar 1, 2006 02:0937885
John Anonymous - you chose some interesting examples [168 words]SullyMar 2, 2006 00:0737885
Forget about illegals [77 words]Octavio JohansonMar 2, 2006 18:4637885
Surprised by John Anonymous Smith [90 words]Octavio JohansonMar 3, 2006 06:4037885
Really? Xenophobia? [197 words]Jeffrey HApr 23, 2006 08:2037885
Answering my friend Lisa. The translation problem theory and the bible [415 words]HARRAKFeb 23, 2006 18:5837849
To Harrak: Only seeming contradictions [649 words]Richard Lion heartFeb 24, 2006 00:4337849
Re: Octavio and Richard [56 words]HARRAKFeb 24, 2006 10:4237849
To Harrak [24 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 25, 2006 03:5137849
Bibles through history to Harrak [262 words]LisaFeb 26, 2006 00:3537849
Leave exegisis to the experts [185 words]Abdul Rahman ReijerinkMay 26, 2006 11:1237849
Reply for Nicholas and Jeremy -The parable of the flying goat- [215 words]HARRAKFeb 23, 2006 13:0537812
The insensitivity of Harrak and Amir [270 words]Richard Lion HeartFeb 23, 2006 19:0437812
Backwardist Richard the Lion's heart [194 words]HARRAKFeb 23, 2006 20:5337812
My answer to Richard the Lion Heart [163 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 24, 2006 02:1237812
Harrak the Wanna Be Imam [207 words]Another InfidelFeb 24, 2006 15:0737812
To Harrak: I guess you are calling God a murderer [205 words]Richard Lion heartFeb 24, 2006 17:1137812
is god a murderer! [84 words]HARRAKFeb 26, 2006 14:1037812
To Another Infidel on..Tennis dress [67 words]ForTheWestFeb 26, 2006 22:2637812
Each to their own [42 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 27, 2006 14:5937812
And ALL non-muslims women are forced. to.......... [99 words]Jeremy MattilFeb 23, 2006 10:0237760
ISLAM'S CONTRIBUTION TO EUROPE [130 words]Jeremy MattilFeb 23, 2006 02:0437510
Let HARRAK finish his game of "TENIS" [34 words]Jeremy MattilFeb 24, 2006 11:5137510
HARRAK lives in the FREE West !!!! [124 words]NicholasFeb 24, 2006 12:3037510
my second fardo of questions for Lisa and volunteers (view long tears) [191 words]HARRAKFeb 24, 2006 20:3637510
Harrak's Double Standards [53 words]Another InfidelFeb 25, 2006 03:5237510
To Harrak: There are no translation problems only your lack of Perspicacity [287 words]Richard Lion heartFeb 26, 2006 15:5437510
The Islamic States of Europe [77 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 26, 2006 16:2037510
Playying Tenis with women, a mature question [73 words]HARRAKFeb 27, 2006 13:2937510
god comments [30 words]HarrakFeb 27, 2006 13:3737510
To Octavio: Europeans need to go back to their Christian roots [373 words]Richard Lion heartFeb 27, 2006 14:0237510
Oh, Richard [38 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 27, 2006 17:4337510
To those who still refuse to understand [29 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 28, 2006 03:5137510
To Octavio Johnson [113 words]NicholasFeb 23, 2006 00:3837449
Reply to Nicholas [252 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 23, 2006 09:5437449
Nicholas and Octavio and the proverb of the cross-eyed [213 words]HARRAKFeb 23, 2006 15:3537449
I am happy to have no choice [112 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 24, 2006 08:5337449
Harrak ... [417 words]Jeremy MattilFeb 24, 2006 15:1637449
I feel better now! [291 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 24, 2006 17:4537449
Amir, Jizya is different than Zakat [120 words]LisaFeb 22, 2006 23:4037363
ANOTHER PROVERB FROM HARRAK regarding Aisha's question [250 words]NicholasFeb 22, 2006 22:5237330
If I want to judge Christianity ... [165 words]LisaFeb 21, 2006 17:0836855
There Is No Worry Here [34 words]AnneMFeb 23, 2006 06:3236855
Reply for: Richard Lion Heart and for Aisha/Solidarity with the USA [389 words]HARRAKFeb 21, 2006 17:0036851
To my friend Harrak re his reply to Richard and the rest [640 words]LisaFeb 21, 2006 21:0236851
To Harrak: more about Jesus [964 words]Richard the Lion heartFeb 22, 2006 00:5236851
Thank You Richard For Sharing This Scripture Based Teaching [40 words]AnneMFeb 23, 2006 06:4036851
Cartoons and Mohammed's Wedding to A'isha [732 words]In Solidarity With The USAFeb 21, 2006 15:2036816
Cartoon and Wedding [432 words]AmirFeb 21, 2006 16:2236816
3Aisha again!!!! [422 words]Bader SFeb 22, 2006 08:0636816
Kudos [6 words]RamyaMay 9, 2006 01:2236816
The Scenario Beyond Oil [305 words]Dr. Jamshid IbrahimFeb 21, 2006 13:5136796
Oil [281 words]AmirFeb 21, 2006 16:4536796
The Scenario Beyond Oil [129 words]Bader SFeb 22, 2006 09:3836796
Muslim apologies being accepted here! [355 words]RPaineFeb 21, 2006 11:0536755
sad [305 words]shazDec 18, 2007 23:0536755
You are a good person. [303 words]YnnatchkahDec 19, 2007 02:2336755
Mohammed cartoons [106 words]NicholasFeb 21, 2006 11:0136753
When is it taboo [116 words]AmirFeb 21, 2006 15:3436753
Taboo since the Muslims say they are Taboo.... [209 words]Bader SFeb 22, 2006 09:0936753
David Irving is Apples and Oranges! [94 words]Kevin MFeb 21, 2006 10:4336747
An image of terror [166 words]Curtis StoneFeb 21, 2006 03:1536668
The Bully and the Thinker [169 words]AmirFeb 21, 2006 13:1436668
CHALLENGE: Part 3..response for Aisha about the Indian Zero, Brandstetter, and Julie [415 words]HARRAKFeb 20, 2006 23:3636654
Value of ZERO [234 words]InfidelFeb 21, 2006 13:2936654
To Harrak: About Jesus [219 words]Richard Lion HeartFeb 21, 2006 13:5536654
Zero? [39 words]AmirFeb 21, 2006 16:5736654
Distorting History [431 words]LisaFeb 20, 2006 21:0136633
history [374 words]AmirFeb 21, 2006 08:5836633
To all supporters of freedom of speech [109 words]Obied KhanFeb 20, 2006 17:5836609
See A Double Standard [35 words]AnneMFeb 20, 2006 21:2036609
You are right Obied Khan [216 words]AllonehobFeb 20, 2006 22:2236609
To Obeid Khan [65 words]VijayFeb 21, 2006 08:2436609
Correction on "To all supporters of freedom of speech" [158 words]nbl957Feb 21, 2006 11:5136609
Murder of Christians in Nigeria [135 words]Richard the Lion heartFeb 20, 2006 15:4036575
1Muslims Fearful Of Growing Christian Population [115 words]AnneMFeb 20, 2006 16:4636575
Nigeria [168 words]AmirFeb 20, 2006 16:4936575
To Richard : You need to know more than title of media news [66 words]NurayFeb 20, 2006 17:0836575
Such behaviour is condemned [57 words]Bader SFeb 20, 2006 17:1936575
Not the same... [142 words]Dinesh PatelMar 16, 2006 05:3136575
Europe's Double Standards [58 words]SomeoneFeb 20, 2006 13:3736559
Massive Muslim confusion [151 words]VijayFeb 21, 2006 08:3536559
Stuck on Islam [141 words]donvanFeb 20, 2006 13:1536556
Aliens [446 words]y brandstetter MDFeb 20, 2006 12:4436552
Re:Aliens [22 words]Bader SFeb 20, 2006 17:2336552
I disagree a lot.... [62 words]bFeb 20, 2006 17:3836552
Humour [96 words]yuval brandstetter MDFeb 21, 2006 08:2636552
Ganging up [196 words]yuval brandstetter MDFeb 23, 2006 17:1136552
G_d Bless,...WHOM?! [420 words]orange yonasonFeb 20, 2006 12:4036551
Islam-killer bees, and I need a bigger flyswatter [138 words]JuliaFeb 20, 2006 02:0036444
JULIA, GIVE EXAMPLES [47 words]HARRAKFeb 20, 2006 14:3036444
Bees? [208 words]AmirFeb 20, 2006 15:3436444
To Amir: Don't be afraid of the Gospel [101 words]Richard the Lion heartFeb 20, 2006 16:4736444
Bigger flyswatter - Julia is right [34 words]faqiFeb 20, 2006 17:1636444
What About All Those Anti-Jewish Cartoons? [47 words]AnneMFeb 20, 2006 21:1036444
Examples of muslim hatred as requested [333 words]JuliaFeb 20, 2006 21:4336444
Afraid? Got to be kidding me. [542 words]AmirFeb 20, 2006 22:2336444
What about them? [44 words]AmirFeb 21, 2006 09:0236444
killer bees [170 words]AmirFeb 21, 2006 09:2236444
Resistance is futile...You will be assimilated. [49 words]Kevin MFeb 21, 2006 10:4736444
To Julia [44 words]madslamMar 8, 2010 09:4836444
Me worry? [129 words]jaimitoFeb 20, 2006 01:0636439
Mr. Pipes - Thanks [85 words]MJFeb 20, 2006 01:0336438
Cartoons [81 words]Clifford IshiiFeb 19, 2006 21:4336424
reply for: Clifford Ishii BOOKS RECOMMENDED FOR YOU [161 words]HARRAKFeb 20, 2006 10:4436424
To my dear friends Harrak, Badr and Amir [895 words]LisaFeb 19, 2006 18:0436406
Thanks Lisa, from a Muslim [137 words]Obied KhanFeb 20, 2006 00:0236406
Lisa I like the point you made- I am not pro, I am neutro [207 words]HARRAKFeb 20, 2006 10:3336406
Very good words indeed [223 words]PaulFeb 20, 2006 18:4436406
good words indeed [23 words]HARRAKFeb 20, 2006 20:5736406
Lisa my friend [131 words]Bader SFeb 21, 2006 11:4436406
Muslim contribution to European culture [42 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 24, 2006 08:1436406
CHALLENGE part 3, WHO IS GOD! the problem of translation in Middle Eastern religious thoughts [266 words]HARRAKFeb 19, 2006 16:3736385
A reply to Harrak [206 words]BruwerFeb 19, 2006 23:5636385
To Amir, Harrak, Nuray [212 words]InfidelFeb 20, 2006 02:0336385
To Brewer regarding food for thought [205 words]Bader SFeb 20, 2006 09:3236385
answering the infidel RE: the Virgins [146 words]HARRAKFeb 20, 2006 14:4436385
Paradise [295 words]AmirFeb 20, 2006 17:4736385
Reply to Bader S [359 words]BruwerFeb 21, 2006 00:5736385
Reply to Bruwer [117 words]Bader SFeb 21, 2006 05:3336385
Italy 0 - Islam 1 [402 words]ItalianFeb 19, 2006 15:1336360
To Italian : Correction Italy 0 Islam 11 [67 words]NurayFeb 19, 2006 16:0536360
i read dear Nuray [42 words]italianFeb 20, 2006 17:4836360
discuss [68 words]patemFeb 19, 2006 15:0836359
Thats the way it is.And has been. [97 words]renchFeb 19, 2006 14:3736354
The Cartoon Controversey -a Global Intifada? [725 words]Ed GordonFeb 19, 2006 14:2636352
Weak, very weak ending Mr. Gordon [297 words]Jeffrey HApr 23, 2006 09:2836352
Scandals in the Muslim and Western Media [158 words]Dr. Jamshid IbrahimFeb 19, 2006 12:1636341
Media [220 words]AmirFeb 19, 2006 15:5336341
Media, thanks to Amir, Harrak,and Nuray [187 words]Obied KhanFeb 19, 2006 23:5236341
To Obied Khan [50 words]NurayFeb 20, 2006 17:1936341
Islam Is Seeking World Domination [90 words]Mike RamirezFeb 19, 2006 07:5236324
Islam and world domination [120 words]AmirFeb 19, 2006 16:1336324
To Amir [235 words]Dinesh PatelMar 14, 2006 17:4336324
What's The Point? [504 words]orange yonasonFeb 19, 2006 01:2936295
Behavior [430 words]AmirFeb 19, 2006 17:2036295
To Orange, Why do they hate us [62 words]Obied khanFeb 20, 2006 00:3936295
"Behavior:" Savage And Remorseless [436 words]orange yonasonFeb 20, 2006 03:0436295
Defense? No defense. [300 words]JeremyFeb 19, 2006 00:1136286
To Jeremy, a Muslim point of view [434 words]Obied khanFeb 20, 2006 02:5836286
CHALLENGE: part 2, support for Lisa and answer for Richard and Grosso- [384 words]HARRAKFeb 18, 2006 20:1036271
"0, the Arabs invented" [117 words]Mordechai RamachandranFeb 19, 2006 18:4636271
Islam, The Ultimate Zero-Sum "Culture" [260 words]orange yonasonFeb 20, 2006 10:3936271
About the ZERO [136 words]HARRAKFeb 20, 2006 13:3136271
A challenge for Pat, Howard, hr and Pagan BIBLE and VIOLENCE (thanks Amir) [460 words]HARRAKFeb 18, 2006 05:5536188
To Harrack:The gospel of grace [102 words]Richard the Lion heartFeb 18, 2006 16:4936188
Support for Harrak : List of people burned as heretics [446 words]NurayFeb 18, 2006 17:0036188
No discourse [57 words]Gabriel GrossoFeb 18, 2006 17:2936188
Harrak I hear you but this time diferently [138 words]LisaFeb 18, 2006 18:4936188
To Nuray [86 words]PCMAdnessFeb 18, 2006 19:1536188
Pissing match [99 words]PaulFeb 18, 2006 19:4736188
Harrak, you have just given us the solution, The Old Testament (thank you!) [651 words]RPaineFeb 18, 2006 22:1536188
OT [251 words]AmirFeb 19, 2006 00:1036188
For Harrack, something to think about [235 words]RashidFeb 19, 2006 00:5036188
HARRAK AND AMIR: DON'T COME T0 EUROPE [50 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 19, 2006 06:2836188
4For Lisa: Example of New Testament Violence [253 words]Bader SFeb 19, 2006 08:0036188
To: Richard the Lion heart..... please explain [147 words]Bader SFeb 19, 2006 08:5136188
A challenge for Pat, Howard, hr and Pagan BIBLE and VIOLENCE (thanks Amir) [249 words]AmirFeb 19, 2006 15:2936188
Wonderful Logic [179 words]AmirFeb 19, 2006 15:4236188
To PCMAdness: Read and see how much Christianity is transformed [682 words]NurayFeb 19, 2006 15:5436188
Yes, but that is the old testament [345 words]JuliaFeb 19, 2006 16:0036188
Question to Rashid [22 words]NurayFeb 19, 2006 16:2036188
Go Home? [109 words]AmirFeb 19, 2006 17:3036188
Harrak - You Just Don't Get It [261 words]PatFeb 19, 2006 19:3136188
Harrak , the "zero" man [193 words]Aisha RehmanFeb 20, 2006 00:5936188
to Amir (and Harrak) [857 words]RashidFeb 20, 2006 01:3236188
Gabriel Malagrida († 1761) last on the list--List of people burned as heretics [28 words]BarbaraFeb 20, 2006 01:5836188
To Nuray and Harrak: The Armenian genocide [208 words]Richard the Lion heartFeb 20, 2006 02:3336188
Answer to Nuray [64 words]RashidFeb 20, 2006 08:4236188
Missionary Joins In [217 words]AmirFeb 20, 2006 15:0436188
To Bader: don't distort history [149 words]Richard the Lion heartFeb 20, 2006 15:3036188
To Amir: [316 words]Richard the Lion heartFeb 20, 2006 17:0136188
To Richard the Lion Heart: don't put words in my mouth. [330 words]Bader SFeb 20, 2006 17:0236188
Amir- re:Missionary Joins in [310 words]RashidFeb 20, 2006 18:1336188
Aisha Rehman [310 words]AmirFeb 20, 2006 18:2936188
Quote the whole article Nuray [421 words]PCMadnessFeb 20, 2006 20:3036188
Robert again [65 words]AmirFeb 20, 2006 23:0336188
Amir's outbreak on A'isha [217 words]Aisha RehmanFeb 20, 2006 23:0436188
The Good News Of Gospel Attracts Even Muslims [64 words]AnneMFeb 21, 2006 07:0636188
Rashid [126 words]AmirFeb 21, 2006 09:4936188
Harrak thinks he is the prophet!!! [393 words]Aisha RehmanFeb 21, 2006 10:0236188
Aisha Rehman Again [292 words]AmirFeb 21, 2006 10:1536188
Harrak becomes delusionary [93 words]NicholasFeb 21, 2006 10:4936188
Clarify what is old and new testament- HARRAK [577 words]LisaFeb 21, 2006 15:2136188
2To Anne, muslims converting to christianity [313 words]A.A,Feb 21, 2006 19:1136188
To Amir [205 words]PCMadnessFeb 21, 2006 20:0436188
NICHOLAS AND THE PROVERB OF THE DONKEY [94 words]HARRAKFeb 21, 2006 22:4436188
Amir: don't talk about Jesus [37 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 22, 2006 12:5736188
The Good News Of Gospel Attracts Even Muslims [63 words]AmirFeb 22, 2006 16:0036188
Converts [162 words]AmirFeb 22, 2006 17:5836188
To Amir: The coming of Global Christianity [274 words]Richard Lion heartFeb 23, 2006 19:1236188
Christians under attack [44 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 24, 2006 08:5836188
We judge Muslims with western eyes [117 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 25, 2006 13:3136188
FIGHT EURABIA APPROACHING [287 words]Infidel3Feb 25, 2006 23:0336188
your... message [184 words]AronDec 8, 2010 07:2336188
Love-Hate Relationship and Muslim Double Standards [397 words]Dr. Jamshid IbrahimFeb 18, 2006 04:3036184
psychiatric help [1068 words]AmirFeb 18, 2006 18:2236184
1To ...Dr. Jamshid Ibrahim; What the meaning of Islamic science? [159 words]NurayFeb 18, 2006 18:2436184
Amir and Harrak should go to the Middle East [13 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 19, 2006 04:1736184
Islamic science [223 words]Dr. Jamshid IbrahimFeb 19, 2006 07:4936184
Go Home [49 words]AmirFeb 19, 2006 16:0136184
Love-Hate Relationship and Muslim Double Standards [303 words]AmirFeb 19, 2006 16:4236184
to amir [246 words]PaganFeb 20, 2006 16:5236184
No doctors? [245 words]AmirFeb 20, 2006 22:4136184
Amir, the American [34 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 22, 2006 10:5936184
Is this a Serious Argument? [104 words]StasAug 13, 2012 04:4836184
To silent majority; Speak Up [115 words]Max HellerFeb 17, 2006 19:3836146
Roses of the Prophet Mohammed [188 words]NurayFeb 18, 2006 09:4636146
To Harrak and other "peaceful" muslims... [269 words]PaganFeb 17, 2006 17:1036136
To Harrak and other "peaceful" muslims... [60 words]AmirFeb 18, 2006 01:0136136
Perhaps...... [12 words]Bader SFeb 18, 2006 03:1136136
Qaradawi Condemns Violent Cartoon Protests [154 words]Obied KhanFeb 18, 2006 13:0836136
Reply to Harrak [676 words]PatFeb 17, 2006 16:4836134
Why are non-Muslims banned from Mecca [188 words]Obied KhanFeb 18, 2006 16:5736134
I respect your point of view [77 words]SullyFeb 22, 2006 09:3536134
Digging their own grave... [180 words]YovenFeb 17, 2006 16:4636132
Cause of the Muslim predicament [121 words]Robert D. KlimekFeb 17, 2006 09:4436074
Amen! [45 words]Kevin MFeb 17, 2006 14:4836074
Cause of so much rage in muslim countries at cartoons is misinformation [263 words]A.AFeb 17, 2006 17:3036074
Re:Cause of the Muslim predicament -- [145 words]Bader SFeb 18, 2006 17:3036074
Cause of the Muslim predicament [121 words]AmirFeb 19, 2006 00:2836074
Malaysia [596 words]Robert D. KlimekFeb 19, 2006 16:1936074
Robert D. Klimek [323 words]AmirFeb 20, 2006 05:1136074
Re: Malaysia [661 words]Bader SFeb 20, 2006 09:0736074
To Amir re: Robert D. Klimek [177 words]LisaFeb 20, 2006 15:3536074
Minorities [481 words]AmirFeb 20, 2006 16:3936074
A European speaks out [33 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 23, 2006 02:4636074
Octavio - Headscarves in France [161 words]SiddaFeb 23, 2006 11:0536074
Amir and multiculturalism [237 words]Octavio JohansonFeb 23, 2006 16:3536074
The Right Results [81 words]GLENN J WOJCIKFeb 17, 2006 00:0636040
There Is A Very Simple Answer [93 words]BenScoopFeb 17, 2006 10:0336040
The voice of moderate muslims and real Christians [144 words]LisaFeb 17, 2006 00:0536039
Fallout of Cartoons [154 words]Thomas Earl CannadyFeb 16, 2006 21:3036027
There may be an upside to pulling apart [338 words]Elwood AndersonFeb 16, 2006 20:5436024
Any comments regarding Islamic political Corruption [27 words]Mu'een Ud DeenFeb 16, 2006 20:2636021
Culture and Corruption... [107 words]J.S.Feb 17, 2006 18:0436021
Islamic Political Corruption [271 words]Annette HongFeb 17, 2006 20:5036021
Re: Islamic Political Corruption [567 words]Bader SFeb 18, 2006 04:1636021
more on matters of culture... [165 words]J.S.Feb 21, 2006 15:5136021
What is freedom of speech [82 words]Obied KhanFeb 16, 2006 16:5035989
Definition of Freedom of Speech [159 words]The SageFeb 17, 2006 00:5235989
Interesting...How about this, however? [33 words]Kevin MFeb 17, 2006 14:5035989
Deathly afraid of shame [79 words]Kevin MFeb 16, 2006 15:2535973
Why make an issue over BARBIE dolls??? [16 words]yosephFeb 16, 2006 14:4535966
Islam's Double Standard [209 words]PatFeb 16, 2006 13:2835958
-CORRECTION FOR PAT- [253 words]HARRAKFeb 16, 2006 18:3335958
Correction for Harrak [411 words]hrFeb 17, 2006 11:1135958
TO HARRAK [197 words]HowardFeb 17, 2006 16:3335958
Correction to the Correction for Harrak, enjoy! [319 words]HARRAKFeb 17, 2006 19:0335958
Do not bother with HARRAK [47 words]HowardFeb 17, 2006 21:4135958
Christianity's Double Standard [254 words]AmirFeb 18, 2006 01:2635958
Howard on harrak [208 words]jimmytheclawFeb 18, 2006 03:5535958
Amir [34 words]Gabriel GrossoFeb 18, 2006 17:3535958
reply [14 words]mounemJun 13, 2006 04:2535958
Religion Belongs in Mosque [152 words]Naeem DinFeb 16, 2006 11:2435938
one approach [22 words]robert aFeb 16, 2006 02:5735894
I have told you [218 words]Ramsis AlmasryFeb 16, 2006 02:4835892
Who - Which Land ? [63 words]hrFeb 16, 2006 18:1035892
hr and ENGLAND as the promised land [242 words]HARRAKFeb 17, 2006 11:4235892
what land [78 words]AmirFeb 17, 2006 15:2535892
Harrak - Wash! [487 words]hrFeb 17, 2006 16:3235892
Islam dying? [100 words]AmirFeb 18, 2006 01:1435892
The Real Fastest Growing Faith Is Christianity [44 words]AnneMFeb 18, 2006 20:4035892
Fastest Growing [238 words]AmirFeb 19, 2006 17:5235892
Christianity Growing Fast Because Of Global South, Bible Churches [112 words]AnneMFeb 20, 2006 16:3435892
Fatest Growing religions [99 words]AmirFeb 21, 2006 13:3235892
3Islam is dying! [338 words]Rick HouseMay 29, 2006 20:5235892
The death of Islam will be a tragic loss? [48 words]Terra Cotta VaseDec 8, 2012 15:0735892
Cartoon Rage or a Collective pressure tactic against Non-Muslims? [188 words]TTSFeb 16, 2006 01:3535890
Obviously true [43 words]EricFeb 16, 2006 11:0735890
So, what do we do? [229 words]Victor PurintonFeb 16, 2006 22:2035890
uncivilisation [121 words]the believerFeb 17, 2006 10:0735890
They don't care that you care that it's harming them [199 words]Tom PFeb 16, 2006 01:3435889
A wake-up pinch on the cheek for would be liberals [64 words]ZVI-HERSCHFeb 16, 2006 01:1235887
The Muslim Civil War [315 words]Morey AltmanFeb 15, 2006 16:4935843
Philly Inquirer didnt report threat of "attack" -caved to Muslims [162 words]Ben van de PolderFeb 15, 2006 16:0135833
Response to "How the Cartoon Protests Harm Muslims" [78 words]Susan KnopfFeb 15, 2006 15:5035831
Great idea [24 words]EricFeb 16, 2006 10:5035831
You are right but...... [74 words]Dr. Jamshid IbrahimFeb 16, 2006 13:0435831
Muslims Need West? [30 words]AmirFeb 16, 2006 17:1835831
We already have . . . [36 words]PloniFeb 16, 2006 18:5335831
Mutual dependency [73 words]Dr. Jamshid IbrahimFeb 17, 2006 06:3435831
american burning bush [121 words]Donald OFeb 17, 2006 22:3235831
East Asia is an option for Muslims [98 words]AmirFeb 18, 2006 01:3735831
Outlaw religion? [110 words]AmirFeb 18, 2006 16:2235831
To AMIR [24 words]ItalianFeb 19, 2006 15:1835831
Response to "How the Cartoon Protests Harm Muslims" [62 words]AmirFeb 19, 2006 18:0135831
outlaw states [128 words]Donald OFeb 25, 2006 13:0835831
Muslim Isolation [87 words]Kim KendallFeb 15, 2006 15:3335829
Mexicans? [24 words]Victor PurintonFeb 16, 2006 22:2835829
to Victor [275 words]SiddaFeb 17, 2006 12:4435829
All to the good [147 words]SullyFeb 15, 2006 15:1935827
Cartoons can get infidels killed [121 words]N.K.Feb 15, 2006 14:5035822
The meaning of "rule-of-law" [224 words]PaulFeb 15, 2006 19:4035822
To Paul [426 words]HowardFeb 16, 2006 10:4835822
Act of sailors cannot be compared to the act of the postal worker, respone to Paul [456 words]N.K.Feb 16, 2006 15:0735822
Paul, Muslims are only loyal to Allah and Mohammed [188 words]Ex- muslimFeb 16, 2006 16:3835822
To Howard [117 words]Obied KhanFeb 16, 2006 18:3335822
Response to NK and Howard [218 words]PaulFeb 16, 2006 19:5935822
Obeid, Quran allows christians and jews to live as dhimmis by paying jizya tax [240 words]AliFeb 17, 2006 12:5135822
To Ali [151 words]Obied KhanFeb 17, 2006 16:1135822
To Ali - please supply more information about India [47 words]PDMFeb 17, 2006 18:1035822
Response to PDM, Muslims in India [1462 words]AliFeb 17, 2006 23:4535822
Obeid, your knowledge of islam is sanitized, go on faithfreedom.org to learn the truth [219 words]AliFeb 18, 2006 00:1335822
To Obied, Muslim's tradition of violence [533 words]KhalafFeb 18, 2006 10:0135822
To PDM, Typo in my last post [15 words]AliFeb 18, 2006 15:2035822
Quoting bogus sources [380 words]AmirFeb 18, 2006 16:4435822
Thank you Ali - I had no idea [5 words]PDMFeb 18, 2006 18:1735822
Read bigot sites if you want to learn? [96 words]AmirFeb 19, 2006 00:4735822
Response to Amir, prove what faithfreedom.org writes is wrong [664 words]AliFeb 20, 2006 13:1635822
To Amir,Muslims attacked Iran, Egypt, Africa, India etc for jihad to spread islam and gain booty [663 words]AliFeb 20, 2006 14:4035822
3To PDM and Amir: Muslim invaders of India [2200 words]N.KhanFeb 20, 2006 15:1535822
Back to Ali [122 words]AmirFeb 21, 2006 10:4735822
To Ali [319 words]AmirFeb 21, 2006 11:1635822
Back to Amir,nazis were not ex-jews, faithfreedom.org is an ex-muslim website [129 words]AliFeb 21, 2006 17:0835822
To, Amir: faithfreedom.org is an ex-muslim website, not a nazi website [324 words]AliFeb 21, 2006 17:4535822
To N. Khan: Please write about Invasion of Sind from a muslim source [23 words]AliFeb 21, 2006 17:5635822
to Ali [213 words]AmirFeb 21, 2006 21:0435822
What Muslim Source? [85 words]AmirFeb 21, 2006 21:1835822
To Amir ref to Ali. [159 words]M. al-ContentFeb 22, 2006 19:4535822
To Amir:What is so surprising about muslim invaders killing millions of hindus ? [139 words]DavidMar 9, 2006 19:1535822
acceptability [148 words]t.v.seshadriDec 4, 2009 08:4335822
name [4 words]k.l.Jun 3, 2010 21:2335822
THE REAL LOSERS and the possibility of Nuclear war [266 words]HARRAKFeb 15, 2006 14:2835820
Islamic Nuclear War? [83 words]GaryFeb 15, 2006 23:5535820
I hope CNN gets it all on tape! [6 words]PDMFeb 16, 2006 06:1235820
to Gary - nuclear Iran [203 words]SiddaFeb 16, 2006 09:0935820
Iran Vr USA war scenario -Gary [198 words]HARRAKFeb 16, 2006 10:5935820
THAT IS A TOTALLY UNTRUE ARTICLE WRITTEN BY A 3RD GRADER [229 words]ManukFeb 21, 2006 21:4635820
Muslims destroying their own countries [912 words]AliFeb 15, 2006 13:3835815
GOOD EXCUSE [145 words]Gabriel GrossoFeb 15, 2006 13:3235814
Illegal Immigration? [27 words]AmirFeb 16, 2006 05:2235814
Immigration and the Democratic Political Process. [392 words]Janet AnnFeb 16, 2006 16:4835814
Off-topic [178 words]Gabriel GrossoFeb 16, 2006 17:0435814
Dear Janet [155 words]Gabriel GrossoFeb 17, 2006 02:1135814
to Gabriel - illegal immigration [209 words]SiddaFeb 17, 2006 13:5235814
to Amir [240 words]Gabriel GrossoFeb 17, 2006 18:4935814
Illegal Immigration [82 words]AmirFeb 18, 2006 16:5435814
Gabriel - illegal immigration again [484 words]SiddaFeb 19, 2006 13:0835814
Sidda: common sense [180 words]Gabriel GrossoFeb 19, 2006 16:2135814
Arab trade [47 words]Michael CraneFeb 15, 2006 12:5435805
MICHAEL: a lesson for you on Arab dates and camels.. [179 words]HarrakFeb 15, 2006 20:0535805
Neverthless [114 words]yuval brandstetter MDFeb 16, 2006 16:5835805
Reply for Yuval brandstetter MD [40 words]HARRAKFeb 17, 2006 11:4735805
GDP Again? [80 words]AmirFeb 17, 2006 11:5335805
to Amir, Harrak and the others... [459 words]PaganFeb 18, 2006 05:2835805
Oil is not a Human Endeavour [113 words]yuval brandstetter MDFeb 19, 2006 16:1335805
Consequences for the West [40 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
AlexFeb 15, 2006 12:2035796
Cartoon protests backfiring [243 words]EricFeb 15, 2006 11:1635792
Tolerance towards overreaction? [245 words]PaulFeb 15, 2006 17:2835792
East is East and West is West [363 words]bashaFeb 15, 2006 10:4435788
SAME WAR, CHANGE IN DESTRUCTIVE POWER [170 words]YAIR DOTANFeb 15, 2006 10:0735785
Stopping global Jihad [254 words]Richard the Lion heartFeb 15, 2006 16:0635785
Re: Stopping global Jihad [111 words]Bader SFeb 16, 2006 08:0435785
To Bader: Global Jihad [163 words]Richard the Lion heartFeb 16, 2006 18:5335785
NO [12 words]Victor PurintonFeb 16, 2006 22:3135785
Lack of understanding remains [316 words]Bader SFeb 15, 2006 09:3635782
no "lack of understanding" here [184 words]PigfootFeb 15, 2006 17:4335782
Re: Lack of understanding [274 words]PaulFeb 15, 2006 18:5135782
Re: Re:Lack of understanding [377 words]Bader SFeb 16, 2006 07:0235782
The double standards are appalling... [106 words]Qwerty UiopFeb 16, 2006 07:4735782
Still on the Lack of Understanding theme [385 words]PaulFeb 16, 2006 23:0635782
Entrenched Positions [302 words]Bader SFeb 17, 2006 14:2035782
About Entrenched Positions [576 words]PaulFeb 18, 2006 15:3335782
Extremism.....and how it can be stopped [432 words]Bryan JacksonFeb 15, 2006 09:1935780
Which Muslims [573 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Abir ChaabanFeb 15, 2006 07:3135768
Thank you for your comments Abir [129 words]TimothyFeb 15, 2006 22:2235768
what kind of opinion is that ? [52 words]NimaSep 21, 2006 00:2535768
reformation is needed [171 words]Dr. Nahed HamidFeb 15, 2006 05:3835753
isolation for the good [134 words]JOHN MANITTAFeb 15, 2006 04:4735730
DESECRATION ALERT! DESECRATION ALERT! [277 words]orange yonasonFeb 15, 2006 02:4035708
Quote Of The Day [204 words]orange yonasonFeb 15, 2006 01:1935706
Orange Yonason's "quote of the day" hits it on the nail [161 words]Sadhasiv ThoratFeb 15, 2006 13:3035706
ISLAM IS THE LOSER. [162 words]BATYA DAGANFeb 14, 2006 23:1635695
Citizens of the world: the "bronze age" proponents are asking us to return to the bronze age... [258 words]PaganFeb 14, 2006 23:1035692
Modern pagan ritual [187 words]PigfootFeb 15, 2006 13:1635692
No Shari'a law in Ontario [68 words]PaulFeb 15, 2006 13:4935692
How the Cartoon Protests Harm Muslims [100 words]Steven LFeb 14, 2006 23:0335691
Denmark refuses to publish the Cartoons [79 words]Obied KhanFeb 15, 2006 12:5135691
I agree, but... [64 words]brooklynbobFeb 14, 2006 22:1835686
Muslim Isolation [341 words]Dan RusenFeb 14, 2006 21:1935683
Did you buy your burqa yet? [180 words]RicFeb 14, 2006 21:1235681
Self Inflicted Dangers to the Muslim nations [99 words]Jeanne ZangerFeb 14, 2006 20:4135676
The root causes of conflict between the west to Muslim Societies [206 words]Guy LivnatFeb 14, 2006 20:3935675
Sulh and Musalaha [138 words]M'Hamed CHETTALIFeb 15, 2006 07:3035675
Dear Mr. Livnat [98 words]HARRAKFeb 15, 2006 20:1735675
Harrak I hear you [126 words]LisaFeb 16, 2006 14:4435675
Thanks Lisa [53 words]HarrakFeb 16, 2006 17:3235675
An outrageous comparison [96 words]VermelhoFeb 14, 2006 19:4435673
Cause and Effect [112 words]Darwin BarrettFeb 14, 2006 19:3635672
Simple valid rule :Custumer is always right. [72 words]NurayFeb 14, 2006 18:1335665
"Forbidden" Images, An Update... [37 words]orange yonasonFeb 15, 2006 03:0735665
Cheap tickets for being celebrity. [136 words]NurayFeb 14, 2006 17:5835660
an experience in France [470 words]martin bertmanFeb 14, 2006 17:2035651
What to do.... [350 words]ErikFeb 14, 2006 16:4035640
What if the muslim world depend solely on China [26 words]KathyFeb 14, 2006 16:3035639
The Price of transition [131 words]Marcus JulianusFeb 15, 2006 12:3835639
Let them be harmed [21 words]Monty PogodaFeb 14, 2006 16:2435638
Islamists have no western philosophy [125 words]DayVidFeb 14, 2006 16:1635635
Keep muslims isolated [118 words]DavidFeb 14, 2006 16:1135634
Cartoons hurting muslims [228 words]Dale HarleyFeb 14, 2006 15:5735629
The one word needed to explain Muslim rage. [84 words]Benitus CaironimusFeb 15, 2006 09:0135629
I disagree with all your points [567 words]Muhammad aliFeb 14, 2006 15:5535627
Muhammad ali Vs the rogue mentality [78 words]HarrakFeb 14, 2006 17:3835627
To: Muhammad Ali [701 words]J PincusFeb 14, 2006 18:0335627
to mohammed ali [510 words]garyFeb 14, 2006 19:3135627
Literal Interpretation [218 words]PaulFeb 15, 2006 14:4935627
REPLY FOR GARY [144 words]HarrakFeb 15, 2006 15:0135627
GDP of Israel? [76 words]AmirFeb 16, 2006 05:4735627
Illiteracy/Violence/Wickedness/Koran "Satanic Words" by Salman R-It goes hand in hand [242 words]sumanFeb 28, 2006 04:2235627
Psychodynamics of the Muslim world -- an allegory [378 words]Dr RJPFeb 14, 2006 15:2135616
Seek understanding through knowledge [45 words]Robert MerrittFeb 14, 2006 14:3635604
To Robert Merritt [95 words]Kevin MFeb 14, 2006 15:2835604
re: Seek Understanding through Knowledge [135 words]JG MackFeb 14, 2006 15:3835604
HOW DO WE GET THEM (AND US) OUT OF THIS MESS? [314 words]J. Greg MackFeb 14, 2006 14:2235603
A Global Conflict Seems Inevitable [82 words]TibetFeb 15, 2006 21:4035603
Islamic scholars have an explanation [103 words]Norman WandFeb 14, 2006 14:2135602
Muslim dealings [139 words]C. CannonFeb 14, 2006 14:2035601
Once again, Daniel Pipes sees beyond the obvious. [161 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Dan HollowayFeb 14, 2006 14:2035600
Disengagement - technology transfer to Islamic regimes [104 words]michael cFeb 14, 2006 14:1635599
Muslims End Up The Biggest Losers [81 words]AnneMFeb 14, 2006 14:1235598
Chasm [81 words]Donald W. BalesFeb 14, 2006 13:5235594
Chronic Mental Disorder [238 words]Dr. Jamshid IbrahimFeb 14, 2006 13:4135593
Solutions [273 words]rickFeb 14, 2006 13:3935590
Islam is highway to modernity [213 words]M'Hamed CHETTALIFeb 14, 2006 13:2835588
this comment is hypocritical [33 words]ItalianFeb 14, 2006 15:0735588
Ah Ha Ha Ha Ha... good one! [389 words]orange yonasonFeb 14, 2006 16:0535588
Israel should hand over occupied lands? [393 words]Maggie O'HearnFeb 14, 2006 16:0635588
Never their fault [57 words]Cartoon CatFeb 14, 2006 17:1235588
You gotta be kidding? [272 words]SoapScumBuildupJul 2, 2006 18:2435588
The divide must come first [90 words]Stewart C. Jackson.Feb 14, 2006 13:2635587
The Disaster of Disengagement [180 words]Mark TylerFeb 14, 2006 13:2135586
Leverage cartoon protests to get back at the liberal media [41 words]Hari IyerFeb 14, 2006 13:1435584
The "old ways" versus the hip hop [140 words]PigfootFeb 14, 2006 13:1235583
we can only hope [187 words]DanFeb 14, 2006 13:0235580
As I read the article - the future [113 words]Frank OddersborgFeb 14, 2006 12:5235579
Do Not Agree [107 words]HarrakFeb 14, 2006 12:5135578
The Solution to Muslim's primitve squalor [77 words]Ralph C Whaley MDFeb 14, 2006 12:4635576
So, therefore, what? [26 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Lee CaryFeb 14, 2006 12:3535574
Do we need Islamic countries? [56 words]Laina Farhat-HolzmanFeb 14, 2006 12:3535573
very nicely summed up [249 words]RobFeb 14, 2006 12:0135568
NON PROGRESSIVE MUSLIMS [134 words]Tom BerkFeb 14, 2006 11:5635566
Cartoon Protests Cause Islamophobia [224 words]Gabriel GrossoFeb 14, 2006 11:5035564
Islamophobia [69 words]SiddaFeb 14, 2006 14:4835564
Dear Sidda [142 words]Gabriel GrossoFeb 14, 2006 17:3835564
Why not? [40 words]VijayFeb 14, 2006 11:4835562
What if Muslim withdrew from the rest of the world? [132 words]MohamedFeb 14, 2006 15:0635562
Your answer, Mo [28 words]Kevin MFeb 14, 2006 15:3235562
Who needs who? [97 words]SiddaFeb 14, 2006 15:5335562
RE: What if Muslim withdrew from the rest of the world? [233 words]Brad SmithFeb 14, 2006 16:0135562
To the hell with the Arab money [55 words]North AfricanFeb 14, 2006 18:2635562
Oil [22 words]Gabriel GrossoFeb 15, 2006 03:3635562
My answer [58 words]Gabriel GrossoFeb 15, 2006 11:1235562
To Mohammed [299 words]VFeb 15, 2006 11:2735562
to Gabriel [239 words]SiddaFeb 15, 2006 17:1135562
Sidda- Appeasment [57 words]Gabriel GrossoFeb 16, 2006 16:5135562
There is no Palestine [159 words]yuval brandstetter MDFeb 16, 2006 17:1735562
to Gabriel - WMD's [273 words]SiddaFeb 17, 2006 13:2935562
Dear Sidda [100 words]Gabriel GrossoFeb 17, 2006 18:5735562
to Gabriel [266 words]SiddaFeb 19, 2006 13:3335562
Iran [200 words]Gabriel GrossoFeb 19, 2006 15:5435562
Oh yeah right.... [15 words]Jeff P.Feb 21, 2006 15:0635562
last fortress [234 words]vahidMar 12, 2006 12:5135562
ISLAM'S WILL TO POWER [73 words]Howard E. CookFeb 14, 2006 11:3235561
What is the setting? [75 words]David W. LincolnFeb 14, 2006 11:3035560
Catch-22 [189 words]Kathy O'LearyFeb 14, 2006 11:2635558
Re:Catch-22 [202 words]Gabriel GrossoFeb 15, 2006 05:2135558
Cartoon protests [232 words]Gabriel GrossoFeb 14, 2006 11:1735556
Islam [36 words]Mike FayFeb 15, 2006 02:4735556

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)