Mohammed, CPA: Quoting the Koran as proof for itself does injustice to your CPA credentials
Reader comment on item: A Saudi Prince's Threat to the Obama Administration
in response to reader comment: HOLY QURAN IS NOT THE TERRORISTS BUT FOR THE HONEST & CIVILIZED PEOPLE ONLY.

Submitted by Plato (India), Feb 25, 2009 at 20:19

Mohammed, you wrote,

>>You may condemn Allah & Holy Quran but your Condemnation will not change the True Religion of God- Allah & His Last Holy Book- Quran.<<

Who told you the Koran is the last holy book???? The Koran??

>>Your God & my Allah has consolidated the Old Testament & New Testament in the Last Holy Book called Holy Quran. If you don't agree or believe my Statement, I have no Propblem with you or other people in the World.<<

What reason have you provided for us to believe you??

>>This is the Only Holy Book in its Original Form & Original Language- Arabic. There is no other Holy Book in its Original Form & Original Language.<<

How do these "facts" prove that it is from Allah??

>>Besides, the First Opening Chapter- Surah Fatiha in Holy Quran, which must be recited in Every Prayer, the next Chapter in Holy Quran was addressed to the Jews. Surah Mariam ( Mary- Mother of Jesus Christ) was one of the Chapter addressed to Christians, Virgin Mary & Jesus Christ himself.<<

Why should the Jews and Christians believe a book which abuses and curses their beliefs and blasphemes their holy personages?

009.030 YUSUFALI: The Jews call 'Uzair a son of Allah, and the Christians call Christ the son of Allah. That is a saying from their mouth; (in this) they but imitate what the unbelievers of old used to say. Allah's curse be on them: how they are deluded away from the Truth!

>>For God's sake, don't think that Holy Quran is for Muslims only but for Jews, Christians & Disbelievers as well.<<

How can this be when Allah curses the Jews and Christians? How can this be when Allah tells Muslims to fight the Christians and Jews until they believe or pay a humiliation tax?

009.029 YUSUFALI: Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued.

>>It is True that all Muslims must believe in All Prophets of God- allah starting from Adam to Noah, Abraham, David, Soloman, Moses, Jesus & Muhammad ( peace be upon them).<<

This means Muslims must believe that Noah brought down disaster on humanity by pleading with Allah to destroy the world except himself and his family. You have to believe that Abraham was willing to slit his son's throat because Allah wanted to play a cruel joke on him to test his faith. You have to believe that Solomon chatted with birds and ants. You have to believe that Moses turned sticks into snakes and split the sea. You have to believe that Jesus performed miracles like curing lepers, and that he did not die but rose to heaven. Muslims have to believe that Muhammad chatted with Allah in heaven and that he had Allah split the moon as a sign.

>> There is no more people in the World, who truly believe like Muslims.<<

True. But what does that signify?

>>Holy Quran is the Only Holy Book, which is memorized by many Million Muslims. There is no other Holy Book in the Memery of the entire Humaity.<<

Could be true, but so what??

>>Holy Quran is from God- Allah & this Book will last till the End of the World.<<

Only the people who live at the end of time will know if this claim is true or not. You have made a statement that you cannot prove.

>>God- Allah is the Sole Guarantor of this Holy Book.<<

He seems to have guaranteed only that the words will remain intact. But He forgot to ensure that everyone who reads it will gain the same understanding. The hundreds of (or 72) sects that Islam has split into shows that Allah has not been able to guarantee that the meaning of the Koran cannot be trifled with.

>>There is None in the whole World, who can challenge this Guarantee from God- Allah.<<

Modern technology can guarantee that any book, holy or unholy can be preserved exactly as first written without a comma out of place till the end of time. But even modern technology cannot guarantee that people who read them will understand it as it was meant to be understood. Just as the Koran is also understood differently by Muslim terrorists and Muslim moderates, Shias, Wahabis/Salafis, Ahmadias etc.

>>If any Human being tries to challenge God- Allah, you can not do this. This is an Open Declaration by God- Allah Himself.<<

So what is this challenge from Allah? There is only one challenge that Allah has given and that is to come up with verses similar to the Koran. Now who is going to sit in judgment on the challenging verses? Will you accept only Muslims as judges?

Also you will have noticed that Allah insists on remaining in hiding and issues challenges through an illiterate man, who claimed to have received the challenge via another invisible creature he called an angel. Who in his right mind will take this challenge seriously?

>>I don't ask you to accept my Statement but you may read this Holy Book for your Realization & Understanding.<<

I have read this 'holy' book several times and it has always left me aghast at the cruelty of Allah in roasting people for eternity for the silly crime of associating anyone with His lonely majesty.

>>Please see why the White American Priest/ Preacher, Joseph & many other Scholars/ Researchers like him became Muslim.<<

Salman Rushdi, Ibn Warraq, Taslima Nasreen are all ex-muslims and there are scores of others who are ex-muslims. But threatened with murder by their ex-brothers and sisters in Islam they choose not to flaunt their disbelief unlike the people whom you name, who can blithely quote Koranic verses abusing their ex-co-religionists without fear for their lives.

>>Please visit his Web page ... Don't close your Mind & Eyes. Please use it for your Final Destination.<<

You can find similar web sites by ex-muslims who have apostasised. People are always converting from one religion to the other.

>>Please live with your Faith & let me live with my Faith in Allah. A Day will come when we All will see the Truth.<<

After proselytizing (via the Islamic web site) you now tell us it is okay to live with our faith, with a warning rider that we will see your Truth someday.

The truth dawned on Salman Rushdi, Ayman Hirshi, Taslima Nasreen and other ex-Muslims in hiding. Soon with the help of the internet more and more Muslims are seeking and seeing the Truth.

Regards

Plato

---

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened for relevance, substance, and tone, and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome, but comments are rejected if scurrilous, off-topic, vulgar, ad hominem, or otherwise viewed as inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the Guidelines for Comments. For informational purposes, we identify countries from which comments are sent.