69 million page views

Response to Kidney not mentioned in Quran

Reader comment on item: Pope Benedict XVI and the Koran
in response to reader comment: The Qur'an says that semen comes from the kidneys!

Submitted by Nasr (Malaysia), Jan 24, 2015 at 10:02

[[Our dear Nasr who sits day in and day out reading a confused and confusing book while the Chinese, Buddhists, Christians and Hindus are busy working and without them Malaysia would be a basket case right our dear Nasr?]]

This statement does not make sense. Muslims do not work in Malaysia? Care to explain.

[[You are and you must pardon me ignorant. Premarin is a FEMALE HORMONE now you tell me what benefits a man would get from consuming premarin? Growing breasts may be?

Oh you do not believe me? here http://www.drugs.com/premarin.html

Premarin is an estogen! It is a female hormone so you tell us why would your so called prophet tell men to take premarin?]]

that is why e.g was used, to show that urine can be benificial. Simple as that. As in miracle story mentioned in hadith, it works and the travellers stole the camels. If it did not work why would they steal those camels?

[[And why do you want me to read the translation when I can read Islamic texts in Arabic? Give me one good reason and if you have no reason then and you must pardon me shut up]]

You need to read translations as your glossary of Arabs words could be limited. http://beta.quran.com/86/7 Try looking at each translation. Are they the same?

[[And your Allah is silent about the word التوحيد in the Qur'an so what?]]

read last surah. Creator is uniquely one. root word of Tauhid is one. Can you find One in Quran. Yup.. can find it Q2:133.

Try find word similar to kidney please as this is the logic you use in your argument.

[[But most damaging to your case is Allah seems to have no clue about الخصية والبروستاتا not a single word Oh الخصية والبروستاتا? ask your Mullah as I do not translate Arabic to wannabe Arabs like you]]

The region was given back to front. That covers region of seminal vesicle. No issue here.

[[مصدر الحيوان المنوي الخصية or the source of the spematozoa is the testicle! Your Allah had not clue..

مصدر الساءل المنوي الحويصلة المنوية والبروستاتا or the source of the seminal fluid is from the seminal vesicle (which is located next to the prosate far awar from your ribs) and the prostate..

Hello: your spermatozoa and your seminal fluid do not come from your kidneys but again the author of the Qur'an did not get it]]

Try rereading again, Words used are gushing fluid, and loins (lower ribs and pelvis). Again no contradiction about the region.

[[Can you provide me with the text in Arabic? Hint: you have no credibility]]

That what tafsir do. They give interpretations based on their own knowledge.

[[You did not answer my question would you allow your 9 year old daughter to marry a dirty old man of 53 with 22 wives and concubines? A yes or no answer will do...

Your logic is flawed do you get it? So would you allow your 9 year old daughter to marry a 53 year old man with 22 wives and concubines and leave al-Yahood and al-Nasara out of this!]]

If its a prophet prophesied by the Creator. Then of course it shouldnt be an issue as it will tie many warring tribes under one unity.

[[So you are saying because al-Yahood did it then what is wrong with Abul Qasim having sex with a 9 year old? Do you see why your logic is flawed?]]

Not al-Yahood, but God do not forbid marrying girls that have attained puberty.

[[Really? slavery was abolished by Islam? says who? so you tell me where does it say in the Qur'an: ان الرق في الاسلام حرام? and why did the Muslim invaders of India enslave your Hindu and Buddhists ancestors?]]

Read beta.quran.com/2/177 as to gain more rewards from Creator. One of the decree is freeing slaves. Cant blame the Kings as they accept the truth about One unique God instead of many gods working for supreme god.

[[Oh is this breast feeding of the adult? Then you tell me would you allow your wife or daughter to breast feed a 12 year old male servant? a yes or no will do..

So was Aisha lactating? Says who? You did not answer my question: Did Aisha cheat on Muhammad as the Shia tell us or are the Shia liars?..

I'm waiting for the answer..]]

Pouring milk inside a cup for 12 years old would do as it will cause the drinker having relation to the household member. No need of suckling for that would be for infants. This is simple logic.

[[If 25% of cars built by a company are defective and cannot be driven the company will go out of business your Allah is a poor creator]]

Weird comparison, who made Allah out of business since the humans existed on earth?

[[Now compare this with the silly Quranic claim that Jesus did breath life in clay birds which makes him a creator just like Allah and a far better creator because as far as we know the Qur'an does not tell us that 25% of his birds died from major malformations]]

Try rereading again those verse in Quran, you will notice the verse mentioned clearly ... by Allah's Leave / by My Permission. So its good you are admitting God is in the end perfect.


Just stating facts.

[[Let me repeat: Leave islam and get rid of the Arabs and their imperialism and be free]]

Believe in one unique Creator and be free when body starts to age as that is sign to have life on earth ended.


Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2023 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)