Daniel Pipes Mobile Edition Regular Site |
|
Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Other Languages | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List | Search |
Reader comment on item: Jihad and the Professors
in response to reader comment: Shocking
Submitted by Sean Fitzpatrick (United Kingdom), Feb 15, 2007 at 08:14
A very interesting article, and I'm astounded by the quotes from American academia, it is indeed a "scandal" as Daniel Pipes suggests.
The good news is, there's more! May I heartily recommend the following book which cites this article. I've just completed reading it and it's refreshing, and in no way is it a revisionist book - it simply states the evidence and exposes this supposedly "peaceful" religion for what it is.
Osama Bin Laden is not unique and has simply taken up the mantle of what Muslims really desire - the re-establishment of a Caliphate.
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
![]() |
![]() |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
McLarney's book appears to be obfuscated antisemitism. [122 words] | Michael S | Apr 13, 2016 10:46 | 228938 | ||
study islam with an open mind [20 words] | ahmed | Aug 20, 2008 12:37 | 137064 | ||
3 | ![]() | Democracyistheanswer | Dec 26, 2008 14:30 | 137064 | |
1 | ![]() | PE | May 9, 2011 00:02 | 137064 | |
![]() | abu | Oct 3, 2013 13:01 | 137064 | ||
![]() | Mike Conlon | Mar 24, 2016 17:45 | 137064 | ||
1 | There is no shame for an Arab to lie, steal, or murder [27 words] | Ken Besig | May 2, 2008 05:46 | 127424 | |
To attack as best defence. [174 words] | B. Williame | Apr 29, 2008 10:12 | 127163 | ||
1 | ![]() | Sameer | Sep 10, 2008 08:35 | 127163 | |
A rose by any other name . . . [72 words] | Rebecca Moulds | Apr 28, 2008 21:56 | 127124 | ||
If all you have is faith... [250 words] | justsomeguy | Sep 11, 2007 18:59 | 108595 | ||
![]() | B. Williame | Apr 29, 2008 10:18 | 108595 | ||
1 | ![]() | John | Sep 12, 2009 08:10 | 108595 | |
The Death of Islam [151 words] | Thomas Adams | Sep 8, 2007 08:44 | 108261 | ||
The Truth Hurts [63 words] | jennifer solis | Aug 24, 2007 17:22 | 106923 | ||
2 | Islam Not Compulsory [431 words] | Tony X | Mar 13, 2007 09:27 | 86133 | |
1 | ![]() | twaha ismail | Mar 28, 2007 04:08 | 86133 | |
1 | ![]() | Johan Peters | Sep 8, 2007 21:14 | 86133 | |
![]() | mark | Apr 30, 2008 08:24 | 86133 | ||
war in Iraq [143 words] | frank | Mar 5, 2007 23:15 | 80470 | ||
Moslem people tell the truth pls [105 words] | no namee | Dec 21, 2005 09:58 | 30342 | ||
![]() | User | Feb 10, 2006 07:41 | 30342 | ||
![]() | Sean Fitzpatrick | Feb 15, 2007 08:14 | 30342 | ||
![]() | Tony X | Mar 13, 2007 09:39 | 30342 | ||
![]() | Muhammad Saleem | Nov 4, 2007 06:59 | 30342 | ||
![]() | Muhammad Saleem Sa'dan Al-Lihaib | Nov 4, 2007 07:20 | 30342 | ||
![]() | Linda Haslam | May 15, 2008 11:37 | 30342 | ||
![]() | Straight_Talk_Luigi | May 25, 2008 19:42 | 30342 | ||
Please Read This [433 words] | Syed Muhammad Nizami (Pak Pride) | Dec 8, 2005 19:36 | 29678 | ||
![]() | N/A | Jan 20, 2006 20:25 | 29678 | ||
2 | ![]() | Hack Med | Dec 1, 2006 16:54 | 29678 | |
![]() | nazerine | Jul 15, 2007 08:44 | 29678 | ||
Read Sifoui and Faraj and following website for Taqiyya [372 words] | Scott from Sydney | Sep 30, 2005 08:45 | 26488 | ||
Excellent piece; and No, Paul Christopher is not right [1582 words] | Averroes | Sep 20, 2005 22:45 | 26107 | ||
Blowing Themslves Up! [69 words] | Louis Friel | Aug 24, 2005 22:08 | 25083 | ||
![]() | Tyler | Sep 17, 2006 20:39 | 25083 | ||
What A Scared AND Educated American wants to ask a Jihadist!! Please respond! [357 words] | Paul | Aug 12, 2005 15:34 | 24603 | ||
![]() | Don | Aug 13, 2005 20:22 | 24603 | ||
1 | ![]() | Jim McCollem | Apr 16, 2006 16:42 | 24603 | |
![]() | Bubba Smith | Jun 22, 2006 09:18 | 24603 | ||
![]() | abdul nazir | Sep 17, 2006 16:47 | 24603 | ||
![]() | eliXelx | Sep 20, 2006 18:23 | 24603 | ||
![]() | Haider Al-Hac-med | Dec 1, 2006 16:51 | 24603 | ||
![]() | Jim McCollem | Jan 15, 2007 19:49 | 24603 | ||
![]() | JASON IN KY. | Mar 28, 2007 09:20 | 24603 | ||
![]() | JASON | Mar 30, 2007 10:46 | 24603 | ||
![]() | Angry American | Nov 28, 2007 11:20 | 24603 | ||
![]() | Talhah | May 19, 2008 09:37 | 24603 | ||
![]() | Nomorecowards | May 23, 2017 00:43 | 24603 | ||
London Attacks [20 words] | User | Jul 17, 2005 06:11 | 23534 | ||
Dr. Taha Jabir Al-`Alawani [136 words] | Meredith | Jun 12, 2005 00:40 | 22644 | ||
Anti-Catholicism [442 words] | Robert J. | Jun 1, 2005 09:58 | 22508 | ||
1 | Clarification re Crusades [140 words] | Ruth McNulty | May 20, 2005 21:23 | 22246 | |
Islamist Terrorists are Cowardly and Weak [97 words] | Goose | Feb 23, 2005 00:54 | 20480 | ||
2 | Ask the Serbs what Jihad means [225 words] | Nick | Jan 31, 2005 14:38 | 20013 | |
![]() | R | Jul 11, 2006 16:03 | 20013 | ||
2 | Jihad is "Mein Kampf" [80 words] | Mark McMurtrey | Dec 16, 2004 17:54 | 19026 | |
![]() | Frank F. | Feb 15, 2005 13:17 | 19026 | ||
![]() | Mark McMurtrey | Apr 3, 2006 19:59 | 19026 | ||
![]() | Mark McMurtrey | Oct 4, 2006 18:17 | 19026 | ||
c'est giscart qui en est en partie responsable !! [254 words] | David | Nov 6, 2004 13:53 | 18116 | ||
Islamic extremists...living in the 14th century [178 words] | Mike Millared | Nov 4, 2004 13:35 | 18096 | ||
UBL's Interpretation of Islam [93 words] | Weldon Smith | May 11, 2004 23:05 | 15158 | ||
the world as a whole [119 words] | buzzkill | May 11, 2004 22:55 | 15157 | ||
Jihad the way I see it [154 words] | The Iraqi | Apr 24, 2004 09:18 | 14853 | ||
Religion? [106 words] | Damien | Mar 22, 2004 06:43 | 14287 | ||
With you all the way,but how can I get other Australians to read it? [49 words] | Ralph Rose | Feb 10, 2004 22:30 | 13834 | ||
If I'm a hostile non-Muslim, so be it. [31 words] | Ricky D. Calhoun | Feb 2, 2004 11:59 | 13669 | ||
![]() | alla peanut butter sandwich | Sep 14, 2006 01:50 | 13669 | ||
Reply [35 words] | Kaiser Nizamani | Jan 12, 2004 11:17 | 13305 | ||
crusades were really a counterattack against aggresion [70 words] | steve bridges retired US army officer and Historian | Jan 5, 2004 22:47 | 13148 | ||
![]() | JASON | Mar 28, 2007 09:38 | 13148 | ||
![]() | James McCollem | May 28, 2007 13:57 | 13148 | ||
The Religion of Hitler and Slobo [133 words] | noel | Jan 4, 2004 23:03 | 13102 | ||
![]() | Mark | Jan 19, 2008 14:54 | 13102 | ||
Question rather than comment [93 words] | Jerrold A. Weissman | Jan 4, 2004 13:56 | 13088 | ||
Jihad [68 words] | Sufyaan Ahmad | Nov 22, 2003 09:26 | 12265 | ||
Jihad is NOT justified [24 words] | ricky | Aug 18, 2003 19:01 | 10624 | ||
1 | Crusades, the truth! [75 words] | Bill | Aug 6, 2003 16:26 | 10464 | |
Islam is but one religion [140 words] | Abu Muhsin | Jun 5, 2003 19:28 | 9405 | ||
Jihad is not terrorism! [55 words] | Ramadan Alkhazrajy | Jun 5, 2003 19:02 | 9403 | ||
![]() | World Citizen | Mar 18, 2007 20:39 | 9403 | ||
Jihad is justified [230 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Waheed | May 16, 2003 06:58 | 9103 | ||
![]() | Ted | Jul 1, 2003 16:48 | 9103 | ||
![]() | AB | Feb 10, 2004 18:53 | 9103 | ||
![]() | kaif | Oct 6, 2007 07:34 | 9103 | ||
Prophet Jeremiah [132 words] | MWhitton | Apr 8, 2003 00:31 | 8132 | ||
Question for Islamic Religious Leaders [19 words] | Tom James | Mar 31, 2003 13:30 | 7813 | ||
One man's self-defense is another man's predilection [248 words] | Giovanni Platti | Mar 1, 2003 01:19 | 6986 | ||
![]() | Adeel Ahmed | Mar 25, 2003 03:04 | 6986 | ||
![]() | Straight_Talk_Luigi | May 25, 2008 19:48 | 6986 | ||
![]() | Straight_Talk_Luigi | May 25, 2008 19:52 | 6986 | ||
![]() | tom2000 | Feb 17, 2009 09:19 | 6986 | ||
1 | Religion is the culprit [42 words] | Neutro | Feb 1, 2003 21:47 | 6245 | |
Comment on Mr K. Ahmed's Posting [136 words] | Jamal K. | Jan 28, 2003 17:08 | 6070 | ||
Jihad is a plane full of civilians crashing into a building. [101 words] | Moti Givoni | Jan 18, 2003 21:59 | 5850 | ||
Thank you Daniel [57 words] | Peter Edgar | Jan 6, 2003 20:28 | 5529 | ||
excellent [25 words] | Paul Alkebulan, doctoral candidate in history, University of California, Berkeley | Dec 31, 2002 12:24 | 5330 | ||
Jihad and Academicians [812 words] | Jean E. Rosenfeld | Dec 27, 2002 12:25 | 5167 | ||
Clear thinking on Jihad [125 words] | A non-Moslem | Dec 25, 2002 00:48 | 5127 | ||
1 | From a Hindu - "Jihad", "Dharma", "Struggle" [190 words] | Anjali Kumar | Dec 20, 2002 11:20 | 4988 | |
True meaning of Jihad [211 words] | Mahdi | Nov 19, 2002 08:53 | 4013 | ||
Unflinching analysis [178 words] | Rick Bright | Nov 19, 2002 05:06 | 4010 | ||
Abrogating and Arogated Verses of Quran [160 words] | N. Khan | Nov 18, 2002 13:44 | 3998 | ||
What Jihad means [91 words] | Shantilal Dand | Nov 17, 2002 17:20 | 3989 | ||
1 | Dagger of Islam [74 words] | Ephraim Israel | Nov 17, 2002 07:22 | 3981 | |
1 | ![]() | Wali A Ali | Apr 22, 2007 08:40 | 3981 | |
Jihad, A Master Stroke [82 words] | Nazia K. | Nov 15, 2002 17:29 | 3949 | ||
Jihad : a blessing and a curse [364 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Katy Belanger | Nov 14, 2002 13:15 | 3911 | ||
Crusades [47 words] | FLASH91 | Nov 14, 2002 12:35 | 3910 | ||
Good work Daniel! [54 words] | Abu Musab | Nov 14, 2002 08:33 | 3904 | ||
The meaning of jihad [22 words] | Gary Newman | Nov 14, 2002 02:06 | 3897 | ||
Something To Think About [229 words] | Nan Snyder | Nov 12, 2002 16:51 | 3795 | ||
It is not about religion! [77 words] | Jacob Hatcher | Nov 11, 2002 19:52 | 3775 | ||
UBL's Links? [25 words] | PP | Nov 10, 2002 12:57 | 3759 | ||
What did the Harvard student Yasin mean by Justice? [78 words] | R. Singh | Nov 10, 2002 05:56 | 3750 | ||
![]() | Ms Smith | Jul 4, 2003 18:12 | 3750 | ||
From an Arabic speaking person [157 words] | A. Ahmado | Nov 9, 2002 04:38 | 3739 | ||
Jihad in its extreme form [238 words] | Radhakrishna Varma | Nov 9, 2002 01:46 | 3737 | ||
When investigating Islam, go to the source [596 words] | Fouzan | Nov 8, 2002 21:28 | 3733 | ||
More Jihad definitiions [69 words] | Bernard Freedman | Nov 6, 2002 05:56 | 3679 | ||
Jihad [90 words] | Bernard Freedman | Nov 6, 2002 04:32 | 3677 | ||
Alfred Morabia [16 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Jonathan Wilner | Nov 5, 2002 20:50 | 3661 | ||
Concerns about Pipes' observations [385 words] | Dr. Irfan Alladin | Nov 5, 2002 20:14 | 3660 | ||
Jihad [95 words] | Bernard Freedman | Nov 5, 2002 19:39 | 3656 | ||
The bigger the lie, the more it is accepted... [41 words] | Bernard Freedman | Nov 5, 2002 17:48 | 3647 | ||
Religious intolerance [131 words] | G. Singh | Nov 5, 2002 15:48 | 3629 | ||
A lone sane voice speaking truth through the fog of Political Correctness [33 words] | Prakash | Nov 5, 2002 12:15 | 3619 | ||
Dhimmitude Studies, Please! [158 words] | Eva | Nov 5, 2002 12:05 | 3616 | ||
Foreseeable Destruction [86 words] | "JB" in PGH | Nov 5, 2002 11:08 | 3614 | ||
Bat Ye'or [28 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Edith Shaked | Nov 5, 2002 10:26 | 3613 | ||
![]() | Excellent piece; and No, Paul Christopher is not right [1590 words] | Averroes | Nov 5, 2002 06:33 | 3607 | |
Fifty Years of Explaining Away the Evils of Our Enemies [32 words] | Jeremy Freedman | Nov 5, 2002 05:08 | 3606 | ||
Jihad in source texts [65 words] | Jon Paul | Nov 5, 2002 05:04 | 3605 | ||
"International" terrorism is an euphemism for Islamic terror [54 words] | Michael Crane | Nov 5, 2002 03:28 | 3604 | ||
A Correction [62 words] | J. Khan | Nov 4, 2002 18:45 | 3601 | ||
Calls for "Jihad" Continue in Palestine [114 words] | John Reinders | Nov 4, 2002 16:43 | 3599 | ||
Actions speak louder than words. [288 words] | Vincent Hartung | Nov 4, 2002 13:15 | 3593 | ||
Professors and breach of public trust [290 words] | Frank G. Zavisca, M.D., Ph.D. | Nov 4, 2002 12:48 | 3592 | ||
Redefining jihad [131 words] | Alan Sullivan | Nov 4, 2002 12:01 | 3589 | ||
Beauty is in the eye of the beholder [63 words] | DN | Nov 4, 2002 11:25 | 3587 | ||
New Academy [175 words] | Wes Hull | Nov 4, 2002 10:22 | 3585 | ||
Sinecured "faculty" [94 words] | Sedar | Nov 4, 2002 08:02 | 3582 | ||
Should Arab-Americans volunteer for US armed forces? [582 words] | Ted Rose | Nov 4, 2002 02:28 | 3578 | ||
![]() | TOMAS | May 13, 2014 09:56 | 3578 | ||
![]() | Politics and the Arabic Language [151 words] | George McFadden | Nov 4, 2002 01:04 | 3575 | |
Dr. Pipes, what should we do? [29 words] | James | Nov 3, 2002 17:03 | 3569 | ||
Harvard profs whitewash jihad [68 words] | Barry Wood | Nov 3, 2002 15:05 | 3565 | ||
History tells [128 words] | Jean Martin | Nov 3, 2002 14:31 | 3564 | ||
Thank You [17 words] | David Batteau | Nov 2, 2002 21:11 | 3547 | ||
Let's understand Jihad [488 words] | K Ahmed | Nov 2, 2002 21:09 | 3546 | ||
A Greatly Needed Account [93 words] | Kathleen | Nov 2, 2002 19:48 | 3542 | ||
Clueless? [208 words] | T. Helem | Nov 2, 2002 17:45 | 3539 | ||
In defense of anti-intellectualism rightfully understood [144 words] | David Thomson | Nov 2, 2002 17:24 | 3537 | ||
But, Dr. Pipes... [104 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Jim Ryan | Nov 2, 2002 16:30 | 3536 | ||
The "true" meaning of "jihad" [69 words] | S. Matthew Prastein | Nov 2, 2002 15:54 | 3534 | ||
![]() | Jihad Is What It Does [189 words] | Dr. Lee D. Cary | Nov 2, 2002 15:07 | 3531 | |
Mr. Yasin tells the truth... [108 words] | Jim Stanley | Nov 2, 2002 14:26 | 3530 | ||
Jihad and the Saudis [134 words] | Tom | Nov 2, 2002 14:19 | 3529 | ||
Jihad is mainly fighting [34 words] | GG | Nov 2, 2002 13:26 | 3527 | ||
Despite Personal Risk! [17 words] | Mike Aksman | Nov 2, 2002 12:25 | 3526 | ||
Dr. Pipes & the accurate meaning of 'Jihad' [63 words] | TW Childs | Nov 2, 2002 11:10 | 3525 | ||
Thanks for doing what you do [51 words] | John Bentley | Nov 2, 2002 09:36 | 3524 | ||
Warlike and imperialistic. [94 words] | Herb | Nov 2, 2002 08:55 | 3523 | ||
Jihad and its spread [319 words] | Joseph Goldhiemann | Nov 2, 2002 07:10 | 3521 | ||
2 | Taqiyya and the Myth of Moderate Islam [226 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Paul Christopher | Nov 2, 2002 04:15 | 3518 | |
![]() | Monty | Nov 3, 2002 04:06 | 3518 | ||
![]() | Cowboy | Nov 3, 2002 15:45 | 3518 | ||
![]() | van Chapman | Oct 23, 2006 07:36 | 3518 | ||
![]() | paul christopher | Jun 20, 2007 05:57 | 3518 | ||
Academic Jihad [190 words] | Arlinda DeAngelis | Nov 2, 2002 02:38 | 3516 | ||
Three Islamic websites worth checking [180 words] | Karsten Brasch | Nov 2, 2002 01:56 | 3515 | ||
![]() | john smith rogue, Ph.D. J.D. | Jul 7, 2003 11:59 | 3515 | ||
![]() | Fred | Feb 15, 2006 09:23 | 3515 | ||
![]() | Jim | May 26, 2006 14:11 | 3515 | ||
![]() | Rick Poland | Jun 20, 2006 14:15 | 3515 | ||
![]() | Heald Hill | Feb 11, 2007 22:23 | 3515 | ||
![]() | We Try Not To Censor | Sep 7, 2007 17:04 | 3515 | ||
![]() | CD Womack | Sep 7, 2007 19:24 | 3515 | ||
![]() | Najah | Aug 23, 2008 10:51 | 3515 | ||
![]() | William J Fisher | Sep 11, 2010 13:49 | 3515 | ||
![]() | crusader | May 7, 2011 21:56 | 3515 | ||
![]() | Courage and Truth about Jihad [239 words] | Georgia Franklin-Shutan | Nov 2, 2002 00:27 | 3511 | |
1 | ![]() | DON SULEY | Sep 23, 2006 23:10 | 3511 | |
![]() | jason | Mar 26, 2007 12:05 | 3511 | ||
Militant Islam & The Month of October [86 words] | Scott | Nov 1, 2002 23:47 | 3510 | ||
Thanks For Truthful Article [16 words] | Joshua Davis | Nov 1, 2002 23:28 | 3509 | ||
Jihad? [87 words] | Eli Starr | Nov 1, 2002 21:46 | 3506 | ||
![]() | Ken | Nov 5, 2002 15:37 | 3506 | ||
Perfect Definition [209 words] | RD | Nov 1, 2002 19:25 | 3502 | ||
Price of freedom is eternal vigilance [112 words] | WWill | Nov 1, 2002 18:52 | 3500 | ||
Identity and Reality [142 words] | Steve Saaf | Nov 1, 2002 18:14 | 3499 | ||
Jihad: Straight from the horse's mouth. [333 words] | Imran Khan | Nov 1, 2002 17:25 | 3498 | ||
Call it Jihad... or not [17 words] | George Valdshtein | Nov 1, 2002 17:11 | 3497 | ||
A cystal clear analysis and defintion of Jihad and Jihadists [61 words] | Rachterry | Nov 1, 2002 16:46 | 3496 | ||
The truth about "Jihad" [104 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | A Muslim | Nov 1, 2002 16:37 | 3495 | ||
![]() | Bravo! [29 words] | R. Delfin, Ph.D. | Nov 1, 2002 16:27 | 3494 | |
A little truth on the other side? [217 words] | Richard Boltuck | Nov 1, 2002 16:27 | 3493 | ||
![]() | Karsten Brasch | Nov 2, 2002 01:33 | 3493 | ||
![]() | Glyn Carpenter | Nov 2, 2002 22:57 | 3493 | ||
Jihad on a current Islamic web site!! [338 words] | Imran Khan | Nov 1, 2002 15:55 | 3492 | ||
![]() | Jay | Dec 29, 2005 17:43 | 3492 | ||
Why is Indonesia over 90% Muslim? [199 words] | Imran Khan | Nov 1, 2002 15:36 | 3491 | ||
![]() | Chrono | Nov 2, 2002 19:34 | 3491 | ||
![]() | John Philips | Nov 4, 2002 04:34 | 3491 | ||
![]() | Imran Khan | Nov 4, 2002 14:12 | 3491 | ||
![]() | R. Singh | Nov 10, 2002 06:13 | 3491 | ||
![]() | Billy Luftz | Aug 23, 2005 12:46 | 3491 | ||
![]() | Zoravar Singh | Sep 8, 2005 13:46 | 3491 | ||
![]() | Raju naga | Apr 20, 2007 21:22 | 3491 | ||
Analogy to Crusade is Brilliant [30 words] | David | Nov 1, 2002 14:31 | 3484 | ||
Militant Islam suffers from itself [239 words] | Sheerahkahn | Nov 1, 2002 14:17 | 3483 | ||
The truth about "jihad" [73 words] | Michael Joyce | Nov 1, 2002 14:16 | 3482 | ||
A magnum opus piece, Mr. Pipes! [37 words] | George Shapiro | Nov 1, 2002 14:15 | 3481 | ||
![]() | Inexpressable Gratitude for Dr. Pipes' Courage [335 words] | Susan | Nov 1, 2002 14:12 | 3480 | |
![]() | R S Patil | Apr 10, 2008 11:33 | 3480 | ||
Courage, Perseverance and Truth [102 words] | Cubby S. | Nov 1, 2002 13:27 | 3477 | ||
'Jihad-lite' - less filling, more tasteful [94 words] | Chuck Mundy | Nov 1, 2002 12:51 | 3476 | ||
2 | Meaning of Jihad [99 words] | David Pters | Nov 1, 2002 12:44 | 3475 | |
Jihad Sounds a lot like "Mein Kampf" [38 words] | Steven Hess | Nov 1, 2002 12:33 | 3474 | ||
1 | The truth about "jihad" [80 words] | Carey E. Stronach, Ph.D. | Nov 1, 2002 12:25 | 3473 |