4 readers online now  |  69 million page views

i thought you'd never ask

Reader comment on item: "Death to America"
in response to reader comment: I suffer no illusions

Submitted by bayezid (Bangladesh), Aug 2, 2008 at 13:35

May the ALMIGHTY bestow peace upon you. It would've been way simpler if u merely asked me questions like you have in your last response . I would've been more than happy to oblige.

But before I get down to answering your very reasonably posed questions I would like to apologize for any insults I might have thrown at you. Although I was careful not to amidst all those wrong accusations about Muhammad peace be upon him and islam, I was vexed.

1."Is it true that the Koran says, "If you pray to the Trinity, then your abode will be fire?" If it does, please explain it." ----- I would, at first, like to present before you what ALLAH HIMSELF has said in the al qur'an regarding the trinity and then get down to justifying it. O People of the Book, commit no excesses in your religion; nor say of God anything but the truth. The Messiah Jesus son of Mary was (no more than) a Messenger of God, and His Word, which He bestowed on Mary, and a Spirit proceeding from Him; so believe in God and His Messengers. Say not "Trinity": desist! It will be better for you: for God is One: Glory be to Him! (far exalted is He) above having a son. To Him belong all things in the heavens and on earth. And enough is God as a Disposer of affairs. (Qur'an 4:171) They do blaspheme who say: God is the third of three (thālith thalātha): for there is no god except One God. If they desist not from their word (of blasphemy), verily a grievous penalty will befall the blasphemers among them.(Qur'an 5:73) When God says, 'Jesus, son of Mary, did you say to people, "Take me and my mother as two gods alongside God"?' he will say, 'May you be exalted! I would never say what I had no right to say - if I had said such a thing You would have known it: You know all that is within me, though I do not know what is within You, You alone have full knowledge of things unseen (Qur'an 5:116) Man worships GOD alone naturally. It is the ONENESS, the pure INDIVISIBILITY, which stands as testament of the greatness of GOD (ALLAH). When someone imagines a trinity they are saying oh hey there guess what we did we divided GOD in 3 parts. I would like to remind you here that we are talking about the ONE GOD who is beyond all understanding and beyond all imperfections imaginable and unimaginable. How can we worship something which can fall under scrutiny, and can be actually analyzed in the same way a frog or an eel is dissected in a lab under a microscope? Can one worship such a thing? I mean worship is a devotion… a commitment and an obsession which is meaningful. It is reserved for the ONE who is unique in every sense. A being you can divide and scrutinize and observe is infinitely short of being worshipful. Another logical problem with trinity is that it stifles the infiniteness of ALLAH. Its saying that infinity has 3 parts or four parts or 10000 parts.

Anything that you can give a numeric value to is not infinite. So trinity is something which naturally goes against the idea of ALLAH. Besides… ALLAH addresses our souls here. No soul can be happy worshipping something like a being with 3 understandable parts.it can be good storytelling for, lets say, a board game of dungeons and dragons.

So it is actually a crime against ones own self. And ALLAH, needless to say, will definitely punish the wrong doers. I hope this does it but if you are not content I will try harder to explain this to you more later.

2. "Is it true that the Koran says' "If you are friend to the Christian or the Jew, then you are one also?" If this is true, no explanation is necessary." ----- ALLAH does not speak on this matter the way you have presented it. Allow me to lay some ayahs from the quran for you on this topic . O you who believe! take not for friends and protectors those who take your religion for a mockery or sport,- whether among those who received the Scripture before you, or among those who reject Faith; but remain conscious of God, if you are (truly) believers. (Quran 5:57) O YOU who have attained to faith! Do not take the Jews and the Christians for your allies: they are but allies of one another and whoever of you allies himself with them becomes, verily, one of them; behold, God does not guide people who are unjust. (Quran 5:51) .. Then is it only a part of the Book that ye believe in, and do you reject the rest? but what is the reward for those among you who behave like this but disgrace in this life? - and on the Day of Judgment they shall be consigned to the most grievous penalty. For God is not unmindful of what ye do. (Quran 2:85) what ALLAH means by friendship here is clearly an alliance of people. It is certainly not natural for people of conflicting beliefs to be helpers of each other.

But I must also warn you not to think of these ayahs as precedents for aggression against non believers by Muslims. It merely states that only a believer who believes in the ONENESS of ALLAH can be a true ally to another believer who believes in the same. Worship of GOD is at the core of every human. Great care has to be taken so as not to defile it with opposing beliefs. Muslims strictly observe the truth of the tawheed (ONENESS of GOD) which many Christians or Jews do not.

Almost all Christians believe in the trinity and the Jews go far enough to say that GOD's hands are tied. These present a less than desirable idea of the truth of ALLAH. So you tell me, how can it be possible for someone to befriend a people that believe in a distorted picture of GOD ALMIGHTY? ALLAH simply speaks of a basic fact here. And in case it might wrongly occur to you, the muslims are not !! allowed to be aggressive to jews or Christians or anybody else if they haven't been attacked first. ALLAH has forbidden it.

I present to you another ayah. As for such [of the unbelievers] as do not fight against you on account of [your] faith, and neither drive you forth from your homelands, God does not forbid you to show them kindness and to behave towards them with full equity: for, verily, God loves those who act equitably. (Quran 60:8) As I said earlier this friendship is a friendship of alliance in the sense that there is integration of two people where one may have to forgo its beliefs for the other. ALLAH also refers to those righteous jews and Christians and sabeans in the quran which must be presented. And they are as follows.

Of the people of Moses there is a section who guide and do justice in the light of truth. (Quran 7:159) Not all of them are alike: Of the People of the Book are a portion that stand (For the right): They rehearse the Signs of God all night long, and they prostrate themselves in adoration. They believe in God and the Last Day; they enjoin what is right, and forbid what is wrong; and they hasten (in emulation) in (all) good works: They are in the ranks of the righteous. (Quran 3:113-114) And there are, certainly, among the People of the Book, those who believe in God, in the revelation to you, and in the revelation to them, bowing in humility to God. They will not sell the Signs of God for a miserable gain! For them is a reward with their Lord, and God is swift in account. (Quran 3:199) Verily, those who have attained to faith [in this divine writ], as well as those who follow the Jewish faith, and the Christians, and the Sabians - all who believe in God and the Last Day and do righteous deeds-shall have their reward with their Sustainer; and no fear need they have, and neither shall they grieve. (Quran 2:62) ALLAH qualifies those Christians and sabeans and jews who believe in ALLAH alone and do not trifle with this matter, as the righteous.

I pray that these ayahs from the speech of ALLAH will stay in your memory. Please read them carefully as this might remove the negative impressions you have about the quran. Questions 3 to 7 have the same answer. These are but a number of confusing and shameful events that may have given you a bad impression of islam. Let me say that it would be understandable by me if you had no way of being acquainted with islam. But I take it that you are an American and ALLAH has given you all the world's facilities.

You could do your very own verification by picking up the quran and the sunnah. You could have very easily seen the contrast between what ALLAH said and what so called muslims today are doing by juxtaposing them together. Please do not take any offence to what I am saying but you have an abundance of libraries and ‘faster than light' internet connection speed which we third-worlders lack. Allow me to also point out that islam is not what people do. It is what they are supposed to do. Its the way of life from ALLAH which HE wished us to adopt. By we I mean human beings in general. As in all of us. U and me and everyone.

Followers of islam are the called muslims. Muslims being human can be less than desirable in their way of doing things. So yes, you will have muslims that do not live up to the expectations of ALLAH. You will have so called muslims commiting atrocities. People being gifted with that slippery thing known as free will can abuse this trust placed by ALLAH. But are they what ALLAH asks of us? Are they what the Prophet of humanity has taught us? Do we learn about blowing things up or taking hostages in the quran or in the sunnah? Definitely not !!

I am afraid you have judged islam by the irresponsible acts of some muslims or they could have been a set up by other forces trying to defame islam and muslims as a whole. This may sting you but you have to consider the possibilities. Only today…after so many days are people in America getting to know that muslims did not fly that plane on that ill fated spt11. you may not know this but documentaries even from your country have proven this fact. I request you delve deeper into that matter yourself. And I am hurt myelf to know that you were so prompt in pointing to me the evil deeds of muslims which we are not even sure about to be quite honest, but failed to see the aggression against muslims even today .

Don't forget Afghanistan. You are aggrieved for your oil tankers and these people actually lost their entire infrastructure in war with the soviets which was the brainchild of the American government. Tell me I am lying. Don't forget bosnia. Kosovo. Chechnya which does not even exist today. You are worried about your capitol hill and your air tanker, when these people actually lost their families and their cities to invading Serbians. Oh let us not forget the extermination of the muslims there either. Don't forget Palestine where the muslims invited the European jews back inside only to get kicked out of their rightfully owned lands themselves.

I want to hear you tell me I am wrong. I want you to correct me when countless old women and children are actually bulldozed into shreds becoming a part of the grotesque scenery themselves. So I think you know that it is at least a wee bit understandable when they cheer after friends of the Israelis suffer a set back. Don't you think? Don't forget iraq where Americans started the whole mess by budging in. meddling with affairs not even theirs.

I am glad saddam Hussein is out of the picture but lets not forget that if u hadn't interfered…. Countless children wouldn't have to be bombed to oblivion in their sleep. The death toll that took place in Iraq in the two gulf wars was far greater than what would've happened if Americans decided not to join in. Almost forgot about the sabra and shatilla massacres in Lebanon. Israeli troops wrongly occupied the entire Lebanon and sent in Christian bigots into muslim camps mostly populated with women and young men and women.the rest, as you may know, is history. I don't feel I need to go on mentioning such atrocious events hoping that I have proved my point.

You know, muslims were witness to a lot of maltreatments from people of other religions more than they would like to remember. You have history books so lets focus on the present. The fact that france actually banned wearing headscarf for muslim girls is an act of intolerance stands out burning. So yeah I burn too. But then I have the hadith of Muhammad peace be upon him : Let not the injustice of other people prevent you from being just. And it also behooves me to present some ayah again from the book of ALLAH, which was written by HIM alone. "Fight in the cause of Allah those against those who fight you, but do not transgress, for Allah loves not the transgressor. Fight in the way of Allah against those who fight against you, but begin not hostilities. Lo! Allah loveth not aggressors. And slay them wherever ye find them, and drive them out of the places whence they drove you out, for persecution is worse than slaughter. And fight not with them at the Inviolable Place of Worship until they first attack you there, but if they attack you (there) then slay them. Such is the reward of disbelievers. But if they desist, then lo! Allah is Forgiving, Merciful. And fight them until persecution is no more, and religion is for Allah. But if they desist, then let there be no hostility except against wrongdoers." (Al-Baqarah 190-193)[1] To those against whom war is made, permission is given (to fight), because they are wronged;- and verily, Allah is most powerful for their aid;- (They are) those who have been expelled from their homes in defiance of right,- (for no cause) except that they say, "our Lord is Allah". Did not Allah check one set of people by means of another, there would surely have been pulled down monasteries, churches, synagogues, and mosques, in which the name of Allah is commemorated in abundant measure. Allah will certainly aid those who aid his (cause);- for verily Allah is full of Strength, Exalted in Might, (able to enforce His Will). surah 22, verses 39-40:[30]

you are more than welcome to correspond with me if you so please. I am going to leave it all here and I certainly hope it wasn't too painstaking for your read. And need I mention, any questions you may have please feel free to ask. That way I am being a better slave to ALLAH and so are you. Salaam.

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (295) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Irony [83 words]FarhanDec 22, 2011 22:46191978
3You have a short memory [121 words]PhilNov 29, 2011 20:01191312
2The Brits must be suicidal [316 words]Howard HymanMar 9, 2013 16:01191312
1America started fighting terrorist in 1801 with the Barbary Wars [31 words]bobbarkerSep 12, 2010 19:15178150
2The moment you encounter Islam, you encounter an Islamic war [265 words]PrashantAug 17, 2011 21:34178150
1Disgraceful 'Jihad Appeaser' Jimmy Carter LIES openly on CNN's Larry King and no one refutes him? [234 words]MariaFeb 8, 2009 01:35150028
Them guys are deadly, I am afraid to speak against them. [197 words]Jason S.Jun 30, 2008 16:25133955
4The Barbary Wars [215 words]sheik yer'mamiOct 15, 2007 01:20111495
1well said.... [73 words]donvanJan 23, 2008 15:20111495
2USA is moral leader [295 words]Geoff GreenFeb 21, 2008 03:43111495
American porn? [8 words]David BowmanAug 12, 2008 23:20111495
Error - June 1968 was the real beginning. [72 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
TomJul 10, 2007 15:31103368
Only 30 years? [11 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Stuart TeichJul 4, 2007 22:46102984
A palestinian by any other name [130 words]Stuart TeichOct 28, 2008 18:52102984
Islamic Attacks on Americans Date Back to 1974 [104 words]GerryJul 3, 2007 11:41102788
May be even earlier that '79 [170 words]Phil GreendJun 8, 2007 11:0796949
Kudos on exposing this terrorism [40 words]Acharya SMay 4, 2007 17:0291667
Why Everyone Hates America! [179 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Richard NevaApr 2, 2007 23:2988463
Th-th-th-that's all folks! [9 words]Frank MOct 11, 2007 17:4288463
"Living in America is a living hell"???! [288 words]jennifer solisOct 12, 2007 14:1188463
2Stop blaming america [72 words]anonymousOct 9, 2008 18:0388463
Ayee [78 words]AyeMay 15, 2009 20:1488463
To all you America haters out there [167 words]Trident IVMay 17, 2015 22:3188463
Is Islam truly a peaceful nation? [633 words]Frank MascaroJan 22, 2007 16:4074132
Where is the relevance? [131 words]Klaus IllianJan 19, 2008 13:5774132
1The relevance to the topic is in the article. [177 words]Frank MascaroJan 22, 2008 16:1574132
3Violence Isn't Islamic [325 words]Klaus IllianFeb 2, 2008 14:5474132
You feel sorry for me? [374 words]Frank MascaroFeb 2, 2008 21:3174132
Walks like a duck [95 words]DarrenMar 20, 2008 00:5674132
2U.S do not fall for the con trick like we have done in the U.K [173 words]colinSep 25, 2006 07:1357425
Political correctness [89 words]Frank MascaroDec 29, 2006 15:4857425
hatred for americans [22 words]jillJul 21, 2007 18:2557425
1"racism" [36 words]ElleOct 5, 2007 13:4557425
1You're not a racist. [127 words]Frank MOct 10, 2007 20:5957425
you're correct [67 words]AnonymousNov 6, 2007 10:3357425
Almost forgotten [156 words]Tracy RaderMar 10, 2006 08:3639616
USS Stark should be remembered [80 words]JagflyApr 7, 2006 19:4239616
USS Stark, Persian Gulf 1987 [111 words]PhilAug 28, 2006 08:3639616
I agree [175 words]Jeanine PisciottaOct 15, 2006 11:0039616
Agree with Phil [306 words]Pete CommanderNov 23, 2006 00:1939616
2I Was There [246 words]Pete TrunzoMay 17, 2007 13:4039616
Arlington Memorial Ceremony [186 words]Bob HansenMay 18, 2007 01:1739616
Benefits for the Stark crew? [184 words]Ron EatonFeb 13, 2009 16:2839616
1USS Stark should be remembered [337 words]martin garzaJan 31, 2010 01:2839616
2Greg Tweady [55 words]Troy TweadyMay 14, 2010 20:1239616
I Remember Everyday [190 words]FC1 MitchellJun 27, 2010 23:1239616
I knew Greg [60 words]Jeri GilmoreAug 16, 2011 20:3539616
Greg Tweady [54 words]Brett TweadyMar 17, 2012 05:0239616
I knew your father [26 words]mike schwarzeApr 4, 2012 00:2839616
USS Stark [61 words]GonzoMay 29, 2012 23:4339616
Stinger Gunners [97 words]Martin GarzaFeb 10, 2014 16:4039616
Stingers [55 words]GonzoFeb 10, 2014 22:1439616
I was there too [52 words]David DankelmanJun 10, 2014 13:1039616
12First Muslim attacks on America 1783 NOT 1979. [156 words]Citizen WatchdogJan 2, 2006 14:0130936
200 years of history, and we still can't figure it out. [255 words]TriciaMar 6, 2006 14:5230936
For Trisha [80 words]Frank MascaroApr 17, 2006 17:3230936
gasp !! [294 words]bayezidJun 14, 2006 14:4630936
For bayezid: [166 words]dihmmi no moreJun 15, 2006 06:2230936
you sound a little ... [85 words]hawkeyesJul 20, 2006 23:5830936
my best friend died on this ship [17 words]BeanJul 21, 2006 01:0630936
Agree with the Comments by Citizen Watchdog [55 words]Fred FryeSep 7, 2006 16:3530936
Citizen Watchdog is right. Islamists infiltrating the U.S. are presently the biggest threat to U.S. survival [194 words]Stephen PhillipsSep 9, 2006 00:5030936
There is no such thing as extremist or moderate Muslims. [123 words]Stephen PhillipsSep 9, 2006 01:1030936
My heart goes out to you [92 words]Stephen PhillipsSep 9, 2006 01:1930936
to bayezid [256 words]Frank MascaroDec 30, 2006 09:0030936
for dihmmi no more [14 words]Frank MascaroDec 30, 2006 09:0330936
Dear Tricia [46 words]SteveMay 30, 2007 20:2230936
1END the Invasion of the WEST [141 words]Ames TSep 5, 2007 07:0230936
Thank You! [40 words]DarrenMar 20, 2008 00:4830936
I guess you converted [73 words]DarrenMar 20, 2008 01:0730936
i guess i didn't [195 words]syed bayezidMar 21, 2008 03:1730936
for dhimmi no more who doesn't know it's his destiny [249 words]syed bayezidMar 21, 2008 06:4730936
I've seen it all! [274 words]DarrenMar 21, 2008 23:4030936
the people dont define the deen [166 words]syed bayezidMar 23, 2008 15:1030936
be calm [451 words]shakirApr 7, 2008 08:5930936
Agreement [6 words]Jarold C. LeffelApr 30, 2008 11:1030936
to frank [403 words]syed bayezidJul 14, 2008 07:1930936
A Muslim agrees with a Christian [173 words]Frank MJul 15, 2008 17:4030936
if you are suffering from delusions...contact a local muslim imam immediately [181 words]bayezidJul 22, 2008 09:3530936
I suffer no illusions [571 words]Frank MascaroJul 27, 2008 12:0230936
i thought you'd never ask [2594 words]bayezidAug 2, 2008 13:3530936
1Moslems have no shame or empathy for the suffering they cause in Allah's cause [196 words]DemocracyistheanswerNov 23, 2008 09:4330936
wow !! [151 words]syed byezidNov 24, 2008 14:4830936
A perfect example of Islamic bipolarity: lewd, rude and crude [100 words]DemocracyistheanswerNov 24, 2008 16:3630936
Democracyistheanswer [34 words]btilly`Nov 25, 2008 12:4630936
syed byezid [168 words]btilly`Nov 25, 2008 12:5630936
touche ..... not !! [136 words]bayezidNov 25, 2008 12:5830936
getting a litle antsy, arent we ? [312 words]bayezidNov 27, 2008 10:1430936
seriously !! come on ! [133 words]syed byezidNov 28, 2008 04:2430936
a perfect reflection of western secularism [110 words]bayezidDec 4, 2008 10:5730936
YES, THERE IS FREEDOM IN ARABIAN COUNTRIES [166 words]Car JacDec 18, 2005 12:5430144
Who murdered the Marines in Beirut? [199 words]Douglas W. CoulterAug 29, 2005 23:3125192
Why? [311 words]Citizen WatchdogJan 3, 2006 09:4025192
Largest standing army [281 words]Douglas W CoulterOct 19, 2010 18:0525192
No culture, too much cash and crash morals... the recipe builds [946 words]JoeAug 4, 2005 23:5724371
The enemy will always hate us, and the U.S. [328 words]SteveJul 24, 2005 14:5623750
1Arabs need to wake up and stop the unjustified hatred towards America [215 words]Matthew SampsonMay 3, 2005 19:4621976
Keep up the good work [180 words]Stephen PhillipsSep 9, 2006 02:2321976
Kudos Matthew Sampson [169 words]RobertFeb 12, 2007 15:5521976
no, arabs meant that statement DEATH TO AMERICA [181 words]munirDec 10, 2007 21:4121976
5Arabs, Muslims all hate America even if they don't say it [410 words]dar Ayyad min Silwad, RamallahJan 12, 2005 19:4219636
Ahmad Yaseim... [227 words]George ScottJan 18, 2006 21:1619636
re: death to america [272 words]Heather ErvinApr 19, 2006 11:4719636
to duh Arid min Seaweed Salami [182 words]Frank MascaroApr 19, 2006 19:5119636
Muslim hatred for the Americans [97 words]Frank MascaroJul 20, 2006 17:2419636
Sounds like the Sheik has been watching too much TV! [212 words]Kevin MJul 20, 2006 19:0919636
dont blame you [314 words]ShumsAug 7, 2006 07:2619636
to Shums [146 words]Frank MascaroAug 8, 2006 16:0119636
hello [495 words]ShumsAug 9, 2006 04:5519636
I don't understand your hate..... [13 words]TomAug 17, 2006 17:1519636
1SO, WHAT ARE YOU LOOKING FOR, AMERICANS THAT HATE? [115 words]JoanneAug 26, 2006 14:1819636
100 years we are all dead, so what really matters [156 words]John BrownSep 1, 2006 19:3019636
Arab Muslims started the world hate Sheik Ahmad Yaseim [135 words]Fred FryeSep 7, 2006 16:2719636
A lot of the acts you mentioned were the will of God [681 words]Stephen PhillipsSep 9, 2006 02:0919636
feel sorry for you [88 words]kSep 11, 2006 15:0919636
KKK is Islam? Thanks for that info. [595 words]Jake WintersSep 27, 2006 20:2219636
Hating Americans [239 words]EvangelineOct 1, 2006 21:5019636
O vay! [37 words]KarayaOct 22, 2006 01:4019636
No Tolerance or Love [234 words]SaraNov 29, 2006 14:2819636
Let's go back in time. [93 words]Frank MascaroDec 29, 2006 16:0419636
Scary [120 words]Kiersten PipmanJan 13, 2007 21:5319636
You're a stereotypical muslim, Ayyad [9 words]A stupid AmericanFeb 14, 2007 01:0819636
Response to Shums article [84 words]George MMar 29, 2007 12:4219636
reality? [280 words]MikeApr 17, 2007 20:5919636
1Why are we on top then? [122 words]ElleMay 16, 2007 15:5319636
1Then leave [154 words]AJJul 27, 2007 00:0419636
response to all muslims hate america [62 words]angela biancoSep 11, 2007 11:5619636
vindictive and hypocritical........... [418 words]jackOct 31, 2007 10:0719636
America is a "good" country [214 words]ElleNov 1, 2007 15:5319636
illogical, i think not...! [441 words]jackNov 3, 2007 00:1919636
"To whom much is given much is required." [358 words]ElleNov 5, 2007 14:5719636
my reply [228 words]jackNov 5, 2007 22:2819636
Say what? [140 words]ElleNov 7, 2007 15:2119636
ha ha sorry..... [172 words]jackNov 9, 2007 09:0019636
hope and love [311 words]jamie lee wilsonJan 18, 2008 17:1319636
Sheik Ahmad Yaseim [13 words]RBFeb 14, 2008 12:3819636
simmer down [309 words]syed bayezidMar 28, 2008 16:3219636
philippines [75 words]Lucas HJun 15, 2008 20:0219636
youre definitely not running for president [441 words]bayezidJul 14, 2008 08:5819636
YOU'RE HYPOCRITES [110 words]martynAug 7, 2008 21:5819636
Yet you Live here [6 words]David BowmanAug 12, 2008 22:3619636
KKK analogy perfect [32 words]JTSep 29, 2008 16:3919636
Get Out! [14 words]GailOct 9, 2008 12:0619636
Not all Americans [273 words]ToriNov 15, 2008 00:1819636
1no we just want to be rid of you [163 words]syed bayezidDec 6, 2008 09:4219636
Then get out.... [91 words]SmithFeb 7, 2009 00:0619636
comment [52 words]nunya bissFeb 23, 2009 19:2219636
AMERICA IS THE BEST!!! [101 words]Terry Jade SpearceMay 6, 2009 18:0219636
try to see! [43 words]HanniSep 3, 2009 00:3319636
our government started this [169 words]john doeSep 30, 2010 01:2419636
read it [67 words]randomSep 26, 2011 17:0319636
LaGuardia Terrorism 1975 [269 words]Lindsay B.Nov 28, 2004 00:4518680
The 'War on Terror' is a joke [219 words]PhilipJul 20, 2004 16:4516014
War on terror is a government led media campaign ... [103 words]MikeJul 14, 2006 08:0416014
War on Iraq [179 words]Frank MascaroJul 18, 2006 16:3916014
a lot of people think islam is peacefull [163 words]Richard tasseyJul 3, 2004 19:5415880
Re: [31 words]sakijfoMar 26, 2008 12:0215880
JUST THANKS [26 words]A RICHARD BERGMar 30, 2004 12:1114420
Comment on Death to America [42 words]USMarineMar 21, 2004 20:5314282
1 John 4:7-8 [177 words]Stephen PhillipsSep 9, 2006 20:3114282
Please [79 words]DavidFeb 24, 2004 20:1813988
1List Of Terrorist Acts Against US Citizens Numbers About 60 [2244 words]Dakota FreedomJan 2, 2004 21:0713059
Homegrown Terrorists [65 words]jmrFeb 17, 2008 17:4313059
America, we support you! [239 words]JamesJun 16, 2003 05:249565
Thank You [60 words]Frank MApr 15, 2006 11:559565
2US & Australia-allies for 90 years [69 words]Ken TaylorApr 23, 2006 23:149565
AUSTRALIA WILL ALWAYS BE ALLIES WITH AMERICA IF YOU DONT LIKE IT LEAVE. [130 words]Grant AlexanderNov 13, 2010 02:499565
There is more to history... [121 words]Mark BurchMay 28, 2003 19:449274
Don't forget [29 words]Matthew J. RestivoMay 27, 2003 21:529263
2Militant Muslims: the new Nazis [395 words]John GrahamMay 6, 2003 11:078889
Response to John Graham: Looking through Perspectives [404 words]Michael PowellMay 14, 2003 14:278889
Excuse us, John Graham [322 words]Frank MascaroApr 16, 2006 08:048889
Moderate and average muslims are no different than the extremists. They're all the same. [214 words]Stephen PhillipsSep 9, 2006 20:538889
You're splitting hairs [214 words]Stephen PhillipsSep 9, 2006 21:118889
Well Stated [180 words]Rive DurhoneSep 17, 2006 18:358889
muslims nazis drive them out [150 words]JasonOct 22, 2006 19:098889
Moderate Muslims [67 words]Michael FitzGeraldDec 23, 2006 22:438889
Moderate Muslims? [123 words]Frank MascaroDec 29, 2006 15:268889
Bad blood [80 words]Frank MascaroDec 29, 2006 16:148889
Reply to Jason [98 words]colinDec 31, 2006 06:328889
Death to America [436 words]Michael FitzGeraldJan 29, 2007 14:318889
You're wasting your time on me [264 words]Frank MascaroJan 29, 2007 22:028889
Changing our Mind Sets [228 words]Patrice CAug 8, 2007 20:228889
I had that very thought! [19 words]Awake !Jan 12, 2008 20:068889
2The difference between the Ku Klux Klan and extremist muslims. [148 words]Curtis PrestonDec 19, 2008 11:048889
French and America [241 words]OogyMay 3, 2003 14:408848
France [196 words]Frank MascaroApr 18, 2006 17:108848
Foundations [275 words]TomApr 14, 2003 14:498356
America [98 words]JohnApr 9, 2003 02:588198
united states of hypocrisy [936 words]SimonApr 1, 2003 10:207845
What's the problem, then? [20 words]Prof. KilbyMar 31, 2003 23:487832
US brainwash [150 words]late reply!Mar 29, 2003 15:477770
French and Iraq in bed together? [142 words]Pete CommanderMar 27, 2003 11:367708
French and Iraq in bed together with England, Russia and the US !!! [134 words]MartinAug 4, 2007 02:167708
I'm fed up with the hypocrisy [235 words]Allen AndersonMar 25, 2003 15:317611
Americans are kidding themselves [39 words]anonMar 25, 2003 12:267577
Flower Power....... [65 words]Frank MascaroApr 15, 2006 12:027577
From my perspective [136 words]T. Wade RaibornMar 23, 2003 22:257544
A Canadian view [592 words]David GrahamMar 18, 2003 07:507349
Comment to David Grahams article "A Canadian View" [51 words]GeorgeMar 29, 2007 12:147349
Get Real [238 words]Stephen MeyerMar 17, 2003 13:017335
Does any one have the number of dead in the last 50 years? [60 words]JOE A BROOKSMar 6, 2003 18:307124
Payback [290 words]Tom McDonoughFeb 13, 2003 13:176615
Mr. Payback [53 words]Dumb as a stoneFeb 17, 2003 10:356615
The right to pass judgment? [325 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Marc DreyfusJan 28, 2003 10:396046
Advice for Marc Dreyfus [113 words]Kenny L.Feb 28, 2003 23:046046
America, what is wrong with you? [409 words]Mikhail GribajvaJan 17, 2003 17:535838
Death to Persia [95 words]Frank MascaroApr 20, 2006 16:565838
Your best friends [117 words]R SmithJan 11, 2003 17:055675
Take anything out of context and you can make a point [199 words]American FreedomDec 26, 2002 17:465148
What about Leon Klinghoffer? [23 words]Adrienne NajjarDec 12, 2002 09:004551
There were many more [69 words]Frank MascaroApr 20, 2006 16:314551
Nobel Prize? [41 words]KeithDec 10, 2002 14:114509
Its Retaliation [140 words]Syed Danial AliDec 8, 2002 09:424477
Join the Navy and see the world than Die [76 words]Jose RodriguezDec 6, 2002 16:454454
Eye-opener at a school in canada [124 words]BurtNov 19, 2002 23:114061
Pre-Teheran [163 words]Phil BramleySep 18, 2002 20:562555
Three Indians Murdered in Tacoma WA [169 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Len AlenickSep 17, 2002 00:182490
No I think it was localized [108 words]I cant tell you my nameDec 9, 2007 23:052490
I thought the Indian family were killed in 1986 [213 words]John L.Nov 28, 2015 00:452490
When it all started [111 words]Lee D. CarySep 14, 2002 15:322472
The Price of Apathy/Appeasement [200 words]K.S. PlattSep 11, 2002 15:542420
Is America a nation of cowards? I know Canada is. [48 words]Jeff BercovitchSep 11, 2002 08:372404
Use of the term, "Militant" [19 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Yoni FreemanSep 10, 2002 17:302399
Good long term view [47 words]Mark PennimanSep 10, 2002 15:552397
5Allah Ordering Muslims to Kill Infidels [128 words]A. AhmedSep 10, 2002 15:192396
Allah be praised [26 words]bsMar 26, 2008 22:252396
Recent Radio Program on 'Kill them wherever you find them' [1678 words]Waseem SayedOct 11, 2009 00:512396
Once again... [120 words]John ProiaSep 10, 2002 11:442393
More Islamic murders of Americans [25 words]Avraham FleckSep 10, 2002 10:082390
A Key Clarification Needed [83 words]A Reader from USASep 10, 2002 00:162388
Iran to Lebanon [96 words]Daniel MiddlemanSep 9, 2002 22:552387
The True Evil [293 words]Samy MikhailSep 9, 2002 21:402386
Global threats are everyone's responsiblity [100 words]Frank MascaroApr 20, 2006 16:432386
Total Agreement With You [42 words]Mary Jo McKnightSep 9, 2002 20:242384
A Vindication of Belief [54 words]Guy RupertSep 9, 2002 19:202383
Purely ignorant. [873 words]KenJan 10, 2007 00:322383
"We the Ignorant" [872 words]Frank MascaroFeb 3, 2007 12:352383
What was the question [119 words]Pete CommanderFeb 3, 2007 13:532383
Beginning of Islamic Terrorism [106 words]Captain Michael J. LarkinSep 9, 2002 19:032382
Lest we also forget American deaths in Israel [43 words]Mark KingSep 9, 2002 18:172381
A Great Job To Curb Worldwide Islamic Terrorism [320 words]Pandoba DhondibaSep 9, 2002 17:372380
Even More Americans Have Been Murdered by Islamists [144 words]Vijay DandapaniSep 9, 2002 14:572374
When will Americans wake up? [50 words]Marek SuchenekSep 9, 2002 14:462373
Counting carefully [109 words]John T. ManarasSep 9, 2002 13:252370
Compelling evidence demands a response! [115 words]SheerahakhnSep 9, 2002 13:102369
Behind you President Bush!!!!!!! [159 words]Katie FraserSep 9, 2002 13:032368
reply to katie frazier one year later [226 words]tarvis mimmerSep 18, 2003 17:582368
reply to tarvis frazier 21/2 years later [193 words]Frank MascaroApr 19, 2006 19:262368
who said that palestinians were happy for 9-11 attacks [159 words]Elham M. HellesNov 18, 2006 11:142368
I said it [162 words]Frank MascaroDec 29, 2006 15:402368
Carter's Fault [48 words]Paul M. NevilleSep 9, 2002 12:142365
USS Stark [73 words]Chris BischofSep 9, 2002 11:302363
Correction on Stark Attack [90 words]PatrickNov 15, 2002 22:372363
USS Stark [163 words]FC2(SW) JustinFeb 14, 2003 17:502363
More on the USS Stark [29 words]American PatriotFeb 26, 2003 12:052363
USS Stark attack not a mistake [70 words]Tom BeckerMar 15, 2003 22:292363
USS Stark - 47 killed - redemption day [51 words]DuaneNavarreMar 20, 2003 09:202363
USS Stark [40 words]Tom BambaraDec 21, 2003 00:552363
USS Stark [44 words]Don MosherFeb 10, 2005 13:092363
Correction On USS STARK ATTACK [178 words]DelpizzoMay 5, 2005 13:462363
the USS stark [281 words]HJul 25, 2005 18:172363
Visited the Stark @ Ingall's in '88 [519 words]CM ChandlerSep 1, 2005 02:092363
USS Stark Final Correction [91 words]Michael FitzgeraldNov 25, 2005 21:012363
USS Stark [34 words]Frank MascaroApr 15, 2006 17:002363
The Final Chapter [124 words]Tom MaysJan 3, 2007 13:182363
Replying to the Final Chapter of the USS Stark [312 words]Pete CommanderJan 27, 2007 23:402363
my father [33 words]randi lynn pierceOct 28, 2007 23:152363
Thank You [12 words]Peter FountaineSep 9, 2002 11:122362
History is a mirror to the future [160 words]William "J" RuthSep 9, 2002 11:092361
We Never Seem to Learn [124 words]Steven HessSep 9, 2002 08:202358
Older terrorist attack? 1975 or 1976 [236 words]Joseph SummerourSep 9, 2002 08:132357
Cowards and Bullies [45 words]JoeSep 9, 2002 07:472356
Quo Vadis, Uncle Sam? [267 words]A.M. BerlinSep 9, 2002 02:072354
Scio periculum [82 words]Frank MascaroApr 19, 2006 16:502354
Error of omission? [27 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Charles S. WilliamsSep 9, 2002 00:172353
Reference to Jewish Boy Killed on Brooklyn Bridge in 1994 [85 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Joe from BrooklynSep 8, 2002 23:472352
The Gates of Hell [128 words]Ben CreechSep 8, 2002 21:502350
Jimmy Carter's Fault [59 words]MarcSep 8, 2002 20:412349
The Cost of Political Correctness [44 words]Rev. Andy WelikalaSep 8, 2002 20:052348
Liberals [69 words]Frank MascaroMay 4, 2006 16:502348
Good Chronology But Should Begin Earlier [96 words]David JacobSep 8, 2002 19:282347
A list to remember [40 words]A Canadian named LennSep 8, 2002 18:562346
Carter's Weakness [108 words]Larry WinerSep 8, 2002 17:052345
Agreements and Disagreements [210 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Irfan KhawajaSep 8, 2002 15:592343
Additional important points [190 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Howard HymanSep 8, 2002 15:382342
The Use of Force and Militant Islam [25 words]Ramon V. TinioSep 8, 2002 15:322341
The tragedy of history [200 words]ibrodskySep 8, 2002 15:302340
WHERE ARE AMERICA'S "ALLIES" ? [44 words]Prof. Richard MILLMANSep 8, 2002 14:472338
We've got friends [50 words]Frank MascaroAug 8, 2006 16:232338
Here's to England [48 words]Frank MascaroAug 10, 2006 12:462338
The only friends America have are Israel and the english speaking nations. Everyone else is the enemy [48 words]Stephen PhillipsSep 9, 2006 02:272338
Help me out here. [49 words]Frank MascaroDec 29, 2006 16:202338
Clearing up any confusion [268 words]Stephen PhillipsDec 30, 2006 14:192338
to Stephen [73 words]Frank MascaroDec 31, 2006 15:232338

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to i thought you'd never ask by bayezid

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

ADVERTISEMENTS

eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2019 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)