5 readers online now  |  69 million page views

To Interpret or Not to Interpret

Reader comment on item: The Vatican Confronts Islam
in response to reader comment: "...their own mortal intellectual opinions and interpetations."

Submitted by Linda (Canada), Jul 24, 2006 at 00:13

So as to avoid 'misinterpreting' what you say, I have brought your words to this page and will merely insert responses to your statements and the quote you posted below your comments.

Submitted by orange yonason, Jul 23, 2006 at 05:04


You are misinterpreting what I said. If you read what I wrote (and more importantly what was on the reference I gave), you will see there is no room for our opinions or interpretations unless they agree with the Torah. We are often falsely accused of "misinterpreting" Torah by those who think their feelings are more accurate than adherence to G-d's instruction.

The Scriptures have been 'interpreted' by both Jew and Christian, and by virtue of the fact that it is the mortal mind of 'intellect' doing the interpreting, much of it is 'misinterpretation'.

We received not only the Written Torah from G-d at Sinai, but also the Oral Torah which expounds on and explains the Written portion. We do NOT rely exclusively on human interpretation, because we don't have to. What we do rely on (and the G-d requires of us) is using our intellect to learn G-d's explaination of Torah concepts as transmitted to us by our Rabbis for the purpose of making our behaviour conform to the standards of human conduct set by G-d, which is what life in this world is all about. And if you say that we aren't perfect, I will tell you that is why we need the Torah; because we can't do it by ourselves.

The 'oral expounding' to which you refer is, once again, mere mortal intellectual interpetation of the Torah, which most of today's Jewry adheres to more than they study the Torah. Do you acknowledge this? As the Pharisees 'intepreted' the Torah in Jesus' day, so the Rabbis do today, only they are two thousand years further away from the day when the Lord gave the Torah to Moses by His Holy Spirit. The words in the Torah are G-d inspired whereas the words in the Mishna are Rabbinical interpretations and opinions.

Above you admit: "What we do rely on (and the G-d requires of us) is using our intellect to learn G-d's explaination of Torah ..." I say again, only G-d can give revelation concerning His Word; He does not speak revelation to the 'intellect', which is as fallible as human emotions, which you admit below are unreliable. Neither the intellect nor emotion are reliable or adequate or suitable for receiving revelation from G-d. Both intellect and emotion are exposed all our life to the error and bents of a corrupt world and are themselves corrupt and susceptible to satanic influence.

And we certainly don't rely on our feelings, because until they have been refined by our adherence to Torah they can lead us astray, since they are from the animal side of human nature and hence much less reliable than intellect.

G-d is a Spirit and if we are to worship Him, we must worship Him in Spirit and in Truth. The Lord conveys the wisdom of His Word through the Aughor of His Word, G-d, the Holy Spirit, the same Spirit spoken of in Genesis, Who acted upon the Word spoken to create our earth and universe. G-d has always communicated by His Spirit to the human spirit. He has not changed, though modern interpretations suggest that either G-d has changed or we mortals have erred by claiming that He now wants us, with our modern and much more sophisticated intelligence, to 'interpret' His Word with our 'intellect' rather than learn to listen to the Voice of His Spirit.

Are the following familiar to you?

Genesis 1:2 "And the earth was without form, and void; and darkness [was] upon the face of the deep. And the Spirit of God moved upon the face of the waters."

Psalm 51:11 "Cast me not away from thy presence; and take not thy Holy Spirit from me."

Isaiah 63:10 "But they rebelled, and vexed his Holy Spirit: therefore he was turned to be their enemy, [and] he fought against them."

Isaiah 63:11 "Then he remembered the days of old, Moses, [and] his people, [saying], Where [is] he that brought them up out of the sea with the shepherd of his flock? where [is] he that put his Holy Spirit within him?"

Isaiah 55:8 "For My thoughts [are] not your thoughts, neither [are] your ways My ways, saith the LORD."

'Thought' is an exercise of the human intellect, and it is clear from the above Scritpure that the Lord is saying we do not 'think' as He 'thinks'. Therefore, what we 'think' He says in Scripture is alien to what He says and that means that what we 'think' cannot be trusted. However, religions have been built upon intellectual thought and its interpretation of the Word of God. Judaism and Christianity have made that same mistake and both have grieved His Holy Spirit Who has yearned to teach us Spirit to spirit what the Lord says and means in His Word and in Life.

The 'intellect' obviously did the Israelites no good when the Lord brought them out of slavery in Egypt by the hand of Moses. Their 'intellect' saw all of the awesome miracles and wonders the Lord performed for them before they even left Egypt, and yet after only a few days journey, their 'intellect' was telling them that Moses only brought them out of Egypt to die in the wilderness, and that they should return to Egypt because they had garlic and onions there.

After their 'intellect' witnessed the power of the Lord in a pillar of fire and a pillar of smoke and how He parted the Red Sea for them and they walked across on dry land, and on and on, their 'intellect' told them they ought to melt down the gold they had and make a molten calf and declared it to be the god that brought them out of Egypt.

There are many more examples in the Torah of just how the 'intellect' of man is at enmity with the Spirit of G-d. But what the Lord discloses as the real problem with the Israelites is encapsulated in the following passage of Scripture:

"Harden not your heart, as in the provocation, [and] as [in] the day of temptation in the wilderness: When your fathers tempted me, proved me, and saw my work. Forty years long was I grieved with [this] generation, and said, It [is] a people that do err in their heart, and they have not known my ways: Unto whom I sware in my wrath that they should not enter into my rest. " Psalm 95:8-11

'Intellectually', the children of Israel were the ONLY people on earth who had been shown and taught the Lord's ways! How is it then that they did not KNOW His ways? The 'intellect' sloughed the Lord's ways off in preference for its own thoughts and opinions. Regardless of how much their 'intellect' had been exposed to the Lord and His ways, they refused to let G-d's ways enter theirhard hearts.

Only the Spirit of G-d KNOWS the mind of G-d and He works to impart the KNOWLEDGE of G-d to the spirit/heart of man, not his intellect. If the hearts of the Israelites had been 'soft' (receptive and responsive) to the Spirit of G-d, He would have communed His mind/thoughts to their hearts and they would have undergone transformation. But their hearts were closed and hard and their 'intellect' produced all the anti-G-d thoughts that led them to rebel against Him time and time again.

There is a difference between 'thinking' and 'knowing'. For the most part, most Jews and Christians only 'think' they know and their 'intellect' is the feeble foundation of their religion. Christians have a Scripture that spells the Lord's will out very clearly when it comes to what Teacher we are to submit to. It is:

I John 2:27 "But the anointing which ye have received of him abideth in you, and ye need not that any man teach you: but as the same anointing teacheth you of all things, and is truth, and is no lie, and even as it hath taught you, ye shall abide in him."

Note that the Word says "ye need not that any man teach you", but the bulk of Judaism and Christianity is comprised of intellects taught by other mortal intellects, not intellects that have been illumined by revelation transmitted from the Holy Spirit (the 'anointing') through their spirit. G-d has a process for teaching mortals and it is not through the 'intellect', no matte how sincerely it is applied to learning 'spiritual truth'.

The same Spirit of G-d Who strove and still strives to reach and teach the heart of the Jew, likewise strives to teach the heart of the Christian. In the case of Israel, He found a remnant of souls who actually submitted to Him for such teaching. Likewise, He has found a remnant among Christians throughout their generations, who have been willing to submit whole-heartedly to Him; who relinquish the 'throne' of their hearts and lives to Him to rule over every aspect of their being as the King of kings and Lord of lords. This is what He desires and seeks from us ALL.

Something important to keep in mind, and help one keep one's sanity as what we call the "end of days" approaches, is this thought from Chabad.org, entitled "UnApocalypse" ...

"This world was not created for some apocalyptic finale; its magnificence was not formed to dissipate into ionized gas. Each thing was formed for the glory of its Maker who stands forever.

Only the darkness must wind itself to its end, and it must be robbed of the treasures it holds. For the most precious things of this world are held in darkness.

A Daily Dose of Wisdom from the Rebbe
-words and condensation by Tzvi Freeman
Tammuz 15, 5766 * July 11, 2006 "

And when darkness has run it's course, it and only it will cease to exist. And as darkness' end approaches, the world can see with ever increasing clarity what is darkness and what is light.

Yes, time IS running out: for evil. May that day be today!

According to both the Judeo and Christian Scriptures, it is the Lord Who brings the darkness to an end. The corruption upon the earth will indeed be burned up in the last day, not by fire as we know it, but the sheer purity and power of the Presence of the holiness and glory of the Living G-d will have that purifying effect on sin, which cannot endure His Presence.

The quotes you provide are lovely for religious poetry, but there is no Spirit of Truth emanating from them. They are an example of the product of 'intellect', lofty as they may be, but are not based on the Word of G-d, nor are they inspired by the Spirit of G-d. The Spirit of G-d is always in agreement with His Own Word. It has not escaped my notice that the Rebbe does not provide any Scripture from which this
Dose of Wisdom was 'prescribed'.

Some Scriptures indicating that it is the Lord Who has set a time to end 'the darkness' upon the earth are:

"And the LORD said, My spirit shall not always strive with man, for that he also [is] flesh: yet his days shall be an hundred and twenty years." Genesis 6:3 This the Lord spoke as a warning before sending the flood in Noah's day. The Lord ended that period of 'darkness'. He didn't let it run itself out.

"He setteth an end to darkness, and searcheth out all perfection: the stones of darkness, and the shadow of death." Job 28:3 Just as the Lord set a boundary for the night and for the day, so has He determined a set time to end the moral darkness brought to earth by man.

"Behold, the day of the LORD cometh, cruel both with wrath and fierce anger, to lay the land desolate: and he shall destroy the sinners thereof out of it." Isaiah 13:9 Still nothing to indicate the Lord is just going to let 'darkness' run itself out.

"Blow ye the trumpet in Zion, and sound an alarm in my holy mountain: let all the inhabitants of the land tremble: for the day of the LORD cometh, for [it is] nigh at hand;" Joel 2:1

"The sun shall be turned into darkness, and the moon into blood, before the great and the terrible day of the LORD come. " Joel 2:31

Lest anyone suggest the 'day of Lord' refers to some major catastrophe that the planet and life on it will survive and go on as they have after every other disaster,

" And the LORD shall utter his voice before his army: for his camp [is] very great: for [he is] strong that executeth his word: for the day of the LORD [is] great and very terrible; and who can abide it? " Joel 2:11

We have not seen this 'great and terrible day of the Lord', but that there is a 'day' of the Lord for the earth, time and all of us who inhabit them, and that it is an 'end' that the Lord has set, refutes the notion that darkness is just going to gradually fade away in the brilliance emanating from the light of mortal 'intellect'. The intellect is corrupt. The evidence of that is all around us and even in our own thoghts. But one of the effects of corruption is that the corrupt intellect doesn't 'think' it is corrupt, just as it is true that what makes deception so effective is that a deceived mind doesn't know it is deceive because it is deceived.

The mind that is being renewed by the Spirit of G-d KNOWS it's own intellect is corrupt and will not trust it, but seeks the Light from the Sprit of G-d to divide Truth from error, Spirit from 'intellect'.

David was great because the Lord made him great, but the reason the Lord was able to make David so great was because of David's heart, (not his intellect), toward G-d. Read what David said:

"Create in me a clean heart, O God; and renew a right spirit within me. " Psalm 51:10

"But the LORD said unto Samuel, Look not on his countenance, or on the height of his stature; because I have refused him: for [the LORD seeth] not as man seeth; for man looketh on the outward appearance, but the LORD looketh on the heart." I Samuel 16:7

Look, my objective is not to get entangled in vain arguments. The Only One Who is able to convince anyone of the Truth is the Lord Himself. It is to Him that I refer anyone, regardless of whether they agree or disagree with what I say. None of us can afford to rely on our 'intellect' in so serious a matter as our relationship with G-d. What the Lord wants from all of us is to lay our will at His feet and admit with a sincere heart that 'we' are nothing, 'we' know nothing, and are as dead men unless He takes up our lives, gives us a new heart that can at least learn to hear His Voice. We must be resolute that we will not accept anything less or other than His Will.



Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (250) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
1The Vatican confronts Islam [21 words]HelenaApr 26, 2017 11:55238835
2Confronting Islam [219 words]PrashantMay 1, 2017 23:04238835
1Pope Francis and Islam [66 words]UgriJan 13, 2014 04:22212635
1Roman Catholics In Moslem Lands [240 words]DanielNov 23, 2013 20:22211696
1cheap oil painting and oil painting [78 words]simonMay 21, 2012 22:04195743
1I will treat you as you want to treat me christian and muslim alike [192 words]chuck shwiyhatDec 18, 2010 15:27181099
2Religion is metaphoric, not historic. [115 words]TonioAug 14, 2009 08:52160196
Vatican Confronts Islam [86 words]A M PrasadJul 24, 2016 10:10160196
2if we do nothing . . . [99 words]Phil GreendJun 24, 2007 21:32100973
2The Vatican Confronts Islam [375 words]EuGene TurnerDec 15, 2006 13:1969619
1Why can Muslims say whatever they want? [134 words]SpankySep 18, 2006 07:4356340
1Everybody is scared of islam [50 words]JaygenSep 17, 2006 21:2856301
1Reasons to become "Terrorist".. [230 words]Sajid AzizDec 11, 2006 00:3056301
The Real Catholic institution [41 words]George AdamsMay 11, 2008 20:5256301
Catholic Church [107 words]Northern GryphonAug 18, 2008 16:0456301
Incompatibility [82 words]JamesFeb 16, 2009 15:4256301
Everybody is scared of Islam [198 words]HelenaApr 28, 2017 07:2856301
Slightly off topic, but very apropo! [134 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanSep 17, 2006 16:0156276
Why should the Pope apologise? [158 words]WaveriderSep 17, 2006 15:5356273
Pope right. Muslims' response is predictably "don't call our prophet evil, or I'll cut your head off." [448 words]MichaelSep 17, 2006 14:5956266
Hypocrisy [77 words]CristinaSep 17, 2006 14:1656258
Pope Benedict strikes again [73 words]VijaySep 16, 2006 09:0656151
Islam is Terrorism [31 words]ChristineSep 16, 2006 05:1456137
why christian? [131 words]Hussein Al-ShareefSep 26, 2006 16:2956137
1Go read.............. [53 words]sameerDec 21, 2006 08:4656137
What? [32 words]BbJan 31, 2007 12:4056137
1Re; "Islam NEVER spread by the SWORD" [1109 words]GregSep 16, 2006 01:2756119
You call THIS a Holy Figure? [127 words]The ObserverSep 15, 2006 21:5356101
One Sided MultiCulturalism [57 words]JahSep 17, 2006 14:0156101
Islam [171 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanSep 20, 2006 02:1256101
Re: A True Man Of God Speaks The Truth [32 words]AnneMSep 26, 2006 21:5056101
The vatican confronts islam! [207 words]EuGene TurnerDec 29, 2006 16:3456101
Faith is belief w/o evidence or reason [75 words]TomSAug 29, 2007 11:4456101
Who needs this? [315 words]Sensible HumanSep 15, 2006 21:0156097
Pope loses his respect by passing foolish remarks on prophet Peace be upon him [47 words]muhammad aliSep 15, 2006 15:5256067
To muhammad ali [102 words]VijaySep 16, 2006 18:0656067
Respect [249 words]MichaelSep 17, 2006 12:4556067
Understand [50 words]SameerDec 21, 2006 09:2656067
Look around... [196 words]Michael KocianDec 22, 2006 09:2156067
To Michael Kocian [205 words]sameerDec 23, 2006 04:2456067
1Poor brainwashed Islam apologist... [171 words]Michael KocianDec 23, 2006 18:0056067
Poor Michael Kocian......... [21 words]SameerDec 25, 2006 02:2656067
Sameer... [76 words]Michael KocianDec 25, 2006 20:5056067
he called spade a spade [34 words]steve bakmoreJun 22, 2007 10:4256067
JESUS NEVER CAME UP WITH ANY OF THE MAJOR DOCTRINES - [53 words]RaymondApr 8, 2010 23:4456067
2I am shocked! [333 words]mahmoud natoutSep 15, 2006 14:0856050
The Vatican Confronts Islam [711 words]EuGene TurnerDec 18, 2006 17:5556050
Islam must be stopped [244 words]pirroSep 29, 2009 13:0856050
Popes recent comments on Jihad [275 words]J. AbrahimSep 15, 2006 11:5056037
The Pope on Islam [51 words]PatriotSep 15, 2006 11:4656036
You will come to know!!! [57 words]sameerDec 21, 2006 08:5556036
maybe Samuel Huntington had it right [260 words]M.A. RubinsteinSep 15, 2006 09:3256022
The Vatican Confronts Islam Art. No. 3729 [60 words]S.C.PandaJul 21, 2006 02:4850417
Islam Is the religion of peace and mercy [194 words]Hussein Al-ShareefSep 15, 2006 09:2650417
Friends in High Places - Pope John Paul II, Hamas' Pope [483 words]Poles for IsraelJul 18, 2006 14:1250045
'Turning the other cheek' -What did Jesus really say? [154 words]LindaJul 15, 2006 13:0049741
likelihood [84 words]DanJul 11, 2006 15:2749415
Nazareth is in Israel [97 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Wesley LandenJul 11, 2006 14:0049407
Note Added In Proof [60 words]orange yonasonJul 14, 2006 19:3149407
It is time for reality: [37 words]Tony swissJul 11, 2006 11:1049395
United we stand divided we fall! [240 words]Ron HendersonJul 11, 2006 08:5849386
Vatican and Islam [48 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Rick FitzgibbonsJul 10, 2006 09:4949306
What 'more hospitable environment'? [210 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
bat BarnabasJul 9, 2006 21:5449289
"Paranoia Strikes Deep, Into Your..." [152 words]LDCJul 10, 2006 18:0249289
Dear Pastor LDC [305 words]bat BarnabasJul 11, 2006 00:2049289
The Pope Got it Right [294 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Susan WalkerJul 8, 2006 12:2249225
rational authority [57 words]HarrakJul 10, 2006 23:5949225
Comments To Dr. Pipe's Comments To "The Pope Got It Right" [430 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
orange yonasonJul 12, 2006 00:5549225
The PEOPLE OF GOD must repent. [824 words]LindaJul 17, 2006 12:5149225
"...their own mortal intellectual opinions and interpetations." [382 words]orange yonasonJul 23, 2006 05:0449225
To Interpret or Not to Interpret [2588 words]LindaJul 24, 2006 00:1349225
historical texts and cannonical texts are fascinating--as texts of a given time...there is no such thing as revealled truth [257 words]MA RubinsteinSep 16, 2006 05:0749225
Pope got it right [183 words]MichaelSep 16, 2006 15:0849225
God proves Himself [29 words]LindaSep 16, 2006 19:0349225
No such thing as revealed truth?????????? [33 words]EuGene TurnerDec 19, 2006 01:4849225
To interpret or no? [34 words]Eugene TurnerDec 25, 2006 09:0049225
The vatican confronts islam [8 words]EuGene TurnerDec 28, 2006 07:5649225
Pope [39 words]altarainbowJul 25, 2015 10:3649225
Mr.Daniel Pipes , There is no Militant or Fundamental Islam .............. [3311 words]Khushi MehraJul 8, 2006 06:0949199
comments [88 words]SameerDec 21, 2006 09:1349199
Islamic threat [187 words]ThiaganFeb 6, 2007 02:5549199
Fundamental Christianity [24 words]Clifford IshiiMar 2, 2007 20:4749199
Report on Organisation working to Islamise Europe into Eurabia within 20 years [73 words]Johny BhaiJul 8, 2006 05:3849195
If Pope is serious , He must show this by expressing his support for Israel's War against Terror [571 words]Amit KumarJul 8, 2006 01:2849193
If Pope is serious he must show this by expressing his support for Israel's war against terror. [73 words]EuGene TurnerDec 20, 2006 01:5149193
To Amit Kumar [52 words]SameerDec 23, 2006 04:4149193
Tit for Tat [203 words]JaladhiJul 7, 2006 21:5049184
Vatican getting involved [47 words]DavinciJul 7, 2006 20:5149182
infrastructure anyone? [184 words]Donald OJul 7, 2006 18:5449177
My opinion [213 words]Jon Alex SmailJul 7, 2006 14:0849160
?????? [416 words]Mu'een Ud DeenJul 8, 2006 11:0949160
Response to Jon Alex Smail [107 words]Atty ZohuidyJul 8, 2006 16:0949160
to jon alex smail [137 words]mariam( muslim)Jul 28, 2006 10:1349160
Hello Mariam [514 words]Jon Alex SmailAug 23, 2006 19:1249160
forget reciprocity. Thank god if you just survive in Islamic contries. [39 words]Rajesh GognaJul 7, 2006 07:2249141
1Christians are in good position in Arab Countries [125 words]Proud Arab ChristianJul 8, 2006 09:5249141
re: Ethnic Cleansing [88 words]orange yonasonJul 9, 2006 18:3049141
christians in islamic countries [184 words]sohair hakimJul 10, 2006 11:5349141
Seeing and hearing will make believing [118 words]BriarsJul 10, 2006 23:4649141
1Christians in Arab Countries? [377 words]Ron HendersonJul 11, 2006 22:0149141
sad to know [111 words]alanskiDec 24, 2008 11:3249141
Bush, Blair, and now Benedict vs. Ahmadinejad, bin Laden, et alia? Triple sweet!!!! [83 words]C.A.Jul 7, 2006 07:0249140
CA your political views are handicapped [84 words]HarrakJul 7, 2006 16:1549140
"...quiet diplomacy and muted appeasement have clearly failed." [595 words]orange yonasonJul 7, 2006 02:0349123
BS"D???? [10 words]Kevin MJul 9, 2006 22:5649123
BS"D? [19 words]JohnJul 12, 2006 02:4549123
Many thanks! [4 words]Kevin MJul 15, 2006 13:5849123
i bet many americans will speak out against The Church. [33 words]ken mJul 7, 2006 01:4349122
turning the other cheek and moslem reciprocity [734 words]Roger WJul 7, 2006 00:5249117
Welcome to the Party! [9 words]Welcome to the Party!Jul 6, 2006 23:3949109
Finally [91 words]CharlesJul 6, 2006 23:3949108
28Famous Letter of King of Persia [1497 words]SamJul 14, 2006 02:3949108
Letters between Umar and Yazdegard are fakes [64 words]GiishAug 19, 2011 20:4649108
The may be fakes but they speak the truth [41 words]PrashantAug 20, 2011 01:4449108
Reply to Iftekhar Hai: I'm not sure we other Abrahamites can help. [625 words]Peter J. HerzJul 6, 2006 21:4049103
asalamo alaykom [156 words]karimJul 11, 2006 19:0749103
Bienvenue a la famille de dieu [18 words]Peter J. HerzJul 13, 2006 07:3749103
Appeasement Unappreciated [351 words]mad-muhaaJul 6, 2006 20:5049101
Too little too late..... [79 words]MikeJul 6, 2006 20:3249100
Charles Martel [12 words]homeDepotJul 7, 2006 22:4149100
It Takes Time [39 words]BlackspeareJul 6, 2006 18:0949087
To Blackspeare: This is a joke right? [193 words]Richard Lion heartJul 7, 2006 00:2449087
Unreasonable Analysis [256 words]InfidelJul 7, 2006 02:2949087
Wait till they get the BOMB! [6 words]MosheJul 7, 2006 09:2549087
To Lion Heart [7 words]BlackspeareJul 7, 2006 19:3749087
To Infidel [13 words]BlackspeareJul 7, 2006 19:4249087
To Moshe [6 words]BlackspeareJul 7, 2006 19:4649087
oh so not true !!!! [58 words]ahmad zahireJul 9, 2006 22:4749087
Protect the innocent [257 words]Prejudice by any name is harmfulJul 6, 2006 17:5949085
Who is innocent? [119 words]BKJul 6, 2006 22:4849085
Prejudice by any name is harmful [70 words]ToleranceJul 7, 2006 09:4549085
Judy is confused [387 words]pdmJul 7, 2006 13:5149085
Judy [73 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanJul 8, 2006 07:0249085
think again so,so [64 words]ahmad zafireJul 9, 2006 01:2749085
speak my friend speak!! [17 words]ahmad zafireJul 9, 2006 22:5249085
The Truth [21 words]KaraJul 6, 2006 16:3449080
not really [172 words]québéquoiseJul 6, 2006 16:1949077
Ignorance is bliss; war is deceit... [218 words]van der LeyJul 7, 2006 03:2749077
Quebec is much better! [30 words]MosheJul 9, 2006 11:3849077
Very encouraging [312 words]Ron ThompsonJul 6, 2006 14:1649071
Dreams are the beginnings of reality [90 words]Patricia ZentaraJul 6, 2006 13:5849065
Sad Dreams [174 words]MosheJul 9, 2006 12:2149065
THE VATICAN CONFRONTS ISLAM [89 words]Dr. Joseph A barry, MDJul 6, 2006 13:0149059
Reciprocity won't work either [66 words]Fred RaatzJul 6, 2006 12:3949058
Turning the other cheek.. [101 words]DonJul 6, 2006 12:2249057
At last! Three cheers for the new pope! [213 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Persia Gran-FreelandJul 6, 2006 10:3849050
Dellusional [73 words]LDCJul 7, 2006 15:5349050
Sorry to sound like Bernard Woolley, but... [46 words]Kevin MJul 15, 2006 14:0749050
turning other cheek doesn't mean not confronting others [140 words]pluto's dadJul 6, 2006 10:3849049
The pope is a appeasement clown! [20 words]JackJul 6, 2006 10:3649048
Let he who has ACTUALLY been slapped decide if he wants to turn the other cheek [108 words]CarlosJul 6, 2006 10:1549047
Vatican plans to conquer/convert Islam [110 words]David Ben-ArielJul 6, 2006 10:0549045
Thumb in JPII's ecumenical eye [115 words]DLJul 6, 2006 10:0149043
Consider This... [75 words]JeffJul 6, 2006 17:2849043
Jeff, you miss the point [158 words]DLJul 6, 2006 19:3449043
Trickery [158 words]LindaJul 7, 2006 10:0349043
DL Give Benedict XVI Credit That He Is Realistic [53 words]AnneMJul 7, 2006 11:5949043
Too Late [100 words]WestJul 6, 2006 08:5049038
Let the Vatican recognize Jerusalem [108 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDJul 6, 2006 08:3749035
Indoctrination is not compatible with freedom of religion [132 words]History Has ShownJul 6, 2006 07:3849030
Another valuable article [129 words]Char TierneyJul 6, 2006 07:1749029
Muslims Against Humanity! [1410 words]kamekishJul 6, 2006 02:5649014
The Vatican Confronts Islam [87 words]steven LJul 6, 2006 00:5549011
Shhhhh! Don't Anybody Tell the Arabist Dhimmis in the State Department That .... [46 words]gunjamJul 6, 2006 00:3949009
Catholics and Muslims [42 words]Timothy B. RobertsJul 6, 2006 00:1649008
I'm just wondering... [14 words]John C. RandolphJul 5, 2006 23:3149002
Vatican confronts Islam [106 words]Nenette GrunbergJul 5, 2006 23:1949001
The fear of Islam [133 words]f.shakkiJul 5, 2006 22:3848999
The Islamic threat really becoming very dangerous [253 words]MosheJul 7, 2006 09:1448999
You did not learn from history [266 words]f.shakkiJul 7, 2006 23:1048999
f.shakki, you are right! [4 words]MosheJul 12, 2006 03:3848999
Cathedral of Saint Jude [61 words]Thomas MahanyJul 5, 2006 22:1748998
Vatican's Attitude Vs. The world's greatest Colonialist Army called Islam [988 words]TTSJul 5, 2006 22:0248994
Mr.TTS , you are absolutely correct , we need to ........ [293 words]NathulalaJul 8, 2006 10:1248994
Islam is the best [256 words]Muhammad Umar HashmiOct 4, 2009 13:5748994
Wishful Thinking [41 words]John DJul 5, 2006 21:4248988
What rights? [36 words]H. YazdiJul 5, 2006 21:3548985
Paradox [61 words]MosheJul 7, 2006 05:5548985
Yay for Pope Benny! [128 words]Richard B.Jul 5, 2006 21:0348982
Won't be happening... [318 words]DonJul 5, 2006 20:4448979
Reciprocity [36 words]Josef KleinJul 5, 2006 19:0248976
Islam is Work-in Progress [266 words]Iftekhar HaiJul 5, 2006 18:2948972
To Iftekhar: A good idea but... [84 words]Richard Lion heartJul 7, 2006 00:0448972
I'm afraid you're speaking to the wrong audience [89 words]Rick HouseJul 9, 2006 01:3948972
Indian subcontinent is under siege by Islamic Invaders [388 words]Lawrence DavisJul 9, 2006 13:4048972
Islam v. Radical Islam [273 words]Bill StoreyJul 5, 2006 18:0348969
Christians, Catholics, Must Rediscover The Pratice Of The "Just War" Theory [104 words]AnneMJul 5, 2006 17:5948968
Non-Muslims ALWAYS a lower ranking mortal [123 words]HannahJul 5, 2006 17:4548965
Muslims Must Be Confronted About Their Abusive Culture [241 words]AlexanderJul 5, 2006 17:3248960
What Muslims can do ????? [246 words]MarkusJul 9, 2006 14:1948960
It has to begin somewhere [107 words]David W. LincolnJul 5, 2006 17:1748959
Pope John Paul II on Islam [266 words]LindaJul 5, 2006 16:4948953
Reciprocity is a pipe dream [90 words]Rick HouseJul 5, 2006 16:3148951
Thanks, Rick [9 words]LDCJul 5, 2006 17:0348951
Recpirocity is a pipe dream [167 words]AndrewJul 5, 2006 17:4348951
Conversion is the only answer [91 words]docdaveJul 6, 2006 13:5948951
Conversion [82 words]DaisyJul 6, 2006 19:1248951
Mad Catholics? Uh, Oh. [125 words]LDCJul 5, 2006 16:0848949
1Defending Pius XII [817 words]Noah NehmJul 6, 2006 00:1248949
You're Right, Noah... [209 words]LDCJul 6, 2006 17:0048949
Make your mind up, LDC [392 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanJul 8, 2006 07:4848949
For the Ages [209 words]LDCJul 10, 2006 08:1048949
Bang that drum! [736 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanJul 11, 2006 08:4848949
Get some perspective, LDC [763 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanJul 11, 2006 16:3448949
When I type fsat... [433 words]LDCJul 11, 2006 18:1248949
On the Contrary [540 words]LDCJul 12, 2006 19:3548949
Not so fsat! [650 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanJul 13, 2006 21:4948949
Well said [159 words]LDCJul 14, 2006 18:3248949
Interesting indeed! [178 words]Saikat BiswasJul 5, 2006 15:1648948
Meaning of the Word, Radical [191 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Walter ManchurJul 5, 2006 14:5248944
Ya... right! [6 words]Steve JonesJul 5, 2006 13:5848942
It's about time [615 words]ChristinaJul 5, 2006 13:5748941
christina [124 words]ahmad zafireJul 5, 2006 21:2048941
My dear Ahmed [44 words]joeJul 7, 2006 18:1748941
sorry for you joe [65 words]ahmadzafireJul 10, 2006 09:0048941
Mr Pipes is great but he's wrong when he claim "allah is God" and "kuran will be reformed" [468 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
ItalianAug 1, 2006 20:0148941
Islam v Civilization [194 words]surjJan 1, 2007 21:3348941
1Misconceptions about Matt 5:39 [138 words]Steve CooperJul 5, 2006 13:4848939
Correct [35 words]LDCJul 5, 2006 17:0648939
steve [240 words]ahmad zafireJul 5, 2006 21:4648939
APPEASEMENT WILL BE THE DOWNFALL OF THE FREE WORLD. [206 words]Janet AnnJul 5, 2006 13:3648938
What took so long [79 words]Stuart BliwasJul 5, 2006 13:3248937
WCC=UN [99 words]LDCJul 5, 2006 17:1248937
Clarification [64 words]Stuart BliwasJul 6, 2006 19:1648937
WCC & RCC [91 words]LDCJul 7, 2006 15:4448937
To LDC Thanks [33 words]Stuart BliwasJul 11, 2006 19:2048937
Not a Detailed Source [26 words]LDCJul 12, 2006 18:5248937
Finally! [96 words]Kevin MJul 5, 2006 13:1348936
De Paolis deserves being supported But the issue is not Dar al Islam, it is Dar al Dictatoriah (dictatorship) [358 words]HARRAKJul 5, 2006 12:5448935
A possible interesting result of a policy demanding reciprocity [272 words]J. Keen HollandJul 5, 2006 12:5448934
Good news, but it's time for a new paradigm for achieving a sustainable Peace ... only through Justice [100 words]Norman KurlandJul 5, 2006 12:4248933
Abraham Federation & Islamism [123 words]Richard FoleyJul 7, 2006 20:5848933
Truly remarkable [136 words]SHmuel HaleviJul 5, 2006 12:4148932
Vatican prepares to butt heads with Islam [39 words]David Ben-ArielJul 6, 2006 10:1248932
GOOD ARTICLE [5 words]PJMJul 5, 2006 12:0048931
It's getting louder [415 words]No DhimmiJul 5, 2006 11:4648926
Washingon, Jefferson, Adams all terrorized by islam [127 words]PDMJul 6, 2006 10:0548926
confronting Islam [155 words]joeJul 5, 2006 11:3548924
Joe - History repeats itself again and again [130 words]JaladhiJul 5, 2006 17:4348924
elementary demographics [120 words]G.BisvasJul 6, 2006 13:4048924
The same old, same old.... [233 words]JimJul 6, 2006 14:1648924
'Radical' Islam is a misnomer [279 words]JimJul 6, 2006 16:2248924
Peace-loving, egalitarian Muslims are the aberration in Islam. [215 words]RonJul 8, 2006 09:2648924
Faith and Force are inseperable [387 words]Ralph C Whaley MDJul 8, 2006 13:4948924
Selective Reasoning [135 words]Dan ParkerJul 8, 2006 17:5948924
Re: Selective reasoning [139 words]RonJul 10, 2006 13:0348924
Re: Selective reasoning [424 words]MosheJul 11, 2006 06:0248924
Selective Reasoning [194 words]Dan ParkerJul 11, 2006 18:2448924
Thanks Moshe [381 words]JimJul 12, 2006 14:2748924
To Moshe [332 words]RonJul 14, 2006 08:5848924

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to To Interpret or Not to Interpret by Linda

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List


eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2019 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)