1 readers online now  |  69 million page views

How does manusmriti relate to the behaviour of christians?

Reader comment on item: Is Turkey's Government Starting a Muslim Reformation?
in response to reader comment: Manu Smriti XII 3 to 7

Submitted by Proud Indian (India), Jun 26, 2008 at 01:51

Hi nishi,

how do verses in the manusmriti can be related by christian countries? its laughable... how does an ancient outdated hindu text influence the behaviour of christians ? Even majority hindus dont follow the code of manusmriti

On the topic of Bal Thackrey giving a call to hindu sucide bombers to counter the Islamic sucide bombers ( Update your GK ma'am, no mention of Sikhs by him because sikhs, hindus & christians share the common pain.. ISLAM).. let me tell you he is an old senile fool and majority of the mumbaites wish he just konks off at the earliest.

You will not even find 10 hindus lined up for signing themselves up for blowing themselves up at his party headquarters as thousands of muslim youths do at the madrassas in PAKISTAN AFGHANISTAN EGYPT eager to blow themselves and enjoy the goodies they have been promised in paradise.... Thats why his party is not in power in mumbai.. That's sensibility we show.

Thats why you dont see riots in Mumbai after the train blasts and riots in Jaipur after the Jaipur Blasts... Also you mentioned about church bells ringing and temple bells ringing.. I told you how the tables turn in the locations where muslims are in the majority.. For ages we have tried to abolish the heartless slaughter of goats and cows on BAKRI Eid.. but do muslims relent ? THE ANSWER IS NO! but yet in a Muslim populated area , Hindus and others have to be very careful in their festivities because Muslims object . I have personally witnessed riots in my area on diwali and holi . every major festival there is a Police bandobast in our area..

You also mentioned that the people are protecting themselves frrom the ATS and other agencies.. Be specific and have the guts to say MUSLIMS ARE BUSY PROTECTING THEMSELVES FROM THE ATS AND OTHER AGENCIES! we dont have any issues and dont need to protect ourselves from them..they are doing a good job!

It is just the muslim pandering politicians who project that muslims are targetted by the agencies!!! tell me what do they do if every terrorist incidence has a muslim hand? these wretched politicians highlight that only muslim men were convicted in Bomb Blasts.. DO THEY EVER MENTION THAT THE HINDU CUSTOM OFFICERS WHO CLEARED THE RDX CONSIGNMENT WERE ALSO GIVE LIFE SENTENCES AND OUT OF 126 ACCUSSED, 14 WERE LET OFF? no they dont ! its another thing that the custom officers were bribed and convinced that the terrorists were smuggling Gold and silver bars!

See how prophetic my post was.. just the day i posted my earlier response the AMARNATH YATRA WAS STONED IN J&K .. IT IS STILL BIENG STONED AS WE SPEAK.. WE HAVE HAD TERRORISTS GUN DOWN THE YATRIS AND THERE WAS NOT A SINGLE OUTCRY and here we have HAJ subsidy to muslims to visit Mecca.. This subsidy is not even given in Muslim countries but here in India.. Politicians take great pain to see that the Hajis are comfortable , airport has a seperate departure area earmarked from them, special flights are arranged and utmost care is taken for thier wellbeing.. why is this disparity?

India is secular , no doubt about it. but it also knows who is for the country and who aint. Thats why personalities like AAMIR KHAN , APJ KALAM EX PRESIDENT , ( my personal favorite), Irfan PATHAN and scores of others are loved by , millions of Indians .. ( Hindus , christians , sikhs ect). Unfortunately the rabid jehadis are too much in numbers and thats why there is so much of hate against muslims..

You also mentioned about christians who are converting into islam.. you want to know the truth? majority of them convert back in just 3 years... do some research .. And who are the converts? African criminals? convicted people?drug junkies? paedeophiles like Micheal Jackson..?( he has not converted yet but he is thinking about it. read Daniel Pipes Posts on this and see how your In Laws have reacted .They are so happy that they feel lord ram or jesus himself has converted to ISLAM) do you know why? Because it is mentioned in the Quran that if you convert and accept ISLAM, all your Sins will be washed away.. nice incentive ain't it?

Thats why organisations Like the Brotherhood of Islam, Nation of Islam flourishes.. and let me also enlighten you, Muslims convert too.. its just that they dont declare because islam advocates death penalty for converting out. so do you think any sane muslim will declare that he has converted out? Heard about Magdi Aalam? READ HIS BOOK .

You also mentioned about me using some language which is cheap and filthy? just returning the compliments i have recieved from the respected muslim bloggers here Ma'am. by the way quran calls us as INFIDELS APES JAAHILS PIGS etc.. i hope thats fine with you. ( Now dont give that apologist crap that we have misinterpeted the quran.. There cannot be misinetrepretation because quran has to be in its original form.. ) i CHALLENGE YOU TO FIND SUCH REFERENCES IN OTHER RELIGIOUS BOOKS WHO REFER TO PEOPLE OF OTHER FAITHS IN THIS MANNER.

Respect is a two way street ma'am.. Muslims carry a Halo around themselves and each one feels that they are superior in everyway than the infidels and jaahils ( Thats us). Thats probably they feel that they have the right to rule this world.. They dont even abide by the rule of the land.. Sharia is everything.. constitution, country be damned! we dont have any such imperialistic dream.

You talk about US invading other countries? How many of those countries have been converted into christianity? Has US loooted any of the treasures in those countries? it is blowing a lot of its own money this way. I hate US because of this policy.. Let them burn and let them slit each others throat whats we got to do with it?

I have noticed how you cleverly bypassed the issue of Fatwas and other nuances but its ok.. (quoting manusmriti and other outdated books again show the emptiness for your claims and your shallow mind.. ) let me rephrase your manusmriti for you:

1- Three sinful mental actions: i-coveting the property of others ( like the Islamic Raiders did for 750 years against my INDIA ); ii-thinking what is undesirable, (Sharia Law in the entire world) iii- adhering to evil doctrine ( Thats what you are doing while advocating the cult of ISLAM). 2- Four evil verbal actions, i- speaking untruth, ( Potraying Muslims as Victims when they are perpetuators of most hienieous terrorist attackes in all countries ), ii- attacking others in abusive and strong language, ( Like satanic verses in Quran and what the mullahs do on friday sermons), iii- carying tales against other persons, ( what you people are doing in your posts articles etc), iv- talking ill of others, ( Read only the material placed in Quran). 4- # wicked bodily actions, i- taking what is not given, (Conversion of Hindu Temples and chuches into Mosques, Dividing the country on the basis of religion, not allowing otherfaiths to practice i.e partition ) ii- injuring others including living beings, ( see the attacks on America 9/11 Bombay BLast, Madrid & London Blasts.. list is endless!!),iii- illicit intercourse, ( dont ask me where all this is happenning most, 4 wives anyone??? Arabs coming to India to perform MUTHA ( marraiges for 2 months), sexual slavery etc homsexual taliban!! ) . (Manu Smriti XII 3 to 7).

Hope you read this post and revert. Also urge you to read about the formation of Israel and the Middle eastern conflict .Thank you Ma'am


Proud Indian


Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to How does manusmriti relate to the behaviour of christians? by Proud Indian

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List
eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2020 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)