11 readers online now  |  69 million page views

Translations of this item:

Submit a comment on this item

Reader comments (192) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
1Response to your statements about the Quran [90 words]IncognitoJan 30, 2009 09:50149518
111 not 10 wives [133 words]aslam shahidJun 10, 2009 06:37149518
Palestinian Authority Economically Non Viable [127 words]David GoshenApr 20, 2006 14:5443664
Praise to Allah (God) for this awesome article of yours. [16 words]Ahmed Youssif, MDFeb 6, 2006 00:5333895
chavez you are right, [13 words]Sathyan A JohnMar 7, 2006 09:3133895
Rethinking Democracy [126 words]GaryK51188Feb 4, 2006 18:4033778
Democracy, terrorist & idiots [430 words]koFeb 2, 2006 01:3633472
Deputy assistant to the President claims Hamas victory not a failure of democracy [1691 words]Ben van de PolderFeb 1, 2006 22:0633465
It is not the crucible [200 words]yuval brandstetter MDFeb 5, 2006 08:2833465
Why is the West blind to the underlying reasons?? [186 words]HoomanFeb 1, 2006 17:1633443
1Give Hamas a chance [235 words]Galal MohammediFeb 1, 2006 13:5333413
yes, you're right...but... [102 words]italianFeb 1, 2006 15:3433413
Mr. Galal Mohammedi is to be congratulated [12 words]chester spinkJun 18, 2007 22:3133413
The 'moderate Muslim ' is a poliitcal artifact [203 words]Paul ChristopherFeb 1, 2006 06:5533376
Arabs, Nazis, and de-Nazification [292 words]Michael GreengardJan 31, 2006 13:4733285
This is one of your best articles [43 words]John BarrettJan 30, 2006 20:0433182
hamas won the election now we have to find ways to communicate [193 words]richard EJan 30, 2006 14:5533128
we have to find ways to communicate... Hamas, you won democratically, so kill me democratically! [308 words]IanusJan 30, 2006 18:5533128
Democracy to Theocratic Dictatorship [149 words]joeJan 31, 2006 17:0133128
When Will We Learn Not to Meddle [128 words]Alice LillieJan 30, 2006 09:4233100
Re : America Would Still Be Attacked Even If We Did Not Meddle [61 words]AnneMJan 30, 2006 16:4133100
Do not fall for al Qaeda propaganda [429 words]SiddaJan 31, 2006 09:4133100
Do not fall for al Qaeda propaganda [84 words]IanusJan 31, 2006 15:5933100
Israeli Dhimmis [69 words]SiddaFeb 1, 2006 09:0833100
Israeli Dhimmis [211 words]IanusFeb 1, 2006 19:1233100
Democracy Only works when the people create it [428 words]JoeJan 29, 2006 23:1033066
A new Hamas "state" [118 words]PigfootJan 29, 2006 21:1233061
The Hamas election - a possible victory for the West? [615 words]ron thompsonJan 29, 2006 15:4933030
Hamas's Election Victory [300 words]Ed GordonJan 29, 2006 13:0133018
Bush reaction to Hamas victory - does the shoe fit? [209 words]Gunther SteinbergJan 29, 2006 12:5533017
Question [86 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
William SchnitzJan 29, 2006 10:1833006
that pithy comment: Watch Hamas rebrand [504 words]JaneJan 29, 2006 08:1332993
Stability is not the answer [144 words]Yossi Ben-AharonJan 29, 2006 07:5632992
Democracy Now? [225 words]John Randall PeacherJan 29, 2006 07:1332990
West must cross the arms in front of Hamas [96 words]ItalianJan 29, 2006 04:3332983
1Europe its going down like the Titanic [362 words]OcJan 29, 2006 02:1532977
wrong [177 words]aliOct 6, 2008 05:0032977
America is digging hard it's own grave. [228 words]F. ShakkiJan 29, 2006 00:1132970
Non sequitur - Hamas and Democracy [37 words]Marc HandelsmanJan 28, 2006 23:0832968
Faulty Assumptions Paralyze Israel and the West [243 words]Joel HammerJan 28, 2006 17:3432958
Islam' s 1400 year success Story [99 words]Elephant WalkJan 28, 2006 14:3532950
Can Democracy Save the Middle East? [255 words]Frank VoslerJan 28, 2006 13:5732948
JIhad and Islam [333 words]VinodguptJan 29, 2006 12:2832948
War on Propaganda [144 words]Stephan BenedictJan 28, 2006 11:3432936
No one saw this coming, why not? [313 words]Kenneth S. BesigJan 28, 2006 11:3232935
To Mr. Bezig [39 words]RBJan 29, 2006 14:0432935
Defeating Jihad [132 words]Frank VoslerJan 28, 2006 10:5632928
Defeating islam [312 words]edJan 29, 2006 13:1032928
Ed, open your eyes [188 words]joeJan 29, 2006 23:2332928
Eyes wide Open [259 words]edJan 31, 2006 17:2532928
Eyes wide Open ... minds too. [504 words]IanusFeb 1, 2006 17:5432928
More like close minded [679 words]edFeb 2, 2006 08:3532928
RE ed [676 words]joeFeb 2, 2006 18:2132928
Islam as mental crippling [1700 words]IanusFeb 2, 2006 20:1332928
Ianus, you absolutely GOT IT. Hey Light, Get thee to Gehenna [214 words]joeFeb 3, 2006 02:5632928
Re Joe [538 words]edFeb 3, 2006 10:0732928
From Dark to light [185 words]edFeb 3, 2006 10:3632928
re: ed [381 words]JoeFeb 3, 2006 18:5232928
Joe, your opinion counts doubly. [287 words]IanusFeb 4, 2006 06:3832928
"Homo sapiens' versus 'homo Islamicus' [686 words]IanusFeb 4, 2006 07:4332928
re re: Joe [952 words]edFeb 4, 2006 16:3032928
Ed, Ed, Ed... [665 words]JoeFeb 6, 2006 18:4432928
Three times like the candy man [1299 words]edFeb 7, 2006 12:1532928
reaction [189 words]SaraNov 2, 2011 07:3932928
Hamas winning is a good thing. [204 words]Paul BJan 28, 2006 10:1032922
Pros & Cons of this new management [82 words]B. AlotaibiJan 29, 2006 14:2632922
Hamas [1416 words]Sameer JordanJan 28, 2006 08:3832916
German/Japan Models [108 words]Paul M. NevilleJan 28, 2006 07:3132912
If ever there was a Declaration of war, this is is! [55 words]Victor LipshutzJan 28, 2006 07:3032911
The Will of the People [286 words]JonJan 28, 2006 05:1332899
Muslim world is heading for confrontation [474 words]Amitabh tripathiJan 28, 2006 03:5732896
we are all missing the point [216 words]GuyJan 28, 2006 03:1832893
West's dependence on dodgy regimes [156 words]MikeJan 30, 2006 09:3032893
Hitler's "Election" [71 words]P John WeirJan 28, 2006 01:4432883
A history by the winner [129 words]HarrakJan 28, 2006 10:5332883
A history by the winner?... Muslim history! [626 words]IanusJan 31, 2006 08:2832883
Real electoral victory or debacle ? [244 words]NENETTE GRUNBERGJan 28, 2006 00:1932876
Ask why [207 words]HishamJan 28, 2006 00:1532873
Let's end our foreign aid. [46 words]Vivian E. WolfeJan 28, 2006 00:0132871
Conclusion correct; analysis dubious [183 words]Melvin A. FechterJan 27, 2006 23:4232869
Hamas and Democracy [167 words]Bill StoreyJan 27, 2006 23:0832868
Hamas: The legacy of the Bush/Clinton failure [183 words]Thomas Earl CannadyJan 27, 2006 22:2732867
Dictatorship failed, can democracy be any worse? [215 words]PatJan 27, 2006 22:1832866
No Surprise [109 words]Darwin BarrettJan 27, 2006 20:3932861
What Hoist? [247 words]Peter G JonesJan 27, 2006 19:4632859
What Hoist? [70 words]IanusJan 28, 2006 07:3432859
In victory brings the responsibilities of governance [208 words]jack adamsJan 27, 2006 19:3932858
The defeat of reason in the Middle East. [65 words]robert finkJan 27, 2006 19:3532857
The Hamas Victory [174 words]Yale ZussmanJan 27, 2006 18:3532830
The consequence of a Hamas Victory [203 words]Seamus MacNemiJan 27, 2006 18:2632827
Terrorist tail wags the Israeli dog: HAMAS [167 words]Mark-Alan WhittleJan 27, 2006 17:4632817
Finally a realistic "authority" in the PA [143 words]mike in LansdowneJan 27, 2006 17:4132816
Swapping places? [148 words]IanusJan 31, 2006 09:1732816
The more things change the more they stay the same [334 words]John W. McGinleyJan 27, 2006 17:3932815
Germany was a democracy before WWII [47 words]Dave KessingerJan 27, 2006 17:0732813
1Terrorism is built in Islam [148 words]N. KhanJan 27, 2006 16:4132804
West is fooling itself [119 words]VinodguptJan 27, 2006 17:4632804
Re: Terrorism is built in Islam [660 words]R.Jan 27, 2006 19:2532804
accept the freedom and democracy with all your heart ..long live hamas [88 words]mohammad the muslimJan 28, 2006 04:0632804
Response to R, muslim translations are mostly politically correct [633 words]N.KhanJan 30, 2006 15:5832804
How many radical muslims are there? [71 words]KarlaJan 27, 2006 16:3532794
How many radical muslims are there? or on depicting Islam [108 words]IanusJan 27, 2006 18:2132794
Re: Why Should Christians Care? [70 words]J PincusJan 27, 2006 16:3132786
No Aid for Palestinians [145 words]Romesh ChanderJan 27, 2006 16:0932782
israels hand forced [67 words]harry oconnorJan 27, 2006 18:3932782
RE: israels hand forced [101 words]IanusJan 28, 2006 16:4632782
Palistnians called the bluff. [166 words]RenchJan 27, 2006 16:0232780
Palestinian voters, the product of Arafat [104 words]TommyJan 27, 2006 15:2432774
Why should Christians Care ? [293 words]Jeff BurkeJan 27, 2006 14:5932769
Re: Jeff Burke's remarks [355 words]John W. McGinleyJan 28, 2006 16:2732769
ISRAEL - PEACE - SURVIVAL, NOT GENOCIDE! [re: Carter] [4412 words]AlNov 20, 2007 03:2632769
Hamas victory [126 words]steven lJan 27, 2006 14:5032766
No to appeasement [195 words]Jason PappasJan 27, 2006 14:4732765
Hamas, terror [19 words]steven lJan 27, 2006 15:1832765
You are right about Hamas [138 words]Muriel EfronJan 27, 2006 14:4532764
When the petard is hoist, not only the engineer may be injured [187 words]Gunther H. SchiffJan 27, 2006 14:2832762
What can West show Palestinians? [178 words]BorisJan 27, 2006 14:2232761
Hello? Hello? Planet earth? Is there any intelligent life here? [270 words]PDMJan 27, 2006 13:5332759
Meet the New Boss. Same as the Old Boss [102 words]ElliotJan 27, 2006 13:5332758
Facing a State of Hate [154 words]Chris BischofJan 27, 2006 13:4732757
Democracy & Islam [321 words]IbrodskyJan 27, 2006 13:4532756
'Moderate muslim' [93 words]Romesh ChanderJan 27, 2006 14:5732756
'Moderate muslim' [42 words]IanusJan 27, 2006 18:0832756
Peace after total defeat of islamists [49 words]B. AlotaibiJan 27, 2006 13:4332755
Hamas/Islam [195 words]Paul RinderleJan 27, 2006 13:3232754
Election of HAMAS [36 words]A.A.Jan 27, 2006 13:2932753
Hamas election [516 words]Merl Francis KimmelJan 27, 2006 13:2932752
Re Hamas Election [573 words]EdJan 27, 2006 18:0632752
Re Hamas Elections [71 words]Ed_nurJan 27, 2006 18:1332752
"the heaviest chains' ... or a slave's eulogy of slavery [239 words]IanusJan 28, 2006 10:3932752
Re Hamas Election or a syllogism [124 words]IanusJan 28, 2006 12:5432752
Renan [608 words]Ed NurJan 28, 2006 21:2032752
Renan or "research" [998 words]IanusJan 29, 2006 18:2132752
Ed Nur's confusion [657 words]Merl Francis KimmelJan 29, 2006 20:3432752
Neither, Infinite Knowledge [866 words]edJan 31, 2006 19:3832752
The light of faith or the obscurity of knowledge [2213 words]IanusFeb 1, 2006 09:3532752
love not hate [1004 words]EdFeb 2, 2006 07:3032752
Stupid pagans, wise Moslems ... an idyll [563 words]IanusFeb 2, 2006 20:5832752
wise ed [164 words]edFeb 3, 2006 11:0932752
Wise ed... stupid Ianus ...or on honest farewells [723 words]IanusFeb 4, 2006 09:1232752
The Hamas Electoral Victory: Democracy's bitter fruit [95 words]Menahem DunskyJan 27, 2006 13:2032750
Hamas, etc. [64 words]Dave MitchellJan 27, 2006 13:1832749
Hamas Electoral Victory-The Missing Factor in the Analysis [107 words]JAJan 27, 2006 13:0432747
Yes, It Is Islam [169 words]Mike RamirezJan 27, 2006 13:0432746
misinformation and misconception about ISlam [279 words]Aslam ShahidJun 4, 2009 09:3132746
INCITEMENT for DUMMIES [47 words]Bob BreslauerJan 27, 2006 12:5332744
disagree [204 words]DanJan 27, 2006 12:5332743
He was NOT voted in. [299 words]Paul MasonJan 27, 2006 12:5232742
Clarity [76 words]Yaakov WatkinsJan 27, 2006 12:5032740
Hamas and Democracy [87 words]Romesh ChanderJan 27, 2006 12:4932739
Hamas [10 words]Joe RobinsonJan 27, 2006 12:2632736
Remeber Weimar [242 words]Frank AdamJan 27, 2006 12:2632735
Remember Weimar [175 words]IanusJan 27, 2006 16:0432735
Yes, but....Jihad [586 words]Thomas W. MillsJan 27, 2006 12:1132734
No Peace [371 words]howlinJan 27, 2006 12:0832733
A good result [321 words]Victor PurintonJan 27, 2006 12:0432732
The dumbing down of democracy [515 words]janeJan 27, 2006 12:0432731
Crush them like Nazis [75 words][The Hamas electoral victory:] Democracy's bitter fruitJan 27, 2006 11:5632730
But what about... [216 words]David HodgesJan 27, 2006 11:5632729
What about this? [111 words]David W. LincolnJan 27, 2006 11:5232728
Hamas victory and elections [356 words]VinodguptJan 27, 2006 11:5032727
peace [304 words]abd_abdalJan 27, 2006 17:5832727
If peace is war,slavery is freedom, then Islam is tolerance. [470 words]IanusJan 28, 2006 07:0732727
Jesus was recogonized only after his departure [119 words]abd_abdalJan 29, 2006 15:1232727
Rewarding Terror [131 words]JeffJan 27, 2006 11:5032726
Slow down? or move faster. [88 words]Steve K.Jan 27, 2006 11:4332725
Nothing has changed! [296 words]JohnJan 27, 2006 11:3932724
Iran is more of a threat than Hamas [20 words]meredithJan 28, 2006 09:1432724
agree on all except 2 points [238 words]HarrakJan 27, 2006 11:3732723
If only! [155 words]keithJan 27, 2006 17:5932723
It is not Islam [323 words]Steve KleinJan 27, 2006 11:2832721
Financial aid to Hamas? [45 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Leonard BoasbergJan 27, 2006 11:2132719
allow hamas to grow! [166 words]david bryanJan 27, 2006 11:1432716
Too soon to tell.......... [101 words]DrewJan 27, 2006 11:1132715
The Silver Lining [396 words]J HarrisJan 27, 2006 11:0232712
Which way now? [202 words]Robert ShererJan 27, 2006 11:0232711
1933 Redux [76 words]Ben KurtzerJan 27, 2006 10:5032710
Democracies do make war on each other [121 words]Melvin HinichJan 27, 2006 10:4832709
Hinich and History [120 words]WalterJan 27, 2006 15:3532709
Hinich and History ...or on warlike democracies [305 words]IanusJan 27, 2006 16:2832709
More on Hinich; Respone to Ianus [88 words]WalterJan 29, 2006 08:3832709
Democracies do make war on each other [833 words]IanusJan 29, 2006 16:4232709
Wishful thinking [41 words]Edward Margulies, M.D.Jan 27, 2006 10:4832708
With Respect Mr. Pipes, I disagree [120 words]Arnold J. WolfJan 27, 2006 10:4532707
RESPONSE TO HAMAS [144 words]DONVANJan 27, 2006 10:4432706
Islam is the problem [54 words]DonnaJan 27, 2006 10:2432705
islam is not the problem [113 words]edJan 31, 2006 18:0332705
Hamas & Iran [37 words]Gary MillerJan 27, 2006 10:1632703
A Nation of ....... [224 words]JohnJan 27, 2006 10:0432701
The true nature of the Arabs [154 words]Michael SavittJan 27, 2006 09:5432698
Things to come [125 words]AbrahamJan 27, 2006 09:3432696
Muslims and democracy [425 words]S. PetreaJan 30, 2006 00:4332696

Comment on this item

Name
Email Address (optional)
Title of Comments
Comments:

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

ADVERTISEMENTS

eXTReMe Tracker

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials written by Daniel Pipes on this site © 1968-2014 Daniel Pipes. Email: daniel.pipes@gmail.com

You can help support Daniel Pipes' work by making a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum. Daniel J. Pipes