69 million page views

even better

Reader comment on item: How Israel Can Win
in response to reader comment: Whyever not?

Submitted by yuval brandstetter MD (Israel), Apr 15, 2006 at 07:42

The problem does not end with the Arabs occupying the mountainous Judea and Samaria. The problem is intesified by the fact that Israel, within the 1949 armistice lines (not borders, merely armistice) contains close to 1.5 million Arabs, who identify themselves fully as Palestinians. Their Anschluss demand is that ancestral Israel, that is the mountain land, be made Juden-rein, as a prequisite to any negotiations. Only then will negotiations begin for the millions who claim to have been routed out of Mandatory Palestine. That is not a Russina roulette, with five empty chambers. That is Auschwitz roulette as to who shall live after the invasion of the blood-thirsty invasion.
Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (219) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
1Eleven Years Ago & Now: Strategy Accept, Time for Tactics [380 words]RobertJan 26, 2017 21:38235872
No need to pull your punches in the Middle East [472 words]WartySep 10, 2016 23:27232538
Bravo! [26 words]Wallace BrandSep 10, 2016 22:27232535
How Israel Can Win [776 words]DillahSep 15, 2009 15:13161562
How Israel Can Win. [110 words]DebbieJan 15, 2009 11:42148118
Crybabies [65 words]AJul 17, 2008 01:44135315
Never Ending Struggle [17 words]An indifferent observerDec 11, 2007 12:51116021
Defeat and Disbursement [161 words]Jonathan UsherJul 16, 2006 14:2249825
Will it and win it [109 words]SoundNov 21, 2006 19:4549825
Too many concessions [117 words]Alyn StarkmanFeb 26, 2007 11:5249825
Please do not interfere! [106 words]Arial FlorianJun 18, 2006 01:5247847
? [51 words]Catherine MosesApr 27, 2006 15:1644342
Border question for Dr Pipes [25 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
HarrakApr 20, 2006 20:5043676
Eliminating Israel??? [513 words]SoundNov 23, 2006 12:2043676
The object of War [65 words]Matthew RensenApr 19, 2006 12:0343570
i wish you would understand [146 words]MOHAMMAD ARFAQApr 18, 2006 23:1543537
re: crushing wills [581 words]true believerApr 21, 2006 06:1943537
Not be "aggressive"??? [167 words]Ruth LowryMay 16, 2006 17:2843537
The world is governed by ... [202 words]Johnnie AnglerJun 9, 2006 23:1143537
Get the "palestinians" out.... [66 words]Pork ChopJun 30, 2006 16:4643537
Not be aggressive? [24 words]F. FryeSep 23, 2006 07:0243537
I wish that.... [138 words]David BrotskyApr 18, 2006 12:4043480
True victory [278 words]Ian SmithApr 17, 2006 09:0943377
Stop the Violence [54 words]Calvin CarterMay 4, 2006 14:4343377
the meaning of deterrence [123 words]yonatan silvermanApr 16, 2006 07:0343284
Good Lord.... [97 words]Bryan JacksonApr 16, 2006 21:3243284
re: good Lord [254 words]true believerApr 18, 2006 04:5943284
Re: True Believer [64 words]Bryan JacksonApr 18, 2006 20:1643284
How Israel can win [142 words]H. YazdiApr 12, 2006 21:0643075
If victory for Israel means defeat for Palestine. [113 words]John BergApr 11, 2006 21:3542983
The ultimate victory for all will be when..... [409 words]Bryan JacksonApr 11, 2006 10:3042915
bryan jackson [32 words]ahmad zafireApr 11, 2006 21:5042915
stop lying [29 words]jamesMay 26, 2006 10:5142915
Israel can win, if it has the spine to. [511 words]JasonApr 11, 2006 09:5442914
too harsh ;-) [560 words]true believerApr 18, 2006 09:3642914
You squared a circle [165 words]SullyApr 18, 2006 18:2642914
re: squared circle [250 words]true believerApr 21, 2006 03:5242914
to Jason and true believer# Israel is acting stupid [238 words]Silent ObserverApr 28, 2006 05:1642914
Whyever not? [442 words]yuval brandstetterApr 10, 2006 16:3342872
The Sudetenland analogy [290 words]Jeff in USAApr 11, 2006 20:1442872
even better [109 words]yuval brandstetter MDApr 15, 2006 07:4242872
forced population relocation = war crime !!!! [137 words]PhilistineJul 28, 2006 22:5042872
I can't beleive this.. [267 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
AndrewApr 10, 2006 11:0442849
Andrew's outrage founded on ignorance [377 words]InfidelApr 17, 2006 01:0242849
Israel has no muslim significance [105 words]William UKApr 20, 2006 18:0142849
New age rage. [57 words]SilentDec 5, 2006 14:3342849
Ben Gurion`s point of view on the issue [39 words]HarrakApr 9, 2006 19:1342811
Palestinian Arab war morale [46 words]Paul M. NevilleApr 9, 2006 10:5742790
On the contrary - crushing all muslims is all too feasible [229 words]SullyApr 9, 2006 20:0742790
Ignorance of the laws of the creation [219 words]BilalApr 10, 2006 14:5242790
To Bilal : Don't be too sure of India and China's support [54 words]Arvind MadhavanApr 11, 2006 04:1842790
Bilal - you have a fine memory for ancient history but a selective memory for recent events [199 words]sullyApr 12, 2006 09:1042790
2Muslim Menace in Chechnya , Kashmir & Xingxiang : Reply to Bilal [149 words]MichaelJul 21, 2006 09:5842790
Israel must stop granting sanctuary to those who produce the killers [189 words]SullyApr 9, 2006 01:4242760
How will we retain or Jewish and Democratic state? [124 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Zeev RaphaelApr 8, 2006 01:4342688
A response to Ze'ev Raphael [129 words]SevileApr 10, 2006 15:5342688
I think you're both (slightly) wrong here... [262 words]J.S.Apr 11, 2006 17:0142688
palestinian duplicity [37 words]edApr 8, 2006 01:0942687
Israel has no other choice but victory [163 words]Richard Lion heartApr 8, 2006 00:0042686
A Few Thoughts [775 words]orange yonasonApr 7, 2006 17:2742655
May be they can try this Win- Pill [240 words]HarrakApr 7, 2006 08:3942610
To Harrak [53 words]L AmcheslavskyApr 9, 2006 12:2642610
My democracy Vs your theocracy [71 words]HarrakApr 9, 2006 19:2442610
How about the bitter pill of Islam? [145 words]BarbaraApr 10, 2006 17:3742610
the difference [53 words]HarrakApr 12, 2006 09:0442610
re : Harrak [237 words]true believerApr 18, 2006 06:3942610
When is a Defeat, A Defeat? [276 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Fred SchlomkaApr 7, 2006 06:0042606
Islamist Supporters [334 words]Pusyamitra SungaApr 7, 2006 05:2542604
Prophesy: Disproving or Co-opting ? [405 words]TeagueApr 6, 2006 20:5742587
Know who you are dealing with [153 words]SimpletonApr 6, 2006 20:5142586
You raised a good point Simpleton [61 words]B. AlotaibiApr 8, 2006 13:0342586
Only one way to contain the walking bombs [101 words]PatApr 9, 2006 14:4342586
To commenters- What in the World [88 words]BlackspeareApr 6, 2006 20:2342584
Israel v. "Palestinians"? [57 words]Aaron WaxlerApr 6, 2006 16:0242567
Israel vs. Palestine [438 words]Bryan JacksonApr 6, 2006 15:3142562
Bryan. Israel citizenship for palestinians? [168 words]Farid H.Apr 6, 2006 21:5242562
To Farid [221 words]Bryan JacksonApr 11, 2006 12:4342562
can Israel win? [89 words]JAIME EISENApr 6, 2006 15:0142557
mechanical problem in your capital letter mini-lecture [90 words]HARRAKApr 6, 2006 16:1142557
Infidels [120 words]B. AlotaibiApr 6, 2006 17:5642557
Kurds..the unfortunate nation, but not nation state.. [219 words]HarrakApr 8, 2006 13:1242557
re.harrak [173 words]samAug 14, 2006 13:1242557
bravo! [216 words]john w mcginleyApr 6, 2006 13:2942551
Who is the winner as people die from the both sides? [37 words]NurayApr 6, 2006 11:0842542
How Israel and humanity can only win by 'soft-power'. [531 words]Lucky O'DalyApr 6, 2006 08:5242535
Dr. Pipes, you are "right on"! [98 words]Carmen Waggoner, Ph.D.Apr 6, 2006 07:5942532
War without end [196 words]Rebecca BynumApr 6, 2006 07:4842530
What insight! [45 words]Lisa MuskalApr 6, 2006 07:2942529
Don't Rule out the Transfer Option [1085 words]Moshe BrodyApr 6, 2006 04:5842523
Thanks, Moshe Brody [9 words]orange yonasonApr 7, 2006 18:2542523
right on [23 words]yuval brandstetterApr 10, 2006 16:4642523
Israel Must Act [137 words]J GlueckApr 6, 2006 00:2842506
israel [28 words]Ajay Singh ChohanApr 5, 2006 23:1442503
Individual vs. collective psychology [319 words]Farid H.Apr 5, 2006 22:1442499
Farid: Very astute... [270 words]WilliamApr 6, 2006 01:3242499
To William. Psychology, Israel, critique of Islam... [886 words]Farid H.Apr 6, 2006 21:2342499
Farid: Thanks for your thoughts on Islam... [68 words]WilliamApr 7, 2006 20:0942499
re : Farid [73 words]true believerApr 18, 2006 08:4842499
Great post Farid [82 words]TeriApr 23, 2006 11:2242499
To Farid [148 words]TarekApr 30, 2006 00:3642499
separation of islam and the state [172 words]raheel khokharSep 25, 2006 07:1942499
reaction to Farid H [277 words]Jerry KRothOct 1, 2006 08:0242499
Islam [11 words]walter f. piccaOct 17, 2014 17:0942499
rough them up [148 words]anonymizerApr 5, 2006 21:3842498
ALL OR NOTHING AT ALL--CUT THE GORDIAN'S KNOT [846 words]martin kesslerApr 5, 2006 20:3442496
"Winning" [120 words]NoahApr 5, 2006 20:1742494
What it will take [200 words]Darwin BarrettApr 5, 2006 19:5642493
The Peace Response NEVER Tried by Israel [132 words]HERB A.Apr 5, 2006 19:3942491
wrong on two counts [74 words]yuval brandstetterApr 10, 2006 16:5342491
1We WERE winning [327 words]yehuda Ben-AsherApr 17, 2006 13:3042491
Kol Hakavod [50 words]Hadassah HershApr 5, 2006 17:1242476
No More Ceasefires [106 words]Noah NewmanApr 5, 2006 16:2842472
Not even... [83 words]Taj AshaheedApr 6, 2006 04:5242472
PT [12 words]ahmadzafireApr 7, 2006 18:0242472
Un-Transfer Transfer [321 words]Yehoshua MizrachiApr 5, 2006 15:5142469
How Israel will win [448 words]Yale ZussmanApr 5, 2006 13:0742466
Excellent Analysis, Zale! [95 words]J.S.Apr 5, 2006 17:2542466
Israel's response [92 words]Steve V GureApr 5, 2006 12:2442464
The Moral Dimension [267 words]EdApr 5, 2006 11:2342457
UNECESSARY [72 words]CHONI DAVIDOWITZApr 5, 2006 10:2742451
Why America does not let Israel win. [275 words]Maurice PicowApr 5, 2006 10:0042445
Rarely said but true !!!!!!!!! [40 words]George HaasApr 5, 2006 08:4842440
A small start [103 words]David M.Sokol, M.D.Apr 5, 2006 08:2642437
Hamas's victory will pave the way for Israel's victory [224 words]Octavio JohansonApr 5, 2006 07:5242432
Your Recent Article about an Israeli Victory [246 words]Leonard MarkowitzApr 5, 2006 07:4142430
Another consideration [119 words]Yair WeinstockApr 5, 2006 07:4042429
2 States - very Simple Formula - IF NO ONE DO POLITICS [773 words]Muhammad_Jesus_Moses_AdamApr 5, 2006 04:2742416
Only Jews should be citizens of Israel [58 words]Gershon Ben DanielApr 5, 2006 03:1442411
Agree completely [110 words]William J. SturmApr 5, 2006 02:4042409
Your talks in Melbourne [260 words]MICHAEL BURDApr 5, 2006 02:2742408
History of the problem [416 words]Jeff in USAApr 5, 2006 02:2742407
The siezed land argument [154 words]Bader SApr 6, 2006 07:0842407
Conflict resolution and Games Theory [270 words]SHmuel HaLeviApr 5, 2006 00:3242403
How do we achieve victory? [80 words]Elisha GalonApr 5, 2006 09:2742403
How Israel can win the war: What war? [149 words]GregApr 4, 2006 23:4642401
Take a more enlightened view [255 words]J.SalasApr 4, 2006 23:4642400
I am all for a more enlightened view! [222 words]Salomon BenzimraApr 5, 2006 05:4142400
ancestral lands [124 words]yuval brandstetter MDApr 11, 2006 10:5742400
Jews have long history in arab world [173 words]JasonApr 11, 2006 11:3742400
Palestinans? [83 words]Elaine NugentApr 4, 2006 23:4042399
Jewish Palestinians [26 words]Ian LovestockApr 5, 2006 10:5042399
Population transfer [392 words]Jeff in USAApr 4, 2006 23:3642398
The expulsion doctrine [109 words]Bader SApr 5, 2006 05:1742398
Victory [168 words]Milton Fried, MDApr 4, 2006 23:3542397
Time to teach the Saudis a lesson in humility. [238 words]batya daganApr 4, 2006 22:2042393
Ten Questions: What's wrong with the Saudis? [173 words]RPaineApr 5, 2006 05:3742393
Answers to your ten questions. [436 words]Kevin MApr 6, 2006 12:3242393
Thanks for the insight Kevin M [277 words]RPaineApr 6, 2006 21:3642393
A moral defeat [2 words]JoeApr 4, 2006 22:0542391
How Israel Can't Win [159 words]BlackspeareApr 4, 2006 21:5042389
How Israel can win!! [87 words]HARRAKApr 4, 2006 21:1942386
Israel [54 words]Donald W. BalesApr 4, 2006 21:0042384
What about Islam? [257 words]PTApr 4, 2006 20:5942383
It is all about Islam [79 words]Octavio JohansonApr 10, 2006 06:1342383
This response [140 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
SteveGWApr 4, 2006 20:4142382
2No one has to leave their homes ... [95 words]david singerApr 4, 2006 20:2542379
israel must win [206 words]robert fusfeldApr 4, 2006 20:0642376
israeli victory [31 words]ralphApr 4, 2006 19:0142372
How Israel Can Win [223 words]Pastor Jim ScanlonApr 4, 2006 18:5242371
Brillant, Lets go forward and be victorious [47 words]Michael HevajraApr 4, 2006 18:2642367
Palestinian is not only arabs ...!! [99 words]ASYApr 4, 2006 18:1242363
The will to be free [221 words]Bader SApr 4, 2006 18:0742362
The attack has to be on Islam for the World to be safe [54 words]Stuart C. JacksonApr 4, 2006 17:5442358
How Israel Can Win---They Must, but.... [191 words]H I WinterApr 4, 2006 17:4542355
What about Iran? [28 words]LeahApr 4, 2006 17:0542354
which are beyond the technology of the USA and Israel [28 words]Roy GallagerJul 6, 2009 08:3942354
the NGO network that bashes Israel is fostered by outdated UN policies [213 words]David J. BardinApr 4, 2006 16:5942352
Keep on keeping the truth out there. [40 words]victoria shumanApr 4, 2006 16:3642348
Israel must win [110 words]gerald BlumeApr 4, 2006 16:2442345
I agree most of the time, but... [191 words]AnonApr 4, 2006 16:0042340
Too Much Sense [64 words]Dr. Lee D. CaryApr 4, 2006 15:5342339
long time coming wisdom [50 words]maksmanApr 4, 2006 16:2042339
How Israel Can Win [330 words]RichApr 4, 2006 15:4742337
I also agree...HOWEVER.... [437 words]J.S.Apr 4, 2006 15:4642336
Defeating the Palestinians [101 words]Alan SkorskiApr 4, 2006 15:4142334
The solution has been there all along [133 words]David W. LincolnApr 4, 2006 15:3842333
Israel must win. [43 words]Jacob Goldberg, MDApr 4, 2006 15:3842332
Can not convince Palestinians they have lost [50 words]Norman RosenblattApr 4, 2006 15:3642331
Gaza [75 words]Bader SApr 4, 2006 18:2342331
The "Palestinians"cannot win [114 words]Elaine NugentApr 5, 2006 12:3242331
GREAT ARTICLE [24 words]DONVANApr 4, 2006 15:3542330
Paradigm shift [108 words]Hilary LindApr 4, 2006 15:2742327
Israel is losing the war [32 words]Obied KhanApr 4, 2006 15:5242327
Everyone is losing, Mr. Khan [111 words]Dr. Lee D. CaryApr 4, 2006 16:2542327
What you say here is true, but ... [223 words]Melvin A. FechterApr 4, 2006 15:2642326
There's only one way to convince Palestinians -- threat of eviction! [496 words]Dr RJPApr 4, 2006 15:2342325
Could Israel be hated more? [524 words]SJBApr 4, 2006 22:3942325
US vs Iran [76 words]Bob MilliganApr 4, 2006 14:5542321
Iran is a bullet that entered the heart of the 21st century, removing it will cost the life of the heart [176 words]HARRAKApr 5, 2006 10:0442321
Iran is Aryan [167 words]Octavio JohansonApr 5, 2006 18:1242321
Shihab 5, target: Aryan [155 words]HARRAKApr 6, 2006 10:0442321
Indian High caste are also Aryan [35 words]DalitApr 6, 2006 14:3842321
To Octavio [153 words]VijayApr 7, 2006 10:2842321
What is Iran without the Russian infidel? [189 words]Richard Lion heartApr 7, 2006 23:4842321
Indian Aryans links with Iranians [120 words]Dalit SenaApr 8, 2006 05:0042321
Aryan and Indian / Jew History [206 words]Dalit Lal JatavApr 8, 2006 05:5742321
Harrak's language [141 words]Octavio JohansonApr 9, 2006 11:0342321
Iranian Anti-Semitism [92 words]Octavio JohansonApr 9, 2006 17:4242321
Semantics [149 words]VijayApr 11, 2006 05:3642321
Re:semantics [73 words]Octavio JohansonApr 11, 2006 18:1942321
re : all [186 words]true believerApr 21, 2006 06:5442321
Persia or Iran [147 words]SteceNov 26, 2006 04:4442321
The story is faulty [20 words]Gilbert FernandesJan 13, 2007 14:5342321
Relearn your history [159 words]AnnJul 4, 2007 07:4042321
1Iran original name [32 words]cherry mostesharAug 22, 2007 18:1742321
review the history before [207 words]babakNov 12, 2007 01:3742321
The root of Persia name. [450 words]katyJun 11, 2008 23:5642321
Iran is NOT named after German "Aryans". [209 words]KLANOct 24, 2008 22:3342321
1Erroneous [40 words]Mahmood ( Iranian )Jan 20, 2009 07:1442321
KING REZA SHAH [38 words]Jo GAug 18, 2009 19:0242321
1Iranians racial identity [187 words]aryans in IranMar 20, 2010 16:2942321
Ignorance [25 words]Omeed ADec 8, 2010 23:5542321
Iranian Historical Facts [157 words]A.B.Dec 30, 2012 16:5442321
Yes!!! [122 words]Judith SinclairApr 4, 2006 14:4942319
ISRAEL MUST WIN [73 words]Sam MoharebApr 4, 2006 14:4042318
I disagree [72 words]Albert GreenApr 4, 2006 14:1942315
Total Agreement! [64 words]Albert E. Roth IIIApr 4, 2006 14:1542314
1Agreement [69 words]Donald F. PufahlApr 4, 2006 14:0842313
Yes, But Remember.......... [207 words]William J. SturmApr 5, 2006 03:0542313

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)