69 million page views

Salah Ali: Your sufi ramblings end with a show of your Islamic fangs

Reader comment on item: Niqabs and Burqas - The Veiled Threat Continues
in response to reader comment: How things will look in Afterlife

Submitted by Plato (India), Oct 14, 2009 at 08:55

Salah Ali, you write,

>>Christianity is not religion. It is a sort of triology similar to that of pagan religions of India.<<

Christianity is not a religion. Religions of India are not religions. Can you name any religion other than Islam? What is wrong with pagan religions?

>>Jesus X however is one prophet of Islam whom the Jews distorted for fear their Yahweh may disappear.<<

The Jewish book existed centuries before the Koran. Logically, it is the Koran that distorted the story of Jesus to suit Mohammed's ego, as he needed to be on an equal footing with Jesus.

>> Who could the body and spirit be united after death. Death is of the body and Jesus is just a creature of flesh who died for no man's sins.<<

How does Allah reacreate people in the billions on judgment day? Are you doubting Allah's powers?

>>God could not be as stupid to get incarnated into transient material such as the horse of the body.would God eat, sleep and go to WC? <<

But Allah did blow his "rooh" into a woman to bring forth Jesus. Is His "rooh" also transient?

>>The Jewish God is also as idiotic because how could a sane God fight with his own people?<<

The Muslim god is equally idiotic. He claims he made Jews as His chosen people and later on discovers they were not deserving of the title and transfered it to Muslims (what happened to His powers of seeing into the future or His design capabilities?) He curses and abuses them and condemns them to hell.

>>Allah Blessed Be His Name sipport Moslems early fights with invisible warriors from heavens.<<

The Blessed Allah seems to have got tired of helping Muslims in their fights. Or His angel army has gone of strike tired of constantly (1400 years) having to massacre innocent unbelievers.

>>I am dead sure, the End of Time is nearing and 313 holymen including Jesus and Moslem Saint, Elias and unknown simple mystics will approach Jerusalem, Free the world and kill the False Christ. Fortunately Al-Mahdi will kill the Dajjal. They then go to Mecca where they say prayer Jesus will stand behind Al-Mahdi in the prayer. Old babylon and Jerusalam will meet in peace and eternal happiness and justice will prevail for 40 years...<<

From this gobbledygook what stands out is the fact Jesus is now demoted and has to stand behind Al-Mahdi (a new helper of the All-powerful Allah?). When they all fly back to heaven will Jesus' place at Allah's right hand be usurped by Al-Mahdi?

>>Then, God will decide to end the world because by then the world expires as energy and God doesn't like to renew creation.<<

You know Allah's mind?? Tauba!

>> I do not know why he will stop the creation,..<<

So Allah still has some secrets up His sleeve you don't know about.

>>…but it is my impression that Progress is a divine concept and God likes to try another more progressive series of creation.<<

Your impressions are very surrealistic. Allah has to go for a trial and error process to arrive at a perfect creation. Why does Allah claim He is the perfect Creator if this is the case?

>>The Jennah or paradise will be a sort of garden where wise men discuss philosophical issues...<<

LOL. What would the philosophers in heaven be discussing? Whether Allah is right or wrong in keeping billions of people in hell for all time or whether somebody should bell the cat, so to say, and when opportunity arises to remind Him of His Merciful nature and get some respite for the tortured souls.

>>They will indulge in the infinite problems of poetry and language.<<

Will heaven also be a Babel like earth? Or will everyone speak Allah's language?

>> They will also seek means to imitate God not in creating new beings but in relieving the anguished spieits from the pit of ignorance and arrogance.<<

This means the tortures of hell does not do anything to improve the mental state of those in hell. What use is hell except as vengeance to satisfy Allah's wounded ego? What will they be imitating? Allah trying to relieve the anguished spirits of those in Hell?

>>The figures of cross minorah and crescent will be replaced by flowers and books... Faithful saint will pray in the kingdom of light situated at the edge of eternity...It is fantastic world which I cannot disclose all its secret but be sure no religious, racial or other discrimination will be valid there.<<

Apart from being able to peep into Allah's mind you have also been able to peer into what lies beyond judgment day?

>>So our talk counts to nothing if we measure things by the balance of eternity...Religions in this world are used for political objective, in the world of eternal lights where there exist so many baths, fruits and flowers, politics will be expired like rotten pet food. No conflict and no selfishness...We will enjoy the metaphors and the best people there are not prophets but poets and philosophers.<<

Does this mean Socrates, Kant, Tennyson, Blake will be a degree above Mohammed, Moses or Abraham?

>>God will have something for them because they are chosen by God and the wisdom they preached is the wisdom of God. They have nothing of their own while the philosophers and poets are self-made... They worked hard to polish their talents and they see with their own light, while the prophets see in the light of God.<<

Great to know that philosophers and poets have minds of their own and can create without any help from Allah. We must be thankful for small blessings. But you better be careful, what you have stated is fatwa material.

>>Now I advise you to throw Christianity and Judiasm like tissue paper in the nearest trash can... <<

Just when I thought you were a closet moderate Muslim you show your true Islamic colours with this poison-tipped sting.in your tail.




Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2023 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)