17 readers online now

103,116 comments by 27,238 readers

Go to Mobile Site
Homepage Articles Blog Reviews Spoken Books Other Languages Biographical Middle East Forum About this site Mailing List

Please go from non muslim country India
Reader comment on item: [The Issue of Compulsion in Religion:] Islam is What Its Followers Make of It
in response to reader comment: a question for true muslims

Submitted by Manish Saxena (India), Mar 7, 2009 at 07:55

muhammad says we are not true muslims because we are living in non muslim country & working with non muslim organisation. I am angry with him please do hurry & leave immediately this country and spread truth to all muslims. It will be very beneficial for India

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

Search by Enter name or date
Search Forum Comments:

Reader comments (230) on this item

Title By Date
Obsessive cumpulsive and more [110 words]JillSep 15, 2009 05:30
Please provide full Verse, don't quote OUT OF CONTEXT. [103 words]imranMay 19, 2009 09:36
rama [39 words]jonJan 19, 2009 06:21
↔ those who have ears hear [279 words]chiranjeeviOct 21, 2009 21:59
islaam can never be better.. [138 words]indianNov 7, 2008 15:26
↔ Misconception about the word KAFIR among the hindu people [163 words]M Y KHATRIJan 3, 2009 10:54
a question for true muslims [63 words]muhammadAug 16, 2008 02:36
↔ Reigious clash [97 words]R SUBRAMANIANSep 3, 2008 05:48
↔ Muhammad [252 words]SK BallalNov 16, 2008 02:57
↔ ⇒ Please go from non muslim country India [47 words]Manish SaxenaMar 7, 2009 07:55
↔ brother ....what is absurd? [187 words]mayeedApr 6, 2009 09:46
↔ In response of Mayeed's comment [127 words]Manish SaxenaApr 8, 2009 07:54
↔ Manish sexena [392 words]MayeedApr 19, 2009 05:11
↔ Muhammad(Peace Be Upon Him) [325 words]A.Samad KhanApr 28, 2009 01:05
↔ shameless ballal [144 words]bilalJul 7, 2009 19:22
↔ islams ignorance of Hinduism [70 words]proud hinduSep 13, 2009 15:39
↔ to manisha saxena [94 words]naziaSep 29, 2009 11:07
for true muslims [65 words]muhammadAug 16, 2008 02:25
You will Know [39 words]IslamAug 15, 2008 19:55
↔ AKMA [97 words]KabirOct 21, 2009 05:15
hindu or muslim [95 words]hindu-muslimJul 18, 2008 11:16
↔ dream on [29 words]AshwinSep 17, 2008 21:18
↔ agree [15 words]jonJan 19, 2009 06:24
Obsessive cumpulsive disorder [105 words]PatilFeb 29, 2008 01:15
Truth is in the small print [63 words]vamananDec 5, 2007 10:30
Come on people, It's time to be cool!! [319 words]kcNov 17, 2007 09:54
True religion is humanity [204 words]s.azizMar 3, 2007 21:18
↔ True religion is humanity(2) [99 words]IRMar 8, 2007 12:22
Disagreement [57 words]Pro BritainFeb 11, 2006 15:05
Blame it on Saud [240 words]Eddie MustDec 2, 2005 05:23
↔ Agree with Criticism of Saud [537 words]MkFeb 20, 2008 20:43
Jews were in India long before Islam [19 words]Nov 22, 2005 18:50
↔ incomplete knowledge [61 words]ayeshaFeb 16, 2007 14:35
↔ What a parody [30 words]PatilFeb 29, 2008 01:18
you're right about Islam being the biggest threat in the world [187 words]americanaNov 7, 2005 17:19
↔ you're right about Islam being the biggest threat in the world [142 words]MoMay 24, 2006 08:05
↔ Organized Religions [78 words]RationalistMar 6, 2007 23:28
↔ Fruits of colonialism [67 words]BajpaiJun 2, 2007 10:19
↔ You have little knowledge about Islam [173 words]M. AkmalSep 30, 2007 03:04
↔ Science as we know it started from Ancient India and the vedic religion [30 words]Vikram AdityaDec 4, 2007 20:22
↔ What Development ? [1536 words]ShailendraDec 5, 2007 03:27
↔ Biggest Threat? [502 words]MkFeb 20, 2008 21:08
↔ fruit [9 words]jayJul 4, 2008 11:01
↔ Oh poor dear, [136 words]naingwinJan 28, 2009 05:05
↔ hi mr shailander i am sorry i read your comment late [91 words]bilalJul 7, 2009 19:38
↔ richest [29 words]the manMar 7, 2010 16:05
God is watching! [323 words]Dr. MaidunOct 29, 2005 08:46
↔ where is allah? [28 words]aejanJan 30, 2006 06:29
↔ Islam [118 words]ParvezApr 15, 2007 11:45
↔ reply [40 words]vikramMay 14, 2007 04:42
↔ Please have a thought [116 words]RajatJun 3, 2008 12:16
↔ Prophet Muhammed made a blunder by claiming that he was the last one [359 words]PhilosopherJul 1, 2008 01:00
↔ Reply [123 words]SRSep 30, 2008 10:21
↔ response [87 words]youmuslimApr 9, 2009 18:00
Islam V Hinduism [60 words]Ravi LadvaOct 3, 2005 07:36
↔ HATE, VIOLENCE, BLOODSHED, WAR [93 words]RAJVINDER SINGHFeb 3, 2006 10:08
↔ Islam V Hinduism [2588 words]Shaikh ShafiAug 25, 2006 05:58
↔ HOLD UP [309 words]ishqmeil khan convert to hinduismSep 11, 2006 04:16
↔ A True Muslim [428 words]ShafiSep 12, 2006 08:18
↔ Islam and Quran is only a Concept [1804 words]RamaOct 2, 2006 09:26
↔ Absurd Hinduism (Indian Paganism) [93 words]PamodhaNov 10, 2006 11:04
↔ A different perspective!! [440 words]Satnam BansalDec 15, 2006 14:25
↔ Hindu civilization was destroyed in the 1000 years of living as a Dhimmi [131 words]sandyDec 21, 2006 06:50
↔ Finally there is a human among us............. [85 words]KaisJan 14, 2007 03:32
↔ A True muslim [46 words]shafiJan 18, 2007 11:08
↔ knowledge is power [36 words]DR. Naveen RainaJan 20, 2007 01:16
↔ A True muslim [335 words]shafiJan 21, 2007 03:11
↔ Dear Satnam [161 words]MisraFeb 20, 2007 11:13
↔ Modern Physics including Quantum Theory & Hinduism [188 words]ShantanuMar 6, 2007 18:40
↔ Why compare the religions?? [195 words]SoulMar 21, 2007 13:21
↔ God give you wisdom [250 words]rachinApr 21, 2007 17:07
↔ ALLAH (THE ONE GOD) BLESS MUSLIMS [196 words]AysheMay 8, 2007 00:13
↔ reply [88 words]vikramMay 16, 2007 12:16
↔ reply [42 words]vikramMay 16, 2007 12:33
↔ none [10 words]MuslimMay 23, 2007 15:42
↔ absurd [76 words]AnonymousJun 6, 2007 15:44
↔ reply [44 words]TariqJun 20, 2007 16:19
↔ managing your view by your own way [32 words]SujitJun 24, 2007 17:54
↔ Foolish writer [38 words]SujitJun 24, 2007 18:02
↔ Islam V Hinduism [70 words]shafiJul 1, 2007 05:28
↔ foolish writer...not [15 words]rashidJul 9, 2007 10:23
↔ hello [11 words]rashidJul 9, 2007 10:37
↔ islam isn't a concept but a way of life [431 words]rashidJul 9, 2007 11:07
↔ To Satnam [359 words]Sukhdev Singh AulakhJul 20, 2007 20:18
↔ You can not compare philosophy to tribal laws [167 words]sincereefforts (www.faithfreedom.org)Jul 25, 2007 15:06
↔ Reply to : Islam V Hinduism [322 words]Lotus MoonclanAug 22, 2007 22:06
↔ get your life on track [162 words]ram gopalSep 9, 2007 17:53
↔ true hindu [111 words]ram gopalSep 9, 2007 18:20
↔ explain that i have seen that video [9739 words]IbrahimSep 13, 2007 16:42
↔ HINDUISM, JUDAISM AND CHRISTIANITY IS WHAT ITS FOLLOWERS MAKE OF IT [648 words]FerozSep 27, 2007 05:57
↔ reply to Tariq [23 words]rahul(india)Nov 26, 2007 13:52
↔ Mecca is an ancient hindu temple [19 words]ShivDec 4, 2007 20:32
↔ why [79 words]RikDec 10, 2007 03:46
↔ Sure, there is no image of Brahman but that does not mean that He is formless [148 words]AMDec 25, 2007 12:57
↔ Idolatry in Western Testaments [318 words]AMDec 25, 2007 13:54
↔ All for wine in Mohammad's paradise? [166 words]AMDec 25, 2007 14:03
↔ misconception about islam [123 words]iqbalMar 27, 2008 13:55
↔ idol worship,hinduism and other religions [1301 words]sandeep koulMar 31, 2008 03:14
↔ You Said the truth [10 words]peaceboyApr 3, 2008 12:15
↔ reply to Feroz [12 words]MohnishMay 18, 2008 16:49
↔ ALLAH IS THE ONLY TRUTH [35 words]swapnilMay 21, 2008 00:30
↔ Hinduism or Sanatan [476 words]SibaramMay 29, 2008 21:10
↔ Re [47 words]sibaramJun 3, 2008 05:53
↔ YOU ARE WRONG [112 words]swetaJun 7, 2008 23:02
↔ the kalki [778 words]sultanJun 11, 2008 04:11
↔ NO YOU ARE THE ONE WHO IS WRONG [402 words]PamodhaJun 20, 2008 19:52
↔ Absolute non-sense [43 words]VishwasJul 13, 2008 21:39
↔ first think then write [53 words]JasmineAug 13, 2008 00:29
↔ Prove it [11 words]PamodhaAug 13, 2008 16:51
↔ Quran is first and Last, nothing Else [137 words]mohamadAug 15, 2008 15:29
↔ kashmir [40 words]ajay panditaSep 20, 2008 04:38
↔ respect others life [44 words]enlighten yourself this is ulimate goal not bomb blastsSep 27, 2008 10:50
↔ explain [20 words]zodiacloveOct 2, 2008 08:18
↔ Submitted by zodiaclove (Brazil), Oct 2, 2008 at 08:18 [62 words]RikOct 5, 2008 14:36
↔ Pamodha [231 words]Hindu-HumanistOct 16, 2008 02:06
↔ The term 'Hindu Humanist' is an oxymoron [1123 words]PamodhaOct 18, 2008 14:16
↔ The tyranny of Islam [566 words]Terry SmithNov 4, 2008 19:52
↔ For everyone.... [357 words]SathyaNov 26, 2008 10:20
↔ Hinduism, judaism and christianity [328 words]DelwinDec 6, 2008 05:45
↔ Idol Worship mis interpreted [172 words]SauravDec 29, 2008 14:26
↔ R U so foolish enough to say? [206 words]Naing winJan 20, 2009 07:57
↔ You say Hinduism has already defined Islam [168 words]ShivaFeb 10, 2009 06:45
↔ Don't leak traditional secrets [70 words]Rama Z ZutshiFeb 13, 2009 22:56
↔ Islam Versus Civilization [149 words]BajpaiFeb 14, 2009 20:29
↔ Truth Hurts [434 words]PamodhaFeb 19, 2009 18:09
↔ Holocausts, belief, and everything inbetween [136 words]Harkirit Kaur RayattMar 21, 2009 10:36
↔ wherever you find Hindu..Kill him....where does Quran say that? [1161 words]MayeedApr 5, 2009 12:03
↔ brother ....what is absurd? [204 words]mayeedApr 6, 2009 09:20
↔ idiot [192 words]AnonymousApr 8, 2009 21:55
↔ request [9 words]mayeedApr 19, 2009 08:47
↔ to shaik shafi [20 words]racJun 18, 2009 09:04
↔ Kalki is not mohammed. [26 words]M. Srinivas ReddyJun 28, 2009 03:16
↔ ishqmeil khan ruscle [138 words]bilalJul 7, 2009 20:19
↔ ram gopal kutta [91 words]bilalJul 7, 2009 20:33
↔ why we are fighting for a silly thing??? [118 words]omnipresentJul 22, 2009 08:52
↔ manu to shafi [93 words]shaAug 23, 2009 12:35
↔ Please read [9 words]vikramSep 4, 2009 08:05
↔ Islam vs Hinduism [116 words]NikSep 7, 2009 02:45
↔ pak hind superpowers -- ram rahim ek hai - allah aur ram [111 words]rajSep 16, 2009 12:46
↔ hmmmm [194 words]KabirOct 21, 2009 05:27
↔ hmmmm [113 words]KabirOct 21, 2009 05:41
↔ Do not quote out of context [172 words]NileshNov 20, 2009 03:42
↔ TRUTH IS OUT THERE [129 words]MahdiJan 12, 2010 13:57
↔ God is love [49 words]FatimaFeb 9, 2010 12:04
↔ know complete hinduism [110 words]mukesh ranjan mallickMar 5, 2010 04:40
↔ Shiva lingam.Seeds of Jivatmas.God created created force to live in harmony,karmas are linked to bear its fruits. [57 words]shridevMar 6, 2010 14:13
Not intolerant [323 words]ArchanaAug 9, 2005 06:23
Mr.Pipes, please start all new Cable Channel "Freedom" [74 words]HerveMar 14, 2005 13:00
Islam is biggest Threat for Whole World [610 words]HerveMar 14, 2005 12:40
↔ What? [40 words]PEACEAug 13, 2007 13:47
↔ DEAF AND DUMB [159 words]KHANApr 21, 2008 17:03
↔ Wrong [86 words]MyraMay 11, 2008 18:48
↔ Me Again.... [106 words]MyraMay 11, 2008 18:54
↔ Real Educated (not brainwashed) Muslims can save the world [1903 words]XYZNov 2, 2008 12:36
↔ The world would be a better place without Islam [43 words]mieouxNov 30, 2008 01:12
↔ the author is 100% correct [77 words]humanityJan 11, 2009 13:37
↔ islam [173 words]markJan 25, 2010 12:16
↔ muslim is not terrorist [27 words]AyeeshaMar 3, 2010 07:54
Inquisition - Arab Apology Demanded? [226 words]John Randall PeacherMar 8, 2005 17:11
↔ Fear and Absolute obedience [273 words]John CarlsonSep 2, 2006 19:51
↔ RE: Inquisition - Arab Apology Demanded? [513 words]MiquelJan 21, 2007 16:59
↔ Please do some research [223 words]Neutral observerApr 5, 2008 08:47
↔ Excuse-me? [31 words]YnnatchkahApr 7, 2008 01:03
Slave Soldiers of militant Islam and the Tsunami Disaster [132 words]Ilona MelstradsDec 30, 2004 15:36
Re: Militant Islam [158 words]RenataNov 29, 2004 08:25
We should accept Turkey into the EU [20 words]OzgaziOct 28, 2004 11:55
I disagree [104 words]reema saffariniOct 20, 2004 12:29
↔ Strong Opposition [213 words]PublicFeb 25, 2006 10:32
Brutality [141 words]S.C.PandaOct 14, 2004 06:17
↔ prophet mohammed said " who ever changes his islamic religion, KILL him " [223 words]Phil GreendJun 24, 2009 23:30
↔ Islam is a violent religion [163 words]JohnnyNov 6, 2009 11:28
↔ from which side [50 words]doesnt matterFeb 25, 2010 16:20
Not all [34 words]JaimeOct 13, 2004 15:16
Thank you. [57 words]John EkdahlOct 7, 2004 12:43
Muslims are what Islam Makes of Them [97 words]Gamaliel IsaacOct 7, 2004 10:48
Why is there such an anti- Hindu hysteria among some muslims? [73 words]Michael J BlusteinOct 5, 2004 00:25
↔ answer to your question [75 words]a sasidharFeb 12, 2006 23:12
↔ islam- much more than what they call it!!! [129 words]anubha khandelwalSep 5, 2006 12:50
↔ Why is there so much anti islamic remarks? [48 words]rashidJul 9, 2007 10:14
↔ Because they are jealous of hindus [128 words]VJJul 21, 2007 04:30
↔ Islam is the only right way not hundism. [86 words]emran ahmedSep 29, 2007 18:28
↔ Info [109 words]soulOct 26, 2007 11:48
↔ Islam- most intolerant & violent cult of madmen | Hinduism- the most liberal way of Life [130 words]Jai RamFeb 13, 2008 14:17
↔ Disagree: Islam preaches hatred? Where? [48 words]MkFeb 20, 2008 20:47
↔ Muslims hate Hindus because we dont like geting pushed around [130 words]AnonMar 12, 2008 10:29
↔ hindu religion [159 words]MR ?Mar 23, 2008 14:28
↔ Muslims hate Hindus because we dont like getting pushed around [193 words]sandeep koulApr 2, 2008 07:50
↔ Re: Mr? [495 words]sibaramJun 3, 2008 06:17
↔ Tecniques to rule over the world [332 words]surinder singhAug 1, 2008 03:24
↔ Idols [31 words]Hindu-HumanistOct 16, 2008 02:15
↔ the bene israeli jews have been in india for long before the birth of islam [71 words]sheenaJan 15, 2009 13:24
↔ Jai Ram is right [9 words]steadyfriendNov 21, 2009 19:42
↔ muslims have to admit that there are other religions also exist in the world [55 words]ashishDec 29, 2009 15:33
↔ why muslims hate hindus [37 words]siddarthJan 3, 2010 00:18
↔ Ph.Ds not needed to see the sun [175 words]VamananJan 14, 2010 22:51
Excellent! A request [22 words]David TsalOct 4, 2004 03:43
Pakistani Judge's Comment [282 words]John C. ZimmermanOct 3, 2004 17:32
You read my mind [43 words]Harry F StarkOct 3, 2004 13:56
Militant Islam [54 words]Issa BotrosOct 2, 2004 13:09
Militatant Islam and freedom of choice? [66 words]John SmithOct 2, 2004 06:17
Lacunae in Pipes' writings on Islam related issues
[w/response] [230 words]		Shankar SharanOct 1, 2004 07:19
↔ mr shanker you'r e so wrong [41 words]veeraApr 11, 2006 21:35
↔ veera ji aap ko sachhai maalum nahi hain [118 words]dilipJan 19, 2007 10:14
Can we keep it simple? [84 words]Robert M. ArmstrongSep 30, 2004 11:01
↔ no problem, robert [79 words]rashidJul 9, 2007 10:30
La Ikrah Fil Deen [218 words]maurice massaadSep 29, 2004 22:32
↔ jizya [62 words]rashidJul 9, 2007 10:19
↔ do they pay? [12 words]SathyaNov 26, 2008 10:11
A query on literalism and on politics in Islam [290 words]John ClementsSep 29, 2004 19:34
Islam is like all religions?
[w/response] [299 words]		Bill SweeneySep 29, 2004 15:35
What you see isn't What you get [628 words]Raymond LullSep 29, 2004 15:03
Gagging America in the Holy War [555 words]Jordan OroszSep 29, 2004 10:59
Tariq Ramadan [122 words]Dave KabaySep 29, 2004 01:09
Preaching vs Action [321 words]Hari IyerSep 28, 2004 23:54
Islam vs. Freedom of Religion [89 words]Arlinda DeAngelisSep 28, 2004 23:22
↔ re [57 words]veeraApr 11, 2006 21:28
↔ May Allah enlight you [301 words]naing winJan 28, 2009 05:35
"Infidels." [24 words]Douglas BoggsSep 28, 2004 22:13
Good Article [46 words]Umm YasminSep 28, 2004 21:49
Turkey must be allowed to enter the E.U. [49 words]J. SheffSep 28, 2004 19:12
Interpretation [60 words]vladSep 28, 2004 16:24
False Hope [175 words]Tom ClearSep 28, 2004 14:30
↔ Please .......brother [26 words]mayeedApr 5, 2009 12:38
Faith vs. Reason [240 words]Ralph C. Whaley MDSep 28, 2004 13:59
↔ Faith [139 words]PJSep 30, 2006 15:05
Re: The Koran on tolerance of other religions [1557 words]ElliottSep 28, 2004 11:52
↔ control the world [194 words]jackDec 3, 2006 21:54
↔ the quran [37 words]rashidJul 9, 2007 10:33
↔ true history [64 words]jaYDEEPANDec 11, 2008 15:26
Not so different [32 words]marySep 28, 2004 11:24

Comment on this item

Name
Email Address (optional)
Title of Comments
Comments:

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See the 25 most recent outstanding comments.

ADVERTISEMENTS

Premium Links by Wikio

• Computers
• Electronics
• Communication
• Appliances

eXTReMe Tracker

All materials written by Daniel Pipes on this site © 1968-2010 Daniel Pipes. Email: MeqMef@aol.com

You can help support Daniel Pipes' work by making a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.