Reply to : Islam V Hinduism

Submitted by Lotus Moonclan (United States), Aug 22, 2007 at 22:06

Islam is a good religion. Hinduism is an outdated pagan religion full of contradictions, wrong morals, statue worship and nonsense.

Bad things in Hinduism-

Animal sacrifices
Comment :
Muslims sacrifice goats/cows to commemorate Abrahams attempt to sacrifice his son ?

Human sacrifices
Comment : Examples
- Remember David Koresh
- Remember Islamists beheading people.
- Abraham sacrificing his own son.

Stupid worship of cows, monkeys & rats
Comment :
Worship of a roman torture tool (cross) by Christians,
Or a stone(the mecca) by Muslims
Christians eat flesh of thier god ; drink his blood
Muslims belive in Djnss
Kama sutra & sex worship
Comment :
Whats wrong with sex (or worship of sex). Sex is the celebration of life

Fascism as a result of caste system
Comment :
Examples of the most vicious fascists involved in Genocides
- Islamist fascists aiming for world domination.
- Chinese/Russian communist fascists
- Catholic fascsist (Hitler , Mussolini , Franco)

Racism (saying that aryans are superior to all others)
Comment :
'Arya' in old Sanskrit is an honorific - like 'sir' or 'most noble'. Even Buddha used the term for his dharma - calling it 'Arya Sharma'. It is 19th Christian Europe that remodelled Arya into its current racist overtone.

Wrong morals in ramayana, mahabharatha
Comment :
Koran, Bible calls for murder, extermination ,genocide and torture of other peoplePornographic religion / sexual perversion
Comment :
Even Abraham pimps his wife to all sorts of people to forward his interests. Also lots of other such behavior down the line in all Abrahamic religions. Jesus a misogynist, Mohammad - paedophile..All these points are defects in Hinduism and you will find none of them in Islam.
Comment :
If you say so... am a Buddhist who also admires Islam & Muslims. ...
Comment :
Evidently telling truth is not one of those islamic virtures ( taqquiya ?) to be admired.
Before you model yourself a buddhist at least take the trouble to learn something about it. i am an athiest , a Buddhist and a Hindu.

I

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".