Moderate Muslim, the more you talk, the more you expose yourself!
Submitted by Noah Wilk (United States), Mar 7, 2007 at 22:36
Moderate Muslim wrote:
"I didnt say that they got all the land, I just said that the Zionists wanted all the land."
Right. Just another shade of revisionist history. They wanted a homeland. They were promised a certain amount of land, and accepted it. That amount was cut drastically, and they again accepted it. That small amount was once again reduced drastically, and they once again accepted it. It was the greedy Arabs (Muslims) who rallied against the Jews getting any sort of homeland. It was not the Jews being greedy. As I said, consult a map. Israel would fit inside of Saudi Arabia alone about 100 times. And it was the greed of the Arabs that caused them to mass attack Israel.
The propaganda they fed to you in the madrassah simply does not hold up to historical reality.
"I am not anti-semitic and I would prefer one read my WHOLE statement before throwing out controversial titles."
I read your whole statement. It's typical Muslim propaganda. The same old lies, told a thousand times, taken from a page of the Goebbels Propaganda Manual. Muslims love repeating these lies as if there is any truth to them, when there is not.
"By the way, if we have to go over this, semites are also Muslims and Jews, so anti-semitic isnt really the word, if I hated JEws in the first place, which I dont. I just condemn the occupation of Israel."
The moment a Muslim uses the word "occupation" to describe Israel, that's all we need to hear to know he's a radical at heart at not a moderate. The Jews have historical claim to the land, they were granted it legally, and they actually paid highly inflated prices for most of it. Once again, your propaganda reeks of ignorance and revisionist history.
"I am not anti semitic."
No, you just hate the "Jewish Semites".
"A lot of Jews condemn the occupation."
A lot of Jews have fallen for the brainwashing and propaganda. Sad. Either way, that does not make it an occupation.
"I am also not saying that Israel should be kicked out."
Then why do you refer to it as an "occupation"?
"They deserve a state, or at least they did when they moved in."
Oh, I see. They deserved a state back when they "moved in", but they no longer deserve one, since they're just "occupiers".
"the Zionists need to stop killing babies in "prison camps" or is that not what a refugee camp surrounded by guards is."
But then where would the Jews get the blood to make their matzah? [rolling my eyes]
"Moderate" Muslim, it's obvious you're no "moderate"... Let it out already, before you explode.
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
Reader comments (2097) on this item
Comment on this item
You can help support Daniel Pipes' work by making a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum. Daniel J. Pipes