28 readers online now

99,258 comments by 26,347 readers

Go to Mobile Site

NOI AND AFRICAN-AMERICANS
Reader comment on item: Saudis Import Slaves to America
in response to reader comment: What is the Draw of the Black Muslem movement?

Submitted by CMG (United States), Dec 20, 2006 at 17:33

I TEND TO AGREE WITH ALOT OF WHAT MR. FLEMING HAS WRITTEN ABOUT. TWO SMALL-BUT IMPORTANT HISTORICAL FACTS HE LEFT OUT ARE: WHEN THE MUSLIMS CONQUERED 'NORTHERN AFRICA' AND IT BECAME PART OF 'GREATER ARABIA'-ARABS MADE BLACK AFRICANS SLAVES! THEY ALSO WOULDNT ALLOW THEM TO CONVERT TO ISLAM!!!! THESE TWO PRACTISES WENT ON FOR HUNDREDS OF YEARS. THE ' A LLOWING' OF BLACK AFRICANS TO CONVERT TO THE ISLAMIC FAITH IS A RATHER MODERN ONE. RATHER CURIOUS THIS RECENT 'TURN OF EVENTS', THOUGH HISTORICALLY IT MAKES SENSE.

ALSO, IT TOOK MOST ARAB AND AFRICAN COUNTRIES ANOTHER 100 YEARS ( 1960'S) TO 'FREE ' ITS SLAVES, AND THAT IS SERIOUSLY QUESTIONABLE. INDENTURED SERVITUDE HAS ALWAYS THRIVED THERE, AND AGIAN ONE IS SEEING THE 'RE-EMERGENCE' OF AN OUT-RIGHT SLAVE TRADE.

IT IS NOT UNUSUAL TO 'LOOK AROUND' AT ARAB COUNTRIES AND TH E 'BLACKER' THE SKIN, THE POORER ONE IS.

CMG


Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened for relevance, substance, and tone, and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome, but comments are rejected if scurrilous, off-topic, vulgar, ad hominem, or otherwise viewed as inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the Guidelines for Comments. For informational purposes, we identify countries from which comments are sent.

Submit a comment on this item

Search by Enter name or date
Search Forum Comments:

Reader comments (154) on this item

Title By Date
Dhimmitude is just the beginning. [178 words]LynnMay 29, 2009 08:09
Why all the talk about religion? [58 words]JamesJun 29, 2008 12:55
Where religion ends and cuture starts is a little unclear [71 words]SudeepFeb 15, 2009 15:17
Some sense [123 words]MohammedMay 11, 2009 13:10
Aplauses for you dear James. [38 words]halil salihMay 27, 2009 17:33
Facts taken out of context [107 words]Mr. ExpatriateJun 22, 2008 12:41
funny... you know what? [222 words]NanaMay 20, 2008 23:12
wahabis are not muslims, but demi-gods, dont blame the religion blame the people [1095 words]tarigFeb 18, 2009 08:48
Saudi as the trade zone for the slaves??? [210 words]Firozali A.Mulla MBA PhDOct 23, 2007 05:53
Christianity and Nazism [141 words]FernandoSep 11, 2007 18:01
christianity and nazism [108 words]btillyAug 1, 2008 21:27
Please Publish Internationally [32 words]Tahir JavedSep 5, 2007 14:58
islam is all about abuse and control [157 words]Phil GreendAug 26, 2007 15:13
To be fair... [46 words]FernandoSep 10, 2007 22:14
Why I am not surprised [804 words]CCWJul 17, 2007 21:03
It happens everyday and all over the world [216 words]CandideJul 11, 2008 03:50
(Slavery in Islam) I do not agree with your opinion, mind can translate anything to anything [227 words]Azam KhanJul 17, 2007 02:55
Azam Khan you are right. [97 words]RommelAug 9, 2007 09:12
just so [124 words]TerrySep 23, 2007 17:05
It's a fact....but not necessarily the truth. [108 words]RommelSep 24, 2007 21:02
So where is the promotion of freedom? [170 words]RaulFeb 28, 2007 14:14
Two Interesting Points. [379 words]YnnaFeb 18, 2007 17:02
Different point of view [157 words]um sashaJan 6, 2007 21:33
SLAVERY DOES INDEED OCCUR IN SAUDI ARABIA!!!! [272 words]Michael MFeb 20, 2007 10:21
Slavery, lack of basic rights in many muslim countries. [200 words]Farooq KhanMar 9, 2007 18:32
I agree [77 words]paulMar 20, 2007 14:17
Maid for Abuse [1 words]Sanjay ManjrekarMar 21, 2007 20:13
Me too [62 words]TerryMar 25, 2007 17:15
take it to oprah [27 words]jacqueline russoApr 27, 2007 15:41
SAUDI ARABIA AND SLAVERY [924 words]TMay 6, 2007 13:55
Kidnapping [27 words]KatJun 11, 2007 22:39
Not just Filllipinos [34 words]true believerJul 13, 2007 05:16
wish you well [32 words]JoyceJul 17, 2007 23:27
ARAB SLAVE TRADE, Mohammad was not black, and Persians were conquered by Arabs. [657 words]SatantiagoAug 9, 2007 17:19
It's not only third world domestics.... [16 words]PGSep 26, 2007 17:56
respond to slavery according to quran [1211 words]anitaSep 29, 2007 00:34
Unless ! [37 words]dfwhite19438Apr 1, 2008 21:31
Slavery in Saudi arabia [162 words]Kenneth T. TellisMay 23, 2008 12:38
slavery in Saudi Arabia [112 words]btillyJun 20, 2008 22:37
Islam does not teach violence? [14 words]ConcernedSep 18, 2008 07:11
I LIVE IN SAUDI ARABIA [301 words]noor alsawadiOct 1, 2008 13:43
Comment on Saudis Import Slaves to America [37 words]akDec 28, 2008 01:24
about: anita [10 words]racJun 18, 2009 11:16
Islamic slavery [344 words]rickApr 24, 2006 13:05
The Quran Allows Slavery, But Also Diminishes It... [167 words]WaqasJun 14, 2006 18:09
Slavery was abolished in the US in 1865 [1123 words]Denis SchulzJul 5, 2006 18:06
seems like a biased argument [291 words]alan daviesJul 20, 2009 05:18
This is common in the middle east [87 words]Javed SiddiquiApr 15, 2006 17:32
This is not the whole picture!! [170 words]KhalidApr 2, 2007 22:22
nonsense [116 words]TerryApr 3, 2007 18:22
So what is new?? [85 words]MarkMar 11, 2006 23:53
Saudi UAE ARE SLAVERY: ALL ARAB COUNTRIES PRACTICE SLAVERY [573 words]Actual MUSLIMFeb 16, 2006 20:59
Pakistani Indian Muslima chic?? [6 words]Anubhav SinghApr 21, 2006 02:20
You have mentioned about slavery in Saudi it maybe true, but dont compare U.A.E with saudis [144 words]s.azizMar 3, 2007 19:25
Unh? [51 words]TerryApr 2, 2007 17:50
stay away from the thing called keyboard actual muslim .. seriously [448 words]middle-east-ern :DFeb 11, 2008 12:07
You'r kiddin, right!!! [29 words]Hamzah KattanDec 11, 2005 03:11
Who are you kidding Hamzah Kattan [13 words]DavidFeb 12, 2007 08:06
modern slavery in saudi arabia [130 words]farooqNov 19, 2005 14:58
No sorry [306 words]TerryApr 2, 2007 18:20
What is the Draw of the Black Muslem movement? [1036 words]James FlemingOct 7, 2005 22:21
Response to James Fleming [796 words]Survivor of JihadOct 8, 2005 08:00
Arabian Knights around the campfire (Black Muslims) [187 words]Ray SarlinOct 12, 2005 00:56
Arabian Knights around the campfire (Black Muslims)....Ray [669 words]Survivor of JihadOct 14, 2005 07:12
Know what you are talking about [226 words]Salandin black muslimAug 15, 2006 20:41
⇒ NOI AND AFRICAN-AMERICANS [149 words]CMGDec 20, 2006 17:33
It will never happen [110 words]TerryApr 2, 2007 18:34
I completely agree [126 words]TerryApr 3, 2007 18:35
It will not change [68 words]John BerkowiczSep 18, 2005 18:51
reply to the un-educated people out there [144 words]A.A.AAug 24, 2005 11:49
Good grief [161 words]TerryApr 7, 2007 18:19
That's only part of the story [118 words]waleedJul 13, 2005 10:02
To waleed [29 words]MavisNov 22, 2005 14:31
Take a deep breath and clear your head [134 words]R. RaymondApr 15, 2006 15:33
Hogwash [48 words]terryApr 11, 2007 16:09
A Saudi [158 words]A. A. NoahJul 4, 2005 08:19
Slavery [109 words]YovenJun 28, 2005 16:49
Fairness
[w/response] [161 words]
BaderJun 24, 2005 11:09
Our Man in the Trenches [143 words]Dave M. O'NeillJun 23, 2005 02:05
Petroleum uber alles [103 words]Jack LassJun 22, 2005 19:47
The truth [34 words]S.C.PandaJun 22, 2005 04:37
Excessive "kindness" of Islam... [122 words]Bob HylandJun 21, 2005 21:02
Response to Bob Hyland [59 words]DvoraOct 7, 2005 15:15
Similar case in Minnesota [32 words]David GreenbergJun 21, 2005 15:34
only in america... land of opportunity [178 words]Donald OJun 20, 2005 21:06
Don't Blame the USA [287 words]Peter J. HerzJun 21, 2005 10:28
Response to Peter J. Herz [128 words]DvoraOct 7, 2005 15:48
Rosh Meshech and tubal [93 words]ShannonNov 21, 2008 11:49
SADO ARABIANS [601 words]yonasonJun 20, 2005 16:30
Response to Yonason [81 words]DvoraOct 7, 2005 11:37
America proposes, saudi disposes [95 words]samuelMar 4, 2007 23:45
Slavery in 2005 [282 words]Janice GotchetJun 19, 2005 18:16
What do you expect? [22 words]Hari IyerJun 18, 2005 03:00
Saudi Slaves [68 words]Arlinda DeAngelisJun 17, 2005 21:38
Quran allows Slavery and Sex with slave girls [91 words]Nancy K.Jun 17, 2005 19:15
You are so correct ! [309 words]AdnanJan 12, 2006 14:24
Deal With the Issue, Adnan [64 words]Non Slave HolderJan 5, 2007 10:52
Tie us down by the words of Said Nursi instead of Wahhabis whom İ dont accept as authority [878 words]halil salihMay 24, 2009 05:09
Why are we not surprised? [163 words]Arvind MadhavanJun 17, 2005 14:51
Not So New......... [126 words]SJun 17, 2005 14:08
Saudis Import Slaves to America [14 words]koganJun 17, 2005 11:09
Not a surprise at all. [145 words]Kevin M.Jun 17, 2005 08:51
What is the situation in Britain?
[w/response] [184 words]
Octavio JohansonJun 17, 2005 05:55
SAME CASES FREQUENTLY IN FRANCE [34 words]constantinJun 17, 2005 05:43
Saudi Royals' Sexscapades [268 words]Roger QuartonJun 17, 2005 01:58
Real colour of the saudis [147 words]RajFeb 26, 2009 06:16
Why should this be shocking?! [78 words]Tova MatteroJun 17, 2005 01:24
Kulturkampf [56 words]Peter J. HerzJun 16, 2005 22:43
Muhammad had slaves; also sold them [137 words]Mike RamirezJun 16, 2005 21:25
Dirty Politics [137 words]George KeselmanJun 16, 2005 19:16
United States complicity? [51 words]Melvin A. FechterJun 16, 2005 16:10
Throw these bums out of the USA [103 words]P. McGowanJun 16, 2005 14:45
Not shocking at all [120 words]DanJun 16, 2005 12:47
Slavery in Islam is not allowed, rather it's an "abomination". [24 words]MalikJun 16, 2005 12:25
Quran sanctions rape of captured women and slave girls [238 words]A. SiddiquiJun 21, 2005 12:49
More research needed. [452 words]ShahzadJan 17, 2006 13:36
Qur'an sanctions rape? What a convenient mistranslation [255 words]mark bonadioJul 29, 2006 21:06
The Religious Life of Saudis [210 words]JainashtiJun 15, 2007 01:30
The Saudis [148 words]JainJun 15, 2007 01:43
I hope you will check a good translation next time [124 words]hashiAug 16, 2007 03:17
Please learn how to read correctly [20 words]Lawrence of ArabiaOct 8, 2007 10:12
"... Allah is most merciful (to them)." 24: 33 [184 words]AhsanSep 16, 2009 12:00
DoJ or State Department to put a limit on abuses of "diplomatic status" [195 words]David HarariJun 16, 2005 12:18
Sanction of the victim [92 words]Ralph C. Whaley MDJun 16, 2005 11:44
Similar incident in Orlando [80 words]Kevin GrahamJun 16, 2005 11:17
Are these Saudis, members of the Wahabi sect? [160 words]Lee EllisJun 16, 2005 10:38
Saudis Sponsor Terrorism in Riyadh and REMAX sells out new developments as they import radicals into Orlando. [362 words]EmilyAug 24, 2006 12:04
Don't waste our resources [37 words]RINA SCOTTJun 16, 2005 10:34
It is time to get serious! [333 words]Octavio JohansonJun 16, 2005 09:32
Maid abuse part of Saudi way of life [104 words]Adam GreavesJun 16, 2005 08:22
Slavery in islam , just like mohmammed did it. [56 words]Phil GreendJun 1, 2007 15:43
Funny how white people can say about islam when they treated blacks as slaves.... [529 words]AliyahJul 13, 2007 10:45
Funny indeed, Aliyah [879 words]JeffAug 10, 2007 21:53
Islam tried to suppress slavery [1046 words]AliyahSep 2, 2007 16:42
OK, OK, I'm convinced [404 words]JeffSep 6, 2007 19:21
Re: Slaves in Saudi. [49 words]Christina HonigbergJan 11, 2008 11:31
Anti everything but !!! [96 words]dfwhite1943Apr 1, 2008 21:50
Being there doesn't mean you know the place [58 words]experienceMay 6, 2008 06:16
most maids are murders and witches!!!!!!! [103 words]Saudi girlMay 27, 2008 09:19
Expose of typical extremist Muslim lies against Americans [503 words]ErwinJul 6, 2008 04:38
NO hatred towards towards any religion/people! [340 words]AliyahJul 7, 2008 17:47
What a difference a day makes [989 words]The riffJul 9, 2008 10:01
Correction: Islam Watch & Fox published article re. Muslim Imam & Muslim attorney in London [76 words]The riffJul 9, 2008 19:57
Islam does not teach violence of any kind... [702 words]AliyahJul 10, 2008 05:32
What is true and isn't true about Imam Abdul Makin and Attorney Choudary [257 words]The riffJul 10, 2008 18:39
Quotes that Islam teaches peace! [1009 words]AliyahJul 12, 2008 06:07
What a Difference a Day Makes (Revised) [961 words]The riffJul 18, 2008 16:53
saudis import slaves to america [205 words]btillyAug 1, 2008 21:43
saudis import slaves to america [55 words]btillyAug 1, 2008 21:48
LIES [245 words]AliyahAug 2, 2008 17:43
aliyah [116 words]btillyOct 1, 2008 19:27
aliyah [64 words]btillyOct 2, 2008 19:24
the corsairs [107 words]esbenNov 5, 2008 16:35
Now I get it..... [92 words]SidJul 30, 2009 11:52

Comment on this item

Name
Email Address (optional)
Title of Comments
Comments:

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened for relevance, substance, and tone, and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome, but comments are rejected if scurrilous, off-topic, vulgar, ad hominem, or otherwise viewed as inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the Guidelines for Comments. For informational purposes, we identify countries from which comments are sent.

See the 25 most recent outstanding comments.

ADVERTISEMENTS

Premium Links by Wikio

Computers
Electronics
Communication
Appliances

eXTReMe Tracker

All materials written by Daniel Pipes on this site © Daniel Pipes. Email: MeqMef@aol.com

You can help support Daniel Pipes' important work by making a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.