2 readers online now  |  69 million page views

Yoram Schweitzer is right in principle, but not in this case.

Reader comment on item: May an American Comment on Israel?

Submitted by Fred (United States), Aug 3, 2008 at 11:21

In general one should not comment on the domestic politics of a foreign country. It is rude and the citizens of the nation being commented on have every right to be offended at being told how to live.

In most cases that is correct, but the way Israelis have involved themselves in American politics (even voting when we really shouldn't let them) has always made me feel that Israel is a special case.

But also, is commenting on how one country dealt with Islamo-fascism in the case of releasing terrorists in order to get some of their soldiers dead body's back really "domestic policy" or does it fall under foreign affairs? After all doesn't how one country deals with Islamo-fascism effect the entire war on Islamo-fascism? It wasn't like he was telling the Israelis they should raise or lower taxes or change their health care system (which would indeed be their own business).

Perhaps the problem is how Pipes phrased what he wrote. After all there are ways one can say things without telling people "how to live their lives". Like he could have just said that this will lead to more kidnappings and deaths of soldiers and not state whether that would be good or bad for Israeli society (even though the answer to that is obvious but still leave it up to the reader to decide). Or he could stated in the terms "had it", like in had this happened to my country I would demand that the area where the people celebrated the return of the terrorist be flattened. There you are not telling them what to do, but just saying what you feel you would do if presented with a similar problem. Such a technique does risk "apples and oranges" comparisons though. Not in this case I don't believe but in general.

But again, I would question if this was a case of "internal domestic issue" and if it wasn't then of course as someone who could be effected by this decision as much as any Israeli because the Israeli Government caving in to Islamo-terror could increase the chances of them attacking in other countries then Daniel has every right to comment. And like I said, until we solve the problem of Israelis voting in American elections, and Israeli lobbies like AIPAC having too much influence over OUR politicians I am not going to lose too much sleep over telling the Israelis what to do.

If Samir Kuntar somehow ever gets into a position to harm an US citizen cries of it being a "domestic issue" is going to lose all meaning!

But as for the Germans and all the rest of them out there telling us to vote Obama - shut the heck up. He isn't going to be your President (as much as he might remind them previous German leader that they still subconciously long for) . You supporting him just reconfirms to me that he probably won't be working in my best interests but for yours.

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (123) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Rabin, J-Street, & Moral Hazard vs. Privileged Information [215 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
PezDispenserJul 12, 2014 12:34215947
we as texas americans stand with our jewish brothers forever! [71 words]mike nelsonJan 3, 2009 14:52146760
Can the Chinese comment on U.S. politics just because we owe them money? Where is sovereignty? [446 words]Gail TenzerSep 22, 2008 17:53139026
America-Israel [15 words]Jon PurizhanskySep 5, 2008 15:08137988
There Might be Hope for Pro-Americans? [89 words]WatcherAug 24, 2008 16:40137274
Schweitzer can byte me [151 words]jennifer solisAug 18, 2008 17:46136980
1US taxes go to Israel's army [36 words]SarahAug 18, 2008 00:13136922
To Yoram Schweitzer [51 words]EmilyAug 16, 2008 12:53136838
Constructive Criticism Does Wonders to any Issue. [25 words]VictoriaAug 15, 2008 23:13136808
Are you sure you know it all? [81 words]intelAug 12, 2008 00:30136610
Death Sentence [24 words]Peter D.Aug 11, 2008 14:35136589
May an american comment on Israel [117 words]Martin NelsonAug 9, 2008 03:03136494
Israel is too Important to be left to Israelis Only. [185 words]YnnatchkahAug 8, 2008 17:31136476
The Root Cause [117 words]KenAug 8, 2008 10:58136463
Ken, Israel an impediment for Muslims [55 words]InfidelAug 8, 2008 20:44136463
Mr. Infidel- don't give all the credit to Israel. [43 words]Earl HarrisAug 11, 2008 15:26136463
Earl Harris, no mister, just Infidel [74 words]InfidelAug 12, 2008 00:40136463
THE LITTLE GRAIN IS ALSO A PROPHESIZED REMNANT. [292 words]IamJosephAug 31, 2008 00:01136463
Advice [58 words]Carol SolfronkAug 3, 2008 18:53136206
What may an honourable Scholar and researcher comment on? [14 words]KristaAug 3, 2008 15:55136198
Yoram Schweitzer is right in principle, but not in this case. [503 words]FredAug 3, 2008 11:21136180
Any other country, I would say no. [229 words]SteveAug 3, 2008 07:12136169
There are a few things about which only Israelis have a right to voice their comments. [140 words]Avram KaliskyAug 3, 2008 00:07136158
American comment on Israel [39 words]GustafAug 2, 2008 12:25136123
Credentials and Qualification [80 words]AlexanderAug 2, 2008 23:10136123
An American Commenting on Israel and more [246 words]Jack SIGILAug 2, 2008 09:55136118
1Dr Pipes and a few other places deal in truth. [481 words]Kurt SteinerApr 7, 2009 13:29136118
Ready for its duty. [25 words]Jorge CordovaAug 2, 2008 07:53136113
What Israel must do. [108 words]ahmadAug 1, 2008 11:45136059
Ahmed- Quit hiding behind a Muslim name [19 words]Unsa RahimAug 4, 2008 13:38136059
Ahmed-quit hiding behind a Muslim name [104 words]EuskalHerriaAug 5, 2008 19:27136059
What's in a name [201 words]the Grand Infidel of KaffiristanAug 6, 2008 21:42136059
I wish I was an Israeli american [283 words]zari namdarAug 1, 2008 07:15136050
Ramat Aviv [85 words]Richard MillmanJul 31, 2008 09:40135966
I guess it's okay for [31 words]Straight_Talk_LuigiJul 31, 2008 00:53135951
A comment on Mr. Pipes' comments [63 words]William EastJul 30, 2008 22:37135947
Totally Agree about Dr. Pipes writings. [179 words]YnnatchkahJul 31, 2008 13:13135947
HAARETZ CORRESPONDENT TELLS DR. DAN PIPES, 'KEEP OUT OF ISRAEL DIALOGUE." [549 words]JERRY BORISJul 30, 2008 17:39135928
Bravo ! [103 words]Anne-Marie DelcambreJul 31, 2008 04:27135928
Better is open rebuke than love that is hidden. [228 words]ShloAug 11, 2008 16:37135928
HAARETS - Jews' enemy [216 words]NiliMar 14, 2011 18:10135928
Another "gem" from Haaretz - pro-Arab racism media [88 words]LauraMay 1, 2011 02:10135928
"You don't live here" isn't analysis--it's a conversation stopper [104 words]MikeJul 30, 2008 15:51135916
Israel is the Winner [239 words]skmillerJul 30, 2008 09:58135905
too many comments? [251 words]Larry B.Jul 29, 2008 23:11135894
In Support Of Dr. Pipes's Position...And Beyond [1398 words]Gerald A. HonigmanJul 29, 2008 22:41135891
Live Terrorists for Dead Jews who swear to make more Jews dead [769 words]Lame CherryJul 29, 2008 22:30135890
brazil [9 words]fausto dalcinJul 29, 2008 22:03135889
Keep Speaking [75 words]JayJul 29, 2008 21:32135887
May an American Comment on Israel? [97 words]GeorgeJul 29, 2008 17:26135872
Both are right [159 words]huckJul 29, 2008 14:55135870
Sometimes, to win a war, you have to shake hands with your enemy!!! [17 words]Amir Ali TayyabJul 29, 2008 13:21135869
George Patton [66 words]wotthefiqhJul 30, 2008 10:21135869
don't represent Muslims when you are NOT one! [2 words]Amir Ali TayyabJul 31, 2008 13:51135869
Only Israeli citizens can understand ! [219 words]Anne-Marie DelcambreJul 29, 2008 12:47135868
Poll of Israeli Soldiers: Execute Terrorist or Hold & Trade For Remains? [68 words]Kermit J. Halperin, D.D.S.Jul 29, 2008 10:24135865
May an American Comment on Israel? [52 words]Raam BarakJul 29, 2008 04:45135858
Einstein also said it... [24 words]Erick S.Jul 30, 2008 18:31135858
PSYCHOPATHS FOR DEAD BODIES [78 words]ColinJul 29, 2008 02:37135856
Every Jew has a say in Israel [188 words]yuval Brandstetter MDJul 29, 2008 01:00135853
Keep Up the Good Work, Mr. Pipes! [135 words]Johnny CashJul 29, 2008 00:44135852
An Obligation to Comment [53 words]Stuart KaufmanJul 28, 2008 23:19135850
Re: An American commenting on Israeli Policy [345 words]David SchoenJul 28, 2008 21:24135847
7/28/08: May an American Comment on Israel? [3 words]Lynne SchultzJul 28, 2008 19:37135844
May an American comment on Israel? [57 words]Sheldon FinemanJul 28, 2008 19:23135843
Schweitzer's comments [127 words]JACQUES HADIDAJul 28, 2008 19:19135842
Damn Straight! [77 words]Sheldon TyberJul 28, 2008 18:46135841
Unlimited "Cheek Turning" [97 words]Ralph C Whaley MDJul 28, 2008 17:14135834
Forest for the trees in Israel [135 words]AndrewJul 28, 2008 16:15135830
American comment on Israeli action [31 words]Nathan KravetzJul 28, 2008 16:11135829
Another American Opinion - What Happens to Israel Affects the Whole World - Israeli Government Notwithstanding [330 words]M. ToveyJul 28, 2008 15:59135828
May An American Criticize Israeli Stupidity [60 words]Jerry GreenbergJul 28, 2008 15:52135827
A Vote of Support for You [89 words]Bernard I. MursteinJul 28, 2008 15:39135825
Myopia [200 words]Victor GordonJul 28, 2008 15:07135824
Daniel Pipes is objectivity personified [47 words]jennifer solisJul 28, 2008 14:38135822
Another Ed Said? [322 words]Archimedes2Jul 28, 2008 13:43135818
The answer is yes. [315 words]LynnJul 28, 2008 13:26135817
We need more like you... [150 words]TroublesomeJul 28, 2008 12:54135816
Pipes is right on two counts [124 words]MichaelJul 28, 2008 12:50135815
re your article: May an American comment on Israel [72 words]edith m cordJul 28, 2008 12:47135812
Leave the critique to Israel's enemies [31 words]Amos TurnerJul 28, 2008 12:38135811
Agree [135 words]Bryan PoulinJul 28, 2008 12:16135808
Comments on Israel by others [65 words]ar millerJul 28, 2008 12:10135807
It's understandable [201 words]Doug CorriganJul 28, 2008 12:07135806
Can an American Comment on Israel? [255 words]MikeJul 28, 2008 11:49135804
It's time to stop letting the Israeli tail wag the American dog [141 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Holger JensenMar 19, 2015 17:32135804
Everybody comments on Israel [421 words]Ken BesigJul 28, 2008 11:35135802
An Assertions Truth is Independent of its Author [109 words]Bernard SilvermanJul 28, 2008 11:11135801
An expensive price for al Kuntar?...Here it is.... [87 words]M.D'SouzaJul 28, 2008 11:06135800
May an American Comment on Israel [705 words]kim SegarJul 28, 2008 10:41135799
May an American make a comment [171 words]Margaret HoodJul 29, 2008 18:28135799
Move Emanuel Out [72 words]BarbaraDec 28, 2008 21:18135799
The Lord God says, "Bury the dead and let the living LIVE ON [234 words]Margaret HoodJul 28, 2008 10:33135798
The Burden of Being Special [71 words]Mark WaldmanJul 28, 2008 10:19135794
The Burder of being Special [280 words]Margaret HoodJul 29, 2008 18:46135794
The burden of being special "Chosen" [116 words]Margaret HoodJul 29, 2008 18:57135794
Yoram Schweitzer's argument absurd [125 words]RickJul 28, 2008 09:59135790
both sides now [129 words]Elihu D. DavisonJul 28, 2008 09:55135789
My body is where my mouth was. [179 words]Graham R-BJul 28, 2008 09:47135787
Who has to pay the price for kidnapping? [105 words]Charles OrenJul 28, 2008 09:47135786
Amen! [113 words]Herb MichelsonJul 28, 2008 09:07135782
Speaking freely and openly [219 words]Rebecca MouldsJul 28, 2008 09:00135781
A Global World [95 words]RobertJul 28, 2008 08:47135780
An American comment [145 words]Kyle GosnellJul 28, 2008 08:39135778
obvious you are correct [30 words]brad bucherJul 28, 2008 08:09135776
May a person living in USA comment on Israeli actions. [154 words]YosefJul 28, 2008 08:07135773
Question to Yosef [191 words]GeorgeJul 29, 2008 20:38135773
How does one care about fools? [446 words]RB in MuglaJul 28, 2008 06:21135771
may an american (or anybody foreign) comment on Israel? [38 words]irvine polakowJul 28, 2008 05:56135769
Schweizer's blind subjectivity [73 words]Martin E. WeinsteinJul 28, 2008 04:32135768
WE CAN NOT NEGOTIATE WITH TERRORIST GOVERNMENT.AND OR HEZBOLLAH OR HAMASS OR iRANS REGIME OF THE MOLLAHS [109 words]TIRDAD GHARIBJul 28, 2008 04:16135766
PEOPLE COMING FROM IRAN SYRIA THE MIDDLE EAST AND EVEN EUROPE MUST HAND ALL THRIE LAPTOPS TO THE IMMIGRATION AND FOR THE FBI TO CHECK LAPTOP [221 words]TIRDAD GHARIBAug 2, 2008 15:37135766
IRANIAN AMERICANS CHOOSE BETWEEN YOUR REPUBLIC ISLAMIC OF IRANS PASSPORT OR THE GREATEST PASSPORT IN THE WORLD THE US PASSPORT [174 words]TIRDAD GHARIBAug 4, 2008 07:01135766
"The Right and the Duty to Criticize Israel's Inept Government" [356 words]Prof. Paul EidelbergJul 28, 2008 03:47135765
American Opinions [46 words]Clifton ChadwickJul 28, 2008 03:19135764
May an American Comment on Israel? [1470 words]Gabrielle(Australia)Jul 28, 2008 03:12135763
"Not That Bad a Deal", its even WORSE [13 words]isaacJul 28, 2008 02:35135762
Criticism [180 words]Ilbert PhillipsJul 28, 2008 02:10135760
kuntar deal [48 words]zornbergJul 28, 2008 02:06135759
Daniel Pipes' opinions should be considered [77 words]Janusz KowalikJul 28, 2008 02:02135758
Israel is Homeland for the Jews Regardless of Where in the World they Live! [659 words]Gail TenzerJul 28, 2008 01:44135757
May another american comment to Steve [53 words]DASep 22, 2008 05:07135757
Re May an American Comment on Israel? [38 words]Steve SingletonJul 28, 2008 01:20135756

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to Yoram Schweitzer is right in principle, but not in this case. by Fred

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

ADVERTISEMENTS

eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2019 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)