34 readers online now

99,284 comments by 26,351 readers

Go to Mobile Site

Profiling suspect groups
Reader comment on item: The Enemy Within [and the Need for Profiling]

Submitted by Herchelle Young (United States), Jan 24, 2003 at 22:27

A man who works for a plane co. had just returned from Israel to Wichita and we asked him at a luncheon if many of the terrorists bombers were stopped before they could act. He said that about 10 or so were caught and 1 was successful.

So how would things be in Israel if they did not profile groups as suspects? 'Get real' is a slogan we hear often but doing it requires Israeli people to be ever watchful of their surroundings.

The nearest we come to this mind set is to not watch too much- after all who wants to get involved?

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened for relevance, substance, and tone, and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome, but comments are rejected if scurrilous, off-topic, vulgar, ad hominem, or otherwise viewed as inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the Guidelines for Comments. For informational purposes, we identify countries from which comments are sent.

Submit a comment on this item

Search by Enter name or date
Search Forum Comments:

Reader comments (124) on this item

Title By Date
A matter of time [101 words]gdhOct 28, 2009 10:41
Clarification: Islam, Islamic, Moslem, Muslim, and terrorists [148 words]JaniceNov 12, 2008 21:33
Moslems Vs. Muslims [19 words]GibranNov 24, 2008 21:35
Profiling Muslims [74 words]Mary ConnotAug 8, 2007 09:22
Profiling muslims [100 words]AnnAug 15, 2008 15:04
Profiling... [104 words]NadiaFeb 7, 2009 17:50
Finally.... [51 words]Rachel PetersonNov 29, 2006 10:03
This scares me! [272 words]Don McConnellMar 11, 2007 13:40
This scares you?? [200 words]donvanSep 16, 2008 12:43
[128 words]Dec 21, 2005 02:18
Islamofascism in India for the 9th century running... [141 words]MiriamNov 7, 2005 20:30
Response to Miriam [22 words]Nitin IyengarJul 26, 2006 15:19
Muslim Islam [158 words]don vanApr 4, 2005 15:12
Profiling: Emotions vs Security [79 words]L. JewellOct 15, 2004 09:36
reply to L. Jewell [144 words]TehminaMar 12, 2005 23:48
Illegal Alliens! [91 words]MarionSep 16, 2004 16:19
forgein money [89 words]gabriel hermocilloJan 5, 2006 12:41
Illegal alliens proper title [530 words]Rich AdamsJan 19, 2006 17:50
Let's have a vote [161 words]CharmApr 11, 2006 00:26
positive feedback [3 words]Diane BoukidisApr 11, 2006 15:14
illegals [132 words]deeMay 24, 2006 08:47
Illegal alliens [259 words]deeMay 24, 2006 08:59
free trade [144 words]casasAug 20, 2006 04:06
YES! NO! [60 words]ZekeNov 11, 2006 02:21
Illegal alliens are spending my retirement. [232 words]nonie smithFeb 11, 2007 06:42
Right [11 words]LarryMay 15, 2007 14:22
Re. Muslim Claim To Jerusalem [196 words]Alis CamdonOct 28, 2007 07:50
Defining Islamofascism [105 words]VicFeb 7, 2004 22:03
Actual facts [113 words]MatthewJun 17, 2007 08:39
The Koran teaches forced conversion. [45 words]Jim EagleJan 7, 2004 10:27
In reply to "The Koran teaches forced converision" [92 words]fahidAug 28, 2005 16:44
forced or not read the root of the case [146 words]Irving WeinsoffApr 25, 2006 14:53
not up to date? [41 words]ahmedMay 6, 2006 17:33
Great! [10 words]Octavio JohansonMay 6, 2006 17:54
welcome [21 words]MariamMay 14, 2006 19:09
Forced conversion [181 words]Nitin IyengarJul 26, 2006 14:55
Koran and forced conversions [59 words]George P BurdellSep 20, 2006 11:52
I have read the Quran [141 words]EdMar 14, 2007 10:32
No Compulsion [20 words]lafnDec 30, 2007 15:22
Islam and medicine, etc. [113 words]lafnDec 30, 2007 15:35
I have read the Qur'an too [301 words]Chante GVJun 24, 2009 23:51
In defense of CORRECT Islam [361 words]Jamalluddin As-SalafiMar 27, 2003 23:29
Tend to agree [55 words]DerrickMar 15, 2003 12:40
voided concept [100 words]p SoperFeb 7, 2003 20:01
Does Israel Need a Plan [198 words]kathie and Ze'ev BrodkinFeb 2, 2003 19:55
How do we know how many support terrorism? [101 words]Jason BontragerJan 31, 2003 19:01
Illogical argument
[w/response] [79 words]
Jon MillerJan 31, 2003 15:03
re: daniels response to logical fallacy [74 words]mikeFeb 10, 2006 13:18
good muslims should do their part [199 words]Frank GutierrezJan 29, 2003 22:23
Profiling is Necessary [63 words]ChrisJan 29, 2003 17:47
Non Arab Muslims [149 words]Ayesha A.Jan 28, 2003 13:21
What? [342 words]Samina A.May 3, 2003 20:23
Non Arab Muslims are not terrorists? [88 words]VivekSep 17, 2004 13:04
Arabs & Non Arabs [83 words]IbrahimJul 24, 2005 04:59
Due Process? [44 words]Terry MillerJan 28, 2003 05:18
Against principles [116 words]Kyle GosnellJan 28, 2003 04:06
Profiling [20 words]James JonesJan 27, 2003 14:38
Profiling Muslims [236 words]Wes LandenJan 27, 2003 00:25
Tip-toeing through terrorism [250 words]Stewart G. YoungJan 26, 2003 20:09
The real goal of Islam [127 words]JerryFeb 9, 2006 21:23
Mythical cohesive Muslim community of USA [335 words]FreidoonJan 26, 2003 17:46
The Enemy Within [416 words]NasheedSep 19, 2007 22:28
Education of muslim girls [26 words]eileenMay 27, 2009 03:11
What is really right! [274 words]Daniel Potter, M.A.Jan 26, 2003 17:17
Pro-Muslim policy to advance anti-Israel platform [69 words]Harry MelkmanJan 26, 2003 13:41
Targeting Militant Islam [239 words]Arlinda DeAngelisJan 26, 2003 11:38
'Criminal' profiling [57 words]Robert DietrichJan 26, 2003 10:28
Thanks for your articles [8 words]A. BenestyJan 26, 2003 09:21
Thank you! [32 words]Walt YoungbloodJan 26, 2003 03:28
Side effect - and a suspicion [128 words]Leo BruxJan 25, 2003 19:10
Muslim Duties [81 words]Paul M. NevilleJan 25, 2003 14:49
Militant Islamists are Enemies Within [121 words]Ralph C.Whaley MDJan 25, 2003 13:39
York University asymptomatic of Canadian apathy [267 words]Steve BlogginsJan 25, 2003 09:28
Profiling [23 words]Jack H. PincusJan 25, 2003 08:22
Bitter truth [192 words]AnisJan 25, 2003 03:51
Unfortunate but necessary [151 words]Yusef HakimianJan 25, 2003 03:39
⇒ Profiling suspect groups [104 words]Herchelle YoungJan 24, 2003 22:27
Makes sense to profile as a group [18 words]P.T.BurnemJan 24, 2003 22:03
When will it end? [164 words]Robert HarrisJan 24, 2003 21:32
Unproven allegations [218 words]Brenda WalkerJan 24, 2003 21:06
No need for justification [56 words]Bob FusfeldJan 24, 2003 19:49
Watch Out for Extremists [186 words]Nazia K.Jan 24, 2003 19:14
We must have sunset provisions [599 words]John HadjiskyJan 24, 2003 18:27
Moslem vs. Catholic Arabs
[w/response] [218 words]
G.C. Colan, EsqJan 24, 2003 17:26
Quran: Time to screen its believers [258 words]Hari IyerJan 24, 2003 17:01
The principles of the US Constitution and of the Holy Quran are same. [53 words]Farooq KhanApr 5, 2007 16:02
If muslims wish to come here they must follow our rules , right. [135 words]Phil GreendMay 28, 2007 01:26
Moslem: A Believer in Islam [114 words]Jess BarmatzJan 24, 2003 15:32
"What the Moslems do not understand" [404 words]Paul TasinJan 24, 2007 10:57
Racial profiling [210 words]A. AhmedJan 24, 2003 13:47
The Scope of Islamofascism [110 words]Elizabeth CooteJan 24, 2003 13:39
Circular Reasoning [35 words]Standish LawderJan 24, 2003 13:36
Re: comment "Circular reasoning" [84 words]Alan MilesJan 25, 2003 05:25
More on "Circular Reasoning"- Response to 1/24/03 [417 words]Paul StoutFeb 3, 2003 20:56
Oldest democracy? [44 words]Jeff FosterJan 24, 2003 12:04
Oldest Democracy [40 words]bobJun 12, 2007 04:10
Unanswered Questions [341 words]Alo KievalarJan 24, 2003 11:35
For Pipes, more grouping and less nuance...
[w/response] [188 words]
Amjad M. KhanJan 24, 2003 11:14
Comment on Amjad Khan's opinion [142 words]Karsten BraschJan 27, 2003 13:09
A problem [129 words]J. SentaraJan 24, 2003 11:12
For the security of all -- including innocent Muslims! [20 words]Susan WalkerJan 24, 2003 10:44
Deaf Ears [70 words]M Clementina LongfellowJan 24, 2003 10:37
"slay Muslims wherever ye catch them" [827 words]Graham SpenceJan 24, 2003 10:27
In response to Graham Spence [307 words]Saminah A.May 3, 2003 21:29
totally agree with you [64 words]FranckApr 21, 2006 20:06
faint smell of racism [81 words]truthJul 11, 2006 17:37
A note of thanks... [82 words]Joseph SachsJan 24, 2003 10:26
A pattern [197 words]Michael OberndorfJan 24, 2003 10:22
Let us learn from Egypt [306 words]Gabriel GrossoJan 24, 2003 10:13
Comment on "Let us learn from Egypt" [80 words]Richard RiceJan 24, 2003 11:05
Response to commenter on the "Oldest Democracy" [149 words]Luke BrooksAug 3, 2003 20:00
wasn't athens either [7 words]timothy murrayMar 14, 2006 01:14
Um, when the U.S. became a "democracy," England had a King... [173 words]Garry HerzogJun 21, 2008 03:10
Oldest surviving democracy [52 words]Paul WilsonSep 14, 2008 19:16
What is an Islamist? [143 words]TerryJan 24, 2003 10:03
Why did we only get Khan's side of the story?
[w/response] [56 words]
GloriaJan 24, 2003 09:46
Does singling out Muslims for additional scrutiny serve a purpose? And if so, is it legally and morally acceptable? [131 words]Steve BeinartJan 24, 2003 09:44
Roger that [197 words]Irving WeinsoffJan 24, 2003 09:44
Legitimate Defense [99 words]Glenn KlotzJan 24, 2003 09:13
Superb documentation! [10 words]D.SokolJan 24, 2003 08:52
But what about the box-cutters, hair dye and cash? [14 words]Glenn AllenJan 24, 2003 08:35
Lesser of 2 Evils [234 words]Hetal PatelJan 24, 2003 08:26
Militant islamists deny free speech in Canada AGAIN [558 words]Mason VergerJan 24, 2003 08:23
Security is a very important human right [301 words]Gabriel GrossoJan 24, 2003 07:26

Comment on this item

Name
Email Address (optional)
Title of Comments
Comments:

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened for relevance, substance, and tone, and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome, but comments are rejected if scurrilous, off-topic, vulgar, ad hominem, or otherwise viewed as inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the Guidelines for Comments. For informational purposes, we identify countries from which comments are sent.

See the 25 most recent outstanding comments.

ADVERTISEMENTS

Premium Links by Wikio

Computers
Electronics
Communication
Appliances

eXTReMe Tracker

All materials written by Daniel Pipes on this site © Daniel Pipes. Email: MeqMef@aol.com

You can help support Daniel Pipes' important work by making a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.