69 million page views

Response to Mr Alisina for his article 'The Challenge'

Reader comment on item: [Moderate] Voices of Islam

Submitted by Wasim Ahmed Bashir (India), Oct 7, 2013 at 02:54

Respected Sir,

The article is submitted as a response to 'The Challenge' article submitted by Mr Alisina on his website faithfreedom.org. It is felt necessary to be submitted on your article [Moderate] Voices of Islam on your kind self website.Hoping for the release.

I read on the web site http://www.faithfreedom.org/the-challenge/the-challenge/ that Mr Alisina portrait the character of Muhammed that Muhammed was a Narcissist, pedophile, mass murderer, terrorist, misogynist, lecher, a cult leader, madman, a rapist, torturer.

Mr Alisina wrote that Muhammed engaged himself in 78 battles during the last ten years of his life spell, as well as all the bad activities by Muhammed are in this last ten years.

Then a question arises why Muhammed faced these activities that too of this type in the last ten years? When Muhammed carried the movement as a rich man in Mecca upto the age of 51 years, and he had only one wife till this age.

After the death of his holiness Sallam Ahmad (Muhammed) , some Sahabis gain the power then at that instance only, first they denied that Sallam Ahmad was not Muhammed Rasul Allah.

Are you not aware that these Sahabis attacked Yemani Muhammedis and massacred just by saying that they have not paid the zakat (tax). There was no base or order for "Jihad on Zakat" because Muhammed said that "collect the tax from your rich people and spend on your poor people.

Malik bin Nowaira was noble and scholar personality in Yeman these Sahabis killed him under conspiracy and raped his wife .

Muslema was called as "Ameerul Momineen" he was also a respectable, noble and learned person, he too was not spared by these Sahabis they killed him.Then after that they got prepared the book called "Kitab Allah" by collecting the inscribed materials from leaves, leather, earthen pots etc.They did not collect those materials written on paper which was got done by Muhammed.

They treated cruelly her holiness Fatema Zohra by snatching the property "FAY AND FIDAK".

Muhammed said that "whose Maula is I'am, Ali is also a Maula of them."

His holiness Ali was totally remained in mourn and involved to serve her holiness Fatema Zohra, sustaining all the cruelty by patience.

These Sahabis said that Sallam Ahmad was not Muhammed Rasul Allah he is only the Rasul like earlier Rasuls.

They made the false history for Maa Khudeja Tahera that :

  1. She was a widow of two husbands and age was 40 years at the time of marriage with Sallam Ahmad.
  2. Other historian write that Maa Khudeja was bachelor and three years older than Sallam Ahmad.
  3. As everyone knows that Warqa bin Naufil was a well known respectable person and invited all the rich and learned people of Mecca in kaaba and he put up the problem before them that "you people wish that my sister should remain unmarried?" on this they all replied, saying that "she is not accepting our marriage proposal, what to do?"

NOTE: There was a trend in Nasrani girls that they would first analyze the character of that person to whom they wish to marry and then get married. And at the same time there was a rule in practice amongst the Bani Hashim that their gentleman used to get married only at the age of 25 years.

The people of Mecca were called as muslims. The luxuriousness was common amongst them. They were against the lesson of Muhammed. Finally when no path left to Meccan people they accepted the lesson in compulsion. When these people gained the power they totally involved in bad deeds. Like these days, when they made a film 'Innocence of Muslims' in which they showed that 'Maa Khudeja' was in her age of twenty one years.

Therefore it is very much necessary to ponder, and how can one take a decision about the age of 'Maa Khudeja' that at what age her marriage took place with Hadhrat Sallam Ahmad.

Those Sahabis prepared a history in such a way that defamation of Sallam Ahmad should spread in the world, because they felt very much bad that their old religion was getting vanished by the lesson of Sallam Ahmad. Therefore they came forward with every tactics and power that the religion of Sallam Ahmad should get vanished and their old religion should come in force and they succeeded in it.

Those Sahabis shown Sallam Ahmad as Rapist, Looter and a husband of many wives etc like this they put all the false character on him. If at all Sallam Ahmad was like this then, when Sallam Ahmad said to Meccan Muslims to acceptLA ILAHA ILLALLAH, they offered to Sallam Ahmad saying that "The property what you say, the dignity what you demand and the beautiful girl which you propose will be made available to you".

But Sallam Ahmad refused their offers and said "If you accept LA ILAHA ILLALLAH then you will have a influential control over the world.

The Sahabis changed the meaning of Kalmah that Allah a personality in the sky.

When the Allah is a collective noun all the things of universe are included in it, further it is called that Allah is Awwal, Aakhar, Zahir, Baatin (that is first, last, seen, unseen) and how can Allah be a single personality in the sky?

Allah is a Arabic word whose statue was kept in the Kaaba, therefore they called it as BAITULLAH means the house of Allah and denied the Kaaba is the grave of Adam.

The people were under the influenced of good character of Sallam Ahmad so they called him with such a respectable title as Sadique, Ameen and Muhammed.

In accordance with the solar system 53 years and lunar system 55 years is the age of Sallam Ahmad, during this period of life no one could point out or put any bad characterized spot on him.

But the left side Sahabis came into the power, first they denied saying that "Sallam Ahmad was not Muhammed Rasul Allah", they created a history to insult him.

On 3rd Moharram 61 Miladi Shamsi Rasul-e-Akram put up the written order and said that "whosoever go against this order whether he is common man or a ruler, he is not amongst us. And those non Muslims who became our subjects, if an enemy attack on them, then for the safety we should safeguard them by defeating the enemy and if anyone wants to marry amongst them without the consent of those people one cannot marry.

We do not need the 50000 U.S dollar award, you read the history and publicize the reality. Please show the character of Imam Hussain because Muhammed said that "Hussain is from me and I am from Hussain."

Please If you don't know about the life of Imam Hussain, therefore it is requested to go through the book named " HAYAT-E-JAVEDANI(Eternity Life) in English by Abu Shama Niazi Danishi " which is international standard book 020## Connemara Public Library Chennai, India and you may procure the book from library or from Mr. Ali Hasan Niazi, Pureh Jahangir khan, Post : Haldharmau, Dist : Gonda (Avadh), Pin : 271126, U.P. India.


Wasim Ahmed Bashir

Solapur. 413003




Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)