2 readers online now  |  69 million page views

Moderate/non-militant Islam

Reader comment on item: On Being Borked

Submitted by Peter Herz (Taiwan), Sep 8, 2003 at 20:40

Hopefully, Dr. Pipes will help the US government think straight. For what it's worth, I think our govenrment has been lost in space and stumbling over its own feet about Islamist ferment ever since Khomeini blindsided the US back in 1979. When I was with the State Department, I recall being told that the "Monsoon Islam" of Bangladesh and Insular SE Asia was a much softer and gentler thing than the "Desert Islam" of the Arab, Persian, Turkic, and NW subcontinental peoples; and that sufis were the kindest and gentlest Muslims of all (they dialogue with Quakers!). I'm also old enough to remember when the official line was that "(Ugh!) Fundamentalism" was a Shi'ite disease to which Sunnis were supposedly immune. The learned brows that spilled such pap on us back then had no excuse for such nonsense, for the jurementados who gave our troops such trouble back in 1900-02 and whose grandchildren in the Moro LIberation Front torubling the independent Philippines were both Monsoon and Sufi Muslims. Sufis also were long the backbone of Islamic revolt in Western China and resistance to both Tsars and Soviets. Somehow our mentors ignored pro-Western Turks and Sa'udi bigotry among Sunnis; and that the average Afghan mujahid--even ones who hoped for a mutually respectful, stable alliance with the West--believed the Qu'ran cover to cover.

Our elites think that mystical, non-doctrinal religion is good; hard-edged, textual and doctrinal religion evil--yet another legacy of the silly sixties, when it was "in" to be the sort of Zen Buddhist who wouldn't be recognized anywhere west of Guam. Yet I can't help but note that Quaker pacifists are nothing but violent Ranters and Fifth Monarchy men who got the worst of it in armed run-ins with Cromwell's Ironsides--and that the Pentecostals, who are so feared east of the Hudson and West of the Beltway whenever they organize their voters, are in fact a lot like the original Quakers in beliefs and outlooks.

I agree with Dr. Pipes that much of militant Islam (but not necessarily all of it) really, really, really wants a fight with the USA, and dances and ululates at our every injury. We have real enemies in that camp who need to be watched and, when necessary, warred upon. The response to 9/11 also makes me confident that most Americans would probably agree.

But I also fear that a high profile American propmotion of "moderate" Islam won't get us very far, and could well backfire in a world in which "neocolonialist" scares more people than "neo-totalitarian". Worst of all, it commits the United States to policing the Muslim conscience from outside--something that just doesn't seem to work (remember Geraldine Ferarro, the pro-abortion Catholic, going around accusing the recently aroused Evangelicals of being bad Christians?).

Those Muslims who are appalled at co-religionists who see every murder of a peaceful ahl-al-kitab or kafir as "jihad" will just have to organize themselves and sell their program to their own peoples. At the same time, I'm also sure that radical Islamism, if victorious in Muslim-majority countries, will be no more successful than Nasserism or any other West-baiting "ism" tried in those countries. The rigidity and anger of radical Islamism's leaders would probably lead to a lot of intramural Muslim wars and troubles long before it would do anything serious to the West.

There's hope. I note that the Assassins of the middle ages morphed into the peaceful, industrious Ismai'li followers of the Agha Khan (whose center seems to be in a minority community in secular India) some time after Hulaku Khan sacked the Alamut. It could well be that when face with the realities of holding power and answering to the expectations of the governed, today's radical crazies will end up facing the choice of either growing up or getting overthrown.


Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submitting....

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (114) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
5The merits of Democracy! [65 words]Rabab BakrOct 12, 2008 06:36139987
Democracy [34 words]Adeosun habeebApr 3, 2010 05:03139987
THE MERIT OF DEMOCRARY [10 words]VIDHYAApr 12, 2010 11:53139987
on being borked Aug 26,2003 [76 words]S.C.PandaOct 15, 2003 03:1911792
Congratulations [120 words]Dr. Arnold (Avi) YoskowitzSep 21, 2003 23:2011396
Moderate/non-militant Islam [630 words]Peter HerzSep 8, 2003 20:4011091
A good choice [19 words]Peter HerzSep 8, 2003 20:0711090
No better choice [48 words]GuidoSep 3, 2003 10:2310990
Kudos on your appointment, and Thank G-d! [60 words]Allyson Rowen TaylorSep 2, 2003 23:2710974
Mazel Tov! [49 words]Bruce A. BirnbergSep 2, 2003 11:2110960
elated by your appointment [93 words]marcylandesbergSep 2, 2003 00:0810958
Congratulations. [43 words]Lenn ChowSep 1, 2003 15:2110952
Congratulations [41 words]ivan barnaAug 31, 2003 15:1510940
Good luck and keep up the good work [180 words]Edward J. CourtneyAug 31, 2003 04:4010938
5What is the difference between Islam and Militant Islam ? [911 words]Yael Amishav MedvedAug 30, 2003 21:2310936
The depth of your words! [273 words]Amina NdiayeDec 1, 2014 19:4010936
1Victims of Islam and of Arabian imperialism [1024 words]dhimmi no moreDec 7, 2014 08:5310936
NO Surprise [136 words]Neil AbramsonAug 30, 2003 15:3010933
Common Sense [20 words]MarkAug 30, 2003 03:0910926
Congratulations! [49 words]AvrahamAug 29, 2003 19:1810918
Congratulations [16 words]S. & B. GittelmanAug 29, 2003 17:1510916
Support for your nomination [80 words]Joe BeharAug 29, 2003 16:4210915
You have not received a prize! [110 words]Barrie O. WardAug 29, 2003 07:1410910
Well deserved [18 words]Pal MalaterAug 29, 2003 07:0410908
congrats [8 words]charles benderAug 28, 2003 21:5410904
Congrats [99 words]hari iyerAug 28, 2003 18:4810900
On Being Borked [190 words]Carmen Waggoner, Ph.D.Aug 28, 2003 16:1310898
Distortion of your record [86 words]Susan LeskoAug 28, 2003 07:4610893
Bush is a very brave and wise president [10 words]Jin Wee HoAug 28, 2003 07:3210892
Thank you Mr. Pipes [46 words]Katherine McLeanAug 28, 2003 06:3310891
Very Good Choice [66 words]Victor W. JordanAug 28, 2003 02:4810889
Congratulations [66 words]Doron KAug 28, 2003 02:3910888
Moderate Islam [77 words]Israel ZalmansonAug 28, 2003 02:1610886
A hearty congratulations! [56 words]Scott SchneiderAug 28, 2003 01:4210883
History will tell [76 words]MikeAug 28, 2003 00:4510882
Daniel Pipes understands [112 words]Robert BoltonAug 28, 2003 00:3910881
No one better for this than Daniel Pipes [66 words]Byron MurgatroydAug 27, 2003 23:3410878
Congratulations on your appointment [25 words]Joshua TruaxAug 27, 2003 23:1710877
Bravo [120 words]Arlinda DeAngelisAug 27, 2003 23:1210876
At last! [287 words]Shahin ShadmerAug 27, 2003 21:5210874
Congratulations on your appointment [35 words]Robert K. CassattAug 27, 2003 20:1810872
Congratulations! [16 words]YonasonAug 27, 2003 20:1410871
Use the Koran against the Jihadists... [95 words]Debra TAug 27, 2003 17:3410869
Behind Daniel Pipes [119 words]JeffAug 27, 2003 17:2010868
A liberal for Pipes [36 words]Mark MattsonAug 27, 2003 16:4710867
A Man of Integrity [155 words]Richard ZaborskyAug 27, 2003 16:4310866
I support you 100% [15 words]Lucy SamuelsAug 27, 2003 16:2110865
1Democracy's merits? [74 words]Herve SeligmannAug 27, 2003 15:4110864
God does answer prayer... [30 words]Brian EargleAug 27, 2003 15:2810863
Smear tactics [109 words]Laura HagansAug 27, 2003 15:1210861
A Victory for Common Sense and Integrity [103 words]Shoshi BaconAug 27, 2003 14:1010860
You are an Asset to All Americans [53 words]Michael GlazerAug 27, 2003 13:2710859
Thanks Senator Schumer! [116 words]GKAug 27, 2003 13:1810858
Congratulations [80 words]Dan HennessyAug 27, 2003 08:0110856
Congratuations [22 words]Bernard ZimmermannAug 27, 2003 08:5910852
Bork Bork Bork [7 words]Phil WardAug 27, 2003 08:4310851
Congratulations - You made me laugh [61 words]AdamAug 27, 2003 07:3810850
Support for Daniel Pipes [75 words]Norman MenchelAug 27, 2003 06:3610849
Hope for the Future [82 words]Diana SebbenAug 27, 2003 06:1610848
Why Kennedy? [25 words]Arthur CohnAug 27, 2003 06:0510847
The Study of Islam [133 words]Michael BurkertAug 27, 2003 05:4510846
Daniel Pipes: Our Hope [39 words]Lebanese citizen trying to be freeAug 27, 2003 01:3610845
Congratulations on your appointment [103 words]Chana GivonAug 27, 2003 04:5910844
Congratulations [48 words]Liliana Z LeitmanAug 27, 2003 04:0510843
Congratulations! [34 words]Dan GurtaAug 27, 2003 03:5210842
The Stupid Attacks on Daniel Pipes [118 words]Irving D. CohenAug 27, 2003 03:3310841
A right decision, for a change! [120 words]Robert HandAug 26, 2003 23:3110840
Congratulations are in order. [109 words]John R. PeacherAug 27, 2003 03:2410839
Interesting [17 words]Steve RunionAug 27, 2003 02:5710837
Congratulations [45 words]Virginia ThogersenAug 27, 2003 01:5710835
The circus sideshow is over--I hope [82 words]William KinneyAug 27, 2003 01:5210834
Cowards [73 words]Al ChinaskiAug 27, 2003 01:2810833
My support to a fearless warrior. [95 words]KamathAug 27, 2003 01:2410832
Congratulations [94 words]G Y Perry, M.D., FACCAug 26, 2003 20:5110831
Finally recognition so deserved [32 words]Millye & Irving CohenAug 27, 2003 00:1210829
Congratulations! [4 words]Gene BehlAug 26, 2003 23:5610827
It's About Time [169 words]Debbie Wallis LandauAug 26, 2003 22:1410825
Too few of us know [213 words]Ruth LowryAug 26, 2003 17:5210824
congratulations [26 words]Amos TurnerAug 26, 2003 21:0110819
Congratulations [71 words]lkrutAug 26, 2003 20:2310816
Finally [34 words]Tom CabanissAug 26, 2003 19:4910815
Congratulations [98 words]Vivian E. WolfeAug 26, 2003 15:4410814
Congrats! [14 words]Ann SmithAug 26, 2003 19:0510812
Congratulations!! [65 words]Janice SentaraAug 26, 2003 18:4110809
Rebuttal [24 words]Gary MillerAug 26, 2003 17:5310807
Naming of Allies [64 words]thomas lane andersonAug 26, 2003 17:4510806
Congratulations [46 words]Adele Mischel M.S.W.Aug 26, 2003 12:4010802
Congratulations! It's about time. [134 words]Jack LassAug 26, 2003 12:0910799
Congratulations Daniel [90 words]Jack LassAug 26, 2003 12:0110798
very pleased with your articles [199 words]Nuray BamanieAug 26, 2003 11:4810795
Quran Reading [42 words]shahidJan 9, 2009 02:2910795
Congratulations on your appointment [90 words]Cathy WilsonAug 26, 2003 11:3610794
A Voice That Must Be Heard [210 words]Richard L. RubensteinAug 26, 2003 11:0410792
Congratulations!!! [137 words]Jerry SteinfeldAug 26, 2003 10:4710790
Non militant Islam [14 words]GMAug 26, 2003 10:4510789
Vindication [147 words]Alberto MizraiAug 26, 2003 10:3910788
Thank You Mr. Pipes [150 words]John CastleberryAug 26, 2003 10:3610787
Opening another door [196 words]Goldie SacksnerAug 26, 2003 10:3210786
Basis of bias [69 words]Margaret KeysorAug 26, 2003 10:2210785
Positioning [60 words]AJKAug 26, 2003 10:1810784
My Support [105 words]MicheleAug 26, 2003 10:1110783
Bravo! [6 words]Gideon KannerAug 26, 2003 09:5610782
Fax to Bush Thanking Him [25 words]Ron CaryAug 26, 2003 09:5210777
Congrats [63 words]Frank VicenteAug 26, 2003 09:5110776
Dubious honors [193 words]Hamlet's ShadowAug 26, 2003 09:4110775
Congratulations [77 words]Michael WolinAug 26, 2003 09:0610774
Congratulations on Worthy Appointmernt [76 words]Charles GeshekterAug 26, 2003 08:3710772
What a relief [112 words]Daphne BurdmanAug 26, 2003 08:2510771
A Democrat for Pipes [126 words]Lawrence WinansAug 26, 2003 08:2510770
On Being Kennedyed [55 words]Charles LowderAug 26, 2003 08:0210769
Your generosity to those who loath you [301 words]Kenneth BesigAug 26, 2003 07:4210768
Militant Islam [159 words]Alan JacobsAug 26, 2003 07:3810767
Confirmation to USIP [76 words]Joanne PrivesAug 14, 2003 15:5510583
Congrats Mr. Pipes! [17 words]Greg BarnardAug 13, 2003 19:4910567

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to Moderate/non-militant Islam by Peter Herz

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

ADVERTISEMENTS

eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2019 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)