A muslim is as a muslim does..
Reader comment on item: Muslim Soldiers in the West, Criticized by their Communities
in response to reader comment: A real Muslim, a real American Soldier

Submitted by donvan (United States), May 31, 2007 at 14:23

So you are a closet Muslim. Forced by circumstances to hide your true belief, yet you go to such lengths to inform us how you stand for truth, justice and the American way. Just don't sound right. Honesty, you see, also means integrity. It sounds like your Islamism is a " Muhammedism lite".

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened for relevance, substance, and tone, and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome, but comments are rejected if scurrilous, off-topic, vulgar, ad hominem, or otherwise viewed as inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the Guidelines for Comments. For informational purposes, we identify countries from which comments are sent.

Submit a comment on this item

Reader comments (118) on this item

Title	By	Date
Pakistani Vision : Destruction of West by Pakistani Islamic Nukes [80 words]	Birju Amit	Nov 8, 2009 13:56
Surely this is another case of 'Sudden Jihad Syndrome'? [11 words]	J Schamroth	Nov 8, 2009 10:25
The threat to America from radical Islam [201 words]	Bob Jack	Nov 8, 2009 10:24
Homicide Bomber Or Martyr Questions [73 words]	infosifter	Nov 8, 2009 10:19
redemption [95 words]	yuval Brandstetter MD	Nov 8, 2009 07:44
↔ PC correctness [133 words]	dfwhite19438	Nov 9, 2009 15:17
Do muslims fight secular wars? [46 words]	GeorgeP	Jul 11, 2009 02:48
↔ What about the Muslims they're fighting for? [70 words]	Malcolm (Australia)	Jul 18, 2009 07:20
↔ War for religion [335 words]	Rafi	Nov 8, 2009 09:54
British Muslim, British Hero [56 words]	Javed Javed	Feb 18, 2008 08:03
Follow 120000 Prophets, Is that practcale? [52 words]	miriam	Feb 14, 2008 08:49
A real Muslim, a real American Soldier [4809 words]	Al Amreekee	Jan 21, 2007 22:43
↔ Great Man [172 words]	Philip Saenz	Feb 10, 2007 20:57
↔ You Deserve Respect Not Disrespect Forgive The Ignorance Of The Sleep [124 words]	Deshawn Addison	Mar 22, 2007 22:15
↔ ⇒ A muslim is as a muslim does.. [53 words]	donvan	May 31, 2007 14:23
↔ Well-said! [185 words]	deborah majzoub	Jun 18, 2007 13:51
↔ Get a life [174 words]	Doug Corrigan	Apr 17, 2008 13:48
↔ Amreeke: Excellent Points [152 words]	Viking Woman	Apr 21, 2008 05:18
↔ To Doug Corrigan [317 words]	sayitlikeitis	May 7, 2008 20:33
↔ Hatred destroys. Not a relilgion. [23 words]	Anne Ziegler	Sep 23, 2008 15:16
↔ A Muslim is a muslim [148 words]	ariana	Oct 4, 2008 05:35
↔ quite true.. [92 words]	donvan	Oct 6, 2008 08:29
↔ Do research before you refer any references [634 words]	Rektivianto Yoewono	Apr 18, 2009 19:18
↔ dont be ingulfed by flame of the bewilderment you are in and make research to get away from the personal stress [223 words]	faisal	Jul 8, 2009 02:14
↔ Opposites [151 words]	Illary	Jul 13, 2009 00:36
↔ Misquoting the Quran [15 words]	Mike Fontane	Nov 8, 2009 13:38
I am a muslim soldier in US Army [572 words]	'Al Amreeke'	Dec 24, 2006 16:42
↔ A 'good Muslim' cannot be American... [320 words]	Warren Raymond	Dec 25, 2006 03:12
↔ Dubious veracity of 'Al Amreeke' [22 words]	Abu Nudnik	Jan 2, 2007 10:39
↔ You're not alone [157 words]	Frank Mascaro	Jan 6, 2007 14:43
↔ fish nor fowl.. [142 words]	donvan	Jan 9, 2007 16:55
↔ Safety [206 words]	Yaakov Watkins	Jan 11, 2007 22:22
↔ I salute you, Al Amreeke [214 words]	Michel C. Zala	Jan 17, 2007 15:53
↔ Muslim Soldier in US Army [1169 words]	Another American	Jan 18, 2007 02:53
↔ I'm Your Friend [75 words]	Philip Saenz	Feb 7, 2007 20:01
↔ don't believe your story...Sarg..! [366 words]	fatchabrute	Mar 19, 2007 04:09
↔ To "Soldier W...Al Amreeke:" Label me "Unconvinced." [255 words]	mariana	May 14, 2007 12:52
↔ Sad [64 words]	Kat	Jun 11, 2007 22:24
↔ thank you for your service [71 words]	gary fouse	Jun 18, 2007 00:15
↔ i dont understand why american government allow muslims to build mosques in such a huge numbers [65 words]	anil	Aug 15, 2007 15:02
↔ To Al Amreeke & all Muslim-American Soldiers [55 words]	Susan	Sep 17, 2007 10:46
↔ That is wrong!!! [136 words]	AllahAkbar!	Sep 17, 2007 20:49
↔ You can't have it both ways [174 words]	JOE KAFFIR	Jan 14, 2008 15:38
↔ salaam brother [119 words]	Yasser Al Sharara	Jan 21, 2008 07:07
↔ And we rely on guys like this to obtain important intelligence? [48 words]	Doc Tater	Feb 6, 2008 17:57
↔ God save your country [81 words]	tj	Mar 3, 2008 05:08
↔ Life is tough all over - welcome to the real world. [206 words]	Jon White	Apr 4, 2008 09:54
↔ MY STORY:Muslim Marine Everyday [82 words]	muslim marine	Jun 30, 2008 04:34
↔ Joe Kaffir, you are now enlightend [77 words]	Muslim Marine	Jun 30, 2008 04:49
↔ To donvan [74 words]	Muslim Marine	Jun 30, 2008 17:28
↔ Semper Fidelis [192 words]	donvan	Jul 1, 2008 11:06
↔ NO ONE IS PERFECT brother! [47 words]	TIPO ZOLTAN {HOLLAND}	Aug 19, 2008 13:22
↔ to Al Amreeke [63 words]	Liliana	Sep 20, 2008 10:40
↔ Thank you Buddy. [80 words]	John Cerkez	Nov 3, 2008 21:44
↔ TENTH VERSE "...Same As The First... A Little Bit Louder, A Little Bit Worse...." [50 words]	mariana	Mar 5, 2009 12:43
↔ comments on a story [59 words]	Alex	Apr 8, 2009 10:23
↔ "New" Muslim [527 words]	DJM	May 21, 2009 15:33
↔ Nor do I believe you [25 words]	Pippa	Nov 8, 2009 19:47
↔ Our dear DMJ and his imaginary friend [420 words]	dhimmi no more	Nov 9, 2009 07:53
↔ Nice try, Al! [56 words]	Guy Macher	Nov 9, 2009 14:14
i love these brave soldiers [56 words]	danica	Aug 12, 2006 05:14
↔ PROUD TO BE AMERICAN MUSLIM IN THE ARMY!! [369 words]	ahmadzafire	Dec 24, 2006 18:50
↔ ... follow the same Prophets? [103 words]	W. A. Tomlinson	Jan 2, 2007 17:58
↔ I ain't buying ... [324 words]	Mark Major	Jan 4, 2007 09:01
↔ W. A. Tomlinson yes the same prophets... [261 words]	ahmadzafire	Jan 4, 2007 23:36
↔ easy answer [489 words]	ahmadzafire	Jan 6, 2007 02:37
↔ More baloney [121 words]	Mark Major	Jan 6, 2007 14:38
↔ more from what you dont know.... [132 words]	ahmadzafire	Jan 6, 2007 21:24
↔ Still ain't buying it [316 words]	Mark Major	Jan 8, 2007 05:27
↔ I don't think so [317 words]	Mark Major	Jan 8, 2007 06:21
↔ So Elison cannot say if our constitution comes before Quran--- and he swore alligience to USA?? [175 words]	Jaladhi	Jan 8, 2007 15:56
↔ ahmadzafire - the clerics and Iraqis won't agree with you!! [128 words]	Jaladhi	Jan 8, 2007 17:16
↔ Mark Major [262 words]	ahmadzafire	Jan 8, 2007 21:20
↔ not really.... [59 words]	donvan	Jan 9, 2007 17:18
↔ teach what theyre interpretation of... [29 words]	ahmadzafire	Jan 9, 2007 23:06
↔ Personal Jihad Against Jihad [96 words]	Noah Freitas	Jan 12, 2007 13:46
↔ I disagree with you [270 words]	Mark Major	Jan 14, 2007 12:50
↔ Individual moral imperative [123 words]	Mark Major	Jan 14, 2007 13:40
↔ more info on marriage and four wives [566 words]	ahmadzafire	Jan 15, 2007 23:42
↔ You can't justify Polygamy in the west [242 words]	Mark Major	Jan 17, 2007 09:36
↔ Mark Major it's not polygamy if its not out of sexual content. [440 words]	ahmadzafire	Jan 17, 2007 20:58
↔ What I said [254 words]	Mark Major	Jan 19, 2007 09:39
↔ what i said [787 words]	ahmadzaffire	Jan 21, 2007 00:20
↔ people are awakening. [180 words]	surjit	Jan 22, 2007 19:30
↔ sorry you feel that way!!! [28 words]	ahmadzafire	Feb 7, 2007 00:45
↔ Polygamy [581 words]	sam	Feb 12, 2007 23:56
↔ You went off on a tangent [112 words]	Mark Major	Feb 20, 2007 00:35
↔ My Opinion [72 words]	mark Major	Feb 20, 2007 00:43
↔ Mark, with all respect... [1327 words]	sam	Feb 21, 2007 21:01
↔ I like your version of Islam Sam............. [265 words]	Timothy	Feb 22, 2007 12:50
↔ Ahmed whom are you really fooling? [228 words]	morous	Mar 2, 2007 12:07
↔ wrong Sam [47 words]	fatcha	Mar 19, 2007 04:34
↔ ahmadzafire ... ? [218 words]	fatcha brute	Mar 19, 2007 05:31
↔ Ahmadzafire [63 words]	fatchabrute	Mar 20, 2007 02:53
↔ fatchabrute [150 words]	ahmadzafire	Mar 22, 2007 20:44
↔ ELLISO NEEDS TO DROP THE FRONT... [18 words]	verballistic	May 4, 2007 03:44
↔ Bible or Country? [20 words]	Donna	Nov 7, 2007 23:55
↔ Not true [428 words]	cennicia	Feb 14, 2008 08:41
↔ Mark Major I dont believe you [23 words]	Muslim Marine	Jun 30, 2008 05:02
↔ What point are you trying to make [97 words]	mark major	Jul 6, 2008 06:10
↔ Believe what you will, I won't try to convert your way of thinking [278 words]	Mark Major	Jul 6, 2008 06:33
↔ Lets look at this in context to the lives they lived and what is god like [279 words]	Mark Major	Jul 6, 2008 07:13
↔ A lot of what you say is true though: [125 words]	Mark Major	Jul 6, 2008 07:38
↔ listen!! [299 words]	ahmadzafire	Jul 7, 2008 21:39
↔ prove it [21 words]	ahmadzafire	Jul 7, 2008 21:44
↔ Mohammed was still different by the way he lived his life [162 words]	mark Major	Jul 10, 2008 05:38
↔ you don't get the point [56 words]	ahmadzafire	Jul 10, 2008 23:17
↔ free speech Buddy [353 words]	Mark Major	Jul 19, 2008 05:35
↔ Perception is what i call it [515 words]	ahmadzafire	Jul 28, 2008 13:59
↔ Hellfire Blazes over the heads of Kafirs [252 words]	Still a Kafir	Oct 6, 2008 23:37
↔ Still a Kafir [124 words]	ahmadzafire	Oct 8, 2008 15:02
↔ if Support kafir against muslims you will be with them, not with muslims [60 words]	MOHAMMED ABDUL MUJEEB	Apr 6, 2009 07:38
↔ MOHAMMED ABDUL MUJEEB [145 words]	ahmadzafire	Apr 7, 2009 03:16
↔ You don't kill other muslims and that's not your intent...!? [164 words]	MOHAMMED ABDUL MUJEEB	Apr 8, 2009 01:52
↔ MOHAMMED ABDUL MUJEEB [94 words]	ahmadzafire	Apr 8, 2009 22:18
↔ The Lord will take away there crescents [210 words]	Colin	Jul 21, 2009 12:18
↔ People please!!! We are failing the test from Yahew,God,Allah,Jeavoah,Almightly etc... [798 words]	ahmadzafire	Jul 22, 2009 19:51
↔ Reply to ahmadzafire - Jesus Christ is born of Virgin Mary as a SINLESS BLOOD only can save this WORLD [148 words]	A Christian	Nov 20, 2009 17:43

Comment on this item

See the 25 most recent outstanding comments.

Latest Articles

A muslim is as a muslim does.. Reader comment on item: Muslim Soldiers in the West, Criticized by their Communitiesin response to reader comment: A real Muslim, a real American Soldier

Reader comments (118) on this item

Comment on this item

A muslim is as a muslim does..
Reader comment on item: Muslim Soldiers in the West, Criticized by their Communities
in response to reader comment: A real Muslim, a real American Soldier