69 million page views

Change in Iran affects little; Militant. Islam lives because of Saudi royal dreams

Reader comment on item: [The Need to Name and] Know Thy Terrorists

Submitted by T. Kumar (United States), Nov 19, 2002 at 14:08

Dr. Pipes, you are correct. Bush and the crowd have to start telling as it is. The soft light on Militant Islam merely results in confusion.

Re: John Wilkinson comment: Changes in Iran are limited to Shiite Islam. The only difference it makes is to the shias in Lebanon and Iran. Wahhabis don't view the Shias as muslim anyway. So ripples from Iran do not travel far.

It is the meglomanic dreams of the US-educated princes of Saudi Arabia that support and nourish the major portion of Militant Islam. It is not a question of the US telling the SA royals that either they take care or we will. They are the root cause of many of the problems being spread around the world.
Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (178) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
1America's Stark Choices [1103 words]Justin O SmithJul 23, 2012 18:08197395
16The Muslim U.S. Military Experience [1402 words]Justin O SmithJul 23, 2012 17:58197390
Muslim Immigrant Veterans [99 words]S U TurkmanJan 28, 2016 23:00197390
1The True Nature of Islam/ or My Legitimate, Dutiful and Right War [1342 words]Justin O. SmithJul 23, 2012 17:49197386
8what america must do to stop islam/terrorism [57 words]frank wongOct 16, 2006 20:2960644
5response to frank wong [162 words]DorothyDec 19, 2006 10:5460644
2educate yourself [222 words]sarahFeb 21, 2007 17:3860644
1answer to "educate yourself" [274 words]jaffreyJun 13, 2007 00:4560644
2stopping muslim immigration [74 words]KeithOct 9, 2007 20:0560644
3You need muslims [39 words]TausifApr 16, 2008 09:2260644
In Support [112 words]USAJun 12, 2008 19:3560644
1rebuttal to answer to "educate yourself" [83 words]Jim ThomsaNov 17, 2008 21:2260644
Lack of life experience [44 words]PatrickSep 25, 2009 20:5060644
1Answer to Dorothy [166 words]Major OkieJan 10, 2010 13:4560644
3Islam is evil. There is no doubt about it. [50 words]AndyJan 25, 2010 22:3360644
1hello [66 words]mazenJun 1, 2010 19:1360644
3IMPORTANT THING TO KNOW WHY ISLAM IS A FAST-GROWING RELIGION [160 words]Jake CarterJul 5, 2010 06:3360644
2ISLAM TRUTH [72 words]ADAM12Aug 2, 2010 22:2260644
1What values in human existence is INTELLECT [126 words]Shuaibu OchejeAug 20, 2010 07:1860644
2stop muslim immigration in US> [102 words]johnSep 11, 2010 15:2660644
1islam infiltration [400 words]jack evansSep 12, 2010 00:0760644
what america must do to stop islam and terrorism is ... [4 words]Lewis BOct 4, 2010 00:2360644
1Halt Muslim Immigration to the U.S. Now! [910 words]Justin O. SmithJul 23, 2012 17:4160644
3Muslim immigration to the US [109 words]dhimmi no moreJul 24, 2012 07:2860644
1STUPIDITY and LITERACY; two different entities [73 words]LanreDec 20, 2013 22:1760644
1my conversion to christianity [172 words]abdullah mahmoodOct 16, 2006 20:1660642
2choosing the wrong path after having the right path [210 words]GhulamOct 29, 2006 08:2260642
4Islam IS a religion of War [197 words]MarigotusNov 13, 2006 20:0660642
religion [78 words]fnnielsonNov 27, 2006 02:1460642
Science Religion [69 words]marigotusNov 27, 2006 19:4060642
There is one large distinction here. [138 words]JoeJan 23, 2007 11:1960642
To hell to war................... [172 words]SyawashJan 17, 2008 14:1460642
To hell with war.... Yeah agreed. [283 words]MarigotusJan 19, 2008 18:3660642
1Islam and Terrorism [187 words]Zainul from Kuch IndianJun 2, 2008 08:2060642
GOOD [22 words]OYELEKE SUNDAY OYEDEJIJan 27, 2010 08:3160642
1I have a solution [53 words]Durka DurkaSep 8, 2006 00:3355215
Terrorism [270 words]JackNov 8, 2007 14:2355215
Ethics [729 words]victorAug 12, 2006 02:3352475
Islamic Terror [121 words]J PhilipAug 9, 2006 06:1352174
2The Battle of Badr Surah 8 ayah 65 [186 words]KianaDec 19, 2006 19:1152174
Liberation of Mecca and Medina [137 words]Dr BanoDec 10, 2005 19:3629754
islam is a faith of peace [61 words]allahs boyMay 9, 2006 18:5729754
1Islam is a WAR religion [77 words]MarigotusNov 13, 2006 20:1329754
Consequences. [10 words]IhsanDec 27, 2006 00:4229754
Totally agree with [10 words]PamNov 15, 2005 23:4428455
Islam [74 words]MAISIENov 3, 2005 21:4327758
The Real Problem.... [203 words]Ahmed Omer HussainOct 19, 2005 04:1827092
Reform Works In Both The Jewish And Christian Faith, Muslims Must Not Be Afraid Of Reform [102 words]AnneMJul 8, 2006 08:1427092
islam..and mohhamed [30 words]Joe HackOct 19, 2009 18:1827092
Response to comment by Frank, Dec. 5 [52 words]Dinnah SalamMar 15, 2005 10:5520989
Christmas every day in Turkey [90 words]Michelle KalpakciDec 21, 2004 05:1719057
Dear Iqbal reply [101 words]frankyAug 2, 2004 17:5316194
Mohammedism [172 words]DON VANJun 4, 2004 16:2715542
1What is wrong with Americans? [46 words]PontusMar 8, 2004 07:0414116
The Question Should Be, What Is Wrong With The Rest Of The World? [49 words]AnneMJul 8, 2006 08:2114116
Health Care [94 words]Bill JardineSep 8, 2009 20:0714116
Quran Promotes Peace [201 words]Muhammad IdreesFeb 24, 2004 23:3913991
MOHAMMEDIAN IDEOLOGY [118 words]DONVANJan 20, 2004 15:4913439
Will The Real Terrorists Please Stand [234 words]raheem malik shabazzDec 18, 2003 19:5912744
1What should we do about terrorists? [89 words]CalieDec 14, 2003 14:0912652
Who attended the 2003 Iftaar dinner? [102 words]MarkOct 30, 2003 06:3012018
Come to K.L [132 words]zafirSep 19, 2003 15:0111341
Against All Humanity [73 words]ChuckAug 19, 2003 14:2510648
Giant Monster [37 words]GeorgeApr 10, 2003 23:238255
There is no way out ! Either Islam Or World without Islam [92 words]IndianJun 7, 2006 01:458255
1no way to conciliate with islam [69 words]dawud from moroccoJan 28, 2008 08:028255
continued... [71 words]menonApr 30, 2009 18:028255
What Arabs are capable of? [11 words]MichaelJan 30, 2003 20:456143
1Same narrow-mindedness! [51 words]SalmanJan 16, 2003 08:595804
1terrorism is bad 'it needs to stop [30 words]bilal scottJan 9, 2003 12:405614
1why terrorism should be stopped [13 words]Joseph LorenzoMay 6, 2009 12:075614
fascists [30 words]Gabriel GrossoJan 6, 2003 14:545523
To Terrall Putnam [131 words]Mink RiversJan 6, 2003 14:505521
Re: Political Correctness [391 words]henri bollDec 17, 2002 19:534747
Disagreed [140 words]TaminaJan 11, 2006 20:144747
The key to the solution of Palestine lies with the Arabs. [404 words]Sher Mohammad.Dec 16, 2002 11:184645
Islam wants to conquer the whole world [45 words]JamesDec 11, 2002 08:514517
Quranic concept of Justice [437 words]Rehan AhmadDec 10, 2002 21:434514
christ will rule [127 words]dougSep 18, 2006 18:544514
1We Moderate Muslims Must Stop Living in Denial [220 words]Iqbal C.Dec 10, 2002 12:124506
War on Terrorism, on the right track? [158 words]Brad OrleckDec 7, 2002 22:034474
Call a spade a spade [36 words]Darell IrvingDec 6, 2002 16:504455
Same Old Stuff [136 words]FrankDec 6, 2002 09:154448
Saudi Wahabbi control: Mr Pipes, hope you are listening. [140 words]Hari IyerDec 4, 2002 20:524428
Putin said what Bush did not [237 words]Dr. Ron PollandDec 4, 2002 09:304413
When is the last time an Islamic country celebrated christmas? [102 words]Hari IyerDec 3, 2002 15:174382
open your mind [71 words]DorothyDec 18, 2006 12:064382
Convert to Islam, problem solved [15 words]AbuBakerSmithDec 22, 2007 14:534382
The Losing Game [610 words]Johnny SpearsDec 3, 2002 11:254374
No Militant Islam [292 words]Ned LoraDec 2, 2002 20:314360
Does Islam support terrorism? [42 words]Graham SpenceNov 29, 2002 09:294313
I can't believe these comments! [97 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
AhmadNov 28, 2002 12:384308
America's problem [159 words]Chip JoyceNov 27, 2002 11:554286
The Enemy [239 words]ADeAngelisNov 27, 2002 08:444276
Clear, thoughtful, and courageous. Thank you! [69 words]Jerry FullerNov 24, 2002 13:194188
Thank you: you are a light in the darkness [31 words]Sally RogowNov 23, 2002 20:004179
I hope we pull through [108 words]J.ShearerNov 23, 2002 16:574176
Biased against Islam in India [34 words]RiyazNov 23, 2002 04:584168
Violence in Nigeria Cannot be Called Spontaneous [81 words]Warren SmithNov 22, 2002 17:594157
Response to Tom Penbroke: More Headlines.... [153 words]Tom PensylNov 22, 2002 17:084154
It's Now or Never [123 words]Glenn KlotzNov 22, 2002 15:264150
Most Americans do not seem to see what is unfolding before them. [184 words]KOBE SBMNov 22, 2002 14:494149
THERE IS A DIFFERENCE!!!!!!! [158 words]AhmadNov 22, 2002 09:494148
A difficult question indeed. [360 words]Rodger ClampittNov 22, 2002 02:064143
Are the Nigerian mobs' killing an example of Islam or Militant Islam? [84 words]KumarNov 22, 2002 01:354142
War by Proxy [228 words]David SteinbergNov 22, 2002 00:534140
Question for Dr. Pipes [138 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Karsten BraschNov 21, 2002 23:474137
1We Don't Know What We Don't Know [230 words]George McFaddenNov 21, 2002 22:034135
The problem is with those who don't listen [150 words]Arthur HutchinsonNov 21, 2002 20:084133
Arab-Islamic Terrorism [200 words]Joseph Wahl, MDNov 21, 2002 17:484127
Militant or not, Islam is the same to me [118 words]R.SinghNov 21, 2002 16:514125
What we do know [168 words]WillieNov 21, 2002 13:454121
Pipes needs to advise Jerry Falwell [80 words]T. AndersonNov 21, 2002 13:334120
Be aware of the Islamic cult [60 words]Himalaya GuptaNov 21, 2002 12:584119
See, Hear, Speak No Evil (or Fact) [156 words]Tom PembrokeNov 21, 2002 12:384118
Emil's got a point [110 words]Geraldine ShapiroNov 21, 2002 09:184116
[233 words]J.SchumannNov 21, 2002 01:464111
I Wonder if I should buy an electric car? [226 words]Don RoseNov 20, 2002 20:054109
I agree with Guy Viti [158 words]Patrick PummillNov 20, 2002 19:224107
I see, I see------ [102 words]wm. Regis Mc DevittNov 20, 2002 18:044102
Know ALL Thy Terrorists, not just two. [161 words]Mr. M.S. SmithNov 20, 2002 17:514101
"What should we do now"??? [95 words]RayNov 20, 2002 16:514099
Our real enemy is our "ally" [118 words]SullyNov 20, 2002 15:044091
Powell, Carter etc etc... [88 words]Dave CurranNov 20, 2002 12:364088
Is Militant Islam the same as states that sponsor/harbor terrorism? [131 words]RachelNov 20, 2002 12:114086
To Fundamental Joe: [137 words]D. ConnellNov 20, 2002 12:104085
The answer: Statesmanship [38 words]Clark ThompsonNov 20, 2002 12:024083
Why the ambiguity? [91 words]EmilNov 20, 2002 11:214079
Bush on Militant Islam [197 words]Jimmy D. O'DeaNov 20, 2002 10:444078
2CHRISTIANS AND MUSLIMS ARE ONE [113 words]Subomi I.Mar 20, 2006 19:034078
White House Ramadan Dinner [146 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Debbie TNov 20, 2002 10:064076
Muslims at the Whitehouse, what's wrong with that? [283 words]An American SoldierOct 13, 2006 22:424076
keep islam out of the white house [84 words]joshApr 4, 2007 18:124076
Courageously Calling it Correctly [102 words]Gail DalickasNov 20, 2002 09:354073
Militant Islam [147 words]Andrea HyattNov 20, 2002 03:054066
"The War on bin Ladenism , Wahhabism or Khomeinism " [38 words]Mladen AndrijasevicNov 20, 2002 02:534065
Fundamentalism [17 words]JoeNov 20, 2002 02:344064
Know Thy Terrorists [175 words]Stephen BerghoffNov 19, 2002 23:234062
Exactly right on PC "Profiling-Phobia" [72 words]E. NarrettNov 19, 2002 22:514058
Militant Islam is the enemy but... [112 words]Elliot B. PasikNov 19, 2002 22:174056
Al Qaeda to America: Convert or die [240 words]Joshua TruaxNov 19, 2002 21:224053
Crystal clear writing [51 words]Jay A. Lerman, MSIANov 19, 2002 19:134051
Losing the "War on Terrorism" [441 words]Edward ClineNov 19, 2002 18:394050
Keep your enemies closer [109 words]Boris FrenkelNov 19, 2002 18:034049
Distinction made between Islam and Militant Islam [215 words]Guy VitiNov 19, 2002 18:014048
My Muslim contacts tell me ... [110 words]John L. BergNov 19, 2002 17:114047
Al Jazeera Ownership Shift [28 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Bill KNov 19, 2002 16:104046
If only leaders would listen... [44 words]Marcella JenkinsNov 19, 2002 16:064045
TV and Islamic Terrorists [114 words]JrsDadNov 19, 2002 16:024044
You sure know your terrorists!! [83 words]Su EstrellaNov 19, 2002 15:444043
Identify, Name and Target [184 words]Graham Rael-BrookNov 19, 2002 14:144041
Change in Iran affects little; Militant. Islam lives because of Saudi royal dreams [123 words]T. KumarNov 19, 2002 14:084040
I Hope They're Listening! [35 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Moishe SachsNov 19, 2002 13:094038
What, if anything is wrong with Islam ? [235 words]Graham SpenceNov 19, 2002 12:524037
Islam is Miltiant and Repressive, but rarely free [329 words]ToddNov 19, 2002 12:454036
Defining our enemies [190 words]Boris GalinskyNov 19, 2002 12:444035
Islamic Fundamentalism is the Real Enemy, not just Saddam [101 words]Perry GoldsteinNov 19, 2002 12:414034
islam does not support terrorism [45 words]yussuf adan kuleyJul 13, 2006 11:294034
Right On...as usual [9 words]Bill JohnsonNov 19, 2002 12:134032
Black Muslims as militant Islamists [114 words]Rudi FrankeNov 19, 2002 11:594031
Islam is by the Koran militant [82 words]Greg OfieshNov 19, 2002 11:484030
Words are Important [59 words]Saul CooopermanNov 19, 2002 11:384029
9AMERICA, IDENTIFY YOUR ENEMY! [414 words]G.J.O. MoshayNov 19, 2002 11:214027
2Some Hints on Islam [428 words]Sameh MohamedAug 5, 2006 18:284027
"Your iniquities have separated between you and your God" Isaiah 59:2 [190 words]Alan O'ReillySep 25, 2006 08:294027
A DEAD BRAIN AWAKES TO RUIN "THE REAL HUMAN SOCIAL LIFE"( ISLAM ). [93 words]Shuaibu OchejeAug 14, 2010 16:384027
Revelation to Jesus [681 words]Dirk SmitAug 15, 2010 18:144027
Law and Order: CI (Criminal Intent) use of "Jihad" [124 words]Carol LeborgNov 19, 2002 11:184026
Definition of "jihad" [39 words]ebFeb 18, 2006 19:054026
Militant Islam Blindness- Hopefully Divide and Conquer [143 words]Norman WandNov 19, 2002 11:064025
Divide and Conquer? [125 words]James GlennonNov 19, 2002 11:034024
Thank God for Daniel Pipes! [38 words]Diane HuntNov 19, 2002 10:544023
Well done! [5 words]Robert G. MogullNov 19, 2002 10:454022
Slightly Different Definition [264 words]Mark W. TesarNov 19, 2002 10:444021
Colin Powell's Comments [106 words]Terrall PutnamNov 19, 2002 10:424020
What can we do to help? [95 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
E. DuncanNov 19, 2002 10:404019
While I agree, I disagree [138 words]John WilkinsonNov 19, 2002 10:324018
1Implementing the Islamic Ideology [103 words]TerryNov 19, 2002 09:574016

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)