| Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List |
A difference of opinion
Reader comment on item: Gilad Shalit and Doing Business with Terrorists
in response to reader comment: Rebecca, I have to contest your comments
Submitted by Rebecca Moulds (United States), Oct 18, 2011 at 18:55
Dear Sara,
I respect your opinion about this and I hope you respect mine. I know what you said is true, that every Israeli is rejoicing, and even non-Israelis, like me----are also rejoicing for the freedom of Gilad Schalit,. It's the method of his release, the bargaining table, that I believe was questionable. Perhaps it's because I'm a jaded realist and you may be an idealist, that I don't see the honor in this.
Dislike
Submitting....
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
Reader comments (94) on this item
 |
 |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| tracking devices [35 words] | steve omara | Nov 25, 2011 13:31 | 191176 | ||
| update relations with Egypt [65 words] | Gary Josephson | Oct 29, 2011 20:50 | 190503 | ||
| 7 | How about the Irish option? [69 words] | Malcolm | Oct 25, 2011 05:15 | 190353 | |
 The Irish method is only good in Ireland [91 words] | Nadia | Apr 16, 2017 14:41 | 190353 | ||
| 8 | WHAT LOOKS LIKE A TACTICAL MISTAKE IS A GOOD STRATEGIC MOVE [567 words] | SGAN LEVI | Oct 24, 2011 01:08 | 190327 | |
| Protecting Shame [120 words] | Jay1 | Oct 23, 2011 20:47 | 190321 | ||
| 1 | Cook the Frog slowly [430 words] | ASh | Oct 23, 2011 07:44 | 190303 | |
| 1 | At least the Quartet remained silent. Progress! [41 words] | Robert W. | Oct 23, 2011 03:34 | 190299 | |
| 1 | Doing Business with terrorists [22 words] | Daniel Wang | Oct 22, 2011 21:21 | 190296 | |
| As One dimensional, as concrete, and as slogan-istic " revengeless" as possible! Who needs More? [241 words] | Ash | Oct 23, 2011 08:14 | 190296 | ||
| 1 | Death penalty for some murderers [71 words] | SM ISAC | Oct 22, 2011 13:40 | 190281 | |
| They have us by our !@#$% [128 words] | car313 | Oct 22, 2011 10:09 | 190279 | ||
| 1 | Horrible Deal [2164 words] | Dave Gerber | Oct 21, 2011 13:54 | 190249 | |
| Shame and Deal [34 words] | Jay1 | Oct 26, 2011 18:15 | 190249 | ||
| 1 | The Return of Gilad Schalit [106 words] | Nathan Rosenblatt | Oct 20, 2011 21:09 | 190214 | |
| The Media [202 words] | Mike Kurtzig | Oct 21, 2011 20:16 | 190214 | ||
| We are an amoral society [77 words] | Bev Rosoff | Oct 22, 2011 14:52 | 190214 | ||
| 1 | no next time [109 words] | Glenda Urmacher | Oct 23, 2011 00:36 | 190214 | |
| 1 | pride, not shame! [117 words] | ahuva kapon, Israel | Oct 20, 2011 17:03 | 190204 | |
| Doing Business With Terrorists [404 words] | Renee Bouvier | Oct 20, 2011 17:28 | 190204 | ||
| A Different Spin [97 words] | Barry Black | Oct 20, 2011 16:52 | 190203 | ||
| Of Course you are right; of course you are wrong [76 words] | john w mcginley | Oct 20, 2011 16:45 | 190201 | ||
| 1 | a question: why did the govft. of Israel (GOI) accept this deal NOW? [423 words] | aryeh berkovich | Oct 20, 2011 12:59 | 190193 | |
| 1 | Hapiness borders insanity [203 words] | NuritG | Oct 19, 2011 19:13 | 190177 | |
| Making Maximalist Demands [402 words] | Renee Bouvier | Oct 20, 2011 17:21 | 190177 | ||
| Up to Israel to do what is good for her [416 words] | NuritG | Oct 20, 2011 21:23 | 190177 | ||
| Shalit Release [82 words] | sam | Oct 19, 2011 16:51 | 190175 | ||
| 12 | Doing Selective Business with Terrorists [157 words] | Michael Hanni Morcos | Oct 19, 2011 09:51 | 190171 | |
| 2 | Another approach to freeing Shalit [8 words] | Kafirman | Oct 19, 2011 08:45 | 190170 | |
| 1 | Killing NO. Settlement and annexation? a different view [110 words] | Ash | Oct 23, 2011 08:31 | 190170 | |
| 1 | Forsaking principle and common sense [127 words] | Albert Edelson | Oct 19, 2011 08:02 | 190169 | |
| IDF is not measured against the number of its enemies [127 words] | myth | Oct 21, 2011 03:59 | 190169 | ||
| 4 | Symbolism of Shalit's swap [18 words] | Ben Haggai | Oct 19, 2011 06:36 | 190168 | |
| Lawfare Questions: WIll the US Seek Extradition? [97 words] | PezDispenser | Oct 19, 2011 04:52 | 190163 | ||
| 2 | the gilad schalit exchange [144 words] | michael tal | Oct 19, 2011 04:47 | 190162 | |
| 1 | Whose Shame/. [74 words] | Harry | Oct 19, 2011 03:56 | 190161 | |
| 2 | Did you impply that Israel should not have made the 1 to 1000 exchange? [262 words] | Prashant | Oct 19, 2011 02:35 | 190160 | |
| 3 | Shame on them? [375 words] | Ron Gerskup | Oct 19, 2011 01:50 | 190159 | |
| Shame on them? [55 words] | Ron Gerskup | Oct 20, 2011 01:56 | 190159 | ||
| Prisoner swap [52 words] | niyaz | Oct 19, 2011 01:23 | 190158 | ||
| 1 | Questions for Niyaz [103 words] | Prashant | Oct 20, 2011 22:09 | 190158 | |
| 2 | Asking the hyenas to go vegetarian [172 words] | car313 | Oct 26, 2011 14:16 | 190158 | |
| 1 | tracking terror [20 words] | jerome Henen | Oct 19, 2011 00:21 | 190155 | |
| 4 | double bind [205 words] | Nora A | Oct 18, 2011 22:28 | 190152 | |
| What about Jimmy [69 words] | Michael Kurtzig | Oct 20, 2011 15:24 | 190152 | ||
| yech Jimmy Carter [30 words] | Nora A | Oct 20, 2011 22:01 | 190152 | ||
| Jimmy [66 words] | Mike the K | Oct 21, 2011 20:06 | 190152 | ||
| 4 | Shalit Exchange Benefits Israel [200 words] | Dan Rusen | Oct 18, 2011 21:43 | 190150 | |
| I agree Dan, it only benefits Israel and saves lots of money [284 words] | Nadia | Apr 15, 2017 19:59 | 190150 | ||
| 1 | Wonderland [36 words] | D. Krabbenhoft | Oct 18, 2011 21:32 | 190149 | |
| 2 | Right on! [83 words] | Ralph C Whaley MD | Oct 18, 2011 20:15 | 190146 | |
| 1 | My Letter in the Jerusalem Post on this [109 words] | jd | Oct 18, 2011 20:03 | 190144 | |
| No Trade. [27 words] | Dennis Wojciak | Oct 18, 2011 19:54 | 190143 | ||
| 5 | 1 Shalit = 1000 Palestinians? HA HA [202 words] | Pied Piper | Oct 18, 2011 19:45 | 190142 | |
| 3 | וְשָׁבוּ בָנִים, לִגְבוּלָם [11 words] | SHOSH | Oct 18, 2011 19:21 | 190139 | |
| shalit [35 words] | louis françois abba shalom | Oct 18, 2011 19:11 | 190137 | ||
| The prisoner swap is a disaster [45 words] | MEContrarian | Oct 18, 2011 19:02 | 190136 | ||
| 1 | Idiocy [15 words] | Kerry | Oct 18, 2011 18:55 | 190135 | |
| 3 | Real Mathematics [80 words] | Sudad Jawad | Oct 18, 2011 18:19 | 190133 | |
| Glad to see him free... BUT [55 words] | Abu Nudnik | Oct 18, 2011 18:07 | 190131 | ||
| 2 | Microchip The 477 [47 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | jrpeacher | Oct 18, 2011 17:56 | 190130 | |
| 2 | fiction or fact [81 words] | Jules Posten | Oct 24, 2011 14:22 | 190130 | |
| 2 | You can't bring the dead back. [20 words] | Abe | Oct 18, 2011 17:48 | 190129 | |
| 7 | Nobody wins [118 words] | Rebecca Moulds | Oct 18, 2011 17:30 | 190126 | |
| 8 | Rebecca, I have to contest your comments [277 words] | sara | Oct 18, 2011 17:40 | 190126 | |
| 1 |  A difference of opinion [74 words] | Rebecca Moulds | Oct 18, 2011 18:55 | 190126 | |
| 1 | A very sad day for Israel [50 words] | patricia | Oct 18, 2011 19:21 | 190126 | |
| 1 | Negotiating a Peaceful Solution in the Face of Hostility [181 words] | M. Tovey | Oct 18, 2011 19:29 | 190126 | |
| 2 | How Much is one Jewish life worth? [30 words] | Mark Harding | Oct 18, 2011 21:10 | 190126 | |
| The US Marines, Talmud, History & the future [195 words] | Gary Josephson | Oct 19, 2011 12:57 | 190126 | ||
| politicial stupidity [95 words] | rodney allsworth | Oct 18, 2011 17:21 | 190125 | ||
| the koran as I understand it [463 words] | Gary Josephson | Oct 20, 2011 17:33 | 190125 | ||
| 6 | Sanctity of life vs. Sharia and life [81 words] | Michael Hanni Morcos | Oct 18, 2011 17:13 | 190124 | |
| 1 | Re: Gilad Shalit's Release [90 words] | Linda Ann Long | Oct 18, 2011 17:11 | 190123 | |
| 1 | A Great day but a sad day [34 words] | peter | Oct 18, 2011 17:09 | 190121 | |
| 6 | Disagreeing with you [206 words] | Philippe Lavie | Oct 18, 2011 17:09 | 190120 | |
| 1 | Right thing to do [82 words] | Mark | Oct 19, 2011 18:32 | 190120 | |
| 3 | Gilad had a right to be saved [64 words] | joshua | Oct 18, 2011 17:05 | 190119 | |
| Comfort to soldiers [137 words] | Josh G | Oct 19, 2011 05:29 | 190119 | ||
| 1 | How will they justify [42 words] | Steve | Oct 18, 2011 17:04 | 190118 | |
| 2 | Thousands of terrorists freed [31 words] | zac | Oct 18, 2011 17:03 | 190117 | |
| 1 | Had to be done [16 words] | iggy | Oct 18, 2011 17:01 | 190116 | |
| Michael Kurtzig [105 words] | Mike the K | Oct 18, 2011 19:30 | 190116 | ||
| 3 | Gilad's release had to be, despite the awful implications [172 words] | sara | Oct 18, 2011 16:57 | 190115 | |
| yes, but.... [72 words] | Nora A | Oct 18, 2011 22:34 | 190115 | ||
| 5 | NO Shame, yes Pride! [161 words] | reuven Ofir | Oct 18, 2011 16:52 | 190114 | |
| The real danger [55 words] | Josh G | Oct 19, 2011 05:23 | 190114 | ||
| 3 | You don't understand the Basic Jewish and Israel Values [270 words] | Joe Ziv | Oct 19, 2011 06:20 | 190114 | |
| Arabs Play Hardball & Jews Play Softball [4 words] | Dan Friedman | Oct 18, 2011 16:51 | 190113 | ||
| Perhaps [3 words] | Abu Nudnik | Oct 18, 2011 18:08 | 190113 | ||
| 3 | Shait bless you & and may there not be any more Shalits (although I'm afraid it's inevitable) [78 words] | Lee | Oct 18, 2011 16:38 | 190112 | |
| Shalit, bless you...may there be no more Shalits [86 words] | elated&sad | Oct 18, 2011 16:31 | 190111 | ||
| 2 | "deal" [more accurately termed capitulation] a great argument for capital punishment; questions [113 words] | Rob | Oct 18, 2011 16:29 | 190110 | |
| 1 | Make Sure there's no Next Time [81 words] | Benj Pollock | Oct 18, 2011 17:43 | 190110 |
Latest Articles
Follow Daniel Pipes
All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2025 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes
Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes
(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.
Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.
For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)