3 readers online now  |  69 million page views

„ Under the spreading chestnut tree I sold you and you sold me."

Reader comment on item: A Critical Moment For Turkey
in response to reader comment: "Fool Me Once, Shame On You; Fool Me Twice, Shame On Me!"

Submitted by Ianus (Poland), Jun 6, 2007 at 07:54

Dear Mariana ,

Thank you very much for your thorough and thoughtful analysis . Again , what you write about the state of the nation sounds really alarming and dismal . The American power elite seems to have become aristocracy in all but name – exclusive , estranged from the people , squandering the nation's resources , corrupt , unaccountable . It is at the core of the present problems and if nothing changes radically much evil awaits the country.

I'd like you , dear Mariana , to see my remarks below in the similar context . They don't result from any malice or anti-Americanism whatsoever. On the contrary, I am for America, wish it all the best . I do know that if something bad happens to it, all the world will suffer immensely as a result .

The difference between a flatterer and a friend - to my mind – is that a friend helps define and correct what is wrong and what harms the friend . A flatterer doesn't do that because he is interested in perpetuating the wrong thing and in harming the "friend" for his own benefit. So please , read what follows as words of someone who is not a flatterer but who would like to be seen as a friend (not a "friend") .

">> Yes, these are very serious reproaches . But perhaps the Russians also have some serious doubts and counter-charges ? The US didn't treat the Soviet Union fairly and rationally ."

> This I get not at all. Russia's becoming part of the Civilized World should not require the American Teat for success; rather, they need to better manage the resources of their rich homeland, and mostly, reorder their priorities. Already, we're paying for and subsidizing their space program, paying their scientists who have not gone over to Iran , N.Korea, and anyone else with $$ opposing us. At the same time, they use their own fungible funds to strengthen and increase the grip of KGB and rearm Military, nationalize industry, shut-down independent media, and export assassins to the Civilized World [to intimidate dissenters], just like the old Stalinist USSR.

I admit you're right on this point .

But as to „independent" media , still they seem to depend on many biased sponsors outside Russia. When I hear on radio Liberty a eulogy of the Chechen "dissenters" , I can't but think of Beslan and Budionnovsk. Even at the time of those mass kidnappings there were some "independent" media that tried to blame the Russians for the horrors of traditional Chechen banditism . Kidnappings were something most common during the old Chechen independence and the Dudayev era . But the "independent" media somehow preferred to ignore history and blame the victims . I wonder what sort of "independence" of the media it is then ?

">> The US didn't treat the Soviet Union fairly and rationally . First , the US allied itself with radical Islam to defeat the Soviet 40th army in Afghanistan."

> And the USSR had the right to invade, destroy and occupy Afghanistan...because...?

Cold war logic , you know. I try my luck in the Bay of Pigs , you try yours across the Pamir . Both parties played the game, didn't they ?

> Invasion and occupation by the 40th Soviet Army was not a picnic by the lake for the tens of thousands they brutalized and or killed, or the hundreds of thousands of Afghans who were forced to flee their homes and country into exile.

As long as the Soviets stayed , Kabul was intact and the civil war which was responsible for the worst atrocities and destructions was kept under control. With the advent of mercenaries from the Arab world and modern American weapons overflooding the countryside the war assumed its total and uncontrolled dimension with more terror and retaliations . Remember the Russians were not so stupid and used troops preferable with Tadjik and Usbek background in Afghanistan to accomodate the Afghans. But it didn't help much against Osama bin Laden and his ilk .

> Why would you try to make this outrageous Soviets behaviour sound like a benign, legitimate undertaking?

Compared to US-backed Mujahedeens the Soviets behaved benignly , didn't they ? I've never heard they had ever played Buzkashi (sort of polo) with cut-off heads of their POW-s as was the case with the Mujahedeens who used to do that with the Soviet POWs' heads.

> Putin in Prague has just explicitly threatened another Cold War and Arms War." He's not getting things all his way all the time, so he's going to throw bombs?

And what would you do in his position ? Greet the missiles in Poland which we here in Poland don't need or want at all ? Thank the US for creating two Moslem states on the Balcans - Bosnia and Kosovo ? Shake the president's hands and be grateful for his supporting of the UCK terrorists who specialized in blowing churches and kidnapping Orthodox clergy ? The US is responsible for expelling Orthodox Christianity from its cradle in Kosovo and making Bosnia a bridgehead of Wahhabism . If there is anyone who should thank the US for these „gifts" it is no doubt the Saudi king and his Wahhabi entourage . This honeymoon with Islam on the US side is a sheer folly ! Two new Afghiansitans have been created in Europe. The US will harvest the fruit of its mad acts.

">The result was 9/11. Then they cheated Gorbachov - the only politician I've ever trusted...and supported all the centrifugal forces to break up the USSR to get rid of its competitor. Gorbachov was betrayed not only by Yeltzin but also by his Western "friends". Then the intrigues in the Caucaus to get hold of Baku and in Central Asia, military missions to Georgia ."

> Hearing this from you saddens me more than I can express. THIS DID NOT CAUSE 9/11!

No ? The US supported radical Islam to expel the Russians from Afghanistan. Islamists did the assigned job with American stingers and other modern weapons . But they had their own agenda and started a civil war which brought the most radical faction (Taliban) to power . All this happened with American support. Now the Mujahedeens turned against their benefactors of yesterday and one of their organizations (al-Qaida) paid them back with 9/11. Wasn't it so ?

> Gorbachov's genius was in understanding that centrifugal forces and Soviet brutal mismanagement of resources, peoples, and the economy for 70 years, were inevitably {finally} catching up to them. His "opening" was designed to be like all the prior Soviet "openings," but Yeltsin [with a lot of help from Reagan, the Pope] and enough Freedom seekers among his own people, wrested the process from his hands, accelerating the timeline and redirecting his "initiatives" to "serious reforms."

I don't think your analysis, dear Mariana, is correct. Gorbachov was sincere in his efforts to reform the USSR without ruining and destroying it . He was an honest and responsible man . He failed because the US wanted no Soviet Union at all . They wanted a weak, divided set of small states in lieu of the old big USSR . It was the well known "divide and rule" policy . Hence the US support for all centrifugal forces - even if meant that a factory in Armenia which produced chains for saws made in another factory in Latvia would both be ruined . Even if most radical Islamist forces in Central Asia should be unleashed with a resulting civil war in Tajikistan .

Yelstin was an incompetent drunkard and a thug that used tanks to smash the parliament under the eyes of the entire world (3.10.1993). He stole more money than all the thieves Russia has ever had . Some estimates say that the economic losses Russia suffered during the Yeltzin era were greater than the losses Russia had suffered during WW II . He allowed wild corruption and crime to flourish , he deceived pensioners , workers , intelligentsia , the military , all except his family that he made rich . Under his regime life expectancy declined dramatically . And you call it „serious reforms" ?

">> I have never heard a single condemnation from the US of the discriminatory treatment of Russian minorities in the post-Soviet states - Latvia with c. 50% non-Latvians gave them no right to vote and no citizenship . Estonia did the same with c. 30% of Russians living there... , Yet , the West blamed the Russians , not the new oppressors whom it protects ."

> Again, the Soviets intrigued and occupied the Caucuses, murdered and subjugated their peoples, confiscated their lands, businesses and resources for the greater good of the "ethnic Russians" they infiltrated to repopulate, exterminate and rule over the indigenous populations. These Russians delegitimized the languages and cultures of these countries, forced collectivization, nationalized private industries and properties [as they did with their own Kulaks].

> There's history here, Ianus.

What history is it , dear Mariana ? The Caucasus and Central Asia before the advent of the Russians were delacerated by never-ending bloody wars and banditism . I have told you a few things about the Chechens before . The Cherkess were not better. When the Russians came and put an end to their robberies and kidnappings they emigrated en masse to Turkey and they were settled in Bulgaria where they continued their traditional „way of life" . They were responsible for the Bulgarian horrors which triggered the Russo-Turkish war of 1877-1878 . These atrocities for the first time in history made even the Brits ( the Ottomans' tradtional godfathers ) consent to the Russian intervention to stop the extermination of the Christian Bulgarians .

You can't imagine what those regions looked like before the Russians stopped the endemic lawlessness reigning there . Instead of history anti-Russian propaganda is spread across the West . As you rightly hinted referring to the US citizens , the West lives in a largely unhistorical worldview . They don't read historical books . What for ? They think they are so clever that they have escaped that boring useless past !

What would have happened to the Amernians if the Russians had not intervened in the Caucaus ? As to the Baltic region it was an artificial German creation after 1918. Russia conquered it from Sweden during the Great Northern war at the beginning of the 18th century.

> Just as you fervently opposed the deliberate occupation, division and polarization of Cyprus by Turkey; the USSR ate all of "Eastern Europe," treated native populations barbarously, flagrantly disregarding even a modicum of Human Rights with impunity.

Come on ! Turkey is a scourge of Europe. Russia broke that scourge and pushed Moslem Turkey far away from Europe. You should appreciate the role of Russia in taming and breaking Islam in Europe and in the Caucasus instead of repeating anti-Russian slogans invented by Chechens , Cherkess and other Moslems frustrated by the Russians . If you weaken Russia you strengthen Moslems. Do you really want that ?

Here in Poland the Russians are hated by some nationalist intellectuals. the latter will never tell you that the Russians gave the Polish serfs liberty and land which belonged exclusively to the nobility that lost much as a result of that . It happened in 1863 . The Russians abolished slavery in the newly acquired Moslem terrotories , stopped Moslem banditism , including the worst of them all - the Chechen terrorism . Small wonder the Chechens and their ilk are angry.

> And what had these captive peoples done to deserve this?

Captive people ? You should live for a year in the Caucasus to see what sort of people you have to deal with ! The best place I might suggest would be some villages in Dagestan or on the frontier between Nagorno Karabakh and Aserbaidjan.

> Simply, Russia wanted to "secure [read annex] it's Near Abroad."

In most cases , it was an enslaved or endangered nation that turned to Russia to protect them against more powerful Moslem neighbors . It was the case with Georgia that was protected against Turkey. The Armenians survived only thanks to the Russian protection . Probably you forgot the pogroms of Armenians in Baku at the end of the Gorbachov era or the intrigues of the Turks in Aserbaidjan and in Central Asia to reinforce Islam and Pan-Turkish ideas there ?

> They accomplished and maintained this annexation with impunity, using the most brutal and violent means at their disposal, and they remained, largely unhindered for 50 years.

As long as the Soviets stayed in the Caucasus , no wars were raging there. That was very much for the people living there . The moment they left , the old story began anew. And of course the Soviets were to blame. Who would dare criticize the "freedom-loving and self-determining" nations ?

> Now these Commissars and their privileged families expect to keep their illegitimate status as "overseers," the properties they confiscated, while demanding to be loved, honoured, and afforded the very rights and "equitable treatment" they forcefully denied their victims in their own countries.

What is someone's medicine is someone else's poison , dear Mariana. In the Caucasus or Central Asia you have the choice either between a strong overseer or a permanent war . You don't have a choice between good and evil , democracy and totalitarianism. This beautiful theories have a very limited applicability indeed. W hat happened in the „liberated" Afghanistan when the Soviet overseer left , happened also across the former USSR when the Russians were expelled . Sad but true. The Soviets were bad , but still better and more equitable lords than the former emirs and sheikhs in Central Asia and Chechen tayp (clan) lords .

> The realization that sixty years after the forced conquest of the Caucuses, the majority of these "squatters" refused to learn or use the local languages,

How many Americans speak Navaho or any other exotic native dialects ? There are several hundred languages in the Caucasus and they are so complicated that you'd have to spend several years to be able to understand any single of them basically . And what gain would you have from it ? Any rational Russian person would rather learn English or German instead of Kabardian or Azari.

> insisted in living in and maintaining [de facto and de jure] ethnic Russian communities, were uninterested in becoming Estonian, Lithuanian or Latvian but rather deliberately remaining "Russians," says it all.

No, it doesn't , dear Mariana . Can you realize how much hate and contempt for all things Russian is hidden behind all these formalities to acquire a Latvian or Estonian citizenship , to deprive the Russians of their identity. The Latvians or Estonians will never treat a Russian as equal even is he or she happens to know their language and their distorted history-books ( where the SS Division „Estland" or „Lettland" or „Galizien" is a heroic unit fighting for liberty ) .

> Their hearts are with "Mother Russia;" it is to Mother Russia they whine and moan about their plight, and it is obviously in Mother Russia that they belong.

And what do you know about the hearts of the Latvians e.g. ? Do you know how many of them are anti-semites , how many served in the Nazi extermination camps and SS and police units ? Ask any Jew and he'll tell you where a Latvian's or a Lithuanian's heart belongs. Understandably enough , this isn't well-advertised in the Western media where the new oppressors are given a privileged treatment and undeserved amnesty at the expense of the old oppressors . I myself wouldn't rather prefer to identify myself with "Mother Russia" than with "Stepmother Latvia" with such a dubious record of hers.

> The "new oppressors" who are being "protected" by the West, are the indigenous peoples whose countries are under discussion.

„Indigenous people" ? Lithuanian peasants were made aware of their nationality by Polish and German linguists and ethnographers in the 19th century. They were ruled by totally Polonized nobility. Anyway , they treat the Polish minority near Vilnius not better than their Russian minority. Latvians and Estonians were just illiterate peasants ruled by German aristocracy who left due to the Soviet-Germany treaty of 1939 before being persecuted and largely expropriated by the nationalists . They fully discovered their „nationality" after the Kaiser German troops occupied these regions in 1917-1918 . As the Germans had not enough personnel to run the Baltic provinces they created local administrations which with the collapse of Germany and Russia took over . Had it not been for the German Freikorps the Bolsheviks would have easily re-occupied the Baltic states in 1919.

> Russians unhappy with having to give up their ill-gotten status and some abusively ill-gotten gains, need use their 60 years experience to go home to "improve Russia" the same way they "improved the Caucuses."

Don't jump to conclusions , dear Mariana. Russians are no Moslems and improved the Caucasus by liquidating Moslem states and weakening Islam all along , building churches there . Now look at the Americans ! They „improve" Europe by creating Islamic states here ! The Russians deserve some respect for their efforts . I observe with horror the ongoing Islamisation of Europe and how America contributes to it .

As to the Russians' homeland it is where they were born and grew up. By expelling them , no one is going to win. Least of all the Baltic states that now so gaily destroy Soviet World War II memorials and build their own to their local antisemites and SS fighters .

> As for Chechnya and Georgia. USSR replacing their government with Russian Viceroys or ethnic puppets has no legitimacy; and the deliberate subversion of the elected President Schevardnadze, is utterly indefensible. This man had previously represented USSR as Foreign Minister, is known to us all, and is no more gangster or terrorist than the rest of the Russian government.

Do you remember Gamsahurdya and the Gerogian civil war ? There is enough powder inside Georgia to blow the republic without a single Russian match. The main problem there is lack of control from above and traditional Caucasian feudal mentality . It led to permanent wars in Gerogia after 1991 – against South Osetia and against Abkhasya and the civil war under Zvyad Gamsakhyrdya , to corruption , banditism and all things Georgia had been notorious for during its days of independence .

> I guess Ianus, in this, I'm basically Reaganite. I believe that those countries and peoples the USSR forcibly dominated and held behind the "Iron Curtain" for 50 years, have a right to self-determination without Russian interference.

Sure , but do they have a right to make use of this right to deprive those who were born there of any rights ?

> Russia has screwed-around with these peoples one way or another for many hundreds of years, and they'd been seriously restive for 15-20 years before the long overdue, inevitable "break-up."

Lithuania was heavily subsidized by Moscow. Lithuanian communists enjoyed a privileged status within the Communist Party of the Soviet Union . The same can be said about all those most rabidly anti-Russian ‘new democracies". By the way , in Latvia e.g. they hate not only Russians . They dislike even Poles.

> That Russians themselves are [like frogs swimming in a pot of warm water over a high flame] calmly accepting re-conquest, confiscation and inevitable collectivization by the KGB. In time, this will redound to their everlasting shame; they've made their bed and it will be a long time before Americans will be interested to take another bite of this apple.

I admit Russia is a rotten state. But you've said America is rotten too. This inner structural failure must get its expression in foreign policy as well.

> >...I do believe that esentially Russia and the US share the same civilization,..."

> This comparison of yours, I reject utterly. Neither Russians nor Soviets were raised with the American Constitution or Bill of Rights; THEY DO NOT BELIEVE THEMSELVES ENTITLED to Liberty, Freedom, Right to own arms, Worship [or Not] unhindered in any manner they choose, and to elect their own [albeit, feckless] Representatives, according to one [approved] set of rules and laws.

As to common civilization I meant Christianity and Enlightenment . Both Russia and the US share this principal Eurpean heritage. It is only about this that I was speaking.

Now with all respect I have towards the Amercan way of life , I find the right to carry arms quite questionable . If you had our (Middle European or Russian) history , you'd know why. Arms are there not only to make their producers rich , but to be used . Here they were massively used and we thank you for this „right". (Again someone's medicine is someone else's poison.)

And as to „freedom and liberty" it is a nice but a tricky slogan. We've had extreme social conflicts here and know ad nauseam that the soft talk of „freedom" is most useful where something else is meant . Just like democracy turned out to mean „oligarchy" , so „freedom" turns out to mean „freedom for wrong people" . By „wrong people" I mean those who have riches dubiously acquired and whose cultural and intellectual level reminds of that of some „heroes" of popular soap operas produced in Hollywood . They have freedom to make the world around them in their own image. And this is a nasty and hateful world indeed !

> Russians and Soviets have never believed that they are "... Endowed by their Creator....to Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness..." They went from a Theocratic Monarchy to Secular Monarchy masquerading behind a fictional "Supreme Soviet" and "Polit Bureau," and {they} in all cases expected Benefits and Blessings to come down from a privileged minority, above.

Well , if you think what problems the Russians had to cope with during their 1000 years of history , if you think of the vastness of the land masses they had to cross and make secure , of numbers and savage character of their enemies around , then you should probably be less categorical in your judgements , dear Mariana . The American historical experience you're referring to is a trifle compared to what the Russians had to get through .

Still , the Russians remained a Christian nation , stopped and pushed back the Islamic monster and would have almost wiped it out in Europe had it not been for the ignorant and selfish West that saved the sick man on the Bosporus from certain ruin and thus prepared a delayed ruin for itself .

Troubles in Russia will help no one . Demanding that Russia play the game only according to the wrongly defined interests of the West will bring chaos across Eurasia and nothing else . It happened so in 1917 and in 1991 . Chaos in Russia may be in the interest of the West , but isn't in the interest of Russia and all those who happen to live near Russia or appreciate a few Russian things like the Russian intelligentsia that I respect highly.

To put it in a different way – It's bad to be with Russia . It is worse to be without Russia.

> Americans chose to come here to become "American,"
carving lives out of the wilderness [read J.F. Cooper's "The Last of the Mohicans"], with little or NO involvement from an earthly "authority" [until, alas, the recent perversion and over-reach of government], believing for the most part that they/we should be left alone to make our own way, "do our lives" and raise our children. It is American "Leadership's" disrespecting, disregarding, and ignoring these fundamental beliefs held by Americans [constituents who elected them], that have ignited the growing discomfort, "murmurings" and rage: the Immigration bill has simply become "the spark."

Sorry , but the Wild West stories sound rather unconvincing in my ears. They show a lawless , violent and brutal society where the difference between a freedom-loving type and a ganster type is often invisible. Again it's an experience that can't be generalized.

And corruption and abuse of power in American public life has a long and "glorious" tradition , if I remember Tweed Boss' story well .

">... [US & Russia] face the same implacable enemy of their common civilization - Islam..."

> While this is certainly true where terrorism for the revivification of the Caliphate by Militant Islam is concerned, it's obvious that Putin and his cohorts do not consider this sufficient cause to diminish their hostile, aggressive behaviour vis a vis his own people, his former [Near Abroad] prisoners or "the West." Putin continues advising, arming, providing technical assistance to, and exporting forbidden items in trade to Iran , encouraging AhmediNejad's Nuclear program, and shielding them from even the pitiful US, UN, EU sanctions and consequences of their persistent, flagrantly contumacious behaviours. The anti-missile system to Poland is a result of this threat Russia/Iran pose to the West.

So why not proclaim openly Russia and Iran the enemy ?

In my opinion Russia is using Iran against the US in the spirit of the game played by her adversaries as well . Once it was the US that mobilised Islam against teh Soviets . Now Russia is doing that against the US . Under the spreading chestnut tree I sold you and now you sold me.

The bad guys are on both sides. The tragic thing is only that both sides are going to lose if they continue to befriend and arm the wrong ‘ally' that hope to cheat them all and rule alone .

> As for putting this anti-missile system in Turkey, you yourself have posited some of the best arguments I've seen against this.

Sure . But here in Poland I know no one who is really afraid of Russia . And people just sneer when told we are threatened by Iran. , let alone North Korea ! No one buys that nonsense! Instead they are concerned that now that we are going to install the ‘shield' we will just become the real target !

> Putin does not consider himself part of the West except insofar as he can derive credits, recognition and benefits from distracting and deceiving us. He explicitly rejects Freedom and Liberty for either his own people or those he coerces into Russia's orbit. Anyone who convinces himself otherwise, is ignoring past and present history and events, and deluding himself.

So choosing between open enemy -Russia and hidden enemy ( Saudi Arabia and Turkey) the US will prefer the latter of course ? This way the US will commit a fatal mistake . It gets more and more islolated and behind its back a huge anti-American coalition is building up – Islam +Russia+ China. The US is unable to deal with a single of these threats , how will it be able to face the combined force of them all , if they really one day decide to join forces and strike ?

> > Islam has ALWAYS won its jihads through the hands of the infidels themselves. It is strong through the weakness and civil wars prevailing in the dar-al-harb."

> About this, time will tell and we shall see. mariana

This is a historical statement , dear Mariana . I know not a single victory in Islam's history which was achieved by Moslems alone. Starting from Mohammed himself who was assisted by Jews from Medina , through conquests in Persia , the Byzantine East , Spain , Turkey . You have everywhere the same pattern . Moslems' success was ALWAYS due to defectors , useful idiots , kafirs' quarrels and envy .

So I'd rather say that time has already shown this . And I can only hope that we'll learn from that historical experience and not repeat fateful mistakes which turned out to be the undoing of great civilizations and proud nations.

All the best , Ianus


Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (265) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
4apologize [48 words]duygu kumaşOct 13, 2010 13:47179233
1europe needs more smart and fair people like sarkozy to tell the truth [283 words]erolJan 27, 2009 10:14149221
Cultures in EU [40 words]TTTJun 3, 2009 10:26149221
to erol : europe needs more smart people. [438 words]farukSep 4, 2012 17:36149221
6we shall never forget [24 words]Michael Hanni MorcosSep 5, 2012 01:59149221
1really? [151 words]TimJul 24, 2013 20:45149221
4We shall Never Forget [140 words]Michael Hanni MorcosJul 26, 2013 12:00149221
1peace [17 words]TimJul 26, 2013 21:16149221
What about other countries genocides? [219 words]TaskinAug 23, 2015 09:08149221
Response for genocide [32 words]EsaMar 5, 2016 05:04149221
1Turkey Attacking Iraqi Kurds, and the House non-vote on the Armenian Genocide [507 words]Doc TaterOct 26, 2007 15:48112397
3Aren't you overlooking something? [241 words]saraOct 26, 2007 17:41112397
reply to sara [853 words]Doc TaterOct 29, 2007 12:45112397
Armenian Genocide bill timing [491 words]saraOct 29, 2007 16:32112397
To sara: Pass the bill. The Turks are going to do what they want, anyway. The truth matters. [1829 words]Doc TaterOct 30, 2007 18:53112397
Armenian Genocide bill timing and other political observations [1559 words]saraOct 31, 2007 17:27112397
Reply to Doc Tater : Turkey Attacking Iraqi Kurds, and the House non-vote on the Armenian Genocide [1206 words]farukSep 4, 2012 16:50112397
Democrats or Rebuplican does not matter , politicians use Armenians and vice versa Armenians use politicians. [577 words]farukSep 4, 2012 21:58112397
3Our dear faruk is really saying that there was an Armenian genocide and as if we kuffar did not know [194 words]dhimmi no moreSep 6, 2012 07:18112397
genocide in islam [128 words]Phil GreendAug 15, 2007 00:35106250
Genocide at Hocaeli. How About the Armenians Soldiers Wiping Out Azeri Civilans at Hocaeli? [168 words]Ceyla TeomanSep 5, 2007 16:10106250
11000? [91 words]susanSep 7, 2007 16:00106250
1Islam is just [288 words]MagedJun 21, 2008 04:02106250
Real Face of Islamist Musharaf ! But Clerics of Lal Masjid are more dangerous as compared to him. [1041 words]GormiMay 29, 2007 11:1595121
correcto Gormi [57 words]free beeMay 30, 2007 17:2295121
Free Bee : All problems related with Islamists are interconnected , You cannot solve one and ignore other. [693 words]GormiMay 31, 2007 08:0195121
2 Cardinal Facts about Pakistanis [299 words]free beeMay 31, 2007 16:0395121
2 other cardinal facts about pakistan [194 words]susanMay 31, 2007 16:3395121
4"Fetih bayram" - Islamists and secularists march together to celebrate the 554th anniversary of the "liberation" of Constantinope from the Greek occupation [671 words]IanusMay 28, 2007 13:1695018
An internal Turkish political crisis, an invasion of Kurdish Iraq, or just "Fetih bayram"? A reply to Ianus. [1658 words]James VesceJul 18, 2007 15:3395018
3Americans dreams and Turkey's plans [1750 words]IanusJul 22, 2007 06:1995018
2To Ianus (Poland) : liberation of Constantinope from the Latin occupation [1075 words]farukSep 4, 2012 20:1795018
21453 another "defensive" Turkish war ! [1980 words]IanusSep 5, 2012 21:2595018
Ianusidis [48 words]MaliSep 18, 2012 15:3695018
1A pictorial reply after a verbal one has visibly failed [415 words]IanusSep 18, 2012 18:4995018
1Turks ... [62 words]maliSep 21, 2012 15:1195018
5Not Ianus, but great Jalal ad-Din Rumi will tell you why Turks are barbarians. [480 words]IanusSep 22, 2012 13:3895018
1How to Islamize Classical European Literature ? The Turkish Ministry of National Education knows how ! [592 words]IanusMay 25, 2007 18:0294559
Turkey Prime minister is not Islamist [95 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Diane HaddadMay 22, 2007 18:4094003
3Moderate Muslim equals to Moderate Nazi [229 words]Egyptian ChristianMay 21, 2007 12:4193913
Mr Egyptian Christian- Full rights in Muslim Lands [139 words]Free BeeMay 22, 2007 12:3893913
"Full rights in Muslim Lands" ;) [8 words]IanusMay 22, 2007 16:5893913
1Islam Will Not Grant Equal Rights..... [169 words]Domenic PepeMay 22, 2007 19:3493913
ya masri [83 words]liby muslimMay 23, 2007 12:0293913
Ya Libi inta wa al-Islam [156 words]dhimmi no moreMay 23, 2007 20:0593913
1Our dear FreeBee another wannabe Arab [70 words]dihmmi no moreMay 24, 2007 07:1393913
Domenic Pepe NO [88 words]Free BeeMay 24, 2007 16:3793913
dhimmi's FEAR [81 words]free beeMay 24, 2007 16:4593913
1Proud to be a Muslim- dhimmi [93 words]Free BeeMay 24, 2007 17:5393913
Brutalized by Arabs? [78 words]Free BeeMay 24, 2007 18:2993913
free bee, you're not free [124 words]susanMay 25, 2007 11:2493913
Oh yeah? [16 words]dhimmi no moreMay 25, 2007 19:3193913
Our dear FreeBee and "Paranoid with islam"? [91 words]dhimmi no moreMay 25, 2007 19:4293913
Your ancestors too! [50 words]dhimmi no moreMay 25, 2007 19:4893913
For our dear Freebee and No she did not wear a hijab! [29 words]dhimmi no moreMay 25, 2007 20:0693913
For our dear FreeBee and fell free to prove me wrong! [118 words]dhimmi no moreMay 26, 2007 06:2793913
muslim brothers like sunni shia clashes? [72 words]susanMay 26, 2007 10:5293913
??? [68 words]susanMay 26, 2007 10:5593913
Getting Bored [37 words]EuropeanMay 27, 2007 20:5693913
Our dear European (sic) and is he really jealous? [89 words]dhimmi no moreMay 29, 2007 12:3593913
dhimmi no more or just Dim? [77 words]EuropeanMay 29, 2007 19:3193913
to European on islam religion of arabs [328 words]ASMay 30, 2007 00:2393913
For our dear European and of din and yawn and other sordid matters [169 words]dihmmi no moreMay 30, 2007 07:0493913
dhimmi's comments [89 words]free beeMay 30, 2007 14:2093913
"european"? cough cough [45 words]susanMay 30, 2007 14:2493913
ms susan [20 words]free beeMay 30, 2007 14:2693913
little History for dhimmi and susan [208 words]free beeMay 30, 2007 14:5993913
1For our Dear FreeBee and more Muslim meltdown big time [332 words]dhimmi no moreMay 30, 2007 19:3693913
The logic and poor education of our dear Freebee the wannabe Arab [59 words]dihmmi no moreMay 30, 2007 19:5193913
ROTFL: Our dear Freebee declares a fatwa [55 words]dhimmi no moreMay 30, 2007 19:5693913
To European [68 words]SimonMay 30, 2007 20:2893913
Muslim megalomania [70 words]VijayMay 31, 2007 04:1193913
some more history for the wannabe arab [249 words]Anubhav SinghMay 31, 2007 06:0293913
Our dear FreeBee and the absurd [281 words]dhimmi no moreMay 31, 2007 07:0593913
1muslims teaching history? [110 words]susanMay 31, 2007 09:4393913
free bee tells us muslims are a murderous people [45 words]susanMay 31, 2007 09:4793913
WHAT A FOOL BELIEVES... [80 words]DONVANMay 31, 2007 16:5193913
To Vijay [66 words]Un DrainedMay 31, 2007 17:5893913
To Vijay and Singh [80 words]un drainedMay 31, 2007 18:0693913
for susan [16 words]free beeMay 31, 2007 18:1293913
Singh [53 words]free beeMay 31, 2007 18:2093913
Vijay Singh [42 words]free beeMay 31, 2007 18:3793913
Simon, you are correct the word Qur'an is a loan word [38 words]dhimmi no moreMay 31, 2007 18:4393913
Brainwashing!! [89 words]JaladhiMay 31, 2007 21:4593913
my dad is not george washington [131 words]susanJun 1, 2007 16:5893913
muslims are obsessed with "ruling" [91 words]susanJun 1, 2007 17:0393913
slaves are the muslims [152 words]susanJun 1, 2007 17:0693913
again you admit muslims are murderous people [47 words]susanJun 1, 2007 17:0793913
Un Drained and muslim logic [139 words]dhimmi no moreJun 2, 2007 07:0993913
More blah...blah ...blah from our dear un drained [116 words]dhimmi no moreJun 2, 2007 07:1793913
sure [37 words]VijayJun 2, 2007 10:0293913
For Vijay [27 words]dhimmi no moreJun 2, 2007 18:0093913
to undrained from Afghanistan [254 words]ASJun 3, 2007 12:2293913
to freebee on myth of muslim might [138 words]ASJun 3, 2007 12:3493913
Smile to Vijay [53 words]Un DrainedJun 4, 2007 17:3693913
AS ...? [49 words]Un DrainedJun 4, 2007 17:4393913
Mr AS [36 words]free beeJun 4, 2007 17:4693913
to freebee and the kings of arabia [43 words]ASJun 5, 2007 16:1193913
yep, lets talk freebee [69 words]ASJun 5, 2007 16:2393913
Pot calling kettle black!!! [26 words]Oscar NavarroJun 7, 2007 21:1893913
be respectfull while argue your point [50 words]farukSep 5, 2012 05:2593913
Why is secularism becoming irrelevant in the muslim world? [565 words]Syed KasimMay 21, 2007 00:0093874
Muslim World Needs Secularism More than Ever [588 words]Turk in DCMay 22, 2007 15:5393874
1"Secularism versus Islamism in Turkey " - A beautiful theory versus an ugly detail [954 words]IanusMay 20, 2007 15:4793851
Islamist Takeover of Our islamic "Allies" Military [69 words]Domenic PepeMay 24, 2007 12:1093851
Agreed (I think) [182 words]PatMay 25, 2007 18:1093851
2" Long live Vladmir Iliych Lenin! Long live Gazi Mustafa Kemal !" [363 words]IanusMay 26, 2007 18:1593851
Ianus, Thanks [37 words]PatMay 27, 2007 17:4493851
Muslim belief about Attaturk [24 words]free beeMay 30, 2007 15:1393851
On gazis and insects [90 words]IanusMay 31, 2007 15:0193851
fighting equal enemies [424 words]mehmet kosucuMay 25, 2008 07:3293851
3Greek logic vs Turkish megalomaniac ravings [156 words]IanusMay 26, 2008 05:2393851
1Turks achieved success [103 words]MehmetMay 27, 2008 02:5093851
2Turkish "successes" - Turks and Aristotle [228 words]IanusMay 27, 2008 18:3693851
555 th Anniversary of Istanbul's Conquest be Glorius [570 words]mehmetMay 28, 2008 16:2993851
1"If Turks are humans, then humanity has no future at all". [94 words]IanusMay 28, 2008 17:3193851
ianus keep complex inside you. [245 words]MehmetMay 29, 2008 02:3693851
1Narcissism vs Truth [960 words]IanusMay 30, 2008 13:5093851
1Long Live Turks [430 words]mehmetMay 31, 2008 07:1893851
4"Ne mutlu türküm diyene" or Gazi Kemal's postal jihad against the name "Constantinople" [1779 words]IanusJun 1, 2008 06:5093851
what about Greek's dreams [581 words]farukSep 5, 2012 05:1593851
2The victims of the Turks and their imperialism [226 words]dhimmi no moreSep 5, 2012 17:5393851
3The barbarian ancestors of the barbarian Turks [1070 words]IanusSep 5, 2012 18:4493851
Peace According to a Habitual Murderer [133 words]Young MCSep 6, 2012 11:0793851
The reverse truth is the truth [355 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDMay 19, 2007 12:4393626
So the US hurt Europe? [276 words]PatMay 20, 2007 19:3793626
did you read the article I referred you to? [215 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDMay 22, 2007 08:4893626
Plain talk, please. [228 words]PatMay 23, 2007 19:2793626
stop kow-towing [105 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDMay 24, 2007 15:2593626
do not trust the americans [39 words]obzerver turkMay 18, 2007 20:3493567
Erdogan and AKP are puppets of the EU and the Arabs [80 words]Turk In DCMay 19, 2007 09:5693567
If that's the way you want it...... [71 words]PatMay 19, 2007 12:5393567
Back to the darkness [72 words]MosheMay 19, 2007 17:3093567
Muslim moderate [28 words]anticommieMay 18, 2007 05:1793459
A Critical Moment For Turkey [26 words]Steven LMay 18, 2007 00:2193447
OUR "FRIENDS" IN TURKEY [420 words]marianaMay 17, 2007 14:0893409
Thank You Dr. Pipes [38 words]Turk in DCMay 17, 2007 10:5093396
Islamic extremism is shame for the Islam [50 words]Anton RanelovMay 17, 2007 04:5793310
Turkish electoral peculiarities [41 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
QuaoarMay 16, 2007 13:1093246
1Briefly... [73 words]ÖmerMay 17, 2007 02:2493246
Turkish parliament threshold [43 words]Melvin HinichMay 17, 2007 13:0593246
2Dr. Pipes and Cyprus [333 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
IanusMay 16, 2007 10:0593170
www.guyleventorres.co.uk [176 words]Guy Leven-Torres (Agricola)May 17, 2007 02:5093170
1One more remark on Cyprus [233 words]IanusMay 17, 2007 17:0093170
Backing the wrong horse [149 words]David W. LincolnMay 16, 2007 09:2293169
Mr Pipes, you misread Turkey [300 words]Atilla YaylaMay 16, 2007 05:4793160
First SECULARISM.... [284 words]TijenMay 24, 2007 15:5893160
3Why Turkey will never be a democracy [929 words]IanusMay 24, 2007 16:5293160
1secular or not you still murder minorities [68 words]susanMay 25, 2007 11:3593160
The islamic curse [161 words]G.VishvasMay 16, 2007 05:3593159
15Ataturk Declared Islam Was the Enemy of Turkey. Today Islam Is the Enemy of the World. [475 words]Domenic PepeMay 16, 2007 05:2293158
It's not 1924 anymore [137 words]PatMay 16, 2007 23:5993158
Domenic Pepe [62 words]Azeem MehmetMay 17, 2007 11:1093158
American Awakening to the Threat of Islam [163 words]Domenic PepeMay 17, 2007 17:0793158
go back [26 words]surjMay 18, 2007 18:2093158
READ Pat's Comments [8 words]Azeem MehmetMay 21, 2007 14:3293158
Relax Mehmet! [74 words]MosheMay 24, 2007 03:0893158
10ataturk started fascism in turkey [371 words]susanMay 25, 2007 11:4793158
Moshe [23 words]A MehmetMay 25, 2007 17:2693158
1poor excuse [77 words]susanMay 26, 2007 11:0693158
SUSAN [10 words]SAMSON BELLJun 1, 2007 13:2593158
What Is This All About [250 words]KemalJun 20, 2007 09:2293158
boo hoo ... what a surprise [477 words]susanJun 20, 2007 16:4793158
Yes, but,.. [183 words]berkMar 12, 2010 22:3793158
atatürk [133 words]duygu kumaşOct 13, 2010 13:1693158
La.illaha ill Allah mohmnadan rasulullah [24 words]Ex Secular TurkNov 5, 2016 14:3393158
Are these so called Moderate Muslim Turks willing to apologise for Massacre of Armenian Christians ??? [72 words]ChadashMay 16, 2007 00:4993146
1Hitler as a prophet [67 words]IanusMay 16, 2007 17:5993146
In reply [16 words]ÖmerMay 17, 2007 02:2993146
As a person who you call "moderated" my answers are... [675 words]Deniz TolgaMay 20, 2007 20:1893146
2"Armenian genocide ?" "Either it never happened or it was just a mass suicide . The Turks were in any case innocent." [1881 words]IanusMay 22, 2007 16:3793146
typical answers of turks, please read here the "moderation" [231 words]susanMay 25, 2007 11:5393146
Reply to Susan [329 words]Deniz TolgaMay 27, 2007 09:4393146
usual reply [1110 words]susanMay 28, 2007 10:4793146
Mosques in places once subjugated by Moslems [260 words]IanusMay 28, 2007 18:3093146
1THE TURKISH RACE IS A JOKE [86 words]TURKSLAPPERNov 6, 2009 11:5793146
1Turkish race is a joke [16 words]IanusNov 7, 2009 14:4193146
"NO ENTRY" in European Union . [116 words]JaanMay 16, 2007 00:2193145
What I'd like to see in US diplomacy toward Turkey... [143 words]Rick HouseMay 15, 2007 18:3593130
SORRY RICK! Turks give NOT ONE FIG about America's "vision for Turkey" [228 words]marianaMay 17, 2007 19:4693130
1" Turks give NOT ONE FIG about America's "vision for Turkey"" - Isn't it an understatement ? [936 words]IanusMay 19, 2007 11:3693130
Metal Firtina - the new smash hit [211 words]PatMay 20, 2007 19:5693130
Mecca - the new UN headquarters [70 words]IanusMay 22, 2007 16:5393130
1Metal Firtina - the final scene [228 words]IanusMay 23, 2007 15:3793130
There's already some footage available [109 words]PatMay 23, 2007 19:4693130
Maybe an "optimistic" scene at the end ? [611 words]IanusMay 24, 2007 11:5493130
PM Recep Tayyip Erdogan: ""Let's not focus on this but on making friends,..." [988 words]marianaMay 25, 2007 00:4093130
Only in America [209 words]PatMay 25, 2007 09:3993130
4Turks are more dangerous as friends than as enemies [1996 words]IanusMay 26, 2007 17:0893130
No "optimism" then [39 words]IanusMay 26, 2007 17:4993130
ALL OF AMERICA'S "FRIENDS" ARE MORE DANGEROUS TO US THAN OUR ENEMIES..."Let's not focus on this [overt acts of aggression], but on making friends,..." [1805 words]marianaMay 30, 2007 17:0593130
1ALL OF AMERICA'S "FRIENDS" ARE MORE DANGEROUS TO US THAN OUR ENEMIES... Russia is not a friend , so perhaps it might be given a chance ? [989 words]IanusJun 3, 2007 15:1293130
"Fool Me Once, Shame On You; Fool Me Twice, Shame On Me!" [2403 words]marianaJun 4, 2007 16:2493130
1„ Under the spreading chestnut tree I sold you and you sold me." [4733 words]IanusJun 6, 2007 07:5493130
Back to Basics. [1317 words]marianaJun 7, 2007 15:5693130
1A thought experiment [2613 words]IanusJun 9, 2007 19:1793130
Rearranging deck chairs on the titamic [114 words]Roosevelt's DiscipleMay 15, 2007 14:3093098
A Critical Moment for Turkey [109 words]Iftikhar AhmadMay 15, 2007 13:3593092
I'm - almost - at a loss for words [291 words]ÖmerMay 15, 2007 16:5593092
1For our dear Omer, and speaking of being at a loss for words [528 words]dhimmi no moreMay 16, 2007 07:5993092
Iftikhar Ahmed [14 words]Un DrainMay 16, 2007 15:0893092
I'm a proud Turk [73 words]Azeem MehmetMay 16, 2007 15:1593092
alphabets [91 words]surjMay 16, 2007 16:0493092
Proud Muslim [103 words]surjMay 16, 2007 16:2993092
Blind Brain washed Turks [105 words]MahoganyMay 16, 2007 17:3193092
1Our dear Azeem the Turk (sic) is on the verge of a nervous breakdown [109 words]dhimmi no moreMay 16, 2007 18:5393092
In response [802 words]ÖmerMay 17, 2007 02:1593092
The simplest rationale [77 words]ÖmerMay 17, 2007 02:2193092
1Our Dear Omer the Turk and the Armenian genocide! [291 words]dhimmi no moreMay 18, 2007 07:2993092
Reply to Dhimmi no more [127 words]EuropeanMay 18, 2007 20:2293092
"Crude racist remarks" Really? [15 words]dhimmi no moreMay 19, 2007 09:4493092
Our dear Omer the Turk and his bogus falsafa [301 words]dhimmi no moreMay 19, 2007 18:5293092
dhimmi check your copy of the Quran [89 words]Azeem MehmetMay 21, 2007 14:5993092
To dhimmi no more [59 words]ÖmerMay 21, 2007 15:0293092
In final response to Ex-Dhimmi [433 words]ÖmerMay 21, 2007 15:3793092
For our dear Omer [186 words]dhimmi no moreMay 22, 2007 07:2793092
azeem [192 words]dihmmi no moreMay 22, 2007 20:0293092
Turkish homeland [237 words]TijenMay 24, 2007 11:5693092
dhimmi no more [132 words]Azeem MehmetMay 24, 2007 16:2893092
19Conversion of the Turks to Islam [654 words]IanusMay 25, 2007 08:4193092
study YOUR history [719 words]susanMay 25, 2007 12:1593092
silly questions [255 words]susanMay 25, 2007 12:3093092
1"Vatan"(homeland) - an Arabic word for a non-existing Turkish concept [544 words]IanusMay 25, 2007 15:3593092
But you can prove me wrong! [48 words]dhimmi no moreMay 25, 2007 19:5193092
I'm proud to be a kaffir! [32 words]dhimmi no moreMay 26, 2007 06:3393092
More bogus claims by our dear Tijen the Turk [152 words]dihmmi no moreMay 26, 2007 06:4193092
Here is the proof for dhimmi from Quran [161 words]A MehmetMay 30, 2007 17:4093092
Islam is the religion of the Arabs and this is what the Qur'an really says and you ain't no Arab [539 words]dhimmi no moreMay 31, 2007 19:3293092
dhimmi makes NO sense [155 words]Un DrainedJun 4, 2007 18:3593092
Lousy Arabic? Wanna share with us? [44 words]dhimmi no moreJun 5, 2007 17:0393092
Drano and the Qur'an really says that islam is really the religion of the arabs and you ain't one [202 words]dhimmi no moreJun 5, 2007 21:0793092
dhimmi [79 words]un drainedJun 7, 2007 11:0993092
the Qur'an really says that islam is really the religion of the arabs and you ain't one part deux [83 words]dhimmi no moreJun 7, 2007 20:0693092
Another bogus claim by drano [109 words]dihmmi no moreJun 7, 2007 20:1493092
More fantasy from our dear drano [51 words]dhimmi no moreJun 7, 2007 20:4093092
Drano and the Qur'an really says that islam is really the religion of the arabs and you ain't one part trois [336 words]dhimmi no moreJun 8, 2007 06:4593092
Just facts [58 words]TijenJun 8, 2007 10:5293092
The Turk Tijen and two words: Bogus again [200 words]dhimmi no moreJun 8, 2007 16:4593092
1Drano and the Qur'an really says that islam is really the religion of the arabs and you ain't one part quatre [328 words]dhimmi no moreJun 9, 2007 07:2793092
The Demographic Puzzle and the Kurds [81 words]SophiaMay 15, 2007 12:4093090
The Demographic Puzzle and the Kurds [550 words]IanusMay 15, 2007 17:5093090
Natural allies of the USA and contradiction with recent articles by Dr Pipes [187 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
HarrakMay 15, 2007 12:1593087
The Turkish prime minister [144 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
HarrakMay 23, 2007 00:2093087
Thanks, that was a better explaining reference [81 words]HarrakMay 31, 2007 10:3793087
A Critical Moment For Turkey [146 words]Kim SegarMay 15, 2007 10:3692971
The "secularists" are not a good choice either [102 words]AMDGMay 15, 2007 08:4192965
Iraq, Kosovo and Turkey - Does Bush the Bungler have a clue? [342 words]James BurkeMay 15, 2007 08:3992963
Grateful - who Muslims?? Nah!!! [126 words]JaladhiMay 15, 2007 15:4592963
Folly or money ? [142 words]IanusMay 15, 2007 17:1392963
World is fed up of Islamic Terrorism and Bloodshed [70 words]okisMay 16, 2007 11:0892963
I am shocked to see these photos , its beginning of World War III . [66 words]FinusuMay 16, 2007 11:1392963
Both Folly & $$$ - Giving aid and comfort to enemies is standard for the White House [305 words]James BurkeMay 17, 2007 07:2892963
Europe is already Islamized [278 words]PatMay 17, 2007 11:5592962
are you looking closely at USA? [93 words]susanMay 25, 2007 12:3592962
Oh really? [98 words]PatMay 26, 2007 08:0992962
Susan: please check your statistics [40 words]free beeMay 31, 2007 16:0792962
muslim doctors are a fraud, here's link to prove it [321 words]susanMay 31, 2007 16:2392962
Our dear Freebee and statistics! [190 words]dhimmi no moreJun 1, 2007 07:1092962
About FREE BEE forcing Data. [286 words]Ynna(tchkah)Jun 1, 2007 15:1192962
FREE BEE NEVER answered my e-mail which proves.. [42 words]YnnatchkahJun 2, 2007 01:5492962
Salaamun. (Peace). [200 words]Jason Quddus MowSep 4, 2007 19:3592962
pleaaaase [35 words]susanSep 6, 2007 05:5292962
1Salaamun. (Peace). [499 words]Jason Quddus MowSep 6, 2007 18:1192962
moderate islamist [49 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
koolkargaMay 15, 2007 07:1592955

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to „ Under the spreading chestnut tree I sold you and you sold me." by Ianus

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List


eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2020 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)