2 readers online now  |  69 million page views

My answer to DNM

Reader comment on item: The Temple Mount's Indian counterpart
in response to reader comment: Our dear deb and the very long version

Submitted by Debanjan Banerjee (India), Jun 25, 2010 at 14:17

What does the holocaust have to do with our little chat? Surpise me with an answer! al-Yamaniyuun selected him because he knows his Arabic"

>My Answer : Ohh common , you ... Do not you know something called analogy ? I compared the findings of the so-called Arabist Gerd Puin with the holocaust deniers in the West since both are liars . Now do you get it ?

A tablighee who worries about the Jews! Oh spare me this one

My Answer : A typical American empty brain intellectual. You still do not get the point I made right ? Or do you have any answer to what I said or not ?

>"And I care"My Answer : Ohh , you care ???? I thought it was the job of your masters in AIPAC to care and you just follow their orders.

What does AIPAC have to do with your masters the Arabs and their history?

I'm here to dismantle the foundation of the religion of the Arabs

My Answer : Ohh , I , Deb the wannabe Arab is fearful that you are going to destroy my religion. Hahahaha .....

Anyway it is still clear that you do not get what analogy is stupid.

Now common let's have it as a challenge. I know so many things about your western civilization that you do not .

Now take it as a game. Let us try to dismantle the foundation of each other's civilizations.

Are you man enough to be up for the challenge ?

>My Answer : OK common. Your western civilization foundation is based upon a heap of lies. I would like to expose them.

Then exopse it we are not worried here in the West about being "exposed"

My Answer : Ohh right !!!! Have you heard about something called Al-Jajeera ? This was a channel which was exposing to the world about the lies inherent in Western policies in the Middle East. That is why your dear old president Dubya wanted to bomb it ?

And you still claim that you are not worried about being exposed !!! Are you kidding or what ?

1, Why would the first attested Arab in the saga of islam have an Aramaic name and not an Arab name as Mu3awiyya means in Syriac the weeper any guesses?

>My Answer : What do you mean by first attested Arab ?

mr careless reader: I wrote the first attested Arab IN THE SAGA OF ISLAM

>What do you mean by an Aramaic name ?

Hello: the name Mu3awiyya is an Aramaic/Syriac name and it is not an Arabic name

My Answer : See how idiotic you people are. In your own country people embrace Islam and they do not change their names. Remember Keith Ellison ? Now he is a Muslim while he holds a perfect Anglo name. So why cannot some one like Muwayiaah do the same ?

2. Why would the inscriptions in the gadara baths have the name of Mu3awiyya with the sign of the cross next to it?

>My Answer : It does not mean anything.

I read this that you have no answer

>What is the proof that the Muawiyya you are talking about is the Muawiyya bin Abu Sufian ?

ROTFL Pakistani Arabic

For the readers the bogus islamic tradition tells that in the 3rd century of Islam the the weeper's name was really Mu3awiyya ibn abu Sufian

My Answer : I tell you that according to the Islamic tradition the Muwaiyya bin Abu Suffian died well within the first century of Islam. Then from which tradition you are telling n the 3rd century of Islam the the weeper's name was really Mu3awiyya ibn abu Sufian ?

Wait a minute what do you mean by Pakistani Arabic ? Tell me you blockhead how can one be Pakistani and Arabic at the same time ?

2. Why would the inscriptions in the gadara baths have the name of Mu3awiyya with the sign of the cross next to it?

>My Answer : It does not mean anything.

I read this that you have no answer

My Answer : Dumbass what is the proof that the coins you are talking about was used by Muwaiyya ibn Abu sufiyaan's time ? Anyway you probably even do not know about someone called Abu Sufiyyan right ?

Do you know someone called Abu Sufiyyan ?

Anyway I think it is too much for me to expect a dumbass like you to know who Abu Sufiyaan was ?

3. Why would Mu3awiyya select his capital as Damascus anot not miserable Mecca unless he was a Syrian Arab and almost all of them were Christian?

>My Answer : And why did the so-called founding fathers made their capital in Washington DC and not in Athens , Rome or Jerusalem if all of you are descendants of the so-called Greco-Roman civilization. If you get this answer then you will not ask that question that you asked above.

No I'm asking you about Mu3awiyya so why did he select Damascus as his capital and not Mecca? Surpise me with an answer

My Answer : Stupid when you answer my question why your founders did not establish the capital at Athens,Rome or Jerusalem but in Washington DC you will know the answer of your question why Muwaiyya set up it's capital at Damascus .

5. Why would the coins minted have the sing of the cross on them?

>My Answer : Barack Hussain Obama has "Hussain" and "Barack" in his name. Does it mean that he is Jew or Muslim ? Signs on coins does not mean anything. Have you heard about someone called Sultan Baybars al-Bunduqdari ? In his coins we find a lion inscribed. Now lion as you know is also a sign of the flag of the Buddhist nation of Sri Lanka. By your analogy then if crosses on coin means Christian then lion on coin must mean Buddhist. Do you want to mean that Sultan Baybars al-Bunduqdari was a Buddhist ?

Gobbledygook. So why do we have the sign on the cross on his coins? Any guesses?

My Answer : How do I know that there were crosses at those coins ? Show me at least the video of those coins , blockhead ?

6. How come we do not hear about the name Muhammad for 72 years after the death of that Muhammad? Could it be because he never existed and was a late creation?

>My Answer : See the first Gospel was written down 75 years after Jesus. How can we do not see anything about in the meantime.

Well your Allah says that al-injiil inahu kitaban muharraf

Oh this is not Syriac it is Arabic! But you know what? I do not translate Arabic for wannabe arabs like you

> Does that mean Jesus was a late creation and never existed ?

I care less if he did or did not exist

My Answer : Who told you this information that there is no mention of Mohammad 72 years after his death ? I hope your references are not those two old German haggards ?

> Does that mean Jesus was a late creation and never existed ?

I care less if he did or did not exist

My Answer : Too bad , if I contact some of your friends in the Bible belt that this crusader Dhimmi no more does not care about Jesus , you know what is going to happen to you , right ?

You still did not answer the question so let me ask you again: How come we do not hear about Muhammad for 72 years after his death?

>Who told you anyway that there is no mention of the Prophet 72 years after his death ?

Hello: read Hoyland survey

My Answer : You Americans need to come up with something intelligent. In which page of Hoyland Survey it is mentioned that Prophet Mohammad did not exist ? In which page it is mentioned that Prophet Mohammad was not mentioned for 72 years after his death ? I just searched Hoyland Survey in wiki and there is no mention of anything like you said ?

Next time you bring up Hoyland survey , kindly bring me the PDF version and the page numbers you are referring to.

> So kindly check before you post. And how do you say allah aka Jesus ? Jesus cannot be equal to Allah . Do you get it ?

Then prove it!

My Answer : In Arabic Jesus name is called Issa , and of all the names attributed to Allah in Quran there is no such term as Issa, So Jesus cannot be Allah , right ?

But the Qur'an says that Jesus is God would you like to know more? Then ask.

My Answer : Yah , prove it to me.

> Western civilization.

Freedom to think and debate is what this great civilization is all about

My Answer : Absolutely rubbish claim. If you really have freedom to think and debate in the Western Civilization then someone like John Walker Lindh and Mordechai Vanunu would not have been in Jail , right ? They expressed their right of freedom and you know what did your western civilization did to them ?

>My Answer : But your so-called Greko-Roman civilization is already extinct, right.

Not is it not it is the foundation of our Western civilization

My Answer : Wait a minute. Your own fellow US citizens shout that Judeo-Christianism is at the foundation of your "civilization". Do you contradict your fellow citizens like your dear old president Mr. Bush the Dubya then ?

>Who gives a damn about Greko-Roman Pagan civilization now days ?

We here in the West care

My Answer : And who gives a damn what you Westerners think now days , do you get it ?

And what goes around comes around and Islam will crash again because it is no more than fascism

My Answer : You ignorant do you even know what is facism ?

> By your own logic , the founding fathers of the USA are world's biggest imperialists since they annihilated and destroyed the millions of native Americans to build the USA . Now are you ashamed of that ?

Oh sobhanallah a tablighee who worries about al-hunud al-humr

My Answer : I guess then you accept that the founding fathers of the USA are world's biggest imperialists , I guess. I guess you have no answers to that right ?

And it was the muslims that killed 90M of your own people the Hindus remember?

My Answer : Give me solid and irrefutable proof of that 90M Hindus. If Muslims killed so many Hindus then how come there are 900 million Hindus existing in India so many centuries after the death of prophet .Mohammad ?

>Remember the USA alike Greece and Rome are founded on greed , violence and mass murder.

And so was Arabian imperialism

My Answer : Give me my answer.

USA WAS FOUNDED ON GREED , LUST AND MASS MURDER AND YOU ARE THE VICTIM.

do you get it you stupid slave of AIPAC ?

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to My answer to DNM by Debanjan Banerjee

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List
eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2020 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)