Daniel Pipes
Mobile Edition
Regular Site

Destruction of Ethnic Minorities in Malaysia
Reader comment on item: Countries Threatened with Extinction

Submitted by Seremcha (India), Aug 22, 2007 at 02:45

rom 22.2.2006 TO 13.6.2007 (one year and four months), 79 HINDU TEMPLES in MALAYSIA were faced with:

BEING DEMOLISHED,

GIVEN NOTICE TO BE DEMOLISHED

RELOCATED NEXT TO SEWERAGE TANKS,

BURNT TO THE GROUND, or

DEITIES FORCIBLY REMOVED

Over the last 15 years, Hindu temples in Malaysia are being demolished at the rate of ONE temple in every THREE weeks.

According Mr. P. Waytha Moorthy, Chairman HINDRAF (Hindu Rights Action Force):
From 22.2.2006 to 13.6.2007 (about one year and four months) HINDRAF have recorded 79 Hindu temples to have been unlawfully unconstitutionally and with impunity demolished, given notice to be demolished, burnt down, relocated next to sewerage tanks deities removed etc.

From 22.2.2006 to 26.6.2006, 99 police reports have been lodged in respect of the said Hindu temple demolishments. Not a single criminal has been prosecuted as of date.

From 22.2.2006 to 26.6.2006, HINDRAF have written 74 letters and memorandums to the Attorney-General and the relevant state authorities, but are yet to receive a single response.
For more details, contact:

P. Waytha Moorthy, Chairman HINDRAF (Hindu Rights Action Force)
No. 135-3-A, Jalan Toman 7,Kemayan Square,70200 Seremban, Negeri Sembilan. Tel : 06-7672995/6 , Fax: 06-7672997
Email: waytha@hotmail.com

FIFTEEN (15) HINDU TEMPLES DEMOLISHED IN THE KLANG VALLEY

1. The Sri Ayyanar Sathiswary Alayam Temple (more than 65 years) Jalan Davies was demolished on 22.2.2006 and the statues buried at site.

2. The Malaimel Sri Selva Kaliamman Temple Pantai(more than 100 years) was demolished on 17.4.2006 by the Kuala Lumpur City Hall.

3. The Vaalmuniswarar Rajaamman Kovil(more than 60 years) at Lady Templer Hospital demolished on the 3.05.2006 by City Hall Kuala Lumpur.

4. Sri Kaliamman temple at Midlands Estate, Seksyen 7, Shah Alam (more than 100 years) was demolished by the Shah Alam City Hall on 9.5.2006.

5. The Sri Balakrishan Muniswarer temple in Setapak (more than 60 years) was partly demolished on 11.05.2006 by the Kuala Lumpur City Hall.

6. The Sri Balakrishan Muniswarer temple in Setapak was completely demolished and deities broken up on 8.6.2006.

7. The demolished Sri Kaliamman temple at Midlands Estate, Seksyen 7, Shah Alam was demolished for a second time on the 12.06.2006 wherein 3 main Hindu deities were hammered and smashed up to pieces with a sledge hammer by the Shah Alam City Council enforcement officers.

8. On 1.08.2006 the Om Sri Sakti Nagamma Allaya Hindu Temple in Taman Sri Manja, PJS 3/30 Petaling Jaya, Selangor was demolished by the Petaling Jaya City Council.

9. Demolishment of the Sri Subramaniam temple in Country Homes, Rawang, Selangor, Malaysia on 29.09.2006.

10. On 31.10.2006 Sri Muniswarar Temple (more than a 100 years old) which was built on private land in Bandar Rinching, Semenyih Selangor was demolished.

11. The demolishment of the Devi Sri Karumaniamman Hindu Temple, Petaling Jaya Utara, Section 21, Kampung Taman Aman on 30.11.2006.

12. On 29.12.2006 Sri Muniswarar Temple (more than a 100 years old) which was built on private land in Bandar Rinching, Semenyih Selangor was demolished.

13. On 22/2/2007 the Sri Maha Nageswari Hindu Temple in Taman Cahaya 7, Ampang, Selangor Darul Ehsan was demolished.

14. On 15.5.2007, the JKR Sri Muniswarar Hindu Temple, Jalan Kapar, Klang was demolished.

15. On 13.6.2007 the Sri Kaliaman Hindu temple in Midlands estate Shah Alam was demolished.

FOUR (4) OTHER DEMOLISHED HINDU TEMPLES LOCATED OUTSIDE KLANG VALLEY BUT WITHIN PENINSULAR MALAYSIA:-

16. The Demolishment of the Sri Maha Sivalingaeswarrar Hindu Temple, Batu 7,
Gemas Tampin 10/04/2002.

17. The 80 year old Sri Muthumariamman Alayam Hindu Temple in Skudai Johor
Bahru was demolished in August 2006.

18. Statutes from Sungai Wangi Mathurai Veeran Temple (60 years old) in Sitiawan, Kampung Tirali, 9th Mile Jalan Air Tawar, Sungai Wangi Estate, Perak were hammered, smashed up and thrown into a drain and temple demolished on 17.10.2006 by the Manjung District Council.

19. The 55 year old Kaliaman Alayam Hindu Temple in Taman Impiana Mengelembu
in Ipoh was demolished on 27/11/2006.

THIRTY ONE (31) HINDU TEMPLES WITHIN THE KLANG VALLEY THAT HAS BEEN THREATENED WITH DEMOLISHMENT NOTICE:-

20. Kuil Hindu Sri Mariaman di Seksyen 11, Shah Alam has been given notice to the demolished on 26.4.2006 from the Shah Alam Municipal Council.

21. The Sri Maha Mariamman Temple Taman Intan Baiduri Selayang has been given notice to be demolished recently (Nanban June 2006)

22. The Sri Subramaniam Temple Kg.Jawa Klang(107 years old) has been given notice to be demolished (June 2006).

23. The Mariamman Temple Jalan Meru Bandar Setia Alam, Shah Alam (101 years old) has been given notice to be demolished (June 2006)

24. The Kg.Jawa Mariamman Temple (more than 120 years) has been given notice to be demolish (June 2006).

25. The Sri Maha Laxhsmi temple in Sunway has been given notice to be demolished by the Petalaing Jaya City Council in June 2006.

26. The Sri Angineer Temple in Taman Tun Dr. Ismail, Kuala Lumpur built on a private land has been given notice to be demolished by the Kuala Lumpur City Manager(June 2006).

27. Sri Mahamariaman Hindu Temple in Kg Semarak, Old Klang Road has been threatened with demolishment five (5) times before on TOL Land-Nanban(6/7/06) pg. 12

28. Sri Sai Bala Raman Hindu Temple in Klang Jaya is being threatened with demolishment - Nesan (7/7/06)

29. 101 year old Dewi Sri Karumari Aman Temple in 4 1/2 Mile Jalan Meru, Klang was ordered closed by Selangor State Government on 10.07.2006 and thereafter the said temple is threatened to be demolished to make way for housing development.

30. The 101 year old Thevy Sri Karumariamman temple's Bandar Setia Alam, Shah Alam access road to be closed on 10.7.2006 by the Selangor State Government and later to be demolished to make way for a private housing development.

31. Arun Estate Temple in Shah Alam- Nesan (12/7/06) pg. 6

32. In July 2006 the 110 year old Tepi Sungai JKR Mariaman Temple was given notice to be demolished.

33. In July 2006 the Sri Muniswarar temple in Jalan Air Panas Baru Setapak was given notice to be demolished.

34. In July 2006, the Sri Jada Muniswarar Hindu Temple in Danau Kota, Kuala Lumpur was given notice to be demolished.

35. Jedda Manismanar Hindu Temple in Jalan Setapak was informed to vacate is being threatened with demolishment - Nesan(17/8/06)

36. Sri Maha Megeswari Hindu Temple in Lembah Jaya, Ampang is being threatened with demolishment -Nesan(20/8/06)

37. Muniswarar Hindu Temple in Bandar Baru Ampang is being threatened with demolishment -Nesan(20/8/06)

38. Sri Sakti Vinayar Hindu Temple in Kampung Ampang Indah is being threatened with demolishment -Nesan(20/8/06)

39. Mariaman Hindu Temple in Kg Tasik Permai, Ampang is being threatened with demolishment -Nesan(20/8/06)

40. Siti Subramariam Hindu Temple in Kg Tasik Permai, Ampang is being threatened with demolishment -Nesan(20/8/06)

41. Sri Mariaman Temple (60 years old) in Section 18 given notice to relocate on 18/10/2006.

42. Sri Kaliaman Temple (80 years old) in Section 18 given notice to relocate on 18/10/2006.

43. Sri Vinayagar Temple (80 years old) in Section 18 given notice to relocate on 18/10/2006.

44. Sri Mariaman Temple (109 years old) in Section 19 which has a sacred 100 year old tree given notice to relocate on 18/10/2006.

45. Sri Mariaman Temple (100 years old) in Section 15 given notice to relocate on 18/10/2006.

46. Sri Maha Mariaman Hindu Temple in Section 11 given notice to relocate on 18/10/2006.

47. The 80 year old Sri Athi Muniswara Temple in Jalan Semarak, off Jalan Gurney in Kuala Lumpur was given notice to be demolished on 19.10.2006.

48. On 21.11.2006 the Sivaksakthi Linggeswara Hindu Temple in Kampung Tropikana, Jalan Padang Tembak, Subang Jaya given notice to be demolished.

49. The Sri Kamatchie Amman Telecoms Temple Cheras (more than 100 years) is being threatened with demolishment.

50. Despite receiving recognition from UNESCO, Nageswari Hindu Temple in Bangsar is being threatened with demolishment.

SEVENTEEN (17) OTHER HINDU TEMPLES LOCATED OUTSIDE THE KLANG VALLEY BUT WITHIN PENINSULA MALAYSIA THAT HAS BEEN THREATENED WITH DEMOLISHMENT:-

51. The Sri Muniswarar Aalayam Seremban (150 years) and a 150 year old Raintree have been threatened with demolishment since March 2006 by the District and Land Office .

52. On 26.6.2006 the 110 year old the Sri Chinna Karuppan Temple in Masai Johor was given notice to be demolished.

53. The 60 year old Saiva Muniswarar Temple Temple in Sg.Petani Kedah given notice to be demolished (Nanban 29.6.2006 pg 4)

54. Sri Muthumariaman Aman Skudai Hindu Temple (70 years old) in Lindon Estate risks being demolished- Nesan (3/7/06) pg. 7

55. Sri Muniswarar Temple in Slim River- Nesan (14/7/06)

56. On 15.7.2006 the Muniswarar Temple in Sitiawan was given notice to be demolished- Nanban(15/7/06)

57. Hindu Temple is being threatened with demolishment - Nesan (19/7/06) pg. 6

58. Sri Nageswari Amman Alayam Hindu Temple is being threatened with demolishment - Nesan (19/7/06) pg. 6

59. Muniswarar Hindu Temple is being threatened with demolishment - Nesan (19/7/06) pg. 6

60. Sri Sakti Viyanayagar Hindu Temple is being threatened with demolishment - Nesan (19/7/06) pg. 6

61. Sri Maha Mariaman Hindu Temple is being threatened with demolishment - Nesan (19/7/06) pg. 6

62. Sri Subramaniam Hindu Temple is being threatened with demolishment -Nesan (19/7/06) pg. 6

63. Muthu Mariaman Hindu Temple in Liutan Estate Skudai threatened to be demolished on 13.08.06.

64. Sri Subramaniam Hindu Temple in Kampar is being threatened with demolishment -Nesan(21/8/06)

65. Bangi Mariaman Hindu Temple is being threatened with demolishment -Nesan(23/8/06)

66. Taman U Hindu Temple in Skudai, Johor Bahru was on the verge of being demolished when about 600 Hindu devotees protested on 23.08.06.

67. Sri Mathuraimeeran Hindu Temple in Kampar Taman, Sri Wangi is being threatened with demolishment -Nanban(25/8/06).

THREE (3) HINDU TEMPLES THAT HAVE BEEN BURNT TO THE GROUND:-

68. The Ganggai Muthu Karumariaman temple in PMR Batu Buntung Estate Kulim,
Kedah on 15.5.2006 was torched by unknown / mysterious criminals.

69. The Sri Kalikambul Kamadeswarar temple in Ebor Estate Batu Tiga, Shah Alam Selangor.

70. The Sri Kalkattha Kaliamman temple in Kampung Sungai Kayu Ara, 47400 Petaling Jaya.

SIX (6) TEMPLES FORCED TO BE RELOCATED NEXT TO SEWERAGE TANKS:-

71. The Sri Muneeswarar JKR Temple, Batu 5/12, Jalan Kapar, 42100 Klang, Selangor (73 years old) was given notice to be demolished forced to be relocated next to a severage tank (June 2006). (Hindraf)

72. Sri Kumaravel Hindu Temple in Kampung Medan, Petaling Jaya, Selangor was forcibly relocated next to a sewarage tank, electric station (TNB) and high voltage cable on 14.07.2006 . (Makkal Osai 15.7.06)

73. Mariaman Hindu Temple in Bukit Beonang, Taman Bukit Melaka forced to relocate next to sewerage tank.(Nanban 25/8/2006)

74. Sri Raja Rajeswarar Hindu Temple in Taman Tunku Jaafar, Senawang, Seremban. (Hindraf)

75. Mariaman and Perumal Hindu Temple in Puchong Perdana, Selangor. (DAP sources)

76. Mariaman Temple in Desa Mewah, Sunway Semenyih forcibly relocated next to a septic tank. (Bandar Rincing, Semenyih Temple Chairman)

THREE (3) HINDU TEMPLES WHERE DEITIES FORCIBLY REMOVED:-

77. Statues from 73 year old JKR Sri Muniswarar Temple, Jalan Kapar Klang Temple was forcibly removed and taken away under mysterious circumstances in July 2006.

78. Deities from the Devi Sri Karumariaman Hindu Temple, Petaling Jaya Utara, Section 21, Kampung Taman Aman forcibly removed and left in a construction site.

79. Kaliamman Hindu Temple, Jalan Matin Batu 5 Seremban (more than 28 years) deities and temple bell was removed. (Nanban - 3.9.2006


Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened for relevance, substance, and tone, and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome, but comments are rejected if scurrilous, off-topic, vulgar, ad hominem, or otherwise viewed as inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the Guidelines for Comments. For informational purposes, we identify countries from which comments are sent.

Submit a comment on this item

Search by Enter name or date
Search Forum Comments:

Reader comments (106) on this item

Title By Date
geographical minute minutiae [159 words]jennifer solisAug 29, 2007 00:33
Nuclear Iran dreams of Israel's extinction. [423 words]ArcAug 28, 2007 12:26
Not just in the Middle East.... [63 words]TomAug 24, 2007 13:31
⇒ Destruction of Ethnic Minorities in Malaysia [1882 words]SeremchaAug 22, 2007 02:45
A day not far behind in Malaysia when Hindus, Christians and other minorities will have to convert to"religion of peace" under the threat of beheading!!! [71 words]JaladhiAug 22, 2007 17:53
No Peace between Israel and Palestine [264 words]InfidelAug 17, 2007 00:21
Dont worry [38 words]Friend of InfidelJun 22, 2009 07:09
Stop this promotion of showing a wrong image of Islam [244 words]HassanSep 6, 2009 20:20
Yes you are true [73 words]Mohsin AliOct 30, 2009 00:55
countries disappearing. .. Sweden [177 words]Phil GreendAug 16, 2007 10:58
ha..... [19 words]lanaaAug 18, 2007 09:21
Countries threatened with extinction: a reply to Phil Greend [324 words]Jaisingh ThakurAug 20, 2007 03:56
Enemies of the peoples of Europe. [367 words]VeronicaAug 26, 2007 06:52
Remove Jordan From Your List [212 words]RickAug 15, 2007 13:41
Jordan hates "Palestinians" despite being over 75% "Palestinian" [314 words]Dr RJPAug 22, 2007 11:40
You are absolutely right. [293 words]RickAug 22, 2007 16:43
Muslim rules and etiquette for Jews and Infidels [354 words]InfidelAug 15, 2007 12:27
Extinction of small states : A response [306 words]Jaisingh ThakurAug 15, 2007 04:00
another country? [148 words]John PhilipsAug 14, 2007 21:09
Huge leap of imagination required! [141 words]VeronicaAug 26, 2007 07:17
Taiwan [135 words]NickAug 14, 2007 13:52
Beaten to it [37 words]NickAug 16, 2007 17:42
Just excellent [15 words]Ken BesigAug 12, 2007 10:50
Don't Forgot Kosovo and Bosnia [108 words]obilicAug 11, 2007 12:17
Four muslim states in Europe : Albania , Bosnia , Kosovo and Turkey ..................... [90 words]OrianaAug 13, 2007 06:02
Obilic: Go back to Serbia [59 words]Becky MeinhartAug 13, 2007 14:16
huh? [105 words]obilicAug 13, 2007 17:49
Bosnian and Albanian muslims are terrorists [100 words]MarcelAug 14, 2007 14:28
Serbia [181 words]JessyoscotlandAug 16, 2007 13:00
Sorry Becky..CLINTON AIDED ISLAMIC TERRORISTS IN EUROPE. [475 words]veronicaAug 19, 2007 12:22
Fort Dix Six Jihadists are ... [48 words]JaladhiAug 24, 2007 20:33
America's Kosovo [125 words]obilicAug 24, 2007 21:43
Mis-understanding. [192 words]VeronicaAug 26, 2007 06:09
No misunderstanding - Veronica [100 words]JaladhiAug 27, 2007 18:31
Turkey is not an Islamic State [219 words]JohnSep 12, 2007 17:24
Totally agreeing with you [6 words]Riva Philiop, IndiaMar 16, 2008 06:56
Every muslim in bosnia and albania is not a terrorist [159 words]HassanSep 6, 2009 20:32
IRAN-SYRIA ALLIANCE IS A DEADLY THREAT TO ISRAEL [262 words]DAVID DASTYCHAug 10, 2007 07:57
Daniel , You have shown the problem , But what is the solution ??? [385 words]RasiAug 10, 2007 01:49
Countries Threatened with Extinction [170 words]Paul la DemainAug 9, 2007 12:31
Other countries [35 words]VijayAug 9, 2007 04:34
Vijay, what are you talking about? [43 words]Mark MarkAug 10, 2007 17:52
Megalomania with no connection to reality [75 words]VijayAug 12, 2007 09:13
"Mark Mark" is just another "Muslim Muslim" who is doing Taqiya to create a divide between Common Non Muslin Front against Islamism [209 words]ImageAug 13, 2007 05:51
Image & Vijay, can't believe its true? [108 words]Mark MarkAug 14, 2007 13:56
Islamic Neverland!? [101 words]Another InfidelAug 15, 2007 02:53
Countries threatened with extinction: A Reply to Mark Mark [243 words]Jaisingh ThakurAug 15, 2007 04:20
Bark Mark Bark [73 words]Wing-nutAug 15, 2007 04:55
Endangered States outside the ME [48 words]Gareth LewisAug 8, 2007 15:00
Endangered States due to other reasons will not pose a Threat to whole world by States threatened by Islamisation will threaten whole world [69 words]PeterAug 9, 2007 05:46
Rights to the Land [589 words]M. ToveyAug 8, 2007 14:03
Goodbye Iraq too? [170 words]Archimedes2Aug 8, 2007 20:39
Rights to the Land - A Promise to be Kept [549 words]M. ToveyAug 9, 2007 19:00
Hey Archimedes2... consider this [239 words]Wing-nutAug 10, 2007 05:35
why should we care? [21 words]susanAug 8, 2007 13:59
How many eggs in each basket [127 words]David W. LincolnAug 8, 2007 12:11
Israel's situation is different than the Bahrain, Jordan etc. [37 words]Peri GarfinkelAug 8, 2007 11:34
Taiwan also threatened with extinction
[w/response] [232 words]
Dan SchwartzAug 8, 2007 07:36
A continent threatened with extinction [193 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDAug 11, 2007 13:26
Israel's Reality to be Fulfilled Over Islam's Dream [160 words]M. ToveyAug 13, 2007 10:25
Confederation [110 words]HarrakAug 13, 2007 11:08
Countries Threatened with Extinction [55 words]S.C.PandaAug 8, 2007 04:39
ISLAMIC IRREDENTISM [140 words]DAVID R. GROESBECKAug 8, 2007 03:06
John 8:44 [38 words]infidelAug 9, 2007 03:13
Threatened extinction of nations [252 words]Rebecca MouldsAug 8, 2007 02:39
Non-ME state that is also facing extinction [133 words]John HadjiskyAug 7, 2007 18:38
Iraq Could Also Become History Down The Road [124 words]AnneMAug 7, 2007 17:31
Israel is "motor force of the entire region's problems" [44 words]Andras BerenyAug 7, 2007 15:55
Andras. You should Thank America. [27 words]UnilateralAug 15, 2007 13:59
Re: Countries Threatened with Extinction [105 words]JAAug 7, 2007 15:37
INDIA THREATENED WITH EXTINCTION [1218 words]Anti TerrorismAug 7, 2007 15:35
If Indians don't learn from history, they are on a fast track to Islamizatio!!! [124 words]JaladhiAug 7, 2007 16:09
Muslim population In India [45 words]VijayAug 7, 2007 17:32
Islamisation of Fiji Islands , New Caledonia , Papua New Guinea , Maluku Islands , Solomon Islands , Torres Strait Islands , Vanuatu , Palau Islands , Nauru , Timor , Flores Islands , Sumba Islands and other Islands in the region [1532 words]MargaretAug 8, 2007 11:35
Muslims are more than 20 % in India and they are obviously visible in every State , City , Town , Village and areas [430 words]AshishAug 9, 2007 00:44
India's muslims [9 words]VijayAug 10, 2007 04:15
muslims and peacelesness [144 words]G.VishvasAug 10, 2007 14:35
Because of the Muslims, the non-muslims get mercy from God. Allah will destroy the Earth if no Muslims existed in it. [40 words]Noor Gul PathanAug 10, 2007 17:23
Tableegee Jamaat is very active in the Far-East (our study shows) [73 words]Barb McDonaldAug 10, 2007 17:43
BBC ( BS Broadcasting Corporation) calls Terrorist activists and militants. [147 words]StevenAug 11, 2007 01:43
Muslims of India needed a separate country of their own ! [113 words]ItihaasAug 11, 2007 01:48
neglecting India [94 words]G.VishvasAug 12, 2007 01:06
Good reading [377 words]dhimmi no moreAug 12, 2007 08:19
Some light, some god [109 words]VijayAug 12, 2007 09:07
Pakistan's Tableeghis are brand ambassadors of Islamism ! [73 words]DurraniAug 13, 2007 06:12
Durrani: You have NO Proofs for your claims. [6 words]constant headAug 14, 2007 14:00
From your commets we know you are NOT a Muslim, so your anti-Muslim comments don't carry any weight. [24 words]Gul Khan PathanAug 14, 2007 14:04
What rubbish [238 words]JackAug 16, 2007 17:32
dhimmi ..have your all the ideas against islam .....you will find islam among your kids in your own back yard [110 words]syed mohammad aliAug 19, 2007 04:49
Syed Mohammad Ali's screed [145 words]Mel LarawayAug 22, 2007 17:34
How a Democracy can be defended from Invasion of Islamism ?? [3291 words]M.MoorthyAug 25, 2007 10:39
Islamisation of Fiji Islands etc [108 words]paarsurreyDec 26, 2008 07:19
Arab 'Palestinians' Self Destructive Lying Criminal Drama language [269 words]AprilFeb 15, 2009 14:31
thank you [42 words]HassanNov 7, 2009 14:18
Israel-Palestinians conflict [189 words]Janusz S.KowalikAug 7, 2007 14:14
Gulf War 1991 Redux?
[w/response] [56 words]
AlexAug 7, 2007 15:58
I'd like to take a stab at speculating [276 words]HomefrontAug 13, 2007 21:35
Extinction [32 words]MontyAug 7, 2007 14:05
Extinction [78 words]paarsurreyDec 26, 2008 09:31
The UN is doing its best [206 words]PatAug 7, 2007 13:36
How far behind is the US? [60 words]Steve SimmonsAug 8, 2007 09:23
How far behind is Canada, England and the EU? [94 words]Breslan 72Aug 10, 2007 08:52
Not far at all [255 words]PatAug 10, 2007 10:50
wait a minute 72! [13 words]HarrakAug 22, 2007 21:50
Yes On Certain Issues Bush 1 & Bush 2 are similar to Zapatero [98 words]James BurkeAug 25, 2007 14:08
Mr. Bush and Mr. Bean [113 words]HarrakAug 26, 2007 23:22

Comment on this item

Name
Email Address (optional)
Title of Comments
Comments:

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened for relevance, substance, and tone, and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome, but comments are rejected if scurrilous, off-topic, vulgar, ad hominem, or otherwise viewed as inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the Guidelines for Comments. For informational purposes, we identify countries from which comments are sent.

See the 25 most recent outstanding comments.

Back to top of page