69 million page views

The lost tablighees

Reader comment on item: Friendless in the Middle East
in response to reader comment: Proof of God existence

Submitted by dhimmi no more (United States), Jan 1, 2012 at 09:48

Our dear slayhy whose Hindu ancestors were brutalized by Islam wrote this little gem

>your talk about life and death and putting your trust in the only one (except you name Him other than He is)

And who is the Him/He O glorious madrassa graduate? you see our dear slayhy it is he who has a claim is the one that has to rpovide us kuffar with evidence to support his claim so

1. Where is your evidence that there are Gods or even a God? hard and solid evidence

2. Who is that Gods/God is he Amon/Ra', Zeus, Rama, Krishna, The ethnic God of the Jews, the God of Chritianity Jesus, or is he Allah the Arabian deity? Hard and solid evidence

3. And if it is only one God then who really created this God?

4. How come this life is a big mess with much sufferings and wars and famines and diseases and crime and fires and earthquakes and floods and death. It seems that this God or gods have no control of their own creation and why is that our dear slayhy?

5. So who really created Allah? hard and solid evidence and for answer to this question see sirat rasul allah by Ibn Hisham page 572 and you tell us what it says

6. Prove to us our dear slayhy el-tablighee that there was indeed an Arabian warlord and caravan raider whose name was Qutham and his kunya wa Abul Qasim aka Muhammad? hard and solid evidence

7. Prove to us that there are angels hard and solid evidence

8. Prove to us that there is an angel called Gabriel hard and solid evidence

9. Prove to us that Gabriel spoke to Muhammad on behalf of an Arabia deity called Allah hard and solid evidence

10. Prove to us that Muhammad got the message of Allah that was delivered to him via an angel right but in this case you have to explain to us how come no one seems to know if the word MLK in surat al-Fatiha is read as either Maalki and also as maliki and it cannot be both which means that Allah's messgae to Muhammad was destorted

11. And if you believe that Allah spoke to Muhammad via an angel them you must believe my claim that Allah also spoke to me via an angel too and I have a book for you therefore you must believe me right our dear slayhy

12. but the ultimate case against Islam must be the book of Arabian ingornace aka the Qur'an

>YOUR ARE actually a Muslim

... if you can answer the above questions to our satisfaction then you have a point

But you know what? Good luck

>Putting your full trust in God is ISLAM, but with a bit of tuning (not to name others as God)

Anyone who trusts a God that has no control on disasters that occur every day from his own creation is no God and the so called God of islam aint' no God

>The reason I brought the scientific information is because it shows clearly that a person lived 15 centuries ago in complete ignorance about science, can not bring such information. It has to be from a Higher Divine Entity.

Hello: the information that you provided was bogus as in the case of your little baydat al-na3ama when your Allah says that the earth if flat

What a joke

>The information is real because scientist observed it, it is well know facts. not relativity theory

What information? your Allah is sayig that the earth is flat and that the sun orbits the stationary earth and is this science our dear slayhy the lost tablighee?

>God put many proofs in The Quran to prove that He exists,

Where? Oh that the earth is flat? so is the earth flat and is it stationary as your Allah claims?

>some already fulfilled and others we wait for advancement in science to be discovered.

Like what?

>Proof of Al-Mighty depends on many factors, his acceptance or denial of a person in this life is a proof of His existence, He sends his angels to facilitate the life of a pious person, or make it hard for others to live if they are sinners or evil doers. life is full of those, and their life is a proof of His existance.

I read this as you have no evidence to provide to us kuffar that there is really an Arabian deity called allah

>But yet, to make sure that everyone is aware of His existence, other than worldy experiences, he put his proof in the Quran in the sort of Miracles that no one can bring forth by any human the like of, before or now.

The Qur'an? The Qur'an is poor literature that is full of mistakes in spelling and mistakes in Arabic grammar and it does not make any sense, it is a violent book and the author was a poor theologian, it is full of mistakes in science, medicine, history and on top of this the author plagiarizes the sacred history of the Jews and the Christians and the secular literature of the Syrians and the Greeks and he claims that he is the author os such literature

So much for the words of Allah

you must admit that it is not possible for Muhammad to bring such information during his era. and what I brought you is a mere water drop in a sea

And you must admit now that such information that you provided us about this bogus science in the Qur'an is no more than drivel as was proven to you

So is the earth flat our dear slayhy? and does the sun orbit the stationary earth as the Qur'an claims?

Muhammad or is it Ahmad or is it Qutham or is it Abul Qasim was an Arabian warlord and caravan raider and no more and you are no more than a victim ...

The difference between you and me is that you follow a corrupted book, I follow a divine book

Here we go again

1. Your Allah says that he is the author of the OT and NT and the Pslams right our dear slayhy the lost tablighee?

2. Your Allah says that no one can change or corrupts his words right? then no one can corrupt the Bible

Then congratulations our dear slayhy but the Bible is not a corrupted book

3. Your Allah quotes the Bible as a reference where we can find the name of Muhammad so you tell us why would Allah use as reference a corrupted book you tell us

4. And how come Allah did not protect his own words (The OT and NT and the pslams) from corruption unless he does not exist or he is not omnipotent so which one is it?

You are ignorant and shame on you


Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)