| Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List |
Akhand Bharat Never Existed
Reader comment on item: Subsidizing the Enemy
in response to reader comment: Akhand Bharat - Afghanistan, Burma, Srilanka, Nepal and Bhutan must also merge with India
Submitted by Faisal Iqbal Ch (Pakistan), Oct 17, 2008 at 10:56
Its part of history Akhand Bharat or Undivided India never existed. This Region is Divded into severl parts for thousands years there was no central command.
Akbar had also made sort of political agrements with rajas but again no central command
every state had its own rules and even currency so this concept is not corrcct.
Dislike (1)
Submitting....
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
Reader comments (139) on this item
 |
 |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Non sense [72 words] | Hamesh | Dec 21, 2009 07:53 | 166093 | ||
| Cant stop the inevitable [94 words] | Alpha | Jun 13, 2007 07:12 | 97931 | ||
| hate can only be taught , kids don't hate [90 words] | Phil Greend | Jun 8, 2007 01:21 | 96685 | ||
| That's it......... [165 words] | dfwhite | Sep 30, 2006 02:36 | 58297 | ||
| 3 |  Who will undo the inevitable? [626 words] | PUSHPAL ROY | Oct 5, 2006 17:27 | 58297 | |
| Terrorism in Sri Lanka [21 words] | Ashok Ranatunge | Jun 19, 2006 01:55 | 47875 | ||
| 4 | World vs Islam [183 words] | James Brown | Mar 28, 2008 10:45 | 47875 | |
| shabby work [127 words] | Rollin S | Dec 11, 2009 15:23 | 47875 | ||
| 1 | People who line in Glass House should'nt through stones to others [309 words] | Ramesh Paswan | May 22, 2006 09:30 | 46134 | |
| 1 | We have some good things too and some more problems! [224 words] | Irshad Naqvi | May 24, 2006 01:53 | 46134 | |
| 2 | reply to Ramesh Paswan [84 words] | Amitabh tripathi | May 24, 2006 02:52 | 46134 | |
| If we take donation or loan what is the harm for development?? [135 words] | ayrankhan@hotmail.com | May 28, 2006 01:14 | 46134 | ||
| You can only see a glass half empty! [127 words] | Darshil | Aug 22, 2013 04:30 | 46134 | ||
| Response from The Charity Commission [438 words] | Ilya Gedye | May 5, 2006 20:18 | 44927 | ||
| UK OK? [115 words] | Donald O | May 4, 2006 21:01 | 44877 | ||
| 1 | why do muslims have to apologize? [316 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | AO | May 3, 2006 13:56 | 44801 | |
| You just don't get it [47 words] | Octavio Johanson | May 3, 2006 16:39 | 44801 | ||
| Why? [478 words] | Sword of Islam & The Babies of Beslan | May 4, 2006 07:19 | 44801 | ||
| Dispelling the excuses that imprison them [1142 words] | RPaine | May 5, 2006 09:38 | 44801 | ||
| What do we expect.... [103 words] | San | May 6, 2006 19:50 | 44801 | ||
| Responce to Mr. Pipes - Subsidizing the Enemy [100 words] | Jamaal Abdul-Bari | May 3, 2006 13:09 | 44798 | ||
| Islam and Qur'an Not Subject to Criticism [198 words] | Infidel (the ape) | May 2, 2006 15:36 | 44753 | ||
| They're intimidating everyone, [112 words] | JustMe | May 3, 2006 16:09 | 44753 | ||
| cult schmult [183 words] | Donald O | May 4, 2006 21:55 | 44753 | ||
| 1 | Now Osama targets Hindus [1076 words] | Amitabh tripathi | May 2, 2006 04:28 | 44717 | |
| Thank you [126 words] | Ilya | May 5, 2006 20:42 | 44717 | ||
| To Amitabh [219 words] | faisal | May 15, 2006 11:43 | 44717 | ||
| Reply to Faisal [288 words] | Amitabh tripathi | May 16, 2006 04:20 | 44717 | ||
| To Amitabh [173 words] | faisal | May 19, 2006 17:44 | 44717 | ||
| Reply to Faisal [116 words] | Amitabh tripathi | May 20, 2006 04:09 | 44717 | ||
| 1 | islam and its aggressions [289 words] | G. Bisvas | May 20, 2006 09:53 | 44717 | |
| To Amitabh [183 words] | faisal | May 21, 2006 06:04 | 44717 | ||
| Reply to Faisal [49 words] | Amitabh Tripathi | May 21, 2006 23:53 | 44717 | ||
| TO Bisvas [359 words] | faisal | May 22, 2006 06:57 | 44717 | ||
| Islam's evils are special [242 words] | G.Bisvas | May 22, 2006 10:24 | 44717 | ||
| To Amitabh [216 words] | faisal | May 22, 2006 17:05 | 44717 | ||
| re: Mr Bisvas [117 words] | true believer | May 23, 2006 04:40 | 44717 | ||
| discussing with muslims [496 words] | G.Bisvas | May 23, 2006 05:23 | 44717 | ||
| Thanks Mr Bisvas [119 words] | faisal | May 23, 2006 09:18 | 44717 | ||
| To true believer and faisal [123 words] | G.Bisvas | May 23, 2006 15:53 | 44717 | ||
| Reply to Faisal [190 words] | Amitabh tripathi | May 24, 2006 03:42 | 44717 | ||
| To Amitabh , Thanks for replying [298 words] | faisal | May 24, 2006 20:08 | 44717 | ||
| MR Bisvas [357 words] | Faisal | May 25, 2006 17:25 | 44717 | ||
| Last reply to Faisal [71 words] | Amitabh tripathi | May 26, 2006 02:15 | 44717 | ||
| TO Amitabh [162 words] | faisal | May 26, 2006 17:31 | 44717 | ||
| Mr Bisvas ji [252 words] | Faisal | May 26, 2006 18:05 | 44717 | ||
| be an independent thinker [491 words] | G.Bisvas | May 27, 2006 05:31 | 44717 | ||
| Mr.Bisvas unfair to Muslims [385 words] | Vijay | May 27, 2006 17:44 | 44717 | ||
| Islam [417 words] | G.Bisvas | May 28, 2006 06:06 | 44717 | ||
| Brother Vijay the Great - A true, honest, brave and Real HINDU man [61 words] | Ayran Khan | May 29, 2006 02:05 | 44717 | ||
| to Vijay [506 words] | G.Bisvas | May 29, 2006 04:58 | 44717 | ||
| 1 | Bisvas has lost Vishwas from Muslims? [172 words] | Issa Muhammad Issa | May 29, 2006 05:52 | 44717 | |
| Nice posting Mr Bisvas [569 words] | faisal | May 29, 2006 18:58 | 44717 | ||
| 1 | indian or muslim (to faisal) [269 words] | G.Bisvas | May 30, 2006 07:31 | 44717 | |
| To Mr.Bisvas [244 words] | Vijay | May 30, 2006 08:39 | 44717 | ||
| Vijay, much truth in what you say [149 words] | G.Bisvas | May 31, 2006 06:32 | 44717 | ||
| 32 | Hindus are the best people in world [358 words] | Mohammad Khan | May 31, 2006 12:16 | 44717 | |
| 1 | To Mohammad Khan [157 words] | G.Bisvas | Jun 1, 2006 09:02 | 44717 | |
| 1 | Forget Black History and Look for Bright Future! [167 words] | Mohammad Khan | Jun 2, 2006 03:31 | 44717 | |
| 37 | Muslims Ruled 1000 years in India! [374 words] | Mohammad Khan | Jun 3, 2006 08:05 | 44717 | |
| 3 | To Mohammad Khan [370 words] | G.Bisvas | Jun 4, 2006 06:05 | 44717 | |
| 2 | I don't agree with your points for Birth of Pakistan [346 words] | Mohammad Khan | Jun 11, 2006 09:39 | 44717 | |
| 14 | Akhand Bharat - Afghanistan, Burma, Srilanka, Nepal and Bhutan must also merge with India [38 words] | Proud Indian | Jun 12, 2006 01:41 | 44717 | |
| 1 | How will you Digest Christian, Muslims and others! [56 words] | Proud Bangali | Jun 15, 2006 08:49 | 44717 | |
| 1 | Indian Muslims are in much better conditions than Bangladesh! [115 words] | Moosa Mohammad | Jun 16, 2006 09:49 | 44717 | |
| 2 | Islamic nationalism- a utopia [601 words] | Pushpal Roy | Sep 16, 2006 16:24 | 44717 | |
| think again [119 words] | sujai gopal | Oct 13, 2006 04:33 | 44717 | ||
| 2 | muslims [103 words] | raman goswami | Oct 20, 2006 11:18 | 44717 | |
| I dont agree with u raman goswami [76 words] | Faisal | Oct 22, 2006 02:37 | 44717 | ||
| 4 | Islam Vs Hinduism [488 words] | James Brahmin | Mar 28, 2008 10:13 | 44717 | |
 Akhand Bharat Never Existed [56 words] | Faisal Iqbal Ch | Oct 17, 2008 10:56 | 44717 | ||
| 2 | AN OPEN LETTER BY A BHARATIYA MUSLIM TO THE PRESIDENT OF PAKISTAN [933 words] | bharatiya muslim mansoor khan | Feb 4, 2009 14:53 | 44717 | |
| very well written [11 words] | bhavesh | Feb 5, 2009 04:03 | 44717 | ||
| stupied [72 words] | Rifat | Jul 29, 2009 18:33 | 44717 | ||
| All Fake Stories [67 words] | Daniel | Aug 13, 2009 13:20 | 44717 | ||
| greatful information [8 words] | vijay dubey | Aug 19, 2009 04:53 | 44717 | ||
| Akhand Bharat [30 words] | pravin chauhan | Sep 22, 2009 14:05 | 44717 | ||
| not afghanistan [13 words] | Anonymous | May 26, 2010 01:09 | 44717 | ||
| Agree [162 words] | Ananth Krishna | May 7, 2011 03:18 | 44717 | ||
| thanks daniel [9 words] | rajesh legend | Jul 26, 2012 23:25 | 44717 | ||
| False claims [244 words] | Mohan | Jan 18, 2015 09:32 | 44717 | ||
| SAARC RENAMED AS INDIAN PENSUILA [24 words] | LUCKY | Dec 23, 2015 23:47 | 44717 | ||
| No way muslims could rule india in next infinite years to come. [190 words] | wellwisher | Oct 10, 2016 06:17 | 44717 | ||
| Best analysis [16 words] | Knreddy | Nov 5, 2017 00:45 | 44717 | ||
| Muhammad Khan from Kuwait perpetuates many lies. [179 words] | Prashant | Nov 7, 2017 23:56 | 44717 | ||
| VEDAS : THE REAL DHARMA (RELIGION) [48 words] | ARJUN KARPE | Jul 16, 2018 04:57 | 44717 | ||
| Muslim rulled [49 words] | Navneet | Jan 19, 2020 14:54 | 44717 | ||
| My foot [28 words] | pranjal saikia | Jan 21, 2020 12:25 | 44717 | ||
| Gift Aid - Money for what? [121 words] | Ilya Gedye | Apr 30, 2006 22:35 | 44644 | ||
| We should not forget ourselves! [282 words] | Ilya Gedye | Apr 30, 2006 21:59 | 44642 | ||
| Be Prepared [135 words] | Abraham J. Santiago | Apr 30, 2006 18:57 | 44633 | ||
| Teachings of Faith or Hate [241 words] | Thomas Earl Cannady | Apr 30, 2006 10:25 | 44609 | ||
| THOMAS [94 words] | AHMAD ZAFIRE | Apr 30, 2006 19:13 | 44609 | ||
| American Values or World Values [396 words] | Thomas Earl Cannady | May 1, 2006 06:11 | 44609 | ||
| to Thomas [576 words] | Sidda | May 1, 2006 16:09 | 44609 | ||
| AH-MAD IS WRONG - The terror, violence, blackmail, the anger is how many Islamists express themselves [48 words] | Jeff Burke | May 1, 2006 18:00 | 44609 | ||
| re: Proof for Jeff Burke [3075 words] | true believer | May 2, 2006 10:30 | 44609 | ||
| categorization [127 words] | yuval brandstetter MD | Apr 29, 2006 16:10 | 44546 | ||
| Reply to Categorization: [211 words] | All is Lost | May 1, 2006 07:28 | 44546 | ||
| to All is Lost [171 words] | Sidda | May 2, 2006 11:28 | 44546 | ||
| Commission's Duties clear, if short-sighted [120 words] | Deborah Zippel | Apr 29, 2006 15:49 | 44545 | ||
| THE NEW BRITAIN - FUTURE CAPITAL OF EURABIA [302 words] | Jeff Burke | Apr 29, 2006 09:57 | 44533 | ||
| Wasn't 7/7 America's fault? [86 words] | Pat | May 1, 2006 16:37 | 44533 | ||
| Indifference, Inertia and denial. [478 words] | Reuben Horne | Apr 29, 2006 07:42 | 44532 | ||
| More Lethal Than Nuclear Bomb [372 words] | kamekish | Apr 29, 2006 02:12 | 44507 | ||
| doing their "Job"? [105 words] | Darwin Barrett | Apr 28, 2006 19:06 | 44493 | ||
| Significance [587 words] | John R. | Apr 28, 2006 18:13 | 44478 | ||
| Tax subsidies for charities [42 words] | Michael | Apr 28, 2006 18:09 | 44477 | ||
| 'Disbelievers are filth' [63 words] | Donald W. Bales | Apr 28, 2006 17:37 | 44474 | ||
| no security for me? no tax payments [223 words] | Italian | Apr 28, 2006 16:29 | 44456 | ||
| Fight fire wirth fire [82 words] | Dr RJP | Apr 28, 2006 15:32 | 44454 | ||
| Completely agree! [52 words] | Octavio Johanson | Apr 29, 2006 06:52 | 44454 | ||
| 1 | Solution for the West: Islam classified as a CULT? [217 words] | RPaine | Apr 30, 2006 05:06 | 44454 | |
| Name the Enemy First [181 words] | Jaladhi | May 1, 2006 12:02 | 44454 | ||
| re: solution [95 words] | true believer | May 2, 2006 06:35 | 44454 | ||
| Laws Against Hate vs Apologists Rhetoric [51 words] | steven | Apr 28, 2006 14:48 | 44439 | ||
| The rule is to protect the school, not the students [112 words] | Sol Shinder | Apr 28, 2006 14:42 | 44435 | ||
| 1938 and beyond [185 words] | Funk Soul Bruhva | Apr 28, 2006 21:42 | 44435 | ||
| please be careful [107 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | roger wilkinson | Apr 28, 2006 14:13 | 44431 | ||
| Irresponsible and incorrect use of the word 'enemy' . [103 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Ghulam Muhammed, Mumbai | Apr 28, 2006 13:59 | 44430 | ||
| 1 | Muslims (many or all?) do not understand the golden rule. [151 words] | Prashant | Nov 15, 2017 01:05 | 44430 | |
| how to approach the Charities Commission about Hawza's misuse of its status [132 words] | Juan Golblado | Apr 28, 2006 13:51 | 44429 | ||
| Irresponsible government. [47 words] | Charles Smyth | Apr 28, 2006 12:00 | 44425 | ||
| Cultural timidity [65 words] | David W. Lincoln | Apr 28, 2006 11:58 | 44424 | ||
| G-d shines on you [76 words] | Laura Maizels | Apr 28, 2006 11:11 | 44421 | ||
| Now is the time [65 words] | Saikat Biswas | Apr 28, 2006 10:35 | 44420 | ||
| re:problem [57 words] | true believer | May 4, 2006 09:46 | 44420 | ||
| Sami Al Arian's school still open in FL despite having funded terrorism [149 words] | Ben van de Polder | Apr 28, 2006 10:12 | 44418 | ||
| The North American Islamic Trust [38 words] | williamgeorge | Mar 10, 2009 11:25 | 44418 | ||
| Half of the story [91 words] | Sam Urquhart | Apr 28, 2006 08:50 | 44417 | ||
| Response to Sam Urquhart's excuses for Islam teachings [202 words] | JustMe | Apr 30, 2006 17:24 | 44417 | ||
| the wrong governing body [75 words] | Roslyn Esther | Apr 28, 2006 08:33 | 44415 | ||
| Oh, to be in England [127 words] | Phillip | Apr 28, 2006 07:53 | 44413 | ||
| All is lost [135 words] | Tired Reader | Apr 28, 2006 07:15 | 44410 | ||
| Have a look at Sistani's site [34 words] | Silvester | Apr 28, 2006 07:06 | 44409 | ||
| Booklet CC47 'outlines [the Charity Commission's] role clearly? [135 words] | Syarikat | Apr 28, 2006 05:49 | 44405 | ||
| Last Time I Checked .... [30 words] | Bombs Of The USA & The Babies Of Iraq | Apr 28, 2006 04:07 | 44400 | ||
| Seeing is believing, Bombs Of The USA [143 words] | JustMe | Apr 30, 2006 17:08 | 44400 | ||
| Amazing... [3 words] | TM | Apr 28, 2006 03:15 | 44397 |
Latest Articles
Follow Daniel Pipes
All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2025 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes
Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes
(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.
Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.
For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)