3 readers online now  |  69 million page views

Common sense is quite uncommon

Reader comment on item: The Burqa Wars
in response to reader comment: Intelligence includes common sense

Submitted by Kashayar (United States), Sep 18, 2009 at 04:05

>>Hindu fascism is a reaction to the successes of islamic fascism and imperialism and deceits in the Indian Subcontinent (ISC)
Same NAZI rant applied in a different context.

>>There is no anti-minority religious fascism in India by hindus
Joke !

Hegdewar the founder of the RSS and Golwalkar his successor have been total fascists who praised and propounded Hitler's theory of genocide. RSS was founded in 1925 with clear Fascist objectives (much before the partition of the ISC). Their membership is above 5 million as of today. And I have not considered the numbers of Bajrang Dal and VHP. Toghther they even outnumber the Indian armed forces and indulge in the typical low tech high volume terrorism aka rioting. And their numbers are much much higher than the black sheep within our community.

They control the Hindu right wing party BJP which was in power at the center and holds power in many states of the Indian union.

>>All those who entered ISC became Indians.
Really !
Why were Biharis bashed up in Mumbai ? Or Hindi signboards blackened in Tamil Nadu ? Or a madrasi or a person from north-east ridiculed in the North ?

>>The kuran teaches muslims even today (more than ever before) that they are a separate, superior and supremacy-entitled nation or supra-nation.
Same as the BJP+RSS/VHP/Bajrang Dal combo who shout "Hindustan only for the Hindus"

>>Islam has been always a fascist totalitarian imperialist and terrorizing ideology even since the times of Mohammad. Islam will never allow muslims to be genuinely loyal to India and indianess.
What about the caste system in your own community ? What about your law-giver Manu and his Manusmriti ? What about the caste system in your own community ? It is the fanatics from the majority community who question/provoke the loyalties of the average Indian Muslim.

>>The muslim understanding of brotherhood is exemplified by the relation between Dara Shukoh and Aurangzeb (who assassinated the elder brother Dara in 1659).
What about Bali in Ramayana who kept his brother Sugreev's wife by force after kicking him out ? What about Pandavas and Kauravas in Mahabharat ? Your Dharmaraj Yudishtra wagered his wife to his brothers in the game of dice? Or Bimbisara and Ajatashatru where son killed the father for the throne ?

>>but rather a weak and belated reaction to the disloyal anti-indian ideologies and activities of the muslims (in general, but with some few exceptions) and some few christians.
So you burned Graham Staines alive along with his two kids for serving lepers from your lower castes ?
As per your definition the murderers were not fascists but patriots.

>>It was a great blunder by Mahatma Gandhi to have issued the slogan hindu muslim bhai bhai.
So you believe that Hindus and Muslims should not be brothers. Ironically Gandhi was assasinated by a Hindu terrorist who had similar convictions.

>>The hindu-sikh conflict arose only after some self-appointed sikh leaders started imitating the muslims...
That was a politically manufactured conflict with tacit Paki support. Initially Indira Gandhi supported Bhindranwale to undermine Buta Singh in Punjab and when this very tiny fraction of Sikhs went out of her control she used disproportionate amounts of force to storm the Sikh's most holy shrines. The anti-sikh riots that followed her assasination only worsened the situation.

>The partition of India is a result of the kuran ..
No. It is as result of the existing distrust among the various religious communities and the spineless of the our leaders who let it happen along with the complicity of the British who kept their troops inert. If people want to do something wrong they will always find some book. If they can't they they will write one.

>>The muslim population component (in 60 years) has increased from 6.5% to 16% in India, the hindu population component in Pakistan West has decreased from 25% to 2%
The Indian muslim cannot and must not be held accountable for the actions of Muslims in Pakistan.

>>and in East (Bangladesh) from 40% to 10%.
Correction: from 20% to 10%

In 1971 a Parsi a Sikh and a Jew (FM Manekshaw, Gen. Arora and Gen. Jacob)lead a very successful military offensive on pakis and liberated Bangladesh. And a Hindu (Indira Gandhi) who had far more authority than the above three let nearly 1 lakh war criminals (of the worst kind) from the paki army return unharmed to their homes. All this for a signature from Bhutto on the Shimla Agreement which the pakis anyway never honoured.

>>Intelligence includes common sense. In any case you, as one of the two participants in this competition, cannot decide who the winner is or shall be (hoping it will be a long drawn out competition).
... Don't be surprised if I don't respond to your drivel.


Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (83) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
I don't think Europe is "ahead" of us [290 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Michael SSep 9, 2016 04:21232462
what's the point? [229 words]MitchFeb 3, 2017 06:33232462
Can you please get me back to Kansas? [656 words]Michael SFeb 5, 2017 00:38232462
Freedom to go stark naked? [85 words]Gary E.Sep 29, 2015 07:00225394
There's a direction to all this, and the Muslims aren't to blame. [228 words]Michael SSep 10, 2016 17:40225394
1Worrying about headscarves, while "skirting" around the problem [614 words]Michael SJan 21, 2015 06:53220550
1Unislamic Burqas [130 words]PrashantJan 3, 2012 23:29192256
eyes [21 words]jerome HenenJul 17, 2011 14:18187512
Burqas in France [183 words]John StaufferApr 12, 2011 21:58184204
4the "prophet mohammed" spoke clearly against women, the burqa is just a way of enforcing domination and supression of women. ..May ..2010 [169 words]Phil GreendMay 3, 2010 03:46172027
Burqa video [41 words]JenTDec 13, 2009 01:56165762
2The two faces of Islam - Read the book "23 Years" by Ali Dashti to understand Islam by understanding its development [140 words]FriendOfIslamDec 8, 2009 02:09165486
Burqa or not to Burqa [93 words]DavePOct 1, 2009 13:48162428
To Burqa Or Not To Burqa That's A Question Of World Thought [282 words]D.K.Milgrim-HeathSep 22, 2010 21:41162428
God bless that lady [9 words]dfwhite19438Sep 27, 2009 02:53162171
headscarf ban in vlaanderen(dutch speaking belgium) starting from 2010 [42 words]savingthewesternworldSep 16, 2009 12:41161632
Double standards [183 words]PrashantAug 30, 2009 23:54160848
The thing about living in the EU [28 words]Straight_Talk_LuigiSep 1, 2009 00:56160848
1Time to unveil [168 words]Rebecca MouldsAug 16, 2009 14:19160272
France downhill [67 words]StopoilJul 19, 2009 18:53159035
1My theory of the Burqa [208 words]LynnJul 16, 2009 07:57158911
Sarkozy's Fatwa [26 words]Vinod GulatiJul 13, 2009 22:37158819
legality of banning burka [244 words]G. VishvasJul 19, 2009 05:58158819
Banning anything. [163 words]Vinod GulatiJul 20, 2009 12:17158819
Gulatis naivete will be very costly [354 words]G.VishvasJul 21, 2009 10:44158819
1Hypocrisy just got BIGGER [252 words]KashayarSep 9, 2009 05:30158819
competition about who is the bigger hypocrite [90 words]G.VishvasSep 9, 2009 21:28158819
1You win the competition hands on [206 words]KashayarSep 11, 2009 06:48158819
You cannot unilaterally decide who wins [271 words]G.VishvasSep 12, 2009 20:53158819
1Common sense decides the winner [472 words]KashayarSep 14, 2009 07:44158819
Intelligence includes common sense [884 words]G.VishvasSep 14, 2009 20:02158819
Common sense is quite uncommon [801 words]KashayarSep 18, 2009 04:05158819
discussing reasonably - how to do it [1448 words]G.VishvasSep 20, 2009 01:41158819
It's true [33 words]Vermilion8Nov 5, 2009 13:32158819
2What is wrong in wearing ski masks in public [19 words]PPSMay 6, 2010 04:09158819
1Europe's Burqa Wars [192 words]moJul 12, 2009 06:34158774
2Let us take a clue from passport pictures requirements [219 words]George PJul 12, 2009 00:57158769
Nuns prostitute for Jesus? [22 words]Khalif TandawadonJun 14, 2018 07:48158769
I have a question for our dear Khalif (PBUH) in regard to زواج المسيار and زواج المتعة [107 words]dhimmi no moreJun 15, 2018 05:49158769
UK's poll decision [49 words]James AureliusApr 1, 2009 00:57153077
42Prostitutes had to wear hijab 7000 years ago [2007 words]n.krishnaDec 5, 2006 02:5968303
Respect [43 words]NJ CastroNov 7, 2008 05:4968303
Jews not included? [119 words]Hannah Y. GrauDec 7, 2008 16:2068303
To Krishna [364 words]moJul 12, 2009 06:1768303
Are you any better ? [80 words]KashayarSep 9, 2009 05:3968303
Interesting but... [99 words]AhuJan 27, 2010 16:4868303
1Yes about Jews And Israel [193 words]D.K. Milgrim-HeathMay 17, 2010 07:3068303
You are wrong.. [119 words]amqwertySep 2, 2010 13:0968303
2Historically Inaccurate! [215 words]MaizeSep 18, 2011 04:3668303
rare truth [12 words]2bussyJul 6, 2012 17:4968303
Burkahs should never be required. [5 words]WalkerSep 19, 2012 04:4268303
Optional [6 words]walkerSep 19, 2012 04:4368303
jewish women and veils [178 words]ghaberFeb 12, 2015 19:0168303
Danki [1 words]SundayAug 25, 2015 15:5668303
Now we don't have time to unpack all of this, but: [15 words]NiseJul 1, 2019 18:5568303
Not really ... [113 words]Rk403Sep 12, 2019 09:3868303
Why I am against the Burqa [214 words]Octavio JohansonNov 21, 2006 05:4266794
An outrageous idea [43 words]Aisha GayleJul 21, 2009 16:0266794
Don't like it in the UK [8 words]Straight_Talk_LuigiNov 13, 2009 17:5866794
This is just show that Europeans have no tolerance and oppress women [84 words]tarikurNov 18, 2006 15:3466521
Praise be to the Dutch [53 words]Octavio JohansonNov 18, 2006 19:2966521
The problem with tolerance [165 words]Octavio JohansonNov 19, 2006 14:1766521
Well, now... [238 words]munineyeDec 18, 2008 03:3466521
Amen, Octavio! When immigrating to another country, fit in! [20 words]Mike ConlonNov 23, 2015 23:2766521
Europe's burqa wars [254 words]BrunoNov 18, 2006 14:2466515
burqas [9 words]helloFeb 6, 2007 06:3666515
The march of progress [134 words]RajahOct 26, 2006 01:2264516
who is immoral? [86 words]AnitaOct 25, 2006 18:0364492
Zero Tolerance for the Burqua [203 words]Octavio JohansonNov 19, 2006 05:1264492
1God bless the dutch [32 words]George PJul 12, 2009 01:0364492
Regarding Europe's Burqa Wars posted August 25, 2005 [140 words]MoraaFeb 25, 2006 20:0938031
burkah the shield [52 words]saq from ukMay 1, 2006 17:5538031
Typical [259 words]AaronMay 7, 2006 07:2038031
Not a typical response !! [261 words]KhatibMay 11, 2006 15:2038031
un-moral morals [43 words]susanSep 23, 2006 15:1438031
saq, how naive... [47 words]susanSep 23, 2006 15:1738031
1advice on the superior muslim mothers [61 words]susanSep 23, 2006 15:2038031
Questions [209 words]oswaldSep 24, 2006 01:4838031
Only a man can [121 words]oswaldSep 24, 2006 06:0538031
Musli mwomen better? [204 words]YnnatchkahDec 8, 2008 02:4838031
What about .....? [92 words]ISisJul 13, 2009 02:3038031

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to Common sense is quite uncommon by Kashayar

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List


eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2019 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)