69 million page views

Translations of this item:

en

Submit a comment on this item

Reader comments (188) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
3Keep your hopes low with Tarique Ghaffur [290 words]PrashantJun 23, 2018 13:22243409
187% of the French are right [300 words]PrashantJun 23, 2018 12:51243408
Israel recently stripped Israeli citizens who have joined Isis of their citizenship [23 words]AnonSep 4, 2017 10:16240708
Unfair accusations of fascism [249 words]Moderate PragmatistNov 17, 2016 11:41234121
Eagle Eye [22 words]Savian JimenezApr 2, 2015 12:03222601
Of course [7 words]Landon Van BurenMar 26, 2015 12:12222496
3All attempts to justify it run into a simple fact... [77 words]CalebMay 9, 2010 07:50172462
Martial Law in Hawaii and the Niihau incident [156 words]Henry JenkinsMay 6, 2011 05:36172462
Thank you Henry for strengthening my Argument [166 words]CalebMay 9, 2011 02:55172462
CALEB: AS TO INTERNMENT OF JAPANESE 'FROM HAWAII [584 words]LEE BRANCHAug 8, 2014 13:41172462
3Japanese "relocation", not internment. [1010 words]Wallace Edward BrandApr 17, 2009 16:43154023
4Once again, the Right is wrong. [96 words]High School DiplomaMar 6, 2010 06:37154023
Once again the politically correct are wrong [278 words]Wallace Edward BrandOct 8, 2011 15:02154023
Not racism [159 words]Howard FreemanDec 23, 2008 15:20145745
2WHY THE JAPANESE INTERMENT STILL MATTERS [278 words]Elizabeth van KampenMar 24, 2008 11:09123493
Agree with Bryan Lee [249 words]C.G. AtkinsDec 8, 2007 20:32115933
reply to c.g. Atkins [66 words]howard fremanJan 31, 2009 14:34115933
3Well I've read MAGIC [103 words]Brian D GrayJul 26, 2010 20:31115933
dual citizenship [89 words]hbearDec 15, 2006 14:2069626
1Well... [56 words]Brian D. GrayJul 26, 2010 20:3469626
1Comment [240 words]Bryan LeeDec 11, 2005 23:0229786
1They're not the "other" [337 words]TashaNov 26, 2005 18:2828875
The others.... [106 words]Angel B.Nov 7, 2006 19:3028875
2In Response to Olsen .... [423 words]EmilyNov 18, 2005 01:5428569
purpose of internment [262 words]TAPOct 7, 2005 23:2226701
OGEC [574 words]Edward F. ThieryOct 7, 2005 18:0026687
Japanese Internment [92 words]K. JarvisSep 2, 2005 18:5625427
3against internment [154 words]AnthonyAug 24, 2005 18:5925076
1Response to Barbara Hoshiko [110 words]Farida FaiziJun 6, 2005 12:1522578
1Need more specificity [229 words]KonradMar 30, 2005 10:2521244
2This is how hate starts: response to "Andrew" [220 words]JackieMar 11, 2005 14:3020957
According to the Islamists, Islam is not a peaceful religion. [555 words]Wallace Edward BrandMay 29, 2007 22:4220957
Oh please.... [144 words]donvanMay 30, 2007 16:3620957
quote [92 words]ploomeApr 15, 2009 11:2620957
This is a response to a question from "ploome" on the source of my information on Thomas Jefferson and "Adja" [105 words]Wallace Edward BrandApr 15, 2009 20:5020957
1Response to Malkin [204 words]Arlinda DeAngelisMar 1, 2005 22:3320607
Reply to commenter Andrew [77 words]David JonesFeb 21, 2005 22:3220452
Interpreting the Koran [123 words]Wallace Edward BrandOct 8, 2011 14:1620452
1How new is this idea ? [254 words]John J. DonneFeb 8, 2005 06:3220155
D. Pipes misquoted by columnist in San Antonio, Texas Express News [87 words]Sylvia WeissJan 30, 2005 14:4119994
1Militant Islam in the US hails the death of respect for human life and how it is impacting on America. [224 words]AndrewJan 25, 2005 21:4219871
andrew - wrong info and irrelevant conclusions: LIES! [171 words]PeaceMakerFeb 14, 2007 00:3619871
Reply to PeaceMaker [131 words]Wallace Edward BrandOct 8, 2011 14:2719871
Response to internee re: Malkin book [201 words]Armond FestineJan 20, 2005 14:3319791
The whole story [50 words]Walter E. WallisJan 19, 2005 16:4119777
These are the SDS of the 60's [35 words]ErnieJan 19, 2005 11:5519770
Profiling - limitations [62 words]Michael C [uk]Jan 18, 2005 15:5219746
Response to Barbara Hoshiko [125 words]Philip SchlesingerJan 17, 2005 14:2219712
Jihad by Stealth [290 words]Wallace Edward BrandOct 8, 2011 15:2319712
Harder but Fairer [117 words]RyanJan 17, 2005 04:4419710
2Humanity, YOU FAIL. [654 words]AkioJan 15, 2005 03:4919677
1Profiling Rapists? [184 words]Greg BurginJan 13, 2005 21:0519659
1Internment for Americans? [272 words]BrandonJan 13, 2005 14:4519650
1Response to commenter Schlesinger [52 words]Barbara HoshikoJan 11, 2005 10:1019581
Response to Terry Holland [44 words]Philip SchlesingerJan 10, 2005 17:0619570
Response to Barbara Hoshiko [78 words]Philip SchlesingerJan 10, 2005 17:0219569
1A little foresight [140 words]Cindy GoodmanJan 10, 2005 16:2119567
1Difference between Japanese and fundamentalist Muslim immigrants [161 words]Barbara HoshikoJan 9, 2005 16:2019546
There's alot more you need to know about Islam [131 words]Jailani Bin SalehOct 13, 2006 21:4819546
Ms Hoshiko Got it wrong [170 words]LT Sean ABDOct 19, 2006 07:2119546
response to Barbara Hoshiko [109 words]howard freemanJun 2, 2009 19:0519546
If this is a war then target the soldiers [276 words]Bradley WentworthJan 9, 2005 12:1919543
1Chicken Little logical arguments on internment [1187 words]Ted KayJan 7, 2005 09:3519500
Doesn't fly [274 words]Bonnie BoruckiJan 7, 2005 04:3819488
Defense of Islamist Internment [40 words]Paul R. MillerJan 6, 2005 10:4219452
More From an Internee [374 words]Edwin S. FujinakaJan 5, 2005 21:4019446
Fine Line Between Safety and Rights of the Individual [194 words]Marc ThompsonJan 5, 2005 20:5919444
1Internment - an objectively discredited canard [683 words]Gary R. WhiteJan 5, 2005 16:3419440
Lowman and McCloyMagic: The Untold Story of U.S. Intelligence and the Evacuation of Japanese Residents from the West Coast during WW IIwere correct. [198 words]Wallace Edward BrandMay 29, 2007 22:2519440
2No racism during Japanese internment? [154 words]MarkJan 5, 2005 16:2119438
7Internment Vs. 5th Amendment [106 words]A.M.Oct 30, 2008 17:3919438
Internment of American Citizens [365 words]Big DawgMar 6, 2011 03:2019438
Just A Thought [225 words]Terry R. HollandJan 5, 2005 12:0019433
Profiling [23 words]Richard BaldwinJan 5, 2005 11:2519431
1Supporting racial profiling but opposing internment [139 words]Jonathan RickJan 5, 2005 08:2319422
1Principles [49 words]TomJan 5, 2005 07:3119418
Why repeat a mistake [224 words]CraigJan 5, 2005 06:1719416
1Saudi Arabia's misplaced priorities [67 words]Hari IyerJan 5, 2005 01:5019408
This article should be required reading! [207 words]Diana WhittJan 5, 2005 00:2619404
2In defense of the Constitution [252 words]Mollie BrewsaughJan 4, 2005 22:2919402
Beyond belief [36 words]DonJan 4, 2005 22:1019400
Dangerous [223 words]AmiraJan 4, 2005 21:4119399
Good Grief [30 words]Larry ThorpJan 4, 2005 21:3419398
Be careful of some opposers [248 words]Amiris ReynosoJan 4, 2005 21:0819396
1My voice [184 words]Sandra AndersonJan 4, 2005 21:0119395
My Opinion [40 words]Betty KarnesJan 4, 2005 19:0019389
Profiling [399 words]Steve in BostonJan 4, 2005 16:4519379
Prisons [147 words]Bianca MittagJan 4, 2005 16:3519376
Totally Agree with Mr. Pipes [116 words]Jo MinogueJan 4, 2005 16:3419375
1National disgrace [120 words]TonyJan 4, 2005 16:3119374
Internment Was Correct [237 words]TantorJan 4, 2005 13:0519355
Can we discuss this matter today? [73 words]Jason PappasJan 3, 2005 13:3419331
The "Timothy McVeigh" comment [83 words]ReportJan 3, 2005 12:1519326
1Islam VS US Constitution [279 words]Hari IyerJan 2, 2005 22:1319320
Islam vs. the U.S.Constitution [143 words]Faultline USADec 26, 2007 13:1819320
3JAPANESE RELOCATION MYTH BAINBRIDGE ISLAND, WA [567 words]CAPT James M. OlsenJan 2, 2005 19:5719316
2outraged [284 words]StudentFeb 25, 2007 17:5419316
3We can't take much more of this, CAPTAIN! [213 words]Brendan O'LearyMar 8, 2007 22:1519316
I salute Captain James M. Olsen [382 words]Robert MedleyAug 14, 2007 20:0019316
2thank goodness [125 words]Brendan O'LearyAug 16, 2007 00:2119316
2WAY TO BE [14 words]Brendan O'LearyAug 16, 2007 00:2519316
2No justification [55 words]DerekJul 8, 2010 20:0819316
Citizenship vs Race [384 words]Harvey JenkinsMay 6, 2011 05:0919316
myth [108 words]howard freemanMay 30, 2015 17:5819316
become what we are fighting [38 words]Pogue MahoneDec 11, 2016 00:1419316
Mr. Pipes is right [540 words]W.J.HopwoodJan 2, 2005 15:0919307
Pipes and Malkin are correct. [1995 words]BobJan 2, 2005 13:2219303
2Timothy McVeigh [115 words]Jon YorkJan 1, 2005 16:4019290
2Missing the point... [59 words]AaronJan 1, 2005 16:2119288
1Common Sense [44 words]Mike BochnerJan 1, 2005 11:5819285
1The Japanese Internment [191 words]RickJan 1, 2005 11:3519284
I disagree w/ Pipes and response to Irfan's "I don't buy this" comment [249 words]JohnDec 31, 2004 18:2019278
Dismay and Shock [63 words]Professor Judy SaltzmanDec 31, 2004 15:4819275
2Be careful about profiling Mr. Pipes [357 words]B. AlotaibiDec 31, 2004 14:0019273
How about the White Guys? [48 words]BillDec 31, 2004 12:4619272
Slippery slope [37 words]Paul FDec 31, 2004 12:3019271
1Is that what they mean by freedom? [194 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Stuart DryerDec 31, 2004 11:5519269
Thanks for the German version: it reads better that way! [4 words]DaveDec 31, 2004 11:1519267
Common sense [55 words]Octavio JohansonDec 31, 2004 08:2019266
Malkin on German-and Italian-Americans [143 words]Michelle MalkinDec 31, 2004 03:5319263
German & Italian Internment. [47 words]Tom DundeeJun 3, 2009 22:3519263
Registering members of religious groups [158 words]Lou LilienthalDec 30, 2004 22:3219260
I was in high school at that point in time [150 words]L Andrea CoccoDec 30, 2004 20:4719259
Japanese relocation [1411 words]Bill LearyDec 30, 2004 14:0219248
Read the Constitution! [85 words]UVDec 30, 2004 12:5819246
What really happened [275 words]A. Mark Ratner, PhD, PEDec 30, 2004 12:5719245
1Additional Comments from an Actual Internee [340 words]Edwin S. FujinakaDec 30, 2004 03:0319238
Not all of the French are blind [40 words]CAMELIADec 29, 2004 21:5419228
Japanese Internment Did Not Serve the Allied Cause [480 words]Aaron GoldsteinDec 29, 2004 21:1219225
I don't buy this [442 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Irfan KhawajaDec 29, 2004 19:3119224
Actually, Germans were interned as well as Japanese [289 words]S. O'HaraDec 29, 2004 19:2119223
1Ninth Circle of Hell - Profiling and Discernment [1084 words]Diane AldenDec 29, 2004 15:1119217
Minority Hijackers [122 words]Darwin BarrettDec 29, 2004 14:3219214
Profiling [49 words]L.D. ForeDec 29, 2004 12:3719212
Those who follow TV News are best informed? [153 words]David RedmondDec 29, 2004 12:3519211
An Internee Comments [369 words]Edwin S. FujinakaDec 29, 2004 12:3119210
"Why the Japanese Internment Still Matters" [214 words]Achilles PerryDec 29, 2004 11:0019209
1What about German Americans in the US at the time? [132 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Ruben PerlmutterDec 29, 2004 10:5919208
Error [275 words]Bruce LedermanDec 29, 2004 09:5119206
Germans too? [163 words]Garry PriorDec 29, 2004 09:3319205
Germans and Italians and other were Interned [71 words]Harvey JenkinsMay 6, 2011 04:4219205
1I strongly disagree! [102 words]Richard Houlihan.Dec 29, 2004 09:2519204
Malkin [22 words]S.C.PandaDec 29, 2004 05:0319202
As usual, your brilliant remarks... [242 words]Freda FloodDec 29, 2004 03:0019199
Japanese internment [46 words]Lubicz, StephaneDec 29, 2004 00:5719198
Malkin and Christian Arabs [109 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Robin R KentDec 28, 2004 23:5319197
Why not close the door? [66 words]Brenda WalkerDec 28, 2004 23:4919196
The danger of any fundamentalist faith today [318 words]Andria SpindelDec 28, 2004 23:1219195
A big difference looking back in retrospect [187 words]Joe MittelmanDec 28, 2004 22:2019193
Defintional challenge [107 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
BujevacDec 28, 2004 22:1019192
Internment Was Warrented Then and Surveillance is Necessary Now! [61 words]Dr. Phil CorsonDec 28, 2004 21:3519191
History can teach so let it [160 words]Kathryn McguireApr 25, 2007 16:4119191
But was it truly necessary? [248 words]Peter J. HerzDec 28, 2004 20:2819190
In War, Hard Facts Must Trump Ignorant Sloganeering [382 words]Patrick L. MooreDec 28, 2004 19:5919189
Start with potential immigrants [129 words]PatDec 28, 2004 19:4019188
Thank You, Voices of Reason [235 words]TimDec 28, 2004 19:0319187
Selecting the bad guys [70 words]JimDec 28, 2004 19:0319186
Irrefutable logic once again! [75 words]Leo H. GawroniakDec 28, 2004 18:0819185
Unacceptable [94 words]Philip SchlesingerDec 28, 2004 17:4119184
Unarguable premise is arguable [45 words]Lawrence GoldbergDec 28, 2004 17:2719183
Japanese Internment is Racially Motivated Unless... [116 words]Stanley L. AlekmanDec 28, 2004 17:0719181
WWII & beyond:U.S. at risk [229 words]Marcos BerensteinDec 28, 2004 16:4219180
The more people follow TV news... [101 words]Tom TimmonsDec 28, 2004 16:2219178
Manipulated by the Left [151 words]JohnDec 28, 2004 15:0819175
This WWII vet agrees [27 words]Sol KatzDec 28, 2004 14:2619173
1Japanese American Heros [112 words]Robert AbramsDec 28, 2004 14:2119172
1Name calling [77 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Alvin ZiontzDec 28, 2004 13:4119171
I totally disagree [185 words]Tzvi TamariDec 28, 2004 13:2719170
2A defense of mass internment? [136 words]Fred BinkleDec 28, 2004 13:0219169
Internment Camps in the Present Day [131 words]Jay LeavittDec 28, 2004 12:4219167
Thank you! Again you've hit just the right note. [257 words]John ClementsDec 28, 2004 11:1119164
National Security [37 words]Donald R. FoxDec 28, 2004 11:1019163
Racial issue? [169 words]Fred LapidesDec 28, 2004 10:5619162
I remember Pearl Harbor vividly... [142 words]Janyce JacobsDec 28, 2004 10:5119161
Guilty until proven innocent? [76 words]BSKDec 28, 2004 10:4219160
What about the rest of the Axis? [11 words]Sid PollackDec 28, 2004 10:3919159
PROFILING: where is the limit? [52 words]Ivor LissDec 28, 2004 10:1419157
My knee-jerk reaction [172 words]Burt DeFrenDec 28, 2004 10:0519156
2Who's Next? [173 words]Stephen BermanDec 28, 2004 09:5419155
Correct [166 words]Menahem DunskyDec 28, 2004 09:4819154
1Malkin's Hypocrisy [237 words]Dennis MiddlebrooksDec 28, 2004 09:2319153
Abraham [149 words]donvanMay 30, 2007 16:2319153
1No sympathies for fundamentalist Muslims [58 words]A. BahrupDec 28, 2004 09:1819152
2Profiling v internment [62 words]Mike WevrickDec 28, 2004 09:1019151
War in PC Times [68 words]Elizabeth Weber LevyDec 28, 2004 08:5619150
Why the Japanese Internment Still Matters [228 words]AndyDec 28, 2004 08:5319149
Beautifully stated [41 words]Dean KavourasDec 28, 2004 08:5019148
Interment [61 words]Harden ErvinDec 28, 2004 08:1219146

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)