69 million page views

Translations of this item:

en

Reader comments (113) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
The Gaza pullout [131 words]asafNov 21, 2005 14:4328654
Regarding Ariels Sharon's Folly [505 words]GabrielleAug 14, 2005 08:5224632
re Ariel Sharons Folly [24 words]GabrielleJun 23, 2008 11:3624632
If Israel did not exist would the world be a safer place? [78 words]sharronAug 13, 2005 13:0824619
The real issue [231 words]ScottAug 8, 2005 02:3824418
Is Sharon Still the Sly Old Israeli Warrior With A Motive To His Madness [140 words]Arnold WolfAug 3, 2005 18:1524307
wonder [128 words]Brian FosterJul 31, 2005 14:0324156
The experiment of the creation of Israel has FAILED [63 words]Ali AdawiyaJul 28, 2005 16:1723963
Sharon is for the military strategy "the pullout" [113 words]Albert BelloJul 22, 2005 17:2823705
EXCELLENT ARTICLE AND BRILLIANT INSIGHT by Daniel Pipes [23 words]Z. WrotzlovskyJul 20, 2005 15:0023652
Well written! [49 words]Michael TamblerJul 19, 2005 21:5223619
Democracy? Peace? [189 words]Bella KaltmanJul 19, 2005 21:3323617
suicide, schmuicide [39 words]rafael ben davidJul 19, 2005 15:1023590
Long term vision and planning needed for long term peace [228 words]Steve SilverMay 27, 2005 23:5022455
The Gaza Pull-out [21 words]Pete GibsonMay 23, 2005 02:0422330
Responce to B. Bix [67 words]J. PennApr 25, 2005 13:2021799
On the forcible removal of citizens from their lawful homes [107 words]B. BixApr 18, 2005 18:5921712
1Really lawful? [78 words]Egypt SteveApr 17, 2005 20:0221700
Precedent [168 words]DanApr 15, 2005 12:3621680
The real folly-- settlement without annexation [108 words]Kalman NeumanApr 14, 2005 00:1821649
Removing Gaza residents from their homes [89 words]J. SheffApr 13, 2005 22:5621647
Gaza plan has strengthened Israel's position [419 words]Dan Harder, editor of Danish website Israel-Online.dkApr 13, 2005 19:5421644
Protective Measures [32 words]Casey O'ConnorApr 13, 2005 17:0521640
1Israel's democracy [320 words]Lisette MuradApr 13, 2005 08:2821615
There is a precedent. [121 words]Zev SafferApr 13, 2005 04:0021606
Sharon's folly - on balance, no [547 words]S.BrockwellApr 12, 2005 22:5721598
Skillful engineering of minds [120 words]Mordechai KramerApr 12, 2005 16:4621583
Muslims in Indian subcontinent in 1947 [327 words]Berjees TaajApr 12, 2005 10:5121566
wrong things [165 words]saraMay 11, 2011 12:5021566
Hong Kong and Macau [45 words]Robert MooneyApr 12, 2005 02:2621550
The Ultimate "Fighting Jew" [178 words]Dave M. O'NeillApr 12, 2005 01:3921547
Sharon's move [123 words]jack adamsApr 12, 2005 00:0821545
A golden opportunity! [88 words]Les CherowApr 11, 2005 23:1621542
India and Muslims [280 words]VijayApr 11, 2005 17:5321524
Response to Octavio Johanson's submission [162 words]Vijaykumar ChalasaniApr 11, 2005 16:3421518
Et l'Algérie alors? Don't forget Algeria 1962 [74 words]Georges CLEMENTApr 11, 2005 07:4821511
Hong Kong [131 words]Brian AllenApr 11, 2005 04:3721510
The deal's done - now what [43 words]RafiApr 10, 2005 21:1021509
Response to Eliyezer Ben Ari's "Eminent Domain" comment [74 words]Jim AndersonApr 9, 2005 12:3821497
Good Leadership implies change [173 words]Ross GordonApr 9, 2005 09:1521495
Maginot sindrome [134 words]KantorApr 8, 2005 18:3621490
Morally right [121 words]John HalloffApr 8, 2005 11:5721483
Israeli Tactics [70 words]Rob JamesApr 8, 2005 09:2821482
Painful decisions [31 words]Jaime EisenApr 8, 2005 00:0221480
Sharon is correct, partly [119 words]Walter ManchurApr 7, 2005 17:2521474
Gaza, the new Sudetenland [55 words]JorgenApr 7, 2005 16:1121471
Disengagement [91 words]Yo MenasheApr 7, 2005 13:5521469
With Israelis it is "withdrawal", with Palestinians, it is "expulsion" [114 words]IgnacioApr 7, 2005 07:1621463
Challenge to the reader [103 words]Lauren LokApr 7, 2005 06:5821462
Gush Katif [87 words]Rachel BotbolApr 7, 2005 02:4621459
A follow-up article would be welcome [29 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
MarthaApr 7, 2005 01:5921458
Sharon has gone too far!! [299 words]Linda GoslinApr 6, 2005 22:2521456
Sharon's Folly fails US? [187 words]DebApr 6, 2005 22:0921455
RE: Dr. Pipes' response to the comment, "A Disaster In The Making" [89 words]YonasonApr 6, 2005 21:4421454
"Eminent Domain" clause does not fly! [247 words]Eliyezer Ben AriApr 6, 2005 16:1121450
Sharon is only the leader [36 words]John AuldApr 6, 2005 14:3421447
Sharon's forceful relocation of Israelis [138 words]Howard G MorganApr 6, 2005 13:2721446
Under what circumstances [154 words]IvanApr 6, 2005 13:2621445
Sharon's Folies [76 words]Tom RocklandApr 6, 2005 12:4821444
Give him (PM Sharon) a break! [298 words]Robert B. ArbetmanApr 6, 2005 12:4621443
Not Folly, but rather a rare opportunity [100 words]Chris ChrismanApr 6, 2005 11:5821441
Israel/US policy [19 words]kim segarApr 6, 2005 11:4021440
Sharon's Folly [45 words]Berton ZaslowApr 6, 2005 11:1521439
SHARON -- STRATEGIST AND SEER [79 words]Graham RaelbrookApr 6, 2005 10:4821438
One minor quibble [272 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
J. LichtyApr 6, 2005 10:0321437
Accepting the Challenge [21 words]Matthew DewarApr 6, 2005 09:5121436
Ariel Sharon's Folly [90 words]Menahem DunskyApr 6, 2005 09:1721435
Perhaps there is an upside [307 words]Kenneth S. BesigApr 6, 2005 08:5721434
Relative calm of 2001-03? [183 words]Stephen E. ConnorApr 6, 2005 08:2121433
Possibly there is a "method behind folly" [105 words]Srini VaradarajanApr 6, 2005 08:1721432
Who's behind Sharon's behavior? [245 words]Marcos BerensteinApr 6, 2005 07:5621430
Thank you [191 words]Pircha LottnerApr 6, 2005 06:3021429
Why stay with no water? [178 words]AndyApr 6, 2005 05:3321427
I disagree with your stand on the Gaza Pullout also [138 words]Abbie ApplesteinApr 6, 2005 03:2721425
"...to take private real estate for public use." But for whose "public," ours or theirs? [427 words]YonasonApr 6, 2005 03:0821424
FOURTH GENEVA CONVENTION GOVERNS [80 words]BobJan 27, 2006 15:5921424
As For International Law, I Believe You Are Correct, Bob, And... [44 words]orange yonasonJun 7, 2009 23:1321424
Sharon's Folly [25 words]Steven FishbeinApr 6, 2005 02:0621422
Sharon's and Bush's [89 words]Alain Jean-MairetApr 6, 2005 01:3021420
1Male Adumim [175 words]Moshe MoserApr 6, 2005 01:1221419
You are blaming the wrong party [284 words]Joseph MamelakApr 6, 2005 00:2421417
Untenable Gaza [86 words]Allen Newman, Montreal, CanadaApr 5, 2005 23:4721416
Gaza [156 words]Nora AmraniApr 5, 2005 22:3221413
Sharon and the settlements [129 words]Nora AmraniApr 5, 2005 22:2221412
A Disaster In The Making [89 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Doris J. SnyderApr 5, 2005 21:4021411
The Gaza Pull-out [161 words]MartinApr 5, 2005 21:3321410
Folly [87 words]Paul RinderleApr 5, 2005 20:4421408
Ariel Sharon Has A Past [167 words]YonasonApr 5, 2005 20:1921406
No Folly Then, No Folly Now [184 words]Saul RapkinApr 5, 2005 20:0821403
Forgetting something... [133 words]JosephApr 5, 2005 19:5921402
Another point [351 words]Yuri GuriApr 5, 2005 19:4921401
A disaster called Sharon [102 words]Batya daganApr 5, 2005 19:4021399
Gaza withdrawal [72 words]Bruce BoymanApr 5, 2005 19:3921398
Sharon the Wise [206 words]Dan WeilApr 5, 2005 19:2921396
Removal of settlers from territories [29 words]Karen EbleApr 5, 2005 19:2521395
Governments removing residents.... [24 words]Steve SwajaApr 5, 2005 19:1521394
Let's be realistic [52 words]Neila Charchour HachichaApr 5, 2005 18:5621393
Totally Disagree on Gaza [192 words]Robert SavetApr 5, 2005 18:5421392
American Indians [109 words]Ellyn L WoodApr 5, 2005 18:4021391
Exactly Right [165 words]Jonathan KeilerApr 5, 2005 18:3121390
rebuttal on Ariel Sharon article [296 words]Leo CharendoffApr 5, 2005 18:0921389
Israel's folly? [150 words]Melvin A. FechterApr 5, 2005 18:0621388
Sharon's Decision to Evacuate from Gaza [193 words]Jerrold KatzApr 5, 2005 17:5521387
Democracies seizing land isn't unprecedented... [110 words]Laurence SchreiberApr 5, 2005 17:2521386
My attempt to answer the challenge [249 words]Octavio JohansonApr 5, 2005 17:0621385
NOT SHARON'S FOLLY..IT'S THE PA BEING SQUEEZED [300 words]Martin SchwartzApr 5, 2005 16:4921383
The Wall [131 words]Marci MaysApr 5, 2005 16:2921382
Shades of gray [47 words]Herb JacobsonApr 5, 2005 16:2921381
Legal issues [61 words]Sigmund SilberApr 5, 2005 16:1421380
Democracies that legally and forcibly remove people from their houses [131 words]Kevin HealdApr 5, 2005 16:0421378
Forced removal in a democracy [158 words]jack adamsApr 5, 2005 15:5721377
a soldiers view [38 words]bernard j finestoneApr 5, 2005 14:5721373
I accept your challenge to the reader [29 words]Joshua BrookApr 5, 2005 14:4721371

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)