69 million page views

Iran is not a homgeneous society

Reader comment on item: Deterring Tehran

Submitted by H. Yazdi (United States), May 10, 2006 at 23:19

Contrary to common belief, Iran is not a homogeneous society. Only 60% on Iranian are Persians. The rest is comprised of Turks, Kurds, Arabs, Baluch ,Turkamens and a few others who have very little in common with the Persian population in the center. Even whithin the persian commiunity there are several ethnic group with their own costoms and traditions.

I believe that aside from sanctions which by itself could bring Iran's fragile economy to its knees, one should entertain the idea of fomenting insubordination among the restive and repressed commiunities. Let's not forget that in the last presidential elections in Iran, only 20% of the electorate participated in the election. Of those who participated, the great majority of them were the government and security workers and their family. By fomenting unrest in provices, we can keep the central government so occupied that won't have time or energy to engage in international mischeif.

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (188) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Deterring Tehran [197 words]DebbieJul 13, 2008 16:39135001
Brazil, helping Iran to advance terrorists causes- just "business? Hello White House !!! Hello !!!! [436 words]Ynna-tchkahJun 6, 2007 15:0896272
Why bother?? [191 words]fajensenMay 24, 2006 12:0346296
Rice and Kissinger [329 words]HarrakMay 21, 2006 13:2646078
A good reason why they won't strike Iran [65 words]worlokMay 16, 2006 13:4445724
good article [145 words]HarrakMay 16, 2006 23:5645724
There are certainly 2 things which are worse [236 words]Jon-a brit in EurolandMay 15, 2006 09:4945644
dreams dreams.. [19 words]HarrakMay 15, 2006 17:3045644
Harrak! [378 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanMay 16, 2006 17:5845644
Agree and disagree [208 words]SullyMay 17, 2006 10:1645644
Stop kidding yourself Harrak [189 words]FrankSep 3, 2006 10:1145644
FATWA [171 words]DONVANMay 15, 2006 09:0345641
NO CHOICE [101 words]JOHN MANITTAMay 14, 2006 22:1145610
The time is not ripe and we are not morally prepared to take on Iran now [240 words]SullyMay 14, 2006 01:3345545
Israel must lead the game [311 words]Germain LucasMay 12, 2006 12:1545417
Going in wrong direction [158 words]FaisalMay 13, 2006 03:3645417
it's all blah, blah, blah [50 words]jfbMay 13, 2006 15:0445417
RE: Blackspeare--Confederation in Israel/Palestine [178 words]HarrakMay 11, 2006 18:4045368
deterring Iran [106 words]frank keefeMay 11, 2006 13:0945342
No Stomach [63 words]LDCMay 11, 2006 17:0445342
Couldn't agree more [143 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanMay 11, 2006 19:1045342
US talking stick giving carots..a new Important Fatwa [260 words]HarrakMay 11, 2006 11:0345339
Thank you [36 words]LDCMay 11, 2006 17:2245339
Harraksment--Sticks and Stones Can't Break Pipes Digital Bones [163 words]JoeMay 11, 2006 18:0545339
Harrak Full of "it" [106 words]Funk Soul BruvhaMay 11, 2006 23:3645339
answering LDC and JOE [346 words]HarrakMay 13, 2006 11:5145339
Only Option: Attack Iran when you can [543 words]true believerMay 11, 2006 11:0145338
"true believer" tells truth [124 words]LDCMay 11, 2006 16:5845338
Understand, then act [355 words]DavidMay 11, 2006 17:1745338
... It Needs To Be Said [54 words]Mark RothMay 11, 2006 09:3145335
Politically Incorrect [225 words]LDCMay 11, 2006 22:3645335
A nuclear South Africa? [83 words]AriMay 11, 2006 06:4845330
Iran is not a homgeneous society [152 words]H. YazdiMay 10, 2006 23:1945323
Iran is not a homgeneous society!! [115 words]HarrakMay 11, 2006 18:5445323
Absolutely correct -- Foment UNREST [62 words]J.S.May 12, 2006 16:5845323
Response to Mr. Harrak [123 words]H. YazdiMay 14, 2006 23:4245323
Solution! [245 words]HarrakMay 15, 2006 10:2645323
Response to Mr. Harrak [142 words]H. YazdiMay 16, 2006 00:3845323
Reply 2 for Mr Yazdi [164 words]HarrakMay 16, 2006 17:0245323
deterring teheran [127 words]robert fusfeldMay 10, 2006 22:4945321
How to deter Iran [59 words]Gordon E. AntenbringMay 10, 2006 22:2445320
reality [326 words]garyMay 10, 2006 19:5745314
How Can We Build A Concensus at the UN Security Council? [126 words]Arthur MMay 10, 2006 19:4145313
The best way to build concensus at the UN [216 words]SullyMay 14, 2006 01:5745313
The gravity of it all is heavy no matter what. [436 words]renchMay 10, 2006 17:2845302
Why not a little Shiite vs Sunni War?? [62 words]J.S.May 10, 2006 17:0945300
Shiite -Sunnite War Impossible!! [29 words]HarrakMay 11, 2006 19:0145300
More Harraknophobia - 'Shiite -Sunnite War Impossible!!' he says [60 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanMay 16, 2006 17:3845300
The Shiite and Sunni are not the same as the Cathor and Prontant sects in Europe. [77 words]CharlesBHoffMay 16, 2006 22:4245300
In English, please! [147 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanMay 17, 2006 18:4645300
It is unbecoming of Dr Pipes [214 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Yuval Brandstetter MDMay 10, 2006 16:5445297
I did not overlook. [122 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDMay 20, 2006 15:1045297
Two ways to stop Iran [135 words]Irving WeisdorfMay 10, 2006 16:2545292
A 3rd Way [54 words]LDCMay 11, 2006 16:4245292
Wishful Thinking [122 words]John DoeMay 10, 2006 15:5345288
Blame the Messenger [98 words]BlackspeareMay 10, 2006 15:0145281
How about the messengers of the Confederation of World Jewish Immigrants? [127 words]HarrakMay 10, 2006 17:0045281
Very Old News, Harrak [55 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanMay 11, 2006 16:5545281
Valuable piece from Jihad Watch [192 words]HarrakMay 10, 2006 11:1845269
Another Possibility [105 words]BlackspeareMay 10, 2006 16:4645269
Harrak ridicules USA [186 words]InfidelMay 11, 2006 13:3145269
Barking Harrak [259 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanMay 11, 2006 16:2445269
Infidel [150 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanMay 11, 2006 17:0345269
Don't fool yourself harrak [188 words]Richard Lion heartMay 11, 2006 18:5245269
Forget about Harrak [135 words]Octavio JohansonMay 12, 2006 02:3845269
harrak [35 words]true believerMay 12, 2006 05:3445269
Harrak's rant [76 words]VijayMay 12, 2006 05:5645269
excellent and rare question! about the 8 years war [228 words]HarrakMay 13, 2006 12:0845269
Iranian Weaklings [73 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanMay 14, 2006 04:1545269
to Harrak: not such an excellent answer [455 words]true believerMay 15, 2006 06:0845269
true stuff True Believer but! [65 words]HarrakMay 15, 2006 17:1745269
Surprising? Harrak's delusion is a commonplace in the Middle East [356 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanMay 16, 2006 14:1745269
Iraq was not a cakewalk. [85 words]CharlesBHoffMay 16, 2006 23:0245269
Earth to Charles: Come in please! [364 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanMay 17, 2006 19:0545269
Good thinking! [13 words]Frank VoslerMay 10, 2006 10:5845264
Mullah It Over [125 words]KenMay 10, 2006 10:3145257
Reply to "Mullah-ing it over" [146 words]Merry WhitneyMay 12, 2006 02:3145257
Deterring Iran [285 words]Maurice PicowMay 10, 2006 08:2345247
Could this be a prelude to war? [83 words]Peter J. HerzMay 10, 2006 08:2345246
Or, it could be... [7 words]LDCMay 10, 2006 19:2445246
Insane? [118 words]BlackspeareMay 11, 2006 23:0245246
On Fixing Blame [207 words]LDCMay 12, 2006 15:2845246
Fixing Blame [99 words]BlackspeareMay 14, 2006 10:1845246
the ultimate defense [349 words]Yehuda Ben-Asher, MD Efrat, Gush EtzionMay 10, 2006 08:0545243
Israel first !! [52 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Khalid JamalMay 10, 2006 07:0745239
A gun is a gun [30 words]JJMay 17, 2006 09:3345239
A proper first step. [93 words]Charles SmythMay 10, 2006 06:2745236
Let them [136 words]Vic CoffeyMay 10, 2006 05:3145235
procrastinate - on Iran [52 words]johnmacMay 10, 2006 03:3645228
Deterring Tehran? [249 words]Andras BerenyMay 10, 2006 03:3445227
The black future of the Iranian People [114 words]David GoshenMay 10, 2006 03:3045225
Explain Please [12 words]LDCMay 10, 2006 19:2645225
#end of oil not too far off [47 words]David GoshenMay 12, 2006 12:4045225
A Quick Question [18 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
AlexMay 10, 2006 02:5745223
A 4th Option..... [321 words]W. SturmMay 10, 2006 01:0845217
MAD Reinstated [73 words]LDCMay 10, 2006 09:0145217
Tehran can't be deterred [264 words]PatMay 10, 2006 11:3345217
Why should traditional Nuclear Deterrence fail? [191 words]Al WilnerMay 10, 2006 11:3445217
Your 4th Option is Ill-Advised [55 words]Baron MordoMay 10, 2006 12:4545217
What? [75 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanMay 10, 2006 18:2545217
So, Baron... [4 words]LDCMay 12, 2006 15:3145217
Noises instead of communication? [152 words]David W. LincolnMay 10, 2006 00:4845214
So when the British... [25 words]LDCMay 10, 2006 08:5345212
Flauntist? [115 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanMay 10, 2006 18:4045212
flutist is the English word [62 words]Christopher GameMay 10, 2006 21:3545212
AAAAh... [5 words]LDCMay 11, 2006 16:3745212
It's a trap [378 words]Silent BobMay 9, 2006 23:5345211
Not-so-Silent Bob [38 words]LDCMay 10, 2006 08:4445211
Pipes is piping... [181 words]Jascha KesslerMay 9, 2006 23:2045209
The fear in the heart of the West. [173 words]f.shakkiMay 9, 2006 22:3545205
Tiredness, not fear [96 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanMay 11, 2006 21:4145205
Wake Up Infidels! [109 words]BenedictMay 9, 2006 22:2745203
Deterring Tehran [182 words]Donald W. BalesMay 9, 2006 20:4145193
Are the Iranians really fed up? I doubt it. [381 words]PatMay 9, 2006 19:5545189
Israel Oh Israel what are you waiting for? [84 words]Nenette GrunbergMay 9, 2006 19:2145183
Deterrence Requires Force [158 words]yonatan silvermanMay 9, 2006 18:0345173
Forward to "Silent Bob" [20 words]LDCMay 10, 2006 08:4645173
Boycott Iranian products, beginning with their oil! [141 words]Dr RJPMay 9, 2006 17:5745172
Russia has already refused sanctions [108 words]brendaSep 13, 2009 11:2945172
Iran [127 words]John GreenMay 9, 2006 17:4545170
Assignment of Condition: IRAN = CONFUSION [727 words]DavidMay 9, 2006 17:1945165
The heart of the problem is Russia and China [53 words]MattMay 9, 2006 17:1545164
China [101 words]true believerMay 10, 2006 08:0345164
Walmart Boycott [59 words]LDCMay 10, 2006 08:2045164
It's too late [40 words]PatMay 10, 2006 11:4045164
2Stop trading with China [104 words]MattMay 10, 2006 16:0445164
It is the same in Europe [33 words]Octavio JohansonMay 11, 2006 11:5645164
We gave in to Iran long ago [139 words]PatMay 11, 2006 19:2345164
European dilemma [75 words]Octavio JohansonMay 20, 2006 17:0045164
"we" are not pro-muslim!! [80 words]fajensenMay 24, 2006 12:1945164
china is bad news [21 words]samuel welshMar 13, 2011 12:1745164
The only moral way to deal with Iran [102 words]Ralph C Whaley MDMay 9, 2006 17:1445163
Not so simple [356 words]Silent BobMay 11, 2006 21:5545163
Dr Pipes' forgotten option/ Nuclear letter [118 words]HARRAKMay 9, 2006 17:1445162
The Third Option? [299 words]van der LeyMay 9, 2006 17:1345161
Fuuugggedddabouddit !!!!! [562 words]JoeMay 9, 2006 17:1145160
Iran is harder to defeat than former USSR [258 words]HarrakMay 9, 2006 17:5245160
Iran is Israel's Problem [104 words]Jorgen HabermasMay 9, 2006 19:1745160
1, 2, 5 & 6 - OK [5 words]LD CaryMay 9, 2006 21:2045160
This comment makes sense [14 words]William Sumner ScottMay 9, 2006 22:1545160
To Joe [119 words]JeremyMay 9, 2006 22:3245160
Sure, Jorgen [46 words]LDCMay 10, 2006 09:0945160
Really? Big-Talking Iran humiliated by little Mexico! [123 words]Sword of Islam & The Babies of BeslanJun 11, 2006 17:1845160
Iranian Coup [161 words]Paul M. NevilleMay 9, 2006 17:0445158
A Congress of Chamberlain [127 words]L CaryMay 9, 2006 21:3245158
Iran Nukes [242 words]YovenMay 9, 2006 16:5145155
and in addition [207 words]joel novakMay 9, 2006 16:1345144
Why use of nukes make no logical sense [146 words]S. J. JacobsMay 9, 2006 17:3045144
Been There - Done That [37 words]LDCMay 9, 2006 21:3845144
Logic has no place here [70 words]PatMay 10, 2006 11:5645144
It aint gonna happen [175 words]Gamaliel IsaacMay 9, 2006 16:0745141
The Solution [48 words]LD CaryMay 9, 2006 16:2345141
First, build a coalition [29 words]Octavio JohansonMay 9, 2006 16:4945141
Europe's Moment of Truth [61 words]LD CaryMay 9, 2006 21:1545141
LD Cary, you have been unfair to Italy [150 words]Octavio JohansonMay 10, 2006 04:5245141
OK, maybe Italy [90 words]LDCMay 10, 2006 19:2345141
Germany and France [51 words]Octavio JohansonMay 12, 2006 02:2845141
Yes [74 words]John RMay 9, 2006 15:3845136
Why Not Korea? [70 words]LD CaryMay 9, 2006 16:3045136
Sometimes deterrence really deters [380 words]Kenneth S. BesigMay 9, 2006 15:3745135
ISLAMIC NUKES [255 words]DONVANMay 9, 2006 15:3445134
Iran [34 words]StuMay 10, 2006 01:4645134
IRAN [169 words]DONVANMay 10, 2006 15:5945134
Iran can not be trusted to keep its word. [9 words]true believerMay 11, 2006 11:2245134
fully agree donvan [21 words]fedupMay 13, 2006 02:1145134
Whistling Past the Graveyard [154 words]L D CaryMay 9, 2006 15:2945133
attack to win and win [267 words]Carmen Waggoner, Ph.D.May 9, 2006 15:2645131
Me 2 [15 words]Dr. Lee D. CaryMay 9, 2006 16:0545131
Is non-violence hopeless [59 words]William Sumner Scott, J.D.May 9, 2006 16:3645131
No Will [81 words]LD CaryMay 9, 2006 21:1045131
Another Suggestion [68 words]Jonathan UsherMay 9, 2006 15:2245130
Why Would They Care? [10 words]LD CaryMay 9, 2006 16:0645130
Iran Third Option [441 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Paul Lawrence RoseMay 9, 2006 15:2045129
Wish I had read... [11 words]LD CaryMay 9, 2006 16:0845129
Cold war, deterrence and Iran (response to Mr Pipes view) [87 words]AnubhavMay 17, 2006 08:1745129
Iran's leaders may be insane, and probably are by some definitions but. . [154 words]SullyMay 19, 2006 02:1145129
4th Option: 'Use it or lose it' [149 words]TylerMay 26, 2006 02:3645129
About the "international" community... [281 words]J.S.May 9, 2006 14:5145123
Serves You Right... [25 words]LDCMay 9, 2006 21:4445123
Deterring Tehran [271 words]Dan RusenMay 9, 2006 14:4045121
Who does Iran fear? [83 words]William Sumner Scott, J.D.May 9, 2006 14:2745120
Answer: China [70 words]LD CaryMay 9, 2006 16:1445120
To prevent Iranian Nukes [21 words]Vance A. BaileyMay 9, 2006 13:5245117
Wrong Generation [38 words]LD CaryMay 9, 2006 16:1845117
Persuasion via the mailed fist [140 words]Robert H. Tyrka Sr.May 9, 2006 13:4745116
Thank You Robert [7 words]LD CaryMay 9, 2006 16:2045116
America is not that superpower anymore. [96 words]CharlesBHoffMay 17, 2006 20:1045116
There may be nothing to bomb. [38 words]Graham Rael-BrookMay 9, 2006 13:3545114

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)