3 readers online now  |  69 million page views
Join Daniel Pipes' trip to Dubai & Abu Dhabi, Nov. 4-11. Click HERE for details.

Who was Jesus

Reader comment on item: Who was the Prophet Muhammad?
in response to reader comment: WHO IS JESUS & WHAT WAS HIS GOSPEL

Submitted by Geoff (Russia), May 30, 2010 at 10:57

You speak eloquently but do not understand of what you speak. Mohammad having deemed Jesus as the Messiah has given proof to the truth that he was the eternal son of the Living God. Only through the Lamb of God can you achieve salvation. You may worship as you wish, believe in what you want and follow any religion that you want. That is your right given by God. Your choice seals your relationship with him. He who does good and harms no one will be seen as a servant of God. He who acts in the name of God to do violence perverts the word of God given to Man from Noah to Moses to Jesus.

The Koran states that the Torah and the Gospels are words from God, and as such must be understood, read, and taken into the heart. The Koran has 5 pillars of faith that contradict that which we know must be true. But we do not know who wrote the Koran, because Mohammad did not.

1) That Ishmael was offered for sacrifice at Mt Moriah, not Issac. This can be proven simple by reading the Bible. Clearly there was no enmity between Issac and his half brother Ishmael, clearly God told Abraham as he offered his only son (son from his wife, who was a Shemite, not a Hamite) said that he would make his progeny a Holy Nation. Moses was a Levite, of the house of Israel, son of Issac, not the Son of Ishmael.

2) The Christ did not say that he was the Son of God. This he clearly spoke to the Sanhedrin at his trial before Caiphus. This he did because he was the Son of the living God, sent to us to cleanse our sins, so that he who believed in him would receive everlasting life, which is a pure relationship with God.

3) That Christ was not Crucified. This is a comment and concept that can easily be traced to Coptic text writte in the 2nd century AD. Even the Talmud states that Christ was "hung on a tree" Clearly he was Crucified. To state otherwise is beyond being false.

4) That Christ did not rise from the Dead (because he did not Die). Of course for Christians this is the basis of our Faith and cannot be proven. It is an act of Faith based on the purity of the life of Christ and the lives of his 11 Disciples. It was that faith that gave comfort to all those who dies cruely at the hands of others only for their faith up to the time when Rome chained the Faith of God to man's earthly goals.

5) The Jesus prophesied that Mohammad would come. The prophesy of Christ was clearly...Clearly speaking of the coming of the Holy Spirit, the word of God who would come and enter the hearts of the 11 Disciples to give them strength and comfort in their hour of great need and distress. It was after the Pentecost that these men, simple and humble as they were embarked on the most unique and profound journey. They spread the word of God, through the life and example of Christ to all the known world in peace, without violence, and without threat. They all dies horrible and painful deaths while spreading that faith. Only John, the beloved Disciple lived out his life to spread the word of God in peace, wile taking care of Mary. His Gospel speaks of the divinity of Christ as the Word, and the Word was with God from the Beginning.

Yes my friend, you may believe what you wish and worship as you want. God be with you. I pray that he will reveal to you the true words and heart of our Savior, Jesus of Nazareth who died to forgive our sins.

God is Great! God be with you always!


Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submitting....

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (167) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Just want to say Hi! [13 words]Thanks for sharing your thoughts on Islam Who was the Prophet Muhammad?. RegardsMar 3, 2015 15:53222076
I am the new one [53 words]Right here is the perfect website for anyone who wants to understand this topic. You realize a whole lot its almost hard to argue with you (not that I really would want to…HaHa). You certainly put a fresh spin on a subject which has been written about forMar 3, 2015 13:48222070
Not True - unbroken link chain after the death of Muhammad [139 words]Guardian of DeenJun 28, 2013 08:49207383
Reading my thoughts [7 words]JuniorDec 3, 2012 01:48201116
6The Great Muhammad [64 words]John AbrahamJun 8, 2012 04:31196119
1truth [23 words]khalidDec 6, 2012 11:01196119
1US policy towards Mohammadism [61 words]SHANKAR SHARANFeb 7, 2012 08:02193166
1Mohammed [8 words]David AmogratinsiaNov 30, 2011 14:00191345
1A pinch of salt required to accept revisionist views [258 words]B.N.GururajFeb 21, 2011 00:05182848
11Is allah a real God? [161 words]SaheedJul 30, 2010 09:26176166
1God help us all we are on a sinking ship... [455 words]salamOct 1, 2010 18:22176166
8Have you actually read the Koran? [135 words]Peter HallFeb 6, 2012 20:56176166
jah jah [9 words]kyleApr 30, 2012 20:03176166
About this Blog article [52 words]Micheal DorsninJul 26, 2010 15:12176061
2comparison between holy quraan and holy bible recent copies [121 words]mohamad safarFeb 21, 2010 17:33169258
7Our dear Mohamad safar al-falyasoof al-kabeer [796 words]dhimmi no moreFeb 23, 2010 19:05169258
1the two books [109 words]HarryJun 4, 2010 04:28169258
2no change in islam [50 words]kamalFeb 6, 2010 14:46168553
4No change in Islam [90 words]R. AaronOct 22, 2010 01:33168553
9Did Prophet Mohammad Exist ? [141 words]philipOct 20, 2009 11:23163297
6Did Muhammad exist? reply to philip [241 words]Nozrul HussainJan 2, 2010 12:27163297
one question [121 words]noorOct 13, 2008 18:42140107
lack of knowledge about islam [67 words]jeeyaNov 14, 2008 04:02140107
for my muslim people [37 words]sameerDec 6, 2008 12:34140107
3Islam came [62 words]WhekSep 2, 2009 10:17140107
3Which Muslim ruler invaded Indonesia and converted the biggest muslim nation? [342 words]Baki, BirminghamFeb 23, 2008 10:22120858
14Which Muslim ruler invaded Indonesia and converted the biggest muslim nation? [226 words]EmmaMay 28, 2008 12:17120858
Comments on Emma's comment [46 words]Md. Abdullahel BAKIMay 29, 2008 03:50120858
5Which Muslim ruler invaded Indonesia and converted the biggest muslim nation? [33 words]EmmaJun 12, 2008 07:57120858
8Mass murderers of History [660 words]FaisalAug 12, 2008 06:04120858
Emma, Please read Mr. Faisal Comment made on August 12,2008 [37 words]BAKIAug 14, 2008 04:24120858
Thanks very much for offering good statistics [45 words]BakiAug 14, 2008 04:31120858
5But Jesus doesn't kill any one. [78 words]John GodfreyOct 24, 2008 08:17120858
RE: Jesus doesnt kill any one [116 words]shabir khanDec 2, 2008 11:59120858
1Jesus doesnt kill anyone [83 words]John GodfreyDec 3, 2008 12:50120858
Appraisal [17 words]AhmedJan 8, 2009 16:27120858
3Faisal's post was brilliant [388 words]gavinFeb 6, 2009 16:55120858
1Islam spread to Indonesia by business activities [70 words]bary soetoroMar 1, 2009 01:57120858
Faisal' Comments were Brilliant, but Gavin's Comments were ever better [173 words]FaisalMar 29, 2009 12:47120858
4Islam is Violence [131 words]M HandanSep 2, 2009 11:02120858
1Wars and Religion [77 words]Nozrul HussainJan 2, 2010 12:36120858
1Some factual errors @ mass murders in history [158 words]ZZZJan 17, 2010 18:57120858
Islam is not violence [77 words]leishaApr 28, 2010 20:53120858
2Islam is Violence [66 words]Ron MunroMay 20, 2010 04:11120858
Not so correct [84 words]SomeoneSep 23, 2010 09:00120858
1Islam had nothing to do with World War I? Really? [114 words]R. AaronOct 8, 2010 22:35120858
1stop your bickering [27 words]asmaOct 17, 2010 10:35120858
1RE: christian genocide in yugoslavia and japan [266 words]alloutofgumOct 20, 2010 02:09120858
Crazy is not limited to any group of people [102 words]cecilia HamiltonMar 3, 2011 23:29120858
1Crazies are different from Islamic Terrorists [424 words]GopiMar 6, 2011 00:15120858
TRUE MOSLIMS [341 words]VIRENDERMay 21, 2011 04:47120858
5ISLAM IS NOT BASED ON PEACE BUT JEALOUSY TO CHRISTIANITY JEWS BUDDHISTS AND HINDUS [818 words]HINDU JEWISH CHRISTIAN SOULJul 4, 2011 22:52120858
Response to Bary Soetoros's comment. [124 words]ZeenaFeb 7, 2012 07:42120858
you need to listen to your self [63 words]saraFeb 11, 2012 10:58120858
1Are you ...? [172 words]Peter HallMay 3, 2012 01:25120858
3We need to read the Qu'ran?? [117 words]Peter HallMay 3, 2012 01:35120858
1Dont waste other's precious times by writing this kind of Articles [16 words]SuhailAug 23, 2012 05:33120858
Emma is 100% right about Islamists' technique of projection [83 words]PrashantAug 24, 2012 01:17120858
Islam came into existance with Hazarat Adam As [69 words]nabeelJan 10, 2014 07:37120858
Sunni and Shia [18 words]simonJan 8, 2015 04:14120858
General [28 words]SwadeshSep 25, 2015 16:49120858
Who is Mohammed [284 words]Geoffrey B SlaterOct 7, 2007 00:54110593
Fessenden Books [24 words]Patrick LyonsOct 18, 2007 17:46110593
Deluged Civilization of the Caucasus [62 words]Geoffrey B SlaterOct 18, 2007 21:21110593
Fessenden Maps [80 words]P. LyonsOct 20, 2007 22:13110593
1WHO IS JESUS & WHAT WAS HIS GOSPEL [2961 words]FaisalAug 14, 2008 15:26110593
1Just a question for Faizel [85 words]Renji Daniel DavidFeb 16, 2009 17:56110593
In response to Slater [107 words]SAMEERJul 8, 2009 12:53110593
1Who was Jesus [652 words]GeoffMay 30, 2010 10:57110593
Response to Faisal rossey comments [109 words]IfrahimApr 18, 2011 18:14110593
A Reply to Ifrahim by Faisal [797 words]faisalMay 4, 2011 09:46110593
Respose to Faisal by Ifrahim [392 words]IfrahimMay 6, 2011 15:12110593
A reply to Mr. Ifrahim [1411 words]FaisalMay 14, 2011 11:34110593
3Another victim of Arabian imperialism and ayat al-jizya [1124 words]dhimmi no moreMay 15, 2011 06:54110593
A reply to Faisal by Ifrahim [412 words]ifrahimMay 26, 2011 13:16110593
1You lost me? [83 words]Peter HallMay 3, 2012 02:00110593
1a Quick Question [108 words]Peter HallMay 3, 2012 02:12110593
blessing [8 words]zamamAug 13, 2012 13:59110593
unbroken chain of Hadith collectors [210 words]Guardian of DeenJun 29, 2013 13:26110593
A very interesting point of view. [100 words]YayaJan 26, 2007 08:1774586
ONE RELIGION , FROM THE TIME OF ADAM [154 words]LARAFeb 25, 2007 11:1174586
3Islam did not spread by the sword? [216 words]Jaisingh ThakurJul 11, 2007 03:1574586
who cares what RELIGION [104 words]asimAug 29, 2007 17:5774586
controversy in bible [62 words]rahmanFeb 23, 2009 01:4074586
1Reply to Rahman [121 words]Renji Daniel DaviMar 2, 2009 17:5174586
a real blow to official history [182 words]GulMar 13, 2010 12:1674586
1who cares what religion [67 words]alfredJul 24, 2010 02:2274586
Non muslims converted to Islam forcefully ??? [299 words]naheedJan 19, 2007 16:2373671
45Islam came into being AFTER Hinduism. [175 words]SunilMar 18, 2007 07:0673671
1You're wrong . [474 words]AKHAND-HINDUSTHANMay 3, 2007 06:1573671
8RE: Non muslims converted to Islam forcefully ??? Wake up!!! [266 words]sushilJun 5, 2007 22:4073671
One should not criticise any religion without having the confirmed knowledge of it. [201 words]Parvez AhmedNov 9, 2007 10:5873671
don't speak without knowledge [23 words]TrueMuslimApr 28, 2008 06:1773671
So why is Islam the fastest growing religion? [8 words]--Jul 16, 2008 09:4473671
1Who was Muhammed? [325 words]pJul 22, 2008 17:3473671
as quran says [14 words]tawete, adamSep 16, 2008 06:2273671
3all human beings have a single creator...ALLAH [462 words]shabana anjumNov 30, 2008 05:4773671
itis not fair [21 words]musaDec 9, 2008 11:0473671
in resonse to sushil [326 words]sameerJul 8, 2009 13:1673671
2Islam Image Answer to Sunil India [130 words]Qasim Jan BabarAug 7, 2010 05:2773671
3The truth about Islam [140 words]SunilAug 8, 2010 02:5473671
ISLAM is PEACE: Solution for Humanity [273 words]TabrezFeb 11, 2011 09:5073671
Clarifications on Brother Sunil Comments [238 words]TShaikhFeb 11, 2011 10:2373671
2The solution for Humanity or the problem? [77 words]Peter HallMay 4, 2012 20:3273671
1You must be an example of Muslin education. [168 words]Peter HallMay 4, 2012 20:4373671
ahh [30 words]SpadeJan 22, 2013 10:5873671
Hinduism, Mand Made Gods & Islam [163 words]DanielOct 8, 2013 13:5573671
FYI Must read!!! [348 words]SalMar 7, 2014 16:0973671
True [3 words]RahulMay 5, 2015 04:4673671
Allah [42 words]Munish GuptaJun 15, 2015 13:3573671
Read and Believe [77 words]HumanJul 2, 2015 04:3473671
1the actual truth [147 words]prem sharmaJul 17, 2015 03:0073671
Only one GOD - Nature [25 words]ManuAug 3, 2015 06:1573671
Muhammad is Real. [54 words]Usman SabriApr 19, 2006 16:5243597
On a nightmare [217 words]IanusDec 26, 2005 18:0730590
3Over 100 Million Hindus Killed Under Islam - In India [225 words]RebeccaSep 7, 2006 14:5330590
1Hindu fascism lives on [209 words]V. ramakrishnanSep 24, 2006 05:2930590
4Indian Hindu Genocide Acknowledged by Historians [339 words]RebeccaSep 25, 2006 07:1230590
1Leftists like Ramakrishnan [73 words]Ashish SrivastavaJan 5, 2007 08:0730590
leftist fool is an oxymoron [38 words]V. RamakrishnanJan 7, 2007 06:4630590
2hindu facscism? you gotta be kidding me [399 words]proudpaganFeb 28, 2008 06:3430590
2100 million indians killed by Evil Brittish Christians [59 words]FaisalAug 14, 2008 15:4030590
13Muslims in denial - as to the cruelty of Islamic conquests - 250 million died to bring 1 billion to Islam [272 words]RebeccaAug 18, 2008 08:5530590
Knowledge [43 words]Muhd.AneesMar 11, 2009 03:1530590
1Muslims seek to erase violent history - to show Islam was not spread by the sword !! [334 words]RebeccaMar 12, 2009 07:3530590
80 million hindus diasappeared not killed [36 words]dharminderMar 5, 2010 18:4430590
1Brittish [sic] [103 words]some evil Brittish [sic] personSep 22, 2010 16:0430590
Re: V. Ramakrishnan [53 words]SachinNov 11, 2011 06:4830590
UTTERLY BIASED [26 words]amitJan 5, 2012 03:4930590
To Marc Hill : On an alternative division of sites on Islam [446 words]IanusDec 26, 2005 17:3730584
4Islam NEVER spread by the SWORD. [473 words]assimDec 10, 2005 06:2429734
Dear Assim [112 words]MarjaDec 16, 2005 17:5929734
"Islam NEVER spread by the SWORD"...or the history happened in a better way than the kafirs say... [520 words]IanusDec 26, 2005 18:5429734
Dear Marja [425 words]IanusDec 26, 2005 19:3029734
Kidding ??? [195 words]NewgamersJan 6, 2006 01:0829734
Sword Muslims [51 words]GeoffMar 24, 2006 03:2629734
ASSIM [161 words]DONVANMar 31, 2006 17:0629734
i agree [128 words]mickeyApr 16, 2006 22:5329734
cowards [59 words]normalJun 20, 2006 14:5129734
If Islam was violently spread in indonesia... [15 words]haroon rashid abbasiJul 8, 2006 14:0729734
Islam never spread by the sword [110 words]Muhammad AbdulqaffarSep 15, 2006 14:0829734
Play on Ignorance [872 words]Roger WilliamsDec 2, 2006 17:4829734
dear maria [319 words]sageerDec 22, 2006 02:2629734
1new gamers, true muslims dont drink [267 words]sageerDec 22, 2006 07:2229734
Answers [277 words]naheedJan 19, 2007 16:3829734
READ THEN ARGUE [217 words]LARAFeb 25, 2007 11:3129734
Two verses [82 words]KaiserMar 16, 2007 05:5329734
Point by Point Rebuttal- Islam was spread by sword [864 words]BeststarsignNov 8, 2007 01:5429734
muslims dont drink? [167 words]proudpaganFeb 28, 2008 06:0829734
reply to proudpadgan [289 words]sageerApr 2, 2008 04:5229734
Jesus or Mohammad [199 words]KAROLINE CRAFTAug 24, 2008 09:4029734
Osama in America [366 words]Eye witnessJul 16, 2009 11:3029734
religion of peace ... [70 words]jjjoeApr 2, 2012 11:3829734
This can be considered as a try to find truth [199 words]Muhammad Usman Abdullah MirzaOct 12, 2005 02:0726836
About Syria [100 words]Riva T PhilipApr 13, 2005 05:1921608
I disagree [95 words]UrJan 24, 2005 16:5919835
Holes in Islamic History [198 words]Marc HillJan 10, 2005 19:0619572
3There are too many holes in Islamic History? [487 words]RebeccaJan 10, 2005 08:3319557
1Rebecca [549 words]GulashMay 21, 2007 18:2719557
islamic history [89 words]yakubMar 13, 2008 09:0619557
A scholar [14 words]ypAug 22, 2003 19:3810732
1A reason to believe in the Islamic History [185 words]Muhammad Omer IqbalJun 19, 2003 07:009636
Historical revisionism [189 words]MarkMar 26, 2006 10:229636
2There are at least 2 versions of the Koran [181 words]JasonMar 30, 2006 10:319636
Islam [121 words]HumanJul 31, 2012 12:219636
Nah, that is not true! [30 words]PrashantAug 1, 2012 03:069636
Jesus? [115 words]StephenFeb 24, 2013 17:289636

Comment on this item

Name
Email Address (optional)
Title of Comments
Comments:

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

ADVERTISEMENTS

eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2017 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum. Daniel J. Pipes