69 million page views

To Julie

Reader comment on item: The Travails of Brooklyn's Arabic Academy
in response to reader comment: Muslim School is MUST

Submitted by Ryan (United States), May 26, 2007 at 17:02

According to research by Dr. Ilyas Ba-Yunus, 75% of New Muslim Converts in the US leave Islam within a few years. That would amount to 18,750. Since just as many U.S. born-muslims leave Islam (25,000) as those non-born-muslims who convert (25,000) each year, it's easy to conclude that 18,750 actually leave Islam each year. Now that I've done the math, it seems our future is looking pretty bright. So much for those "expert" journalists and their "scientific studies."

E-mail me in a few years. I'm a therapist.

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (205) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
truth about such events [31 words]haytMar 24, 2011 16:23183583
1well said [2 words]allahNov 19, 2007 07:30114005
Islamic Schools [192 words]WarwickDec 20, 2007 06:49114005
admission [16 words]misbah haroonAug 6, 2012 05:46114005
islamic terror culture schools and acedmic centers [684 words]georgetJul 18, 2007 13:58103956
Militant Islam [92 words]J.KhanMay 8, 2014 13:27103956
Never look inward [66 words]PrashantMay 10, 2014 02:24103956
Nearly simultaneous May-June bomb plots in Britain: from a school system infiltrated by radical Islam? [340 words]James VesceJul 2, 2007 11:52102390
Simple Question- Will students recite pledge of allegiance every morning? [58 words]BrianJun 25, 2007 08:18101001
Good question [61 words]NuraOct 11, 2008 23:38101001
Why Aren't Jewish Leaders Being More Vocal In Their Opposition To This School [42 words]RuvainJun 9, 2007 21:4197158
Travails of Brooklyln's Arabic Academy [312 words]BarbaraJun 4, 2007 19:1696025
islamic schools and islamic culture centers [96 words]georgetJun 4, 2007 15:0495995
To georget: A [68 words]PlatoJun 4, 2007 23:0595995
Several more words from a witness (to Mrs. O'Neill etc.) [784 words]Leonid Kaplun-LeonovJun 1, 2007 16:1795688
Thank you, Leonid [135 words]JeffJun 3, 2007 11:1295688
Be efficient : be primitive. [176 words]Raymond31May 30, 2007 10:1995329
Arabic High School [84 words]FrummerMay 28, 2007 10:4995012
NO PUBLIC FUNDED MADRASSA [257 words]DanMay 31, 2007 15:4795012
Public School [59 words]BeaJun 9, 2007 23:0195012
college kids taught islam in college courses [160 words]DanJun 27, 2007 18:0695012
Islamic School in NYC [197 words]kim segarMay 26, 2007 09:4494645
Will Saudi Arabia , Pakistan , Iran , Syria allow us to build Christian Churches and Jewish Yeshivas ?? [50 words]MapuMay 27, 2007 14:0594645
AMERICANS.... [38 words]Samson BellJun 5, 2007 11:2394645
We already have chuches, Christian Schools and other religions's worship places! [448 words]Muahmmad Tariq DogarJun 22, 2007 01:5494645
1Churches,Gurdawaras, Mandars in Pakistan [223 words]nazarJan 18, 2008 11:4894645
1reply [26 words]NuhNov 26, 2011 05:5094645
War of Words [490 words]M. ToveyMay 25, 2007 20:4094604
INCREDIBLE! [37 words]J. Victor CardooMay 25, 2007 17:0994503
Stop this School of Arab Islamist Propaganda and Hate before its too late ! [57 words]DavidMay 26, 2007 02:0794503
J. Victor Cardoo [31 words]RyanMay 26, 2007 17:4494503
GODLESSNESS [60 words]J. Victor CardooJun 4, 2007 17:0394503
Just words from a witness (to Mrs. O'Neill and other participants) [638 words]Leonid Kaplun-LeonovMay 24, 2007 18:2594293
1From Morrocco to Malaysia , I had the similar experience of Islamism . [242 words]SukhaniMay 26, 2007 02:2194293
Reply to mr. Leonid [119 words]Julie O'NeillMay 29, 2007 14:0094293
question to ms o'neill [26 words]garyMay 29, 2007 19:4294293
1Julie O'Neill are you an Islamist posing as a westerner ?? [137 words]ShaateerMay 30, 2007 01:5494293
more brainwashing for julie [74 words]susanMay 30, 2007 14:2094293
2Susan , Be careful , Imam may give " Death Fatwa " and call for a " Jehad" against you and your country . [164 words]MuriJun 1, 2007 04:5494293
Our dear Julie al-tabligheeia declares that we infidels can also get 70 virgins in heaven and her bogus Arabic [76 words]dihmmi no moreJun 3, 2007 16:5594293
proof for gary [49 words]Julie O'NeillJun 4, 2007 14:2494293
to Shaateer [35 words]Julie O'NeillJun 4, 2007 14:3094293
What proof? [56 words]dhimmi no moreJun 4, 2007 20:0694293
Dah? really? Our dear Julie (sic) and your credibility is on the line! [18 words]dhimmi no moreJun 4, 2007 20:0994293
To Muhammad alias Julie,some news for you! [38 words]MosheJun 6, 2007 10:0294293
give me a break [58 words]garyJun 6, 2007 19:0594293
Agree with Moshe 1000 % ; You are right. [300 words]IndianJun 7, 2007 10:5294293
Muri: yeah, it's soo obvious that muslims are peaceloving...HA! [134 words]tootfairyJul 7, 2007 20:4394293
muslims the most tolerant poeple [64 words]dealisJun 21, 2008 11:0094293
palestinian muslim guy agree with Moshe 10000000 %. [129 words]Israel_ServantFeb 19, 2009 13:0494293
Put Them To The Test [96 words]lindaMay 23, 2007 23:2094131
Islamic School will transfom innocent kids into generation of suicide bombers soon. [106 words]NariMay 26, 2007 02:2794131
Americans Need To Be Shown [119 words]lindaMay 26, 2007 16:0094131
Use the power of live and print media to create awareness about threats of Islam in USA. [245 words]NariMay 27, 2007 03:0794131
Media Is Owned By Islamist-Sympathizers [225 words]lindaMay 28, 2007 13:1394131
We need to stand together and united against Islamism [365 words]MorrisMay 29, 2007 09:3194131
Focus [383 words]lindaMay 29, 2007 19:2294131
to Linda on media [63 words]ASJun 4, 2007 14:4994131
Learn from History [121 words]European MuslimMay 23, 2007 18:0494114
For European (sic) and his bogus command of history [205 words]dhimmi no moreJun 3, 2007 17:2494114
Arab School in Brooklyn [113 words]Barbara PaolucciMay 23, 2007 10:0794070
Arab or Muslim School is nothing but an Islamic Madarassa which will incite murder of innocent Americans. [135 words]MorrisMay 26, 2007 02:0194070
Morris' reply to my post [393 words]BarbaraMay 26, 2007 16:3794070
Nip the problem in the bud [398 words]MorrisMay 27, 2007 02:5894070
to Moris and Barbara, start a signature campaign [36 words]ASJun 4, 2007 15:1094070
start petition online and signature campaign to stop building any Mosque , Madrassa , Islamic Centre , Muslim School in West [33 words]GuruJun 7, 2007 10:5694070
I don't get it [78 words]Anne LiebermanMay 23, 2007 07:2994058
" Private " means Islamic Prayers , Meetings , Fiery sermons and discussion with Tableegh Jamat Imams on ways to Islamise America. [43 words]ThoriMay 26, 2007 02:3294058
Stop destroying your country! [114 words]Leonid Kaplun-Leonov, Russian engineerMay 23, 2007 05:2794052
You are right on the target- 100 % [380 words]YnnatchkahMay 24, 2007 05:0394052
US Immigration Policies Are Destroying The USA [62 words]Domenic PepeMay 24, 2007 12:2294052
Is it too late? [41 words]surjMay 24, 2007 19:5094052
We control the future [69 words]PDMMay 25, 2007 11:0694052
USA is a melting pot but Islamic Immigration will lead to disaster . [139 words]DarmiMay 26, 2007 02:3894052
Islamisation of United States by increasing muslims by immigration , conversion and demographic war. [158 words]RussellMay 26, 2007 02:5294052
Don't be so sure Mr.PDM [48 words]harmanMay 26, 2007 03:0194052
U.S.: Nation of Citizens [143 words]RyanMay 26, 2007 17:3294052
to ryan [247 words]garyMay 30, 2007 16:0694052
ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION [167 words]annaApr 30, 2008 07:0494052
Unsuited for a tax payers funded school [122 words]David W. LincolnMay 23, 2007 01:0194045
Khalil Gibran [33 words]Gary CollierMay 22, 2007 20:1194012
Muslim School is MUST [51 words]Julie O'NeillMay 22, 2007 15:5993992
For our dear julie [117 words]dihmmi no moreMay 22, 2007 20:3993992
Julie O'Neill says kids in USA should learn about ISLAM.. [143 words]Joe Schmoe USAMay 22, 2007 20:4293992
Two Wrongs Don't Make Your View Right. [81 words]RyanMay 22, 2007 21:5293992
Public schools by religion [27 words]BerryMay 23, 2007 09:4893992
"Muslim" is to "school" [265 words]DONVANMay 23, 2007 15:4893992
A madrassa by any other name is still a madrassa!! [112 words]JaladhiMay 23, 2007 22:0293992
9/11 Teaches All We need To Know About Islam [96 words]Domenic PepeMay 24, 2007 12:4793992
Mistakes of the past [67 words]G.VishvasMay 24, 2007 13:3393992
1yes dhimmi [189 words]Julie O'NeillMay 24, 2007 17:0393992
To: Joe Schmoe [70 words]Julie O'NeillMay 24, 2007 17:1593992
To Ryan [74 words]Julie O'NeillMay 24, 2007 17:2193992
wake up. [177 words]surjMay 24, 2007 19:2493992
1To Julie [84 words]RyanMay 25, 2007 02:5393992
good v evil [163 words]surjMay 25, 2007 09:2393992
Islamic expansionism and missionary activity [106 words]MosheMay 25, 2007 10:1293992
Julie O'Neill's misguided fantasies [139 words]Mel LarawayMay 25, 2007 12:5493992
Julie, they taught you sanitized islam at Berkeley [365 words]NaziaMay 25, 2007 19:1693992
For our dear Julie and admit what? [43 words]dihmmi no moreMay 25, 2007 19:4593992
julie......ISLAM, the fastest growing religion in US? ...think again.. [518 words]Joe Schmoe USAMay 26, 2007 02:1893992
First check the content of Islamic Studies ! You will be afraid of Islam ! [67 words]ArthurMay 26, 2007 03:1493992
6Send your childern to Jamia Hafsa Madrassa in Islamabad , Pakistan to learn more about Islam . [53 words]GeorgiMay 26, 2007 03:3393992
Ex- Muslims calls for a ban on Islamic Education in West . [27 words]AjeemMay 26, 2007 03:4593992
Teach the Arabic language not the Islam religion: [56 words]Fred LeeMay 26, 2007 14:3093992
To Julie [87 words]RyanMay 26, 2007 17:0293992
One way ticket to hell !! [82 words]JaladhiMay 26, 2007 17:0993992
Julie, do you know that a Woman needs? four male witnesses to prove a Rape. [313 words]NaziaMay 27, 2007 11:0393992
Islam must be decared a Non Religion for teaching hatred and vilence against Non Muslims. [79 words]N.KhanMay 27, 2007 11:2293992
Julie, The Real Fastest Growing Faith Is The Christian Faith [75 words]AnneMMay 27, 2007 16:1793992
1This is rich.. [120 words]donvanMay 27, 2007 21:0693992
Further Comments on Radical Islam [218 words]MelMay 27, 2007 23:3293992
1Julie , enjoy your islamic fringe benefits [184 words]MohammedMay 28, 2007 02:0193992
1Julie,do you know that in Islam God worships a man? [222 words]Ali KhalafMay 28, 2007 11:1993992
Islamic fringe benefits !! [38 words]JaladhiMay 28, 2007 19:2993992
To Nazia- Another dhimmi [39 words]Julie O'NeillJun 4, 2007 14:4393992
You are NO Mohammed [25 words]Julie O'NeillJun 4, 2007 15:0193992
Jaladhi, you must be kidding! [45 words]MosheJun 5, 2007 14:1593992
hitler too [10 words]garyJun 6, 2007 19:1393992
A Good Instition [14 words]Zarrar HyderJun 7, 2007 01:3093992
NO ISLAM TAUGHT TO MY CHILD [165 words]TeresaJun 21, 2007 01:4593992
Right to Defend [47 words]williamJul 3, 2007 18:0293992
jamia hafsa is not finished in pakistan we will make every pakistni home a jamia hafsa. [115 words]sania khanAug 26, 2007 09:3793992
Bravo [33 words]People with PowerDec 27, 2007 15:1093992
SHAREE'AH YAA SHAHAADAH! [88 words]NidaaSep 20, 2008 13:3393992
you poor americans, from australia [142 words]PeteJun 9, 2009 02:2893992
rights of a woman in islam [48 words]jehad afridiFeb 3, 2012 12:5993992
a MINDSET Problem? [730 words]Ron ThompsonMay 22, 2007 14:2893987
Violence and terror is universal! [351 words]Rodni E. ChaletMay 22, 2007 22:3293987
you speak the truth [244 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDMay 23, 2007 06:5193987
Mr. Chalet's Misguided Views [271 words]Mel LarawayMay 24, 2007 13:3693987
A little sleight-of-hand with Logic and History [674 words]Ron ThompsonMay 24, 2007 17:3393987
The Bat Yeor crowd! [49 words]Rodni E. ChaletMay 25, 2007 12:2493987
here are your replies mr relativism [229 words]susanMay 25, 2007 14:3993987
Mr. Thompson has no problem with the Irish Catholic? [449 words]JeffMay 27, 2007 15:3893987
to rodney e chalet [158 words]garyMay 31, 2007 11:1893987
crusaders all over again [66 words]surjMay 31, 2007 17:2993987
1The immorality of "Public" schools [119 words]Ralph C Whaley MDMay 22, 2007 12:5393985
Immorality of Public Schools [77 words]LoriMay 23, 2007 14:4393985
create awareness among children about Islam by telling them about horrors of Sept 11. [15 words]VanbioMay 26, 2007 15:4693985
Arab institutes schools etc. [438 words]Guy Leven-Torres (Agricola)May 22, 2007 10:3393971
To Guy Leven [36 words]Ynna(tchkah)May 22, 2007 15:5593971
Hoping to be wrong.-To Guy Leven Torres (again) [283 words]Ynna(tchkah)May 22, 2007 17:3693971
Where is the outrage? [215 words]Caesar M.ArevaloMay 22, 2007 23:4493971
To Caesar Arevalo [174 words]Ynna(tchkah)May 23, 2007 20:0293971
Double standards will destroy civilised world. [130 words]BiruMay 26, 2007 15:2593971
Western Universities are becoming Hotbed of Islamism , Its alarming and dangerous for us all [126 words]SaraMay 26, 2007 15:3793971
not new [198 words]surjMay 26, 2007 20:5093971
48Every year 100,000 Hindu & Sikh girls are eloping with muslims by way of rape & blackmail. [497 words]NishaMay 29, 2007 09:5793971
ynna, you have no idea on how russians are "effective" [404 words]susanMay 29, 2007 13:3993971
Thanks Susan. [92 words]Ynna(tchkah)May 30, 2007 01:2793971
Russians can easily crush Islamism but Westerns always oppose them without any reason [123 words]SashaMay 30, 2007 03:0193971
very right. [74 words]surjMay 30, 2007 18:2993971
2to Nisha [41 words]ASJun 4, 2007 14:5493971
to Sara [43 words]ASJun 4, 2007 15:0093971
Sasha... [30 words]Samson BellJun 5, 2007 11:3093971
Sorry Samson Bell, you are daydreaming. [99 words]MosheJun 6, 2007 07:0893971
82Reality of Bajrang Dal , VHP , BJP ?? [335 words]DamodarJun 7, 2007 11:1993971
Israel is 100 % Righteous . We support Israel's War to defend this wonderful nation of great people [101 words]ChampJun 7, 2007 11:2493971
Thanks Champ for your support, but evidently you still need to learn a few facts about Israel. [83 words]MosheJun 8, 2007 04:1393971
1Naivete or stupidity of Hindu Girls?? [266 words]JaladhiJun 8, 2007 13:2893971
If Muslim Mullahs speak in favour of Jehadis ... [146 words]DamodarJun 9, 2007 13:5593971
Israeli Leaders are commiting suicidal mistakes one by one .......... [412 words]ChampJun 10, 2007 04:4193971
Champ, beware of Nazi/Arab propaganda. [113 words]MosheJun 11, 2007 08:3493971
Reply to Yedid Moshe ! [414 words]ChampJun 12, 2007 04:4093971
Ironic [25 words]Salim VasaniJun 28, 2007 17:4493971
1Why you want communities to hate each other [14 words]ImranNov 5, 2007 10:0393971
19The Story of a Sikh Girl Who Was Victimised [3410 words]PRINCESSSIKHFeb 2, 2008 15:1993971
Muslim Fanatism [223 words]AbhishekJun 16, 2008 06:0593971
Narashima avatar is badly depicted [68 words]GuruOct 13, 2008 23:5493971
doesnt make sense [39 words]chetnaDec 10, 2008 13:3693971
Don.t Post like this wrong statement [155 words]ishakJan 19, 2009 07:4993971
The story makes sense [130 words]Hindu From AfghanistanJan 24, 2009 17:2593971
To Nisha [41 words]Hindu RakshakMar 19, 2009 15:1793971
Just STOP ISHAK [130 words]Krishna SantoshMay 10, 2009 01:5793971
girl gone mad and bad against Islam....She is hurting in the SS [92 words]peacefull-MuslimJun 18, 2009 00:4893971
BEWARE OF LOVE JIHAD [45 words]prachiOct 18, 2009 03:3893971
love Jihad [33 words]M.A.SASTRYOct 25, 2009 06:4293971
bhen chod [19 words]ddaNov 13, 2009 15:5993971
muslims who forcingly convert other faith girls. [160 words]abdulDec 3, 2009 12:4693971
regards [36 words]ravikumarFeb 3, 2010 10:4793971
Spread The Issue World Wide [67 words]Mannax SinghMar 18, 2010 05:4293971
please,show denser side not rarer [75 words]yusufFeb 8, 2011 01:3593971
Correction [15 words]booyouMar 24, 2011 08:3893971
its time to take stand against islaam [79 words]deep ranaApr 3, 2011 19:2893971
Muslim men cheating Hindu girls [5 words]ParveennishaAug 21, 2011 09:3793971
disagreement [127 words]jehad afridiFeb 2, 2012 10:5793971
you are not a muslim abdul. [117 words]jehadFeb 5, 2012 12:3293971
Really ? [54 words]LitonMay 1, 2012 04:5693971
reply [60 words]makMay 12, 2012 15:2793971
nisha [133 words]suhaanaJun 12, 2012 17:2093971
so what [27 words]RanaApr 3, 2013 19:5693971
reality of bhagwa parties [85 words]Kazi Sabeeh Ahmed Adv.Apr 20, 2014 01:1993971
false conversions [12 words]AryaApr 21, 2014 14:4193971
Islam has it all covered [55 words]PrashantApr 24, 2014 01:0793971
4Wrong [5124 words]fahadJul 22, 2014 06:4593971
16Who is the father in law of Mukhtar Abbass Naqvi [31 words]AjitJul 22, 2014 08:2593971
1create awareness in our society about misleading propaganda to defame our religion [15 words]neil bhatiaAug 21, 2014 03:4693971
for not [21 words]S K RishiMar 16, 2015 01:3493971
Malika not Hindu [14 words]DeepakJun 1, 2015 22:0593971
sikhism [10 words]sarbjit kaurApr 25, 2017 16:2593971
If a Hindu girl wants to elope with Muslim what her parents could do? [74 words]Anindya ChatterjeeAug 17, 2018 06:1693971
if you convert, no one else but you are responsible [171 words]PrashantAug 17, 2018 17:2293971
uk girls shouldnot be permitted to goto pakistan under any circumstances [18 words]Kirandeep singhAug 23, 2018 11:0093971
Want to know who is father of seema naqvi [9 words]AshutoshMay 30, 2019 10:2693971

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)