3 readers online now  |  69 million page views

Recent Remarks by Former IDF Chief Ya'alon

Reader comment on item: Mr. Olmert Visits Washington

Submitted by Ken Mann (United States), May 16, 2006 at 11:20

Former IDF Chief Ya´alon: "Israel´s Leaders Selling Illusions"
By Ezra HaLevi

Former IDF Chief of Staff Moshe Ya'alon has broken his relative silence, decrying the entire notion of a Palestinian state, and urging Israel to be strong rather than appease the global Jihad.

The longtime warrior drew a comparison between the events leading up to the Holocaust and the present, comparing Ehud Olmert to Neville Chamberlain. "We look back to what the West experienced before World War Two," Ya'alon said. "There was denial of reality, denial of threat. The attitude was, 'Let's leave it to next year, to the next generation.' We don't need Chamberlains - we need Churchills. We are flooded with lies, manipulated by Al Qaeda, but, most prominently, by the Palestinians."

Ya'alon spoke at Manhattan's Lincoln Square Synagogue last Monday, registering harsh criticism of Israel's leadership for offering "illusions" to the Israeli people. Ya'alon was Chief of Staff up until just before the implementation of Ariel Sharon's Disengagement Plan, of which his criticism was well-known. His tenure was not extended and he was replaced with the current COS, Dan Halutz.

The retired general criticized the notion of withdrawing from parts of Judea and Samaria, in addition to the building of the Partition Wall, which he believes is an illusion in terms of security. "The best defense is a good offense, not a fence," he said. "The best way to deal with terrorists is to arrest them or kill them in their beds. The IDF has the intelligence capability to intercept terrorists. They use their civilians as human shields, knowing our sensitivities to killing civilians – but we do have the capability to intercept them in real time. Without dealing with the roots, we can cut down the weeds – to deal with the roots would be to force them to reform their education and culture. I am not sure we will succeed, but we should be under no pressure to make any concessions until this change."

The former Chief of Staff said that not only did the Disengagement propel the Hamas terror group to a landslide victory in PA elections earlier this year, but "what we are doing is leaving a legacy for the next generation that will [have to] deal with Palestinians who believe that terrorism pays, that Israel cuts and runs under pressure."

He said that at this point, when Kassam missiles are already falling regularly on Israeli towns, "we must stop getting used to these constant missile attacks as if they are rain. We can't tolerate this missile threat from Gaza or continued terrorism… We must step up military actions in Gaza despite the problems of not being able to have laser-like accuracy against the terrorists there."

Ya'alon doesn't see negotiations as a reality any time in the future. "I do not see any prospect for peace and reconciliation on the Palestinian side," he said. "I needed no sophisticated intelligence to reach this conclusion; I only had to look at their textbooks, posters and so on. We should not be surprised - but we ignored it. Without this kind of change, not just in Israel but the West, all Western powers will have to fight them. They believe they can defeat the West and Israel first. We need a wake-up call here and across the West. Under no circumstances should we surrender to terror. As long as they see our appeasement policy, they will continue."

Ya'alon takes issue with the assumption that creating a Palestinian State is anything but dangerous for the Jewish state: "From the dawn of Zionism until this day, the source of all terrorist attacks has been the refusal of the Arab world to recognize Israel's existence. Until this changes, we will remain the target of violent terrorist activity. The '67 borders are not a solution to rocket attacks, suicide bombs or more conventional forms of warfare. The two-state solution has failed and to my mind is now irrelevant. Even before the Hamas victory, a two-state solution was a mistaken fantasy - now it's even more irrelevant."

Ya'alon was optimistic, however, saying what Israel needs most is a change of outlook. The man who is credited with pushing through the policy of targeting terrorists and killing them, no matter how unpopular next day's headlines made the Jewish state, said he believed Israelis "must consolidate our Jewish Zionist narrative. Without believing in our case, there is no way to convince someone else. We need moral clarity and clear strategy – or else there is no way to deal with the problem and find a solution. Otherwise, there is no chance for one now over the horizon, meaning in my generation. Yet we prefer to be confused, to ignore reality. This is the case with Israel; this is the case with the West. Iran sees us withdrawing from Gaza, Hamas is elected, they see US trouble in Iraq and because they do not pay price for financing, supporting and encouraging terrorism, they continue.

"The war has become super-conventional. Syrian scud missiles, Iranian Shihab missiles, Iran pursuing nuclear capabilities – these are the threats today ... The deliberate targeting of Israeli civilians – we suffered more than 1,000 fatalities in the last five years, more than 70% civilians because the other side believes that Israeli society is the weakest link in the Israeli security chain… Now it is more and more a religious conflict – from their side, not ours … but like in the past, Hamas says, again, no room for Israel, instead there must be a Palestinian Islamic state. They say what they mean and mean what they say… And Israel is only the first target of their planned Islamic empire."

The speech was organized by the Zionist Organization of America. ZOA President Morton A. Klein said, following the lecture, that, "General Ya'alon brings a very sobering message, people were keen to hear his moral clarity and strategic wisdom that states clearly that the Oslo path of the past 13 years has been a terrible mistake. We will not begin succeed in seeking peace until we first win the war."


Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

Next Comment >>

Reader comments (73) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Upholding a Sensible Approach [140 words]Susan H. SomervilleMay 31, 2006 02:1146754
American pressure on its allies [136 words]Amitabh tripathiMay 26, 2006 02:5046434
Israels new 2008 vulnerable border [304 words]JayMay 23, 2006 01:3046167
The expiation of Jews [167 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDMay 22, 2006 16:1946151
Dr. Pipes is right.. [223 words]M. Saleem AkhtarMay 21, 2006 10:3346074
WASHINGTON RALLY 05/23/2005 12 noon [64 words]odeleya jacobsMay 21, 2006 08:4446070
Mr. Olmert Visits Washington [84 words]steven LMay 19, 2006 16:1945975
Cowardice [72 words]obilicMay 19, 2006 15:5545973
Ayaan Hirsi Ali [73 words]SiddaMay 20, 2006 09:5445973
Sidda [25 words]Octavio JohansonMay 20, 2006 17:0645973
Octavio, I don't know [147 words]SiddaMay 21, 2006 21:2645973
Arabs are not a threat. [188 words]Charles SmythMay 19, 2006 09:2145948
1Israel and Koran, Bible and Torah - Save the whole world! [236 words]Ayran KhanMay 19, 2006 03:0945936
ayran khan [43 words]ahmad zafireMay 20, 2006 08:4745936
check your sources [26 words]anonymousDec 9, 2007 19:0345936
torah and koran are like wheels in a gear whose cogs are finely and properly engaged... [181 words]grant newmanJan 24, 2011 00:4145936
Israel must decide what is good for Israel - and the US must decide what is good for the US [342 words]SullyMay 19, 2006 02:4145933
AND STILL NO PEACE why not? [269 words]renchMay 18, 2006 17:3645903
Why the dismantlement show ??? [113 words]Marlon MoserMay 18, 2006 14:1545897
Build the wall! [129 words]HarrakMay 19, 2006 20:3245897
common sense [289 words]true believerMay 23, 2006 07:1945897
reply for true believer [119 words]HarrakMay 23, 2006 15:4245897
Facts and updates for Harrak [860 words]true believerMay 25, 2006 10:1745897
and another thing for Harrak [37 words]another believerMay 26, 2006 00:4845897
true believer...... [176 words]ahmad zafireMay 27, 2006 22:2045897
from true believer to ahmed zafire [494 words]true believerMay 29, 2006 03:3345897
true believer [420 words]ahmad zafireMay 30, 2006 12:3545897
Ahmed Zafire [425 words]true believerJun 16, 2006 08:3745897
true believer!!! [77 words]ahmad zafireJun 17, 2006 02:3145897
not quite [35 words]true believerJun 26, 2006 09:3545897
true believer [23 words]ahmad zafireJun 26, 2006 21:5445897
not so [31 words]true believerJun 28, 2006 07:1045897
It's time to make GREAT ISRAEL AND COMPLETE PALESTINE COUNTRIES [100 words]Aryan KhanMay 18, 2006 10:0945889
In a perfect world [392 words]Robert ArbetmanMay 18, 2006 09:4345885
Olmert to D.C [416 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Al RameyMay 17, 2006 20:1845838
Mr. Olmert Visits Washington [128 words]quebecoiseMay 17, 2006 17:1145821
Israel: Secular Vs Torah [841 words]YovenMay 17, 2006 16:5245820
Zilzal 1X ATTN: Yoven [295 words]HarrakMay 18, 2006 18:5645820
to yoven [147 words]tariqMay 20, 2006 05:4045820
To yoven Immigration of jews to Israel [371 words]FaisalMay 24, 2006 08:5045820
One can always hope... [131 words]J.S.May 17, 2006 15:5545816
Many Israeli policies make no sense [256 words]Kenneth S. BesigMay 17, 2006 12:4045808
why Israel may be making these withdrawals [81 words]lee brockMay 17, 2006 12:3145807
Jews and muslims [85 words]G.BisvasMay 17, 2006 06:3645790
the unfortunate quislings [76 words]Donald OMay 17, 2006 20:0845790
hoping for a G-d willing peace between jews and muslims [40 words]ahmad zafireMay 17, 2006 22:3845790
Olmert Goes to Washington [273 words]Ed GordonMay 17, 2006 04:1345786
Gush Etzion [67 words]Israel PickholtzMay 17, 2006 01:4345783
The devil is in the details [164 words]Moshe Even-ShoshanMay 16, 2006 23:5645780
Garrison State [122 words]BlackspeareMay 16, 2006 22:5745774
END WITHDRAWAL FROM TERRITORY; DO NOT GIVE UP LAND [177 words]Carmen Waggoner, Ph.D.May 16, 2006 22:2045771
Let Israel Do It [738 words]John RMay 18, 2006 18:5545771
Israeli Strategy [109 words]John RMay 19, 2006 16:0145771
Olmert, the terrorist's ally [222 words]Dr-RJPMay 16, 2006 20:5645763
The fall [197 words]HarrakMay 19, 2006 00:2545763
Israeli retreat [192 words]Daniel MMay 16, 2006 17:3945753
why so glum [362 words]john w. mcginleyMay 16, 2006 16:0445737
Olmert's U.S. visit [71 words]David BenShemMay 16, 2006 15:4445736
What we learn from history is, we do not learn from history [100 words]David W. LincolnMay 16, 2006 15:3445735
history for our country [38 words]adeelOct 13, 2010 01:4545735
Olmerts convergence plan. [37 words]Monty PogodaMay 16, 2006 15:0145733
Israeli Withdrawals [37 words]Jack BremerMay 16, 2006 14:4945731
Israel and Palestine [51 words]Kerry WinnMay 16, 2006 19:3145731
I agree with this article 100% but what are the alternatives? [47 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
roslyn estherMay 16, 2006 14:2445728
The alternative [254 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDMay 17, 2006 15:4545728
a reply to Dr. Pipes Reply [100 words]roslyn estherMay 17, 2006 17:4945728
Compared to Iraq, Gaza is going GREAT! [148 words]SteveMay 16, 2006 13:3745723
JEWISH RETREAT [100 words]Ken ZimmermanMay 16, 2006 12:5545722
Kadima plus Olmert [253 words]true believerMay 17, 2006 10:1445722
Appeasement continues [64 words]Ralph C Whaley MDMay 16, 2006 12:3745720
There she goes again [153 words]yonatan silvermanMay 16, 2006 12:0645718
Recent Remarks by Former IDF Chief Ya'alon [1016 words]Ken MannMay 16, 2006 11:2045712
And Lest We Forget... [103 words]RobertMay 16, 2006 18:2745712

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to Recent Remarks by Former IDF Chief Ya'alon by Ken Mann

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List


eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2019 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)