3 readers online now  |  69 million page views

How Ahmadinejad came to power...

Reader comment on item: Iran's Final Solution Plan

Submitted by Mark Rosenthal (Germany), Dec 9, 2005 at 08:37

Mr. Pipes: Excellent writing, I thank you for what you wrote.

I watched the speech that Bill Clinton gave in Israel in memory of Yitzchak Rabin in Nov. 2005. A part of the speech was about the security of Israel, most importantly about the threat coming from Iran. Mr. Clinton pointed out, most interestingly, that Ahmadinejad came to power not because of any election promise to obliterate Israel, but rather, because of the horrific economic conditions in Iran and his promise to fix those conditions. Now that he is in office and has realized that such problems cannot be easily fixed, he has decided to take the course of hate, and most likely, of war, in order to divert his own people from their economic misery. They trusted him, some of the them with good-will in their hearts, others knowing quite well what an egomaniac and anti-semite he is, and wanting him in power because they are cut from the same cloth as Ahmadinejad.

This does not make what he is doing any more acceptable or understandable. If anything, it makes his actions all the more unexcusable and shows just how bloodthirsty and calculating this man is. Yes, the iranians have been hearing the cries of "death to Israel" for years, but the last years saw a moderate administration trying to sooth and stabilize, and those death cries were getting weaker and weaker and being taken less and less seriously. Now we are confronted with a mini-Hitler who is manipulating his people in EXACTLY the same way and in the same progression of events as from 1932-1945. A man who challenges the historical accuracy and truth of the holocaust is not worthy of being on the world's political stage.

So, I recommend a policy of complete non-tolerance. A 100% absolute embargo, per UN- sanctions, enforced by the member states, should do the trick. Completely seal off the borders, ground Iran's air force, jam it's communications. Shut off the oil pipelines, block the ports. Cut Iran completely off from the rest of the world, and that for as long as it takes in order to convince the iranians that there is a better way to get along with neighbors than by threatening to destroys them. During the embargo, nothing gets in and nothing comes out. Zero-nada-zilch. Close all iranian embassy's throughout the world and send all iranian diplomats from all over the world packing. Recall all foreign ambassadors stationed in Teheran. Carry out the same embargo on lands who do not hold up the embargo against Iran. And then let's see how long the iranian people will put up with Ahmadinejad's lies and manipulation. The embargo against Iraq failed because it was never a complete embargo and never seriously enforced. This time we should be wiser. Irony of history...unfortunately, we may all be too tired from the war that didn't need to be (in Iraq) for a war that may have to be (in Iran).

And don't forget, as soon as Ahmadinejad develops nuclear warheads, he will attach them to rockets with a range of 3,000 kilometers and shoot them at Israel and most likely also at targets in Europe. The europeans cannot be so naive as to think that Ahmadinejad has any great love for europe, he is only hoping to abuse the trust of the europeans. The australians are convinced that Iran is less than 6 months away from a working nuclear warhead and the australian secret service is one of the 5 best in the world. So, let's not kid ourselves here. The appeasement of the 1930's has taught us that just standing by does not work. And though I was and am completely against the Bush policies in Iran, I have been sending Emails for the last 3 years to my friends, saying over and over again that the target is wrong. The problem was not Iraq. The problem was and IS Iran.

If the iranians are really a modern thinking society that wants to be a part of the world community, then the iranian people must depose Ahmadinejad and his cronies.

I am sure that there are just millions upon millions of hard working, honest, open and loving muslims who are appalled to see what is happening now, not to mention christians and (it goes without saying) jews. A nuclear attack from Iran would not just kill jews. Many many many arabs, including muslims, would also die. So, muslims across the world, in my opinion, have a very vested interest in getting rid of the madman before it is too late.

I hope that the world will open it's eyes this time.

Mark Rosenthal
Bonn, Germany
Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (94) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
No shock, at all [72 words]Phil GreendApr 6, 2008 18:20124868
MKO are a disgrace [108 words]Yek Khoob IraniJan 26, 2006 05:2232502
1the truth [48 words]Jamontis RibostinJan 3, 2006 16:5730986
Death to all who dictate religion! [11 words]BobDec 23, 2005 19:3930473
Iran vs. Persian "round 2" [477 words]Jamontis RibostinDec 21, 2005 21:4130386
How Ahmadinejad came to power... [772 words]Mark RosenthalDec 9, 2005 08:3729691
Iranian nuclear program a threat to world [191 words]Frederick J. Bainhauer IIINov 27, 2005 21:1828899
Iran's Final Solution Plan [73 words]Behrouz AzarniaNov 26, 2005 17:0428871
Iran's "Final Solution" would also kill Muslims [245 words]Andy ZackNov 18, 2005 08:5228584
Re: Amar, Christian Arabs Are Victimized Twice [138 words]AnneMNov 17, 2005 23:3128566
IRAN and France [28 words]Ramsis AlmasryNov 11, 2005 16:3228249
7رسالة شكر [67 words]mohamed mawiNov 8, 2005 11:2727971
Arabs can be Christians or Muslims [64 words]AmarNov 8, 2005 00:4027927
What Else Is New? [37 words]Asaf ApplebaumNov 7, 2005 16:1827904
Response to Kevin [165 words]WalterNov 7, 2005 16:1427903
A different game plan? [428 words]KevinNov 6, 2005 21:1827869
Israel's safety and rights equal Pakistan's [192 words]Matthew KennelNov 6, 2005 17:2127863
Iranian nuclear threat [111 words]Bruce BoymanNov 5, 2005 01:0827805
to Joseph and Carter lovers [203 words]Shahin S.Nov 5, 2005 00:0627802
The Axis of Evil. [19 words]P.E.K.Nov 4, 2005 20:1927796
Why not to choose the Third Option as of the final solution to Iran? [545 words]Shirin NarimanNov 4, 2005 15:3827782
Thank you. [24 words]K.BarashNov 4, 2005 15:3027781
All Iran wants to do is produce electricity, people!! [115 words]JosephNov 4, 2005 13:3527780
Global impact of threat of Iraninan president [265 words]Amitabh tripathiNov 4, 2005 06:4227770
What specifically do you suggest Mr Pipes? [37 words]Nick (South Africa)Nov 3, 2005 05:5027722
PLEASE TELL EVERYONE IN WASHIGNTON!!! [79 words]AnnaNov 3, 2005 05:1327720
To Ibrahim Abu Bakar [86 words]Saleem AkhtarNov 2, 2005 19:4527706
--- and one more thing [318 words]John W. McGinleyNov 2, 2005 16:4827699
Why doesn't Israel have a robust shelter program? [95 words]sullyNov 2, 2005 16:2427698
answer to Jim Wilson [82 words]yuval Brandstetter MDNov 2, 2005 15:2227693
Iran's Final Solution [110 words]Arthur YeagerNov 2, 2005 11:1527682
Muslim hate of Jews [21 words]LanceNov 2, 2005 10:5827681
The editorial "we"? [51 words]Martin KesslerNov 2, 2005 10:4627679
Have the Iranian's perfected a "Jew Only" nuke? [23 words]Jim WilsonNov 2, 2005 09:2427674
The Republic of Israel should attack now! [80 words]Francesco Mangascia'Nov 2, 2005 03:5627658
The Republic of Israel should attack now [39 words]VICTOR DELE AKINTAYOOct 15, 2009 07:5527658
2The Enemy of Islam [457 words]John BastileNov 2, 2005 01:3627656
peace in the world [68 words]matinOct 12, 2008 09:4627656
Iranian threats to the state of Israel are joke [391 words]Ibrahim Abu Bakar, Ph.D.Nov 2, 2005 01:2427655
There are no moderate muslims [40 words]Hari IyerNov 2, 2005 01:0327654
The Final Solution Plan [129 words]MarciusJun 7, 2006 19:5027654
Iran about Israel [119 words]steven LNov 2, 2005 00:4327653
president or a thug? [25 words]Saleem AkhtarNov 2, 2005 00:0627651
Regime change [11 words]Isaac EtessamiNov 1, 2005 23:1027649
1The West can not see the danger [203 words]f.shakkiNov 1, 2005 22:5227648
You are right [242 words]NowiseeJun 30, 2007 16:4127648
The Islamic Bomb [137 words]Arlinda DeAngelisNov 1, 2005 21:0227647
How to answer Iran's rhetoric [177 words]Houshang. YazdiNov 1, 2005 20:1127645
Irans declartion of war against the US & Israel [120 words]Faqi HussainNov 1, 2005 19:4727644
iran's a threat to israel [20 words]konwonderFeb 27, 2007 16:1427644
Radical Islam's Totalitarian Tendencies [634 words]AlexNov 1, 2005 19:0227641
1Final Solution [364 words]Dr. Lee D. CaryNov 1, 2005 18:0127637
Iran on Israel [107 words]Donald W. BalesNov 1, 2005 17:3927635
disarming condemnations [121 words]SullyNov 1, 2005 17:2027634
Indeed, will we catch on soon enough? [101 words]David W. LincolnNov 1, 2005 16:2527632
los dos eguales [311 words]mohamed mawiNov 1, 2005 15:5227629
THE RIGHT QUESTION: DO WE TAKE HIS WORDS SERIOUSLY? [555 words]Dr. Steve CarolNov 1, 2005 15:5027628
Time to Act ... [149 words]Pat HurshellNov 1, 2005 15:2727627
Good thing I'm not a diplomat! [84 words]Victor PurintonNov 1, 2005 14:5127626
Hypocrisy 101 [109 words]JaladhiNov 1, 2005 14:1027625
If not now, when? [89 words]AbrahambNov 1, 2005 14:0927624
Muslims Show their true nature (again). [57 words]Michael BondNov 1, 2005 14:0527623
America's enemies within and without [194 words]WalterNov 1, 2005 13:5827621
Iran and her aspirations [547 words]Carl RussellNov 1, 2005 13:5527620
What the U.S. should do about Iran [182 words]Mike FoxNov 1, 2005 13:5327619
Iran [96 words]VictorAug 28, 2006 18:4427619
Iran's "Final Solution" [313 words]D MaraNov 1, 2005 13:4427618
Iran must be punished NOW! [76 words]Ralph C Whaley MDNov 1, 2005 13:4327617
Will History Repeat Itself? [222 words]Yehoshua ZellerNov 1, 2005 13:1027615
Mr. Ahmadinejads comments [192 words]DanNov 1, 2005 12:5027614
So what is Israel to do? [55 words]Joshua lamm, MDNov 1, 2005 12:3027613
Iran vs. Persia [147 words]Ian MordantNov 1, 2005 12:1227612
Persia [70 words]saeedJun 2, 2008 09:2427612
The New Hitler/The Old Persia [68 words]Louis CohenNov 1, 2005 11:5827611
A war against Iran would be counter-productive [200 words]Gabriel GrossoNov 1, 2005 11:5727610
superb [17 words]sharon finegoldNov 1, 2005 11:5727609
Minor(?) Damages [180 words]PatNov 1, 2005 11:5327608
Doing nothing about Iran [66 words]Edward ClineNov 1, 2005 11:4527606
Statement on Iran's Final Solution Plan [285 words]Ed GordonNov 1, 2005 11:4127603
The murder of Jews, Islam's daily bread [204 words]Kenneth S. BesigNov 1, 2005 11:4027602
Dysfunctional Politics [166 words]Aidan MaconachyNov 1, 2005 11:3427601
Solution to Iran [57 words]PhillipNov 1, 2005 11:3327600
Still the Ayatollah's Stooge [79 words]Bill WaldronNov 1, 2005 11:2027598
1Statement by Iran..Nukes [359 words]Kim SegarNov 1, 2005 11:1627597
The Final Solution: WW3 [86 words]Mark-Alan WhittleNov 1, 2005 11:1427596
when fox prone to death, then he is running to thecity [82 words]Faqir chandNov 1, 2005 11:1127595
A further thought [125 words]Anthony DaytonNov 1, 2005 10:5827594
Great article [13 words]bernienaglerNov 1, 2005 10:4927591
"What's new?" and "No threat" [154 words]Michael SandfortNov 1, 2005 10:4727590
And What of the Palestinians [36 words]James WelshNov 1, 2005 10:4227589
iran has nukes... ? [55 words]asim ahmedNov 1, 2005 10:2227588
Iran and Nukes [130 words]PMJun 4, 2006 17:4127588
You have got to be kidding! [329 words]Mark ZAug 14, 2006 14:2627588
Re:Iran's Final Solution Plan [57 words]Atim BasseyNov 1, 2005 09:5827587

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to How Ahmadinejad came to power... by Mark Rosenthal

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

ADVERTISEMENTS

eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2020 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)