69 million page views

حاميها حراميها or the thief is the one who is protecting it and Turkey is a vile country

Reader comment on item: The Middle East Forum Debates Moderate Islam
in response to reader comment: The Islamic "Pope" is the Kalipha

Submitted by dhimmi no more (United States), Apr 2, 2014 at 19:07

Hi Mike

Establish the Caliphate! It appears that this is underway at this point in history.

It is not that simple. The Muslim masorites had great difficulty in trying to explain the word Khalifa because it is supposed to be from the Semitic root Kh-L-F as in he who follows (as in Allah's deputy or Allah's successor) and compare this with the NT Elahi Elahi lema Sabachtani where the word Sabachtani is from the root S-B-Q or to go ahead of me or leave me behind and indeed in classical Arabic we are told that the word is really المُسْتَخْلَفُ or al-Mustakhlif and not Khalifa

The word al-Mustakhlif really means he who follows but as you shall see who was the one to be followed? the answer is unclear.

The word al-Khalifa could be very well from Aramaic as it is very strange to have a Ta marbouta (which makes the word a feminine word when it is not a feminine word) at the end of the word which could very well be the Aramaic Alip

Now early on Muslims view the one in charge of the emerging Muslim community as in charge of both the profane as well as the sacred and he was called خليفة الله or Khalifatu Allah or he who is the one who follows Allah or in other word he was both the spokesman for Allah and he was also the one in charge of the profane as in running the state

Later on the Ulama wanted part of the action and wanted to control the sacred and this is why the title of the Kahlifa became خليفة رسول الله or Khalifat Rasul Allah or he who is a deputy (to follow) of Muhammad the prophet of Allah and this is very well documented in coins extant from the first 2-3 centuries of Islam

This really means that what was to become islam was still evolving and did not drop from the sky as we are told

For more information on this very interesting anomaly sea Crone's great book "God's Caliph"

Well in the case of the Shia it is a very different story but the point is what is really al-Khalifa? there is no clear answer and case in point many Muslims regarded the clueless Morsi as Khalifatu Allah ( it makes you woner if he had a phone connection with Allah) but not many of them and on top of the list would be Sheikh al-Azhar who would not want to see him in charge of the sacred or Sheikh al-Azhar will be out of a job in other words Sheikh al-Azhar would want to be the Pope of Islam

Nothing is ever clear in Islam

The nation of Turkey is seeking to play a pivotal role in uniting the Islamic world (all sects) under one banner of Islam.

1. Surprise surprise: The Arabs do not like the Turks and you need to read Mohamed Abdu to realize that Arabic speaking Muslims would not want to have non Arabic speakers to be in charge of them and they regarded the Turks as "wannabe Arabs" and not "the real McCoy"

2. The Shia never want to have anything to do with Sunni Islam not back then and not now and many Shia Ayatollahs believe that world terrorism is attributed to Sunni Islam so I tell the clueless Turks good luck if they think for a minute think that they can be in charge of the Shia

The Shia have more in common with Catholic Christainty than they have with Sunni Islam

The reviving of the Ottoman Empire plans to reel in the extremist/jihadists so as to tone down their violent forced conversions and persecutions of non-Muslims and western/secular societies.

You are kidding. The Turks committed so much crimes the likes of the Armenian genocide and they murdered 2M Greeks and 700,000 Syrian Christians and many Greeks and Armenians and Syrians escaping these crimes were welcomed by both Muslims and Christians in the Middle East and were saved from being murdered by the barbarian Turks and Muslims in that part of the world know very well about these crimes

The Turks ... denying to this day that any of these crimes took place and it is shocking that of all nations in the Middle East it is the government of Israel does not recognize such crimes when Egypt and its government recognize the Armenian Genocide

The thrust will be to establish Islam as the superior religion but still allow tolerance for non-Muslims - although the jizyah tax will remain in effect.

The Turks hate to be reminded that their own ancestors the Greeks and Syrians and Armenians were brutalized by the barbarian Turks that came from central Asia what can i tell you

The Sufi sect will most likely assist in the development so as to help establish the form of "Moderate Islam" that is wished for by the societies who are plagued by the terror, violence and present-day religious persecutions perpetrated by the extreme fundamental followers of the Qur'an, Sunnah and Ahadith of Muhammad.

Surprise surprise Sufis are regarded by Sunnis as kuffar oh you do not believe me? just google the attacks on Sufi shrines by criminal jihadis

But again delusions is very much a Turkish attribute what can I tell you

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

Reader comments (79) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
The Fallacy of moderate Islam [130 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
SkiltzOct 4, 2014 14:20218461
A water-downed version of "authentic Christianity" [415 words]FalcoSep 9, 2014 07:44217691
The purpose of religion is to control ourselves, not to criticize others [12 words]Nalliah ThayabharanJul 11, 2014 00:42215894
The Logic - Big Three [81 words]Mark DApr 14, 2014 21:42214475
1Manful try, Dr. Pipes [615 words]Kepha HorApr 8, 2014 17:56214377
The Middle East Forum Debates Moderate Islam [722 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Peter F.Apr 7, 2014 13:56214347
Human Interpretation of Christianity May be Moderated - Its Biblical Truth Does Not Change [659 words]M. ToveyMay 16, 2014 14:29214347
1Religion is an Opium [70 words]Nalliah ThayabharanApr 4, 2014 12:35214264
2How long have we got? [52 words]StavrosApr 2, 2014 01:58214190
2Ibrahim is right [101 words]Mahendra MathurApr 1, 2014 16:38214178
Islam doctrine too ingrained to change [148 words]BridgetApr 17, 2014 16:39214178
4Moderate Nazi could be solution. [658 words]PhiliorApr 1, 2014 09:23214176
Moderate followers make moderate religions [554 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
AlexandrosApr 1, 2014 08:27214175
1"Moderate" Religion [160 words]Michael S.Apr 1, 2014 05:56214172
1Pipes and Ibrahim: Is Moderate Islam Possible [349 words]Richard BenkinApr 1, 2014 00:15214170
arab orthodoxy vs south-asian moderate [95 words]mythApr 2, 2014 06:03214170
1Pipes and Ibrahim: Is Moderate Islam Possible: Response [157 words]Richard BenkinApr 4, 2014 00:05214170
2You are misreading religion in India [204 words]dhimmi no moreApr 4, 2014 13:00214170
Misreading? Doubtful. [123 words]Richard BenkinApr 5, 2014 07:56214170
1Motivations and rocket science [429 words]dhimmi no moreApr 7, 2014 17:14214170
1Desert v. Monsoon Islam? [251 words]Peter HerzApr 8, 2014 18:06214170
Ibrahim and Pipes on Moderate Islam [270 words]Mark DMar 31, 2014 20:44214168
reformed or transformed? [345 words]FrankzMar 31, 2014 19:39214166
Moderate Islam [229 words]Dan SchnittkerMar 31, 2014 16:05214165
1Why Ibrahim is right [35 words]Roberto AlazarMar 31, 2014 12:23214162
historical analogies? [164 words]gayleMar 31, 2014 11:55214161
Time Heals [50 words]Jon, a Brit from EurolandMar 31, 2014 09:59214160
A True Dilemma [414 words]john w. mcginleyMar 31, 2014 09:52214159
Taking love for granted [125 words]John BMar 31, 2014 08:13214157
1Reformed Islam - and maybe Moderate Muslims [116 words]Dian KjaergaardMar 31, 2014 07:15214155
1Your Expectations [276 words]MoisheMar 31, 2014 04:31214154
Moderate Muslims "used as objects of derision" [38 words]RhetoricalGirlApr 14, 2014 18:20214154
Feminism & education will be the key (and the Noor soap opera as a bright spot) [334 words]PezDispenserMar 31, 2014 04:08214153
moderate muslims vs. moderate Islam [9 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
MosheMar 31, 2014 03:08214152
Even if moderate Islam takes off, there will still be jihadists and Islamists galore [63 words]Yoel NatanMar 31, 2014 00:15214150
1Reinterpretation of scripture [180 words]Russ GoldMar 30, 2014 23:43214149
To be or not to be .......... [114 words]jon metesMar 30, 2014 22:31214148
5Rebuttal to Mr Pipes on 'Moderate Muslims' [424 words]IQ al RassooliMar 30, 2014 21:14214147
Milquetoast Moderation of Religion [849 words]M. ToveyApr 2, 2014 16:14214147
Islamic Moderation Greater in the Past [211 words]DaveMar 30, 2014 20:27214146
4A COMPLIMENT [176 words]DAVIDMar 30, 2014 20:03214145
Moderate Islam? [14 words]Paul SeverienMar 30, 2014 17:39214141
Moderate Islam ? [74 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
JanaMar 30, 2014 17:22214139
Nothing human is fixed [86 words]Kingsley BeattieMar 30, 2014 16:35214138
2Reforming Islam??? [227 words]Carl GoldbergMar 30, 2014 16:32214137
Wrong analogy [176 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
aviMar 30, 2014 14:07214135
1Pipe's Error [129 words]Nathan DeutschMar 30, 2014 14:01214134
Ibrahim's viewpoint is more compelling. [292 words]Rich McMahonMar 30, 2014 13:36214133
How to save Muslims and the rest of us from Islam and other religions [423 words]A.T. HalmayMar 30, 2014 13:35214132
Do civilizations "progress" [181 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
MARTIN KESSLERMar 30, 2014 13:12214131
"Moderate" sounds like "Luke Warm" [146 words]Tony PattersonMar 30, 2014 12:52214130
I admire optimism but... [265 words]Doug MayfieldMar 30, 2014 12:35214129
Dichotomy: Fundamental Muslims vs Moderate Muslims [430 words]Mike RamirezMar 30, 2014 12:16214128
1I believe change is possible [96 words]Robin RosenblattMar 30, 2014 12:09214126
1'change' possible - but for how long??? [38 words]Mohammed Wazir AhkspaidarApr 1, 2014 22:06214126
Islam is a community religion [96 words]Robin RosenblattApr 1, 2014 23:33214126
תודה [1 words]Robin RosenblattApr 3, 2014 23:56214126
1No Moderate Islam [73 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
AndrewMar 30, 2014 11:54214124
Does Moderate Islam Really Exist? [211 words]M. ToveyApr 2, 2014 19:27214124
1From a British perspective [48 words]ECAWMar 30, 2014 11:31214122
Islam certainly does seem to be the problem [120 words]RaeApr 4, 2014 18:21214122
1Ideology first [47 words]ECAWApr 5, 2014 05:35214122
2The legacy of the the concept of "radical Islam" [159 words]Irving WeisdorfMar 30, 2014 11:18214121
Interpretation Changes Are Possible [317 words]Iftekhar HaiMar 30, 2014 11:13214120
Changing Islam [91 words]JIMJFOXMar 30, 2014 10:43214117
1Moderate Islam oxymoron? [102 words]Wallace SchwamMar 30, 2014 10:37214116
2Inmportant Debate to Have [254 words]Boston Tea PartyMar 30, 2014 10:35214115
1Here is an example of why Islam cannot be reformed [179 words]dhimmi no moreMar 30, 2014 10:11214113
Lev. 20:13 misunderstanding [143 words]New Class TraitorMar 30, 2014 09:49214112
1ISLAM IS ISLAM [93 words]Bob RosenMar 30, 2014 09:42214111
Assimilation effects [178 words]Duncan DruhlMar 30, 2014 09:15214110
What's in Your Pipe? [377 words]TL WinslowMar 30, 2014 09:02214109
1Q9:29 and abrogation and the fatal flaw in Sunni Islam is there is no Pope! [277 words]dhimmi no moreMar 30, 2014 08:53214108
1The Islamic "Pope" is the Kalipha [143 words]Mike RamirezApr 1, 2014 22:17214108
4حاميها حراميها or the thief is the one who is protecting it and Turkey is a vile country [889 words]dhimmi no moreApr 2, 2014 19:07214108
1Great explanation. Thanks! [179 words]Mike RamirezApr 3, 2014 23:50214108
2The amazing Oktar and his women [352 words]dhimmi no moreApr 5, 2014 11:36214108
1There is a difference between Jewish and Christian "holy books" and the Qur'an [240 words]Eric MacDonaldMar 30, 2014 08:52214107
1Truth is absolute [114 words]TBKMar 30, 2014 08:30214106

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to حاميها حراميها or the thief is the one who is protecting it and Turkey is a vile country by dhimmi no more

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)