Daniel Pipes Mobile Edition Regular Site |
|
Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Other Languages | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List | Search |
Reader comment on item: In 1796, U.S. Vowed Friendliness With Islam
Submitted by Jascha Kessler (United States), Nov 14, 2006 at 15:10
Perhaps it will be useful readers to learn more of the entire background and relevance of the Barbary Wars in the early 19th Century. Mr. Pipes' squib seems to me to have tortured all the available records to further an argument that we are not really at war with Muslims or Islam, based on some old records of treaties which he does not place in full historical context and reality, then or now." .
The list of treaties is available at: http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/diplomacy/barbary/barmenu.htm
Now look for example at the 1795 treaty with the Dey of Algiers at: http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/diplomacy/barbary/bar1795t.htm
It has a lot of articles protecting US interests. Then it ends with ...
"... to keep the Articles Contained in this Treaty Sacred and inviolable which we the Dey & Divan Promise to Observe on Consideration of the United States Paying annually the Value of twelve thousand Algerine Sequins (1) in Maritime Stores Should the United States forward a Larger Quantity the Over-Plus Shall be Paid for in Money by the Dey & Regency any Vessel that may be Captured from the Date of this Treaty of Peace & Amity shall immediately be deliver'd up on her Arrival in Algiers." ...
followed by ... http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/statutes/bar01.htm
"Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled, That for the purpose of defraying the expenses of carrying into effect the treaty made between the United States and the Dey and Regency of Algiers, the monies arising under the revenue laws of the United States, which have been heretofore passed, not already appropriated to any other purpose, or so much thereof as may be necessary, to the amount of twenty-four thousand dollars per annum, be, and the same are hereby>pledged and appropriated for the payment of the anuity stipulated in the said treaty, to be paid to the said Dey and Regency of Algiers, and to continue so pledged and appropriated, so long as the said>treaty shall be in force."
That's what the treaties are about. Protection money. This is the pattern with all the countries that used the Mediterranean - pay the Barbary coast pirates bulk or annual sums instead of per-ship ransoms. You can see from the list of treaties that none survived very long.
And the treaties worked so "well" that the US fought the first and second Barbary wars (1801-1805 & 1815), sometimes called collectively the Tripolian War.
Pipes says: "Has the United States ever engaged in a crusade against Islam? No, never. And, what's more, one of the country's earliest diplomatic documents rejects this very idea. [...] This antique treaty implicitly supports my argument that the United States is not fighting Islam the religion but radical Islam, a totalitarian ideology that did not even exist in 1796." Pipes gives this treaty the weight of some major expression of US policy towards Islam. And.. mentions ... as noted by
David Hunter Miller (1875-1961), an expert on American treaties, "the Barlow translation is at best a poor attempt at a paraphrase or summary of the sense of the Arabic."
And yet at the same web page where that quotation came from there is http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/diplomacy/barbary/bar1796n.htm
... Miller also says: "Thus the proclamation was immediate with the ratification and did not await any such formality as notice to the Bey of Tripoli of the ratification of the treaty by the United States. The treaty, like the treaty with the Dey of Algiers of 1795 (Document 17), had been bought; and, as much of the purchase price had already been paid, any subsequent item of procedure was doubtless considered to be of comparatively little importance."
Sooooo … the Senate ratified something already done, a "subsequent item of procedure" that "was doubtless considered to be of comparatively little importance" - rubber stamping a "protection money" treaty.
The foregoing is far too selective a use of sources and rather one constructed for non-too objective argument.
And yes, the Senate did indeed ratify the treaty including the peculiar article 11 that says: "As the Government of the United States is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion; as it has in itself no character of enmity against the law, religion or tranquility of Musselmen; and as the states never have entered into any war or act of hostility against any Mohometan nation, it is declared by the parties that no pretext arising from religious opinion shall ever produce an interruption of harmony existing between the two countries." I.e. the Senate agreed that it has no enmity towards Islam, that the US had no wars (yet) against Islamic states and that religion is not to be a pretext when disputing (har)money. What does that import?
Even if this article is given more importance than it actually carried — where does the article "reject the very idea of a crusade against Islam" as a US policy for the future? It actually implies that if harmony is in point of fact interrupted for a non-religious reason, the US may actually engage in "war or act of hostility towards Islamic states" - which it did (in the two Barbary wars) ...
Incidentally ... from (Marines history division) ... http://hqinet001.hqmc.usmc.mil/HD/Historical/Customes_Traditions/Marines_Hymn.htm
"Following the war with the Barbary Pirates in 1805, when Lieutenant Presely N. O'Bannon and his small force of Marines participated in the capture of Derne and hoisted the American flag for the first time over a fortress of the Old World, the Colors of the Corps was inscribed with the words: "To the Shores of Tripoli."
Jascha Kessler, Professor of English & Modern Literature, UCLA
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
![]() |
![]() |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
retranslation by Snouck Hurgronje cannot be opened [20 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Dag T Elgvin | Nov 20, 2019 05:34 | 256060 | ||
16 | it does not matter that America is not at war with islam, ...islam is at war with America, Canada, Scotland, and the whole world. [93 words] | Phil Greend | Aug 29, 2010 10:34 | 177422 | |
2 | ![]() | Mehmet Keles | Sep 18, 2011 16:09 | 177422 | |
2 | urgent communication on ISLAM AND FRAUD [523 words] | MAR | Jan 27, 2009 12:39 | 149234 | |
RE How Many ? [22 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | A J | Dec 27, 2008 02:57 | 145970 | ||
![]() | Manish | Oct 16, 2009 17:26 | 145970 | ||
I am Not Aware that This Writing...about such a Law, was part of the Administration of President Washington or, [1136 words] | Hazel Davis | Sep 9, 2008 11:28 | 138182 | ||
Neo-conservatism [104 words] | Octavio Johanson | Nov 16, 2006 05:13 | 66293 | ||
1 | America has no choice but to defend European Civilization--but first it must stop bickering and focus on the enemy [1401 words] | Ed Hubbard | Nov 15, 2006 12:31 | 66198 | |
![]() | Jascha Kessler | Nov 14, 2006 15:10 | 66100 | ||
4 | ![]() | Suzanne Sahl | Mar 20, 2007 14:11 | 66100 | |
![]() | H. D. Schmidt | Sep 13, 2009 18:48 | 66100 | ||
What about American Aggression? [184 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Bader S | Nov 11, 2006 05:14 | 65801 | ||
![]() | Bader S | Nov 14, 2006 03:50 | 65801 | ||
![]() | dave viets | Nov 15, 2006 13:52 | 65801 | ||
Clarification please. What is Islam and what is radical Islam? [276 words] | MelM | Nov 10, 2006 23:58 | 65791 | ||
7 | ![]() | Kandara | Nov 11, 2006 20:33 | 65791 | |
![]() | Domenic Pepe | Nov 11, 2006 22:40 | 65791 | ||
![]() | J.S. | Nov 12, 2006 18:06 | 65791 | ||
![]() | zzazzeefrazzee | Nov 13, 2006 11:55 | 65791 | ||
![]() | Judeo-Christ | Nov 13, 2006 13:46 | 65791 | ||
1 | ![]() | MelM | Nov 14, 2006 00:47 | 65791 | |
![]() | E.J. SHAFER | Apr 25, 2007 02:50 | 65791 | ||
Time for a change? Or "How to re-assess who's an 'ally' of the U.S." [219 words] | J.S. | Nov 10, 2006 13:04 | 65758 | ||
America is a strange country [87 words] | f.shakki | Nov 10, 2006 13:03 | 65757 | ||
![]() | Hajaribhai | Nov 10, 2006 19:12 | 65757 | ||
![]() | Donald O | Nov 10, 2006 20:38 | 65757 | ||
![]() | Octavio Johanson | Nov 11, 2006 09:11 | 65757 | ||
![]() | dfwhite | Nov 11, 2006 15:34 | 65757 | ||
![]() | Judeo-Christ | Nov 12, 2006 17:05 | 65757 | ||
![]() | ashmaro | Nov 13, 2006 14:02 | 65757 | ||
1 | ![]() | dfwhite | Nov 13, 2006 16:00 | 65757 | |
![]() | Stephen Phillips | Mar 1, 2007 18:51 | 65757 | ||
![]() | Stephen Phillips | Mar 1, 2007 19:08 | 65757 | ||
![]() | Phil Greend | May 18, 2007 12:19 | 65757 | ||
![]() | 1 | The treaty With Tripoli [130 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Richard B. Parker | Nov 10, 2006 12:57 | 65756 |
![]() | cvt | Oct 24, 2007 11:49 | 65756 | ||
This is no buttering up! just a moment of truth. [148 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Harrak | Nov 9, 2006 23:23 | 65703 | ||
![]() | Infidel | Nov 14, 2006 14:33 | 65703 | ||
![]() | Harrak | Nov 14, 2006 21:47 | 65703 | ||
US "Friendliness with Islam?" [223 words] | Maurice Picow | Nov 9, 2006 16:28 | 65682 | ||
![]() | Infidel | Nov 10, 2006 19:59 | 65682 | ||
![]() | MelM | Nov 10, 2006 21:53 | 65682 | ||
![]() | Maurice Picow | Nov 24, 2006 08:33 | 65682 | ||
Washington's Religious Outlook Towards The Islamic Faiths A Model For Others [132 words] | Philip W. Chapman | Nov 9, 2006 15:30 | 65674 | ||
![]() | ed | Nov 9, 2006 23:09 | 65674 | ||
![]() | Octavio Johanson | Nov 10, 2006 03:46 | 65674 | ||
![]() | Harrak | Nov 11, 2006 00:48 | 65674 | ||
![]() | Octavio Johanson | Nov 12, 2006 14:43 | 65674 | ||
![]() | Octavio Johanson | Nov 12, 2006 16:19 | 65674 | ||
![]() | Harrak | Nov 12, 2006 21:47 | 65674 | ||
![]() | Judeo-Christ | Nov 13, 2006 02:04 | 65674 | ||
![]() | Octavio Johanson | Nov 13, 2006 17:58 | 65674 | ||
![]() | Octavio Johanson | Nov 18, 2006 04:36 | 65674 | ||
Islam and the Islamic Clergy Are the Enemy [195 words] | Domenic Pepe | Nov 9, 2006 01:44 | 65626 | ||
Another interpretation [87 words] | Joel Strom | Nov 9, 2006 01:17 | 65622 | ||
Tripoli Treaty [2085 words] | Paul Rinderle | Nov 8, 2006 19:25 | 65597 | ||
![]() | Bill | Jun 19, 2009 19:59 | 65597 | ||
radical islam existed also in 1796 [153 words] | Martien.Pennings | Nov 8, 2006 18:30 | 65593 | ||
![]() | Octavio Johanson | Nov 9, 2006 16:39 | 65593 | ||
![]() | Gellin and Infidellin | Nov 10, 2006 09:23 | 65593 | ||
Question for Daniel Pipes? [281 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Ron Thompson | Nov 8, 2006 17:50 | 65590 | ||
The United States, 210 years on [149 words] | Octavio Johanson | Nov 8, 2006 14:02 | 65567 | ||
![]() | mark | Nov 9, 2006 12:56 | 65567 | ||
![]() | Alexander | Nov 9, 2006 22:25 | 65567 | ||
![]() | dfwhite | Nov 11, 2006 15:56 | 65567 | ||
Barlow's 11th.article declaring "friendliness with Islam" [3585 words] | Barry Holroyd | Nov 8, 2006 11:49 | 65555 | ||
What Islam Really Wants [58 words] | Mike Ramirez | Nov 8, 2006 10:56 | 65552 | ||
America understood the threat from Jihad terrorism in the 1800's [73 words] | Philip | Nov 8, 2006 10:33 | 65549 | ||
Radical Islam did not exist in 1796 [194 words] | Alfred H. Yoli | Nov 8, 2006 10:07 | 65546 | ||
voa [26 words] | cyrus | Nov 8, 2006 05:19 | 65528 | ||
Nothing Has Changed [488 words] | Caesar Arevalo | Nov 8, 2006 02:24 | 65518 | ||
Same old game [61 words] | David Sabghir | Nov 8, 2006 00:47 | 65510 | ||
The war waged by the Muslims is a war on the Infidels [3444 words] | ahmadnagar3 | Nov 7, 2006 21:29 | 65499 | ||
![]() | Infidel | Nov 9, 2006 13:39 | 65499 | ||
![]() | Jitterboogie | Nov 10, 2006 10:54 | 65499 | ||
Fool's Paradise! [100 words] | Ammar Ahmed | Nov 7, 2006 21:20 | 65498 | ||
1 | ![]() | Judeo-Christ | Nov 8, 2006 23:31 | 65498 | |
![]() | Ammar | Nov 9, 2006 20:17 | 65498 | ||
Totalitarian ideology DID exist before 1796! [397 words] | Martin Henderson | Nov 7, 2006 21:15 | 65497 | ||
the tides of change [148 words] | trans-parere | Nov 7, 2006 19:57 | 65492 | ||
In 1796, U.S. Vowed Friendliness With Islam [135 words] | Amin kobeissy | Nov 7, 2006 18:22 | 65485 | ||
![]() | dhimmi no more | Nov 19, 2006 15:58 | 65485 | ||
Jefferson and Islam 1804 pertaining to this treaty [145 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Jesse Collins | Nov 7, 2006 18:11 | 65484 | ||
Who in Islam recognized this treaty? [230 words] | Pat | Nov 7, 2006 17:50 | 65480 | ||
End the "Stay and Pray" strategy in Iraq and end "harmonious relations" with jihadis [113 words] | MelM | Nov 7, 2006 17:00 | 65473 | ||
![]() | Nalwa | Nov 8, 2006 06:14 | 65473 | ||
![]() | Galu | Nov 18, 2006 06:39 | 65473 | ||
3 | Appeasement of Islam [481 words] | Prof. Paul Eidelberg | Nov 7, 2006 16:53 | 65472 | |
![]() | Harrak | Nov 7, 2006 17:48 | 65472 | ||
![]() | Pat | Nov 7, 2006 18:05 | 65472 | ||
65 | ![]() | Prof. Sharma | Nov 8, 2006 06:32 | 65472 | |
![]() | sgi | Nov 8, 2006 13:18 | 65472 | ||
![]() | J.S. | Nov 8, 2006 17:35 | 65472 | ||
![]() | Eliyahu ben Abraham | Nov 9, 2006 06:45 | 65472 | ||
![]() | Gellin and Infidellin | Nov 10, 2006 09:40 | 65472 | ||
![]() | dfwhite | Nov 11, 2006 16:15 | 65472 | ||
![]() | Pat | Nov 12, 2006 12:24 | 65472 | ||
![]() | Octavio Johanson | Nov 13, 2006 11:09 | 65472 | ||
![]() | Harrak | Nov 15, 2006 14:52 | 65472 | ||
![]() | Octavio Johanson | Nov 16, 2006 19:07 | 65472 | ||
![]() | SG | Oct 21, 2007 16:03 | 65472 | ||
![]() | Tim | Jan 8, 2008 11:39 | 65472 | ||
![]() | Nazia | Oct 7, 2008 12:05 | 65472 | ||
![]() | TY | Jan 8, 2009 16:24 | 65472 | ||
![]() | John O | Feb 25, 2009 08:07 | 65472 | ||
1 | ![]() | jay | May 18, 2009 18:00 | 65472 | |
![]() | Hemingway Wilba | Oct 8, 2009 10:25 | 65472 | ||
![]() | Faruque Ahmed | Jun 30, 2010 12:10 | 65472 | ||
![]() | Tom Martin | Dec 12, 2010 13:54 | 65472 | ||
![]() | hazem | Dec 24, 2010 23:25 | 65472 | ||
![]() | JOE | Dec 26, 2010 01:53 | 65472 | ||
![]() | Anonymous | Jan 26, 2011 19:09 | 65472 | ||
![]() | jo | Feb 1, 2011 20:07 | 65472 | ||
![]() | Ahmet | Mar 8, 2011 23:45 | 65472 | ||
![]() | Ravi Ranjan Singh Bharat Panthi | Mar 12, 2011 22:17 | 65472 | ||
![]() | James Walters | Oct 4, 2011 21:01 | 65472 | ||
![]() | Louis Mathews | Apr 24, 2013 00:03 | 65472 | ||
![]() | Sam | Aug 12, 2013 15:16 | 65472 | ||
![]() | Brute | Dec 16, 2014 07:57 | 65472 | ||
![]() | Ross Hill | Jan 13, 2015 21:20 | 65472 | ||
![]() | Fawad jan | Feb 24, 2015 11:04 | 65472 | ||
long history of Islam's antipathy to the West [170 words] | Shepard Barbash | Nov 7, 2006 15:33 | 65471 | ||
Peace with them, but they are at war with us [140 words] | David W. Lincoln | Nov 7, 2006 15:14 | 65469 | ||
In 1796, U.S. Vowed Friendliness with Islam [147 words] | kim segar | Nov 7, 2006 14:26 | 65466 | ||
![]() | Judeo-Christ | Nov 7, 2006 19:36 | 65466 | ||
![]() | Kuffar | Nov 8, 2006 06:28 | 65466 | ||
![]() | Gellin and Infidellin | Nov 10, 2006 09:44 | 65466 | ||
2 | Real Purpose of the Treaty [112 words] | Sam Pyeatte | Nov 7, 2006 13:39 | 65463 | |
Treaties aren't "signed into law" [49 words] | A. S. Kraditor | Nov 7, 2006 13:37 | 65462 | ||
Mobilization of public opinion in Arab countries [88 words] | Vijay | Nov 7, 2006 13:36 | 65461 | ||
![]() | Infidel | Nov 7, 2006 23:21 | 65461 | ||
Travesty in translation [70 words] | Lowell Bogart | Nov 7, 2006 12:39 | 65460 | ||
America's intentions [300 words] | Safraz | Nov 7, 2006 12:18 | 65458 | ||
![]() | Lewis Loflin | Nov 8, 2006 03:00 | 65458 | ||
1 | ![]() | Pat | Nov 8, 2006 11:44 | 65458 | |
![]() | Mike the infidel | Nov 8, 2006 14:49 | 65458 | ||
![]() | Daisy | Nov 9, 2006 19:29 | 65458 | ||
38 | ![]() | Boura | Nov 9, 2006 22:11 | 65458 | |
![]() | Rahu | Nov 10, 2006 11:35 | 65458 | ||
1 | ![]() | Derek | Feb 14, 2009 12:55 | 65458 | |
1 | ![]() | Buck Crosby | Aug 27, 2010 16:33 | 65458 | |
![]() | ali | Jul 31, 2011 09:16 | 65458 | ||
In 1796, there was no Israel [22 words] | Harrak | Nov 7, 2006 11:52 | 65457 | ||
![]() | Sword of Islam & The Babies of Beslan | Nov 7, 2006 17:20 | 65457 | ||
![]() | Yuval Brandstetter MD | Nov 8, 2006 07:39 | 65457 | ||
2 | ![]() | joe kaffir | Nov 8, 2006 10:25 | 65457 | |
3 | ![]() | Indian Hindu | Nov 9, 2006 06:11 | 65457 | |
![]() | surj | Oct 26, 2007 21:13 | 65457 | ||
![]() | Harrak | Oct 28, 2007 11:05 | 65457 | ||
![]() | Ravi Ranjan Singh Bharat Panthi | Mar 11, 2011 03:05 | 65457 | ||
The Masonic Connection.... [124 words] | DONVAN | Nov 7, 2006 11:12 | 65453 | ||
Offers of Financial Aid [191 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Fredric Fastow | Nov 7, 2006 10:47 | 65452 | ||
1 | ......Fool us twice, shame on us. [72 words] | Jaladhi | Nov 7, 2006 10:24 | 65451 | |
1 | ![]() | Rakesh | Nov 9, 2006 13:09 | 65451 | |
![]() | Ronald Rodrix | Nov 13, 2008 04:00 | 65451 | ||
![]() | Ravi Ranjan Singh Bharat Panthi | Mar 12, 2011 22:13 | 65451 |