Daniel Pipes Mobile Edition Regular Site |
|
Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Other Languages | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List | Search |
Reader comment on item: Turkey's Last Free Election
in response to reader comment: Turkey the land of delusions
Submitted by Ianus (Poland), Jun 16, 2011 at 17:00
Hi, dhimmi no more wrote :
> Can you imagine what would happen to any Turk that writes that there was really an Armenian Genocide?<
The same what happened to Hrant Dink. A minor would be hired to kill him by broad daylight and the police summoned to arrest the killer and investigate the case would first congratulate the killer and take a proud group photo with the Turkish flag flattering around them. But before the cameras of media people they would shed crocodile tears over the victim and even take part in a demonstration "We are all Armenians" ...to fool the naive Westerners.
> There is no pluralism or secularism in Turkey which means that Turkey is not a democracy and will never be one<
I fully agree and I can only add that Turkey was never intended by her so called 'founder' to be a democracy. Kemal founded a one-party system not so different from that of Saddam Hussein or his contemporaries dictators Mussolini, Hitler or his closest friend Lenin.
As to his "secularism" it's also a devious and crooked story.Kemal's war against the Entente between 1919-1922 was a typical jihad with imams,fatwas,services in the mosques on Fridays,promises of paradise and huris,azans etc. etc. Because of that he was honoured with the supreme jihadist Ottoman title "gazi" - "the Destroyers of Infidels". Later when he became a dictator and converted to "secularism" people who mentioned in public the title gazi in its traditional meaning simply disappeared. But in the course of his jihad it turned out that the caliph didn't want to support him. On the contrary the skeih ul-Islam issued a death fatwa against Kemal.The Kemalist counter-fatwa said the caliph was unfree in the hands of the infidels and so teh fatwa wasn't valid and hat is more in secret he was on Kemal's side.But this lie could not last for ever. As the previous fatwa was not revoked by the caliph revered by all Moslems Kemal had no other choice except to depose the cliph and to save his life to fight the force that made the caliph such a formidable enemy, i.e. Islam.
So secularism in Kemal's case was no lofty, far-sighted deep philosophical ideal at all but only an expedient and necessity of which he as a perfect liar knew how to make a virtue.But what obtained personally for him doesn't apply to anybody else in Turkey! He needed something to oppose Islam in order to survive and feel secure in the old palace of the caliph in Constantinople or in the new one built in Angora.The avarage Turk is in a different situation.He takes being a Moslem as granted and no death fatwa with a reward for his head is issued against him.So secularism is for him as alien as shintoism or Taoism.
And if secularism really meant something in Turkey as it does in the West we wouldn't have after 80 years of forced secularization an amazing 99.8% Moslem monoculture but at least 20-30% or more irreligious,agnostics and atheists in Turkey as in Europe where secularism does mean something without a general-prophet of secularism like Kemal ever revealing it to and imposing it by force upon the European public.
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
![]() |
![]() |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Islam is the religion of the Arabs only [74 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | edmond michaels | Dec 22, 2015 00:54 | 227212 | ||
Kurdistan [72 words] | David W. Lincoln | May 25, 2015 20:35 | 223517 | ||
1 | Blame Bush [70 words] | Dave | Apr 24, 2014 16:03 | 214605 | |
Turkey [192 words] | Katie | Jun 14, 2011 00:44 | 186303 | ||
I hope you are wrong [14 words] | Manny Matamoros | Jun 13, 2011 13:42 | 186276 | ||
6 | Right to choose [41 words] | AbuSaad Khan | Jun 13, 2011 12:45 | 186274 | |
2 | ![]() | Naushad Omar | Jun 18, 2011 11:50 | 186274 | |
2 | ![]() | Prashant | Jun 21, 2011 00:11 | 186274 | |
5 | ME expert... [74 words] | aozturk | Jun 13, 2011 10:04 | 186265 | |
6 | Also concerned [154 words] | Ann | Jun 13, 2011 08:59 | 186264 | |
9 | ![]() | Ianus | Jun 15, 2011 18:16 | 186264 | |
2 | ![]() | Bazoonah | Jun 16, 2011 13:54 | 186264 | |
4 | ![]() | Ianus | Jun 18, 2011 04:26 | 186264 | |
2 | ![]() | Naushad Omar | Jun 18, 2011 11:59 | 186264 | |
1 | ![]() | Bazoonah | Jun 20, 2011 04:17 | 186264 | |
8 | ![]() | Ianus | Jun 29, 2011 13:15 | 186264 | |
4 | ![]() | Ianus | Jun 29, 2011 14:21 | 186264 | |
8 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Jun 30, 2011 05:55 | 186264 | |
![]() | Naushad Omar | Jul 9, 2011 18:58 | 186264 | ||
![]() | Naushad Omar | Jul 9, 2011 19:04 | 186264 | ||
3 | ![]() | Prashant | Jul 10, 2011 18:20 | 186264 | |
6 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Jul 12, 2011 07:39 | 186264 | |
2 | ![]() | Ravi Ranjan Singh Bharat Panthi | Jul 21, 2011 14:28 | 186264 | |
4 | Turkey IS gone from the western orbit, if it has ever really been a part of it to begin with.... [114 words] | Adina Kutnicki, Israel | Jun 13, 2011 06:12 | 186262 | |
10 | ![]() | ahmet | Jun 14, 2011 02:28 | 186262 | |
1 | ![]() | Mike | Jun 15, 2011 04:09 | 186262 | |
5 | ![]() | Ianus | Jun 15, 2011 18:45 | 186262 | |
7 | ![]() | Ianus | Jun 15, 2011 20:01 | 186262 | |
3 | ![]() | Naushad Omar | Jun 18, 2011 12:12 | 186262 | |
6 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Jun 18, 2011 16:38 | 186262 | |
5 | ![]() | Ianus | Jun 19, 2011 18:51 | 186262 | |
3 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Jun 20, 2011 07:25 | 186262 | |
1 | ![]() | Prashant | Jun 20, 2011 23:53 | 186262 | |
1 | ![]() | Naushad Omar | Jun 22, 2011 12:49 | 186262 | |
2 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Jun 22, 2011 19:05 | 186262 | |
![]() | sephardi | Jun 24, 2011 19:19 | 186262 | ||
1 | ![]() | Naushad Omar | Jun 25, 2011 14:38 | 186262 | |
2 | ![]() | Naushad Omar | Jun 25, 2011 15:16 | 186262 | |
3 | ![]() | Prashant | Jun 26, 2011 00:43 | 186262 | |
2 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Jun 26, 2011 05:31 | 186262 | |
2 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Jun 26, 2011 06:49 | 186262 | |
1 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Jun 26, 2011 08:17 | 186262 | |
19 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Jun 26, 2011 13:56 | 186262 | |
1 | ![]() | sephardi | Jun 26, 2011 22:00 | 186262 | |
2 | ![]() | Mehmet | Jun 27, 2011 21:03 | 186262 | |
4 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Jun 28, 2011 06:27 | 186262 | |
2 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Jun 28, 2011 07:22 | 186262 | |
2 | ![]() | Mehmet | Jun 29, 2011 02:33 | 186262 | |
4 | ![]() | Ianus | Jun 29, 2011 13:38 | 186262 | |
![]() | sephardi | Jun 29, 2011 14:01 | 186262 | ||
2 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Jun 29, 2011 18:00 | 186262 | |
6 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Jul 1, 2011 05:57 | 186262 | |
![]() | sephardi | Jul 1, 2011 18:45 | 186262 | ||
5 | ![]() | Ianus | Jul 2, 2011 11:01 | 186262 | |
1 | ![]() | sephardi | Jul 2, 2011 19:54 | 186262 | |
2 | ![]() | Ianus | Jul 5, 2011 02:20 | 186262 | |
3 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Jul 5, 2011 08:04 | 186262 | |
5 | ![]() | Ianus | Jul 6, 2011 14:44 | 186262 | |
![]() | sephardi | Jul 6, 2011 22:22 | 186262 | ||
2 | ![]() | sephardi | Jul 7, 2011 23:31 | 186262 | |
2 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Jul 8, 2011 06:55 | 186262 | |
2 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Jul 9, 2011 06:04 | 186262 | |
![]() | Young MC | Jul 10, 2011 19:23 | 186262 | ||
1 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Jul 20, 2011 07:16 | 186262 | |
5 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Jul 20, 2011 13:43 | 186262 | |
![]() | M. Tovey | Jul 29, 2011 18:19 | 186262 | ||
![]() | Islamic Ahimsa | Sep 11, 2011 00:45 | 186262 | ||
![]() | Adil | Oct 20, 2014 14:38 | 186262 | ||
4 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Oct 22, 2014 17:14 | 186262 | |
![]() | Adil | Oct 25, 2014 15:12 | 186262 | ||
![]() | Adil | Oct 26, 2014 17:40 | 186262 | ||
1 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Oct 28, 2014 07:54 | 186262 | |
1 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Oct 28, 2014 17:31 | 186262 | |
1 | ![]() | Prashant | Oct 28, 2014 17:41 | 186262 | |
2 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Oct 29, 2014 07:25 | 186262 | |
![]() | Adil | Oct 31, 2014 12:20 | 186262 | ||
![]() | Adil | Oct 31, 2014 12:22 | 186262 | ||
2 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Nov 2, 2014 08:31 | 186262 | |
3 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Nov 2, 2014 08:35 | 186262 | |
1 | What of Turkey's Foreign Relations? [55 words] | Peter Herz | Jun 13, 2011 05:42 | 186261 | |
1 | Expert Accountability [150 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | kzndr | Jun 12, 2011 22:38 | 186257 | |
Islamist Parties Abroad [109 words] | Sir Daniel M. J. Tobin | Jun 12, 2011 17:37 | 186247 | ||
5 | Election results did not meet PM Erdoğan's expectations [32 words] | soma | Jun 12, 2011 16:44 | 186242 | |
This is a wrongheaded analysis [117 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | Jeff H. | Jun 12, 2011 14:02 | 186235 | ||
11 | ![]() | Ianus | Jun 13, 2011 17:03 | 186235 | |
17 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Jun 14, 2011 06:57 | 186235 | |
1 | ![]() | John | Jun 14, 2011 10:39 | 186235 | |
5 | ![]() | Ianus | Jun 15, 2011 05:15 | 186235 | |
5 | ![]() | Ianus | Jun 16, 2011 17:00 | 186235 | |
11 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Jun 17, 2011 07:21 | 186235 | |
5 | ![]() | Ianus | Jun 17, 2011 15:59 | 186235 | |
2 | ![]() | Prashant | Jun 17, 2011 18:04 | 186235 | |
3 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Jun 19, 2011 18:21 | 186235 | |
1 | ![]() | Ianus | Jun 20, 2011 07:58 | 186235 |