49 readers online now

103,411 comments by 27,309 readers

Go to Mobile Site

He is already in our High Schools!
Reader comment on item: The Iraq Dilemma
in response to reader comment: Howard Zinn on PBS 3/17/03

Submitted by Colleen Willis (United States), May 6, 2007 at 14:14

Many of the replies are from people who say they would not send their child to a school where Howard Zinn's philosophy is being preached.

I found this article while doing research into the ideas that my daughter's high school history teacher has been browbeating the class with. The teacher constantly refers to the United States as an 'Empire', works up the students until they want to take Paris Hilton's wealth from her and redistribute it to the poor, and teaches that the terrorists were justified in their assult on the U.S. on 9/11.

Students that disagree with her are hounded for months on whether they have changed their opinions yet (to an opinion in line with hers). The teacher stated the Alamo was an Imperiallistic act by the U.S. government, while oblivious to the foundation of the Republic of Texas. This is a ninth grade world history class.

The ideas expressed by Howard Zinn have been wholeheartedly accepted by this teacher, who in turn is impressing them upon a group of impressionable youth who do not know enough of the facts of history to even realize the misrepresentations that are being rewritten by Zinn.

Children are being taught these ideas.


Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

Search by Enter name or date
Search Forum Comments:

Reader comments (45) on this item

Title By Date
In Canada [51 words]Gary CathroOct 21, 2007 16:29
What Would Howard Zinn Have Done? [118 words]Don DavidsonNov 8, 2003 14:29
howard zinn [17 words]drew tammaroFeb 11, 2008 14:58
It is scary to read the comments here.... [74 words]Edmond FisherAug 3, 2003 13:00
Howard Zinn needs to be explored [100 words]John AbleMar 18, 2003 19:21
Howard Zinn on PBS 3/17/03 [58 words]William CaldwellMar 18, 2003 18:49
Howard Zinn on PBS 3/17/03 [170 words]Bill FelloMar 17, 2003 22:01
⇒ He is already in our High Schools! [201 words]Colleen WillisMay 6, 2007 14:14
Howard Zinn is a coward [116 words]Halsey WickserMar 17, 2003 21:41
Will this change anything? [321 words]Eric LussierFeb 12, 2003 16:45
True Intelligent Humanitarian Principles [130 words]Jan DunnJan 11, 2003 02:05
Honest American [220 words]Khalil RobinsonDec 6, 2002 00:29
Excellent job [3 words]Greg OfieshOct 15, 2002 01:00
Message for the choir [279 words]Constantine KipnisOct 14, 2002 16:51
David Karnes's open letter [41 words]Jack CaughranOct 13, 2002 11:54
The line must be drawn somewhere! [195 words]Graham PeppercornOct 13, 2002 10:35
Empty rhetoric [346 words]D. WolfOct 13, 2002 00:35
What was supposed to follow the breach of the 1991 agreement? [35 words]Ella OblasOct 11, 2002 16:28
Open Letter- Chair of Boston University Faculty Council [472 words]David KarnesOct 11, 2002 09:58
A Pathetic Tirade by Zinn [14 words]Richard A. FinnOct 11, 2002 07:31
Act III To Come [122 words]Lee D. CaryOct 11, 2002 00:54
Bravo Daniel! Well done in a 2 vs. 1 debate! [59 words]Pete WeissOct 10, 2002 21:42
Don't we learn? [40 words]M. NathanOct 10, 2002 20:19
Thank you. [13 words]Albert GreenbaumOct 10, 2002 17:59
Eagles and weasels! [176 words]SheerahkahnOct 10, 2002 14:32
Here's a good argument [90 words]Josh KatzenOct 10, 2002 14:27
Zinn can always move... [67 words]Glenn KlotzOct 10, 2002 14:12
What Freedom Means [71 words]JeanOct 10, 2002 13:16
Self-control with Howard Zinn [76 words]Joseph GreenbergOct 10, 2002 11:59
WAKE UP JOE!! [117 words]ken johnstonMar 1, 2006 17:21
The Heart of the Left [148 words]SeanOct 10, 2002 11:08
Don't Wait [128 words]"JB" in PGHOct 10, 2002 09:35
An agreement is an agreement. [27 words]Bruce BuntinOct 10, 2002 09:29
Bravo on the superior morals of the US vs. the UN [160 words]Theodore RoseOct 10, 2002 02:35
Who is worse -- Zinn or Chomsky? [208 words]SubhasisOct 10, 2002 02:19
Four years later... [30 words]M WidenerAug 9, 2006 12:33
Changed your minds? [31 words]WalterJun 5, 2008 23:12
Patriotism of Morons? [97 words]Dr. TruthJan 30, 2010 23:14
Your Terrific Arguments! [64 words]Peter SteinOct 10, 2002 01:21
The "Blame America First" Crowd [87 words]Bob GreeneOct 10, 2002 00:56
The World Gone Mad [136 words]Dan EisenbergOct 10, 2002 00:28
Thank you for your diligence and courage [56 words]Phyllys LobdellOct 9, 2002 23:55
Best shot. Congratulations. [82 words]Yuri SOct 9, 2002 23:47
Zinn and the Art of Diversion [225 words]Mary Ann MeierOct 9, 2002 23:45
Hasn't Saddam Already Attacked The U.S.? [54 words]Mike ZeldisOct 9, 2002 23:42

Comment on this item

Name
Email Address (optional)
Title of Comments
Comments:

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See the 25 most recent outstanding comments.

ADVERTISEMENTS

Premium Links by Wikio

Computers
Electronics
Communication
Appliances

eXTReMe Tracker

All materials written by Daniel Pipes on this site © 1968-2010 Daniel Pipes. Email: MeqMef@aol.com

You can help support Daniel Pipes' work by making a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.