1 readers online now  |  69 million page views

Ans. to John Bastille - Palestinians are Not Ancestors of Phillistines -- Nor Are They The Original Inhabitants of Israel

Reader comment on item: Accept Israel as the Jewish State?
in response to reader comment: The Palestinians are victims

Submitted by Sofa Sogood (United States), Dec 6, 2007 at 20:00

First -- Phillistines were an ancient enemy of the early Jews, but they were not native to the land. They had come from somewhere (it can be looked up approximately where) in the northern Mediterranean. After Jewish conquests, almost all the people remaining alive in the area between the Mediterranean and the Jordan River and much surrounding areas became Jews, or likely were driven out -- as Idol worship was prohibited in Jewish lands in those days. This lasted for about 1,000 plus years.

After the return from Babylon, the same was true in the revived nation. This remained so for several more hundred years.

After the Roman conquest and forced diaspora of Jews -- some polytheists from surrounding lands settled there, but then after Constantine, were converted to Christianity. The Muslim conquest brought many Arabs from other Arabian lands to settle in what is now Israel, and they also intermarried with the newly converted. Then the Crusaders drove them out and again converted whoever was left alive. Muslim re-conquest brought more Arabs from other lands. And on and on.

While it's possible that a few of the Palestinians are partially descended from original inhabitants of the land who were first polytheists, then Jews, then Christians, then Muslims, then Christians again and once more Muslims -- since most of the people at the time of the 70 A.D. Roman eviction were Jews who left before all these other invasions -- the numbers of those original inhabitants would have been very few, and they were overwhelmingly mixed, their genes diluted by intermarriage with the other much more populace Arabs from other Arab and possibly non-Arab Muslim lands.

Certainly only a very few might have been fractional descendants of Phillistines who later converted to Islam. The Phillistines who weren't killed off the the early wars, either escaped, or were absorbed into the general population by intermarriage and became Jews. Jews didn't intermarry except by conversion, and this intermarriage was not wide-spread.

And, by the way, some Jews never left during the Roman diaspora, and other Jews always returned to their former lands after the violence of various wars had settled down.

Also, its well documented that during the Ottoman times, the area was highly neglected, ignored and sparsely populated. The overwhelming majority of Palestinians migrated to the area from surrounding lands after the early 1900's.

A good part of that population entered the area after the Mufti of Jerusalem in, I believe, the 1920's, called on Muslim Arabs of all nations to come there to help populate the area with Muslims as a way to overwhelm the migration of early Zionists. (I'm not exactly sure of the year.)

It's a point of history being distorted to the ridiculous regarding descendants of Phillistines -- the only reason they are remembered is because they were mentioned in the Torah as the early enemies of the Jews, and the Romans re-named Judea, Palestina, to humiliate the Jews (i.e. probably -- Phillistine Goliath defeated by tiny David -- so the Roman Goliath defeated the tiny Jews).

And in any case, it's irrelevant to today's issues.

Anyone who is has decent motivations and who takes the time to study the history of current issues can see the absolute absurdity, mandacity and malevolence of today's anti-zionist positions.

After WWI and WWII there were populations transfers involving millions of people. Jews to then Palestine was one of those transfers. (Behind the reasons for this is a very long complex history which can easily be researched.) The result was that the British were obliged to honor their commitments to the Jews, but for many self-serving and also some racist reasons, they renegged, and actually assisted the Arabs in the war of 1947. Oil, access to India, Jew-hatred, arabophilia, etc. etc. It was assumed that the Jews would be wiped out -- (who would have thought they could possibly prevail?) but that didn't happen.

Actually, the words "population transfer" have now become signifiers of evil with regard to Palestinians, but that is exactly what happened to Indians, Cypriots, Turks, Germans, Poles, etc. -- and was considered reasonable -- and still is acceptable for all other nationalities regarding that period of time. But the fact is, although Jews debated the idea, they decided against it. Their one main purpose was self-determination -- that they would not remain governed and therefore usually gravely harmed -- as second-class citizens of other nations. When the "Jewish Homeland" in Palestine was first decided, it was to be in all of what is now Israel and Jordan. Jordan was a vast, empty place. There was so much room, it was decided no one would have to "move." Jews could govern Jews, Arabs could govern Arabs.

Then the dividing of Trans-Jordan and Israel. Then the partitions. Jews were allotted tiny parcels -- which they accepted. Arabs made War on them.

Arabs would allow no Jews to be on Arab lands who were not governed by Arabs. Arabs would not accept the European Jews' migration. Most historical records show that in 1947 most Palestinians fled of their own free will, were forced to flee by fellow Arabs on threat of being considered "collaborators," and some were "transferred" by the Jews. Then, in spite of the Arab villification of any idea of "transfer" regarding Arabs -- they evicted and forced Jews to flee almost every Arab nation (where they had lived for thousands of years) -- which just happens to be a very similar number to the total number of Palestinians who left the area -- whether by their own free will, coersion by other Arabs, or "transfer" -- during the l947 War. So, ultimately a "transfer" did occur with similar numbers on both sides. Also, a large population of Arab-Muslims who stayed, were not "transferred" by the Jews, were given Israeli citizenship with rights and representation in the Knesset. This was done because it was never the Jews intention to "transfer" them, but to live in peace with them. The Israelis believed this could be achieved over the long run, once those citizens grew to appreciate the benefits of the Israeli democracy -- economically, politically and ethically. (And this might well have happened without the interference of the Arab nations to the detriment of their "brothers.")

It seems to me, though I do not know all the facts, that after the 67 War, the Israelis were fully militarily capable of "transferring" the whole population of Arabs in Gaza and the West Bank to Jordan and Egypt. But they didn't.

From around 1967 until the l980's Arabs in the West Bank had a higher standard of living than Arabs in any Arab nations.

There are two reasons this issue has persisted, and Arab and Muslim nations have used and abused their own people, now called Palestinians:

1. No Jew or Christian shall ever have self-determination in any land -- especially in their neighborhood -- which was ever ruled by Muslims.

2. As a rallying point for their subjects to keep their minds occupied away from the injustices in their own countries.

The conflict, from the Muslim point of view, has nothing, nothing to do with how much land, settlements or Palestinian rights. It has only to do with destroying Israel no matter how long it takes.

My question is -- should they succeed in destroying Israel (objective #1) -- which is not impossible given recent events and currents -- and the Muslim world is filled to overflowing with triumphant glory and sense of power -- who will their leaders direct this energy toward (objective #2) instead of the Israelis?

Certainly, they will aim their well-funded and expertly honed (with Western help) propaganda machine against all Jews in the world, and there will be an astonishingly massive revival of rampant (and socially acceptable) anti-semitism which no doubt will engulf our American shores -- and then, secondly, especially once the West jumps on their bandwagon against the Jews, it will be aimed against the West in general.

If you have doubt that the U.S. would condone and even promote any form of racist anti-semitism, refer to Condoleeza, who represents the U.S. Government and the President -- the American Government right here inside the U.S. at Annapolis -- forcing Jews to enter the Conference through the Service Entrance because Arabs refused to enter through the same door -- those Jews including the Prime Minister of Israel and other prominent Israeli officials. Consider the acceptance by Condoleeza of those Arabs refusing to shake hands with Jews at the Conference because they are "unclean." Consider Condoleeza's acceptance at the Conference of those Arabs removing the translation earbuds from their ears as Olmert and other Jews addressed the Conference.

Condoleeza Rice, African-American, member of a race horrifically victimized by racism, Secretary of State of the United States of America, encouraging by accommodation -- vile, humiliating racism against Jews. And President George Bush, the Mainstream Media, TV Talk Shows -- say nothing.

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".


Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (96) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Jews and Christians, you have natural friend ; Sikh [1820 words]Ravi Ranjan Singh BharatPanthiAug 29, 2010 18:23177433
Gaza Once Beautiful But Now Wasted Land Used As A War Zone [143 words]D.K. Milgrim-HeathJun 6, 2010 17:41173962
Jews are a tribe or nation, as are Celts, Angles, Saxons, Arabs, Navajo, Sioux, Poles, and so on. [268 words]JgarbuzApr 18, 2009 18:56154065
but where should the state be? [21 words]AndrusNov 3, 2009 02:35154065
2The Jewish state should be in the same place it was 3000 years ago. [112 words]JgarbuzNov 10, 2009 14:03154065
I speak of Israel and their enemy Hamas [49 words]Tess McNamaraJan 5, 2009 10:03146984
political nomenclature [20 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
lenny rudermanJul 9, 2008 09:18134701
Abraham Burg speaking my language [112 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
HarraKJun 26, 2008 10:02133460
1Maccabean Resistance [1956 words]Ed WarmothJan 3, 2008 00:50117386
A JEWISH STATE [37 words]Tom SmithDec 22, 2007 16:03116814
They have already accepted a Jewish State [128 words]NigelDec 20, 2007 15:42116695
1Fair Enough [29 words]A PakistaniDec 17, 2007 10:39116338
ALL OF ISRAEL [36 words]DoloresDec 17, 2007 04:23116319
Not an inch [11 words]kafir by faithAug 30, 2010 03:56116319
Accept Israel as the Jewish State? [16 words]Alex SabyDec 16, 2007 19:51116293
The Natural Rights Of Nations [220 words]Seamus MacNemiDec 10, 2007 21:30115999
War of Womb [20 words]alex SabyDec 9, 2007 12:09115961
Israel For Jews Only [40 words]surjDec 28, 2007 20:09115961
War of Womb [37 words]Alex SabyDec 30, 2007 23:23115961
surj, you think that "Israel MUST be completely Palestinian free Zone" [12 words]JackAug 14, 2008 03:00115961
Egypt is the world's biggest center of antisemitic literature [6 words]Adam EylatDec 8, 2007 04:38115910
Indeed, very precious source, Adam [5 words]YnnatchkahDec 8, 2007 20:46115910
Right Answer Wrong Question [176 words]JayDec 6, 2007 22:16115848
Hard to Believe [49 words]BlackspeareDec 9, 2007 14:09115841
Ignorance, Smarm ... [122 words]Sofa SogoodDec 15, 2007 02:38115841
Touchy, touchy Sofa [41 words]BlackspeareDec 16, 2007 18:26115841
"Zionist = Jew" is the most significant revelation in 60 years. [437 words]DrRJPDec 6, 2007 10:34115821
Blast from the past (well the 80's) [81 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Nehemia SternDec 4, 2007 16:52115730
1Muslim peace wants to kill my freedom! [39 words]Jorge CordovaDec 4, 2007 07:21115696
Let's Not Kid Ourselves [395 words]BlackspeareDec 2, 2007 18:08115589
Defeated Arab State? [35 words]donvanDec 3, 2007 08:49115589
Duh [17 words]Linda HaslamDec 3, 2007 11:45115589
Reply to Ms. Haslam [79 words]BlackspeareDec 4, 2007 09:12115589
Accepting Israel is THE Jewish State is not the Question, But the Answer! [772 words]M. ToveyDec 4, 2007 13:27115589
Free Elections and Hamas [71 words]David SternlightDec 4, 2007 14:16115589
The Theory of the Second Best [119 words]RAMDec 4, 2007 15:55115589
Palestinian situation [171 words]Linda HaslamDec 6, 2007 10:29115589
Reply #2 to Ms. Haslam [160 words]BlackspeareDec 8, 2007 17:32115589
Unintended Consequences [20 words]Linda HaslamDec 13, 2007 11:19115589
Dr Pipes could you please explain? [151 words]DurendalDec 2, 2007 11:10115575
Re: Terrorism and Terrorist Attacks,Two Eternal Constants [125 words]TTSDec 1, 2007 13:43115537
You have to fight terror with terror!!! [225 words]JaladhiDec 1, 2007 17:31115537
religious text and violence [45 words]Richard BilsonDec 2, 2007 17:44115537
The Old Testament is more violent than the Qur'an? [140 words]jennifer solisDec 2, 2007 21:07115537
some details? [28 words]EsmeraldaDec 3, 2007 02:13115537
Quranic peace.. [80 words]DONVANDec 3, 2007 09:05115537
Ayat al sayaf says it all about peacefulness of Quran - Richard Bilson!!!! [148 words]JaladhiDec 3, 2007 10:17115537
What??? [82 words]Linda HaslamDec 3, 2007 11:55115537
Religion Does Violence to Truth-Seek Truth, Not Religion [228 words]M. ToveyDec 3, 2007 13:37115537
Ah - the old saw about Old Testament versus Koran [92 words]SullyDec 3, 2007 18:25115537
Worse [24 words]BlackspeareDec 9, 2007 22:30115537
To Richard Bilson [230 words]surjDec 27, 2007 17:16115537
re. Richard Bilson [49 words]LarryJan 13, 2008 19:59115537
The Blinding Truth-Israel Will Always Be There [439 words]M. ToveyNov 30, 2007 11:39115436
Jewishness of Israel is 3000 Years Older Than Zionism [150 words]Jerome R VerlinNov 30, 2007 10:25115427
Sudetenland in Galilee [30 words]David ZoharNov 30, 2007 04:03115405
I've said it before and I'll say it again... [14 words]thereisnosantaclausNov 29, 2007 23:58115391
As long as there is infidels on muslim land, there shall be no peace [356 words]John BastileNov 29, 2007 22:53115384
The Palestinians are not victims [64 words]Stephen PhillipsDec 2, 2007 12:32115384
Global Wedge Issue [111 words]Linda HaslamDec 3, 2007 12:16115384
The Palestinians are victims [265 words]John BastileDec 4, 2007 12:31115384
Mohammed and the Jews [89 words]David SternlightDec 4, 2007 14:31115384
Ans. to John Bastille - Palestinians are Not Ancestors of Phillistines -- Nor Are They The Original Inhabitants of Israel [1495 words]Sofa SogoodDec 6, 2007 20:00115384
Muslims will never accept Israel [20 words]treytonMay 29, 2008 22:25115384
The Palestinian conflict [574 words]JeremiahMar 16, 2010 03:48115384
the scratched record of negotiations [226 words]Rebecca MouldsNov 29, 2007 16:44115344
While we wait for the promise to Abraham [186 words]jennifer solisDec 2, 2007 22:25115344
When Vision is Dim, Turn to D Pipes! [78 words]Billy SublettNov 29, 2007 14:38115334
The Usual Islamic Assertiveness... [200 words]GeoffNov 29, 2007 12:53115325
Daniel is explicit about the real, existential, and non-militarily-addressed threats to Israel [257 words]Charles MartelNov 29, 2007 11:44115314
Israel as a Jewish state. [323 words]ronNov 29, 2007 11:27115313
Israel and conflict [160 words]David SternlightDec 4, 2007 15:08115313
There is (definitely) nothing to talk about. [57 words]Michael JoyceNov 29, 2007 11:04115308
Lies of the US Government [49 words]VijayNov 29, 2007 07:20115282
Hope Olmert sticks to his demand [74 words]VijayNov 29, 2007 07:17115281
Much ado about nothing [363 words]Ken BesigNov 29, 2007 06:01115277
Olmert will drop the requirement [93 words]GabrielNov 29, 2007 03:36115268
Successful duplicity tactic ! [87 words]Anne-Marie DelcambreNov 29, 2007 03:14115267
The Jews need to accept Israel as the Jewish State [221 words]MeirNov 29, 2007 02:33115264
Who is a Jew? [49 words]David SternlightDec 4, 2007 14:52115264
comment on : "Who is a Jew?" [148 words]MeirDec 5, 2007 13:38115264
silence of the lambs [221 words]housam jarrarNov 28, 2007 23:58115249
FYI [69 words]harold erdmanDec 1, 2007 11:51115249
short formulations are necessary [92 words]G.VishvasNov 28, 2007 23:11115241
Hypocrisy of the Palestinians [262 words]jennifer solisNov 28, 2007 22:40115239
Faulty Translation [69 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
BlackspeareNov 28, 2007 20:47115234
to Blackspear and Pipes [20 words]TariqSep 19, 2009 15:15115234
Translation [19 words]BadriNov 2, 2009 02:37115234
Erekat's lies and hypocrisy!!! [230 words]JaladhiNov 28, 2007 20:39115232
1Reality at last! [136 words]Mary ConnorNov 29, 2007 02:12115232
The great Dr. Pipes- revealing to us what is THE basic issue: Piece process not Peace process [169 words]James BurkeNov 29, 2007 09:29115232
Arab League can put pressure on Palestinians. [141 words]KatteyNov 29, 2007 13:30115232
yet another ... [45 words]donvanNov 30, 2007 14:39115232
What Does It Mean To Be Jewish? [389 words]Seamus MacNemiDec 12, 2007 08:07115232
wake up [181 words]surjDec 27, 2007 15:07115232

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to Ans. to John Bastille - Palestinians are Not Ancestors of Phillistines -- Nor Are They The Original Inhabitants of Israel by Sofa Sogood

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List


eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2018 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum. Daniel J. Pipes