Daniel Pipes Mobile Edition Regular Site |
|
Home | Articles | Blog | Reviews | Spoken | Books | Other Languages | Biographical | Middle East Forum | About this site | Mailing List | Search |
Reader comment on item: More on the Muslim Claim to Jerusalem
in response to reader comment: Lactantius Jr, I think you misunderstood my comments
Submitted by Elliott (Israel), Nov 6, 2008 at 08:21
Arab spokesmen have been doing Temple denial for a long time. In 1984 [or 1983? ] a woman named Grace Hazlitt wrote an anti-Israel article for Christian Century. She claimed that a high Muslim official in Jerusalem has told her that the Jewish Temple was not really where the Jews said it was, that is at the Temple Mount, what the Muslims call Haram al-Sharif. The real ancient Jewish temple had supposedly been located in Western Jerusalem, according to the high ranking Muslim, as reported by Grace Hazlitt.
The problem is that this silly Ms Hazlitt believed the Muslim, not the Jews. She writes in this very serious, very confidential tone: I was told by so-and-so, who is the imam or the mufti or whatever, that blah blah. She made the mistake of believing what a politically interested party whispered in her ear.
In fact, there is abundant proof about the ancient Temple, including many archeological discoveries since the Six Day War. It is noteworthy, as Ugri quotes above, that in the 1920s the Muslim officials were very proud to conrtol the Temple Mount and freely admitted that it was the site of Solomon"s Temple. Since the 1920s, however, a need for new lies has arisen. So new lies have been created by the exponents of the Arab cause.
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".
<< Previous Comment Next Comment >>
![]() |
![]() |
Title | Commenter | Date | Thread |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Why Islam Cannot Claim Jerusalem - Temple Mount Prophecy Already Fulfilled from Time of Romans Before Islam Arrived [155 words] | M Tovey | Jul 23, 2022 22:21 | 284097 | ||
![]() | M Tovey | Jul 29, 2022 10:19 | 284097 | ||
![]() | Denial of Jewish history is fake news [209 words] | Dave | Jul 22, 2022 15:10 | 284050 | |
1 | Is there a testament of Iftikhar? [62 words] w/response from Daniel Pipes | martin walker | Jun 16, 2016 07:23 | 230029 | |
![]() | Daryl Locklear | Jul 12, 2021 19:05 | 230029 | ||
Israel Liberated Judea and Samaria - Just like U.S. and its allies liberated Kuwait [86 words] | YJ Draiman | May 17, 2015 20:50 | 223398 | ||
The Jewish peoples war of survival was not won when Hitler lost. It continues to this day [610 words] | YJ Draiman | May 11, 2015 03:29 | 223307 | ||
2 | Thanks for the link to Leah Bat-Chaim's Why Jerusalem is Not Holy to Muslims [56 words] | Joe Black | Dec 23, 2009 03:11 | 166165 | |
3 | Arabs and Muslims have no authority to claim Jerusalem [227 words] | Bestley Joe | Dec 11, 2009 08:14 | 165657 | |
How can we expect anything human (or decent) from wacko self proclaimed genius historian Shamekh Alawneh? [260 words] | Svet | Aug 28, 2009 03:19 | 160712 | ||
Zechariah 12 [128 words] | Ugri | Aug 8, 2009 08:35 | 159834 | ||
![]() | BK | Sep 25, 2009 18:12 | 159834 | ||
![]() | Ugri | Sep 27, 2009 04:42 | 159834 | ||
Tick Tock. [112 words] | Lynn | Jul 6, 2009 10:21 | 158530 | ||
TEMPLE MOUNT [9 words] | Fred | Jan 5, 2009 12:14 | 147018 | ||
Undeniable claim to Jerusalem [102 words] | Rebecca Moulds | Jan 4, 2009 23:38 | 146929 | ||
![]() | Ugri | Jan 11, 2009 01:33 | 146929 | ||
Mosque on top of the claimants rock. [132 words] | Lynn | Dec 11, 2008 08:44 | 144903 | ||
More on the muslim claim to Jerusalem [109 words] | Debbie | Dec 3, 2008 23:12 | 144369 | ||
3 | where were the jews during the past 3000 year, why they did not claim the land? [72 words] | sTs | Nov 19, 2008 11:37 | 143278 | |
![]() | Ugri | Nov 21, 2008 01:59 | 143278 | ||
1 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Nov 30, 2008 07:58 | 143278 | |
![]() | catarin | Dec 5, 2008 00:56 | 143278 | ||
![]() | MeeToo | Jan 9, 2009 09:20 | 143278 | ||
4 | ![]() | sTs | Jan 10, 2009 04:57 | 143278 | |
![]() | Lynn | Aug 30, 2009 10:00 | 143278 | ||
Arch of Titus [56 words] | Ugri | Nov 6, 2008 11:13 | 142251 | ||
muslim imperialism [128 words] | G.Vishvas | Nov 5, 2008 05:36 | 142104 | ||
Great! [11 words] | New York University | Oct 31, 2008 16:34 | 141664 | ||
Apples and oranges [149 words] | Rebecca Moulds | Sep 2, 2008 13:53 | 137854 | ||
![]() | Ugri | Sep 3, 2008 01:36 | 137854 | ||
![]() | Kattey | Nov 10, 2008 20:38 | 137854 | ||
2 | Moses, Jesus, Mohammad are ALL Muslims [95 words] | Ahmad | Aug 30, 2008 05:55 | 137656 | |
6 | ![]() | The Grand Infidel of Kaffiristan | Aug 30, 2008 23:54 | 137656 | |
![]() | Ynnatchkah | Sep 3, 2008 22:22 | 137656 | ||
2 | ![]() | Kattey | Nov 18, 2008 17:47 | 137656 | |
![]() | jennifer solis | Nov 29, 2008 16:13 | 137656 | ||
1 | ![]() | dhimmi no more | Nov 30, 2008 07:18 | 137656 | |
2 | ![]() | sTs | Dec 1, 2008 03:18 | 137656 | |
1 | ![]() | Kattey | Dec 1, 2008 21:22 | 137656 | |
![]() | sTs | Dec 3, 2008 01:12 | 137656 | ||
1 | ![]() | Anne | Dec 3, 2008 23:34 | 137656 | |
2 | ![]() | sTs | Dec 4, 2008 10:11 | 137656 | |
2 | ![]() | sTs | Dec 5, 2008 00:48 | 137656 | |
![]() | dhimmi no more | Dec 5, 2008 07:23 | 137656 | ||
![]() | dhimmi no more | Dec 5, 2008 07:35 | 137656 | ||
![]() | Debbie | Dec 5, 2008 20:37 | 137656 | ||
![]() | dhimmi no more | Dec 6, 2008 10:42 | 137656 | ||
![]() | dhimmi no more | Dec 6, 2008 11:01 | 137656 | ||
1 | ![]() | Zen | Dec 13, 2008 01:04 | 137656 | |
![]() | Zen | Dec 13, 2008 01:23 | 137656 | ||
![]() | sTs | Dec 15, 2008 06:17 | 137656 | ||
![]() | sTs | Dec 15, 2008 10:06 | 137656 | ||
![]() | Debbie | Dec 15, 2008 20:32 | 137656 | ||
2 | ![]() | Ifrahim | Jan 5, 2009 22:38 | 137656 | |
![]() | Seif Al Deen | Jan 9, 2009 08:19 | 137656 | ||
![]() | D.Gerard Sebolf | Feb 22, 2009 09:27 | 137656 | ||
![]() | Roy Mason | Oct 1, 2009 06:43 | 137656 | ||
![]() | Alwyn | Oct 25, 2009 12:36 | 137656 | ||
![]() | hiall | Mar 4, 2014 04:27 | 137656 | ||
Here is a Strange Exception [37 words] | Alex | Aug 18, 2008 11:48 | 136948 | ||
WHY NOT GIVE THEM A CHOICE? [20 words] | IamJoseph | Aug 18, 2008 05:44 | 136931 | ||
A Brilliant Idea? What are they smoking? [462 words] | Lame Cherry | Aug 18, 2008 02:38 | 136924 | ||
Q17:1 [641 words] | dhimmi no more | Jul 27, 2008 13:16 | 135742 | ||
3 | muslim greed, more greed and fascism [216 words] | G.Vishvas | Jul 23, 2008 05:53 | 135582 | |
The Qur'an does not say the Prophet was taken to Jerusalem [123 words] | Akbarally Meherally | Jun 26, 2008 07:25 | 133453 | ||
The Temple Mount as a Flashpoint [29 words] | Yisrael Medad | Mar 12, 2008 06:48 | 122473 | ||
Can anyone be a Muslim and STILL defend the name Palestine? [138 words] | Dillah | Jan 25, 2008 23:06 | 119001 | ||
What Muslim holy sites? [195 words] | Kattey | Dec 15, 2007 21:34 | 116228 | ||
![]() | demonarundo | Mar 9, 2008 16:45 | 116228 | ||
![]() | Kattey | Mar 10, 2008 23:24 | 116228 | ||
![]() | demonarundo | Mar 12, 2008 07:53 | 116228 | ||
![]() | Kattey | Mar 13, 2008 16:54 | 116228 | ||
islam thinks the whole world belongs to allaha [76 words] | phil Greend | Aug 31, 2007 19:15 | 107411 | ||
![]() | demonarundo | Mar 9, 2008 16:32 | 107411 | ||
Making colonisation appear indigenous! [113 words] | leigh | Jun 2, 2007 05:48 | 95748 | ||
![]() | Dan the Yid | Aug 17, 2007 04:00 | 95748 | ||
![]() | ilham | Jul 7, 2016 06:01 | 95748 | ||
Proof positive; Jerusalem, Israel belong to Muslims [170 words] | Infidel | Nov 26, 2006 19:34 | 67422 | ||
24 | ![]() | Lactantius Jr. | Jun 5, 2007 15:50 | 67422 | |
1 | ![]() | Infidel | Jun 5, 2007 23:18 | 67422 | |
![]() | Elliott | Nov 6, 2008 08:21 | 67422 | ||
![]() | sTs | Dec 1, 2008 03:20 | 67422 | ||
1 | ![]() | Lactantius Jr | Dec 3, 2008 07:06 | 67422 | |
5 | ![]() | sTs | Dec 4, 2008 07:10 | 67422 | |
![]() | sTs | Dec 4, 2008 11:11 | 67422 | ||
![]() | Lactantius Jr | Dec 5, 2008 05:12 | 67422 | ||
![]() | Lactantius Jr | Dec 5, 2008 06:25 | 67422 | ||
![]() | dhimmi no more | Dec 6, 2008 09:17 | 67422 | ||
![]() | dhimmi no more | Dec 7, 2008 08:29 | 67422 | ||
![]() | dhimmi no more | Dec 7, 2008 09:02 | 67422 | ||
![]() | Dale Brown | Dec 6, 2009 21:27 | 67422 | ||
![]() | Al -Aqsa | Jan 21, 2010 15:20 | 67422 | ||
![]() | Lactantius Jr | Feb 19, 2010 17:53 | 67422 | ||
![]() | Hilme | Feb 28, 2010 09:29 | 67422 | ||
![]() | Lactantius Jr | Feb 28, 2010 17:23 | 67422 | ||
1 | ![]() | Omar Saleh | May 17, 2010 23:10 | 67422 | |
![]() | dhimmi no more | May 19, 2010 07:47 | 67422 | ||
1 | ![]() | Omar | May 19, 2010 22:56 | 67422 | |
![]() | dhimmi no more | May 20, 2010 17:27 | 67422 | ||
![]() | dhimmi no more | May 20, 2010 18:09 | 67422 | ||
![]() | dhimmi no more | May 20, 2010 18:20 | 67422 | ||
![]() | dhimmi no more | May 22, 2010 08:01 | 67422 | ||
1 | ![]() | Angela | Jun 14, 2010 09:20 | 67422 | |
1 | ![]() | yomna | Oct 1, 2011 17:37 | 67422 | |
1 | ![]() | Lactantius Jr | Oct 5, 2011 04:43 | 67422 | |
![]() | saqib | Feb 19, 2013 00:25 | 67422 | ||
![]() | dhimmi no more | Feb 20, 2013 07:04 | 67422 | ||
![]() | hammar | Jul 13, 2013 15:00 | 67422 | ||
![]() | bla bla black sheep | Apr 21, 2017 19:48 | 67422 |