69 million page views

2007 Marked 40 years to the creation of such a term as "Palestinians" by sons/grandsons of Arab immigrants / settlers in Israel "Palestine"

Reader comment on item: Israel is Winning
in response to reader comment: Myth of the palestinian people

Submitted by Al (Spain), Jan 9, 2008 at 15:16

2007 Marked 40 years to the creation of such a term as "Palestinians" by sons/grandsons of Arab immigrants / settlers in Israel "Palestine"

The "Palestinians", no one even bothers anymore to look into this fake term that has become coined into the dictionary by bombarding Arabists anti Israel propaganda.

The Israeli Jews are actually the true "Palestinians".

It is precisely because there is such a great intentional confusion -- or worse, even a myth about the Arab group that are mostly children or grandchildren of immigrants from other Arab countries that came mainly between late 1800 and early 1900, rewriting history as if they are anything of "original inhabitants " -- that it's imperatuve to stress it clearly, that this whole "Palestinian" thing is based on a lie, that the "root" of the Arab invaders are are basically root-less.

Are the Palestinians native to the land where Israel now exists?
"The fact is that today's Palestinians are immigrants from the surrounding nations! (former Arab "Palestinian" terrorist admits) I grew up well knowing the history and origins of today's Palestinians as being from Yemen, Saudi Arabia, Morocco, Christians from Greece, Muslim Sherkas from Russia, Muslims from Bosnia, and the Jordanians next door. The civil and tribal wars between Yemmenites (from Yemen) and Kessites (from Banu Kais of Saudi Arabia) ... are well known among Palestinians.
Travellers (from 1590 to 1867) to Palestine from the Western world left records of what they saw there. The theme throughout their reports is dismal: The land was empty, neglected, abandoned, desolate, fallen into ruins.
By 1948, the Arabs had still not yet discovered their ancient nation of Falastin . When they were offered half of Palestine west of the Jordan River for a state, the offer was violently rejected. Six Arab states launched a war of annihilation against the nascent State of Israel. Their purpose was not to establish an independent Falastin. Their aim was to partition western Palestine amongst themselves.

"Palestine" refers to an area that the Romans have named the vast area of Israelites/Jews' Israel - Jewish Judea, after they destroyed the Jewish temple and exiled most Jews from their land , PALESTINE NEVER EXISTED Further, there has never been a Palestinian state governed by Arab Palestinians in history, nor was there ever a serious Arab-Palestinian national movement, ..there was never an Arab sovereign state in the area, and of course so far, at the beginning of 2008, no country by that name "Palestine" ever existed until today (in Jan. 2008) .

The Arabization that has swept across the middle east stepping on all native people, has created the false perception that the middle east has always been originally Arab. for "thousands" of years.

A perception that the Arab "Palestinian" Pallywood industry knows all too well how to take advantage of it, Who can count the term "indigenous" that this group of liars have mentioned in their monstrous global propaganda greased by Arab Goliath oil?

After the 1967 war when Goliath of Arab nations in a fascist attempt (again) to annihilate Israel (like always) lost to little David that Arafat and his group came up with a great idea of a "Palestinian" people, in which they can use it as a great anti-Israel weapon, the idea of attaching the name of the area to the group of people.

Politically motivated mythology of Palestine The one identity never seriously considered until the 1967 Six-Day War -- and then only as a "tool" -- was an "Arab Palestinian" one.

The goal is to achieve a "right", as the group of Arab immigrants into the land of the Jews are supposedly named by this area 'obviously they must be "from" here'...

No matter what happens next, even if a "Palestine" state will be established, the truth must be told, and in that scenario the Arabs have to kiss kind Israel's feet (as for so many reasons, including treating Arabs as equal great citizens of its beautiful democracy, something that any other Arab population so far has not been fortunate to have) for letting them get away with it.

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (65) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Israel is winning. [99 words]AnneJan 15, 2009 11:50148121
How Luciferian! Black is white and white is black? [94 words]David Ben-ArielNov 30, 2005 10:5029141
Sharon: a losing attitude [223 words]Gabriel GrossoJan 2, 2003 17:105432
Negotiations [177 words]Gabriel GrossoDec 30, 2002 12:575301
Jews and Zionism [67 words]MikeNov 27, 2002 08:394275
There will be peace, someday - But When? [505 words]J ReindersNov 13, 2002 14:573870
I ask again, winning what? [88 words]Greg OfieshOct 15, 2002 22:033094
Thanks [156 words]Constance SchraderAug 19, 2002 14:091990
Jews should get back part of Saudi Arabia [67 words]Jeff GestemerAug 15, 2002 20:441945
cant agree with you more. [26 words]Meir DavidoffJul 30, 2007 15:101945
a parallel (Carey) [31 words]CiarĂ¡nAug 12, 2002 15:451779
they're only regrouping [94 words]larryAug 11, 2002 23:581766
Re "Israel is Winning" [159 words]Arlene SwartzmanAug 11, 2002 19:561763
European Union Disdain again [202 words]NoraAug 11, 2002 11:511762
Winning? Different rules & a different game! [163 words]Joshua ReubenAug 11, 2002 03:401758
Recognition of the Jewish People's historical right to the Land of Israel [58 words]Steve AdlerAug 11, 2002 02:281757
Stop EU money being used to finance terror in Israel! [32 words]JohannaVAug 10, 2002 18:121755
Do Palestinians need to continue this life of misery? [140 words]Chee-kuen LeongAug 9, 2002 09:241736
Swedish perspective [86 words]Filippa von PlatenAug 9, 2002 08:451733
Positive,optimistic article [46 words]Ella BlesofskyAug 9, 2002 02:441728
Myth of the palestinian people [1566 words]Israeli101Aug 9, 2002 01:191727
2007 Marked 40 years to the creation of such a term as "Palestinians" by sons/grandsons of Arab immigrants / settlers in Israel "Palestine" [681 words]AlJan 9, 2008 15:161727
I agree completely Israeli101 [40 words]Emmanuel Etchells-AyreOct 7, 2009 15:331727
Israelis are winning [54 words]Freda FloodAug 8, 2002 23:551725
You must have been watching too many blown-up busses. [175 words]Moishe SachsAug 8, 2002 23:101724
Pipes is right [228 words]Ben ShniperAug 8, 2002 20:441721
Israel Is Winning [81 words]Arnold MillanAug 8, 2002 19:141720
This has been my prayer... [59 words]DonnaAug 8, 2002 18:131719
Accountability is a foreign concept [45 words]Stephen PaulAug 8, 2002 17:511718
No joy [80 words]Henry RosenbergAug 8, 2002 17:261717
Why Israel has already won. [261 words]IamJosephAug 8, 2002 10:291711
WHO SAID "WINNING ISN'T EVERYTHING? [309 words]Norman MannAug 8, 2002 09:451710
optimism for Israel [17 words]MotherAug 8, 2002 09:401709
How Israel will win [103 words]EricAug 8, 2002 01:141706
Comment on "Israel is winning". [140 words]A. M. BerlinAug 8, 2002 00:431705
RE: Only themselves to blame- Jim 8/6/02 [158 words]Arthur HutchinsonAug 7, 2002 23:091703
Questions [178 words]David BaschAug 7, 2002 21:491699
Confirmation of Israel's Winning [34 words]Evelyn SepinAug 7, 2002 21:031696
THE RULES OF HAMA [273 words]Bruce JosloffAug 7, 2002 19:491694
European Union disdain [164 words]John Randall PeacherAug 7, 2002 17:171692
The supply lines must be cut first [294 words]Aaron NaganoAug 7, 2002 16:321690
Israel winning yes, but..... [224 words]doody kaminskieAug 7, 2002 14:501689
Desperate Palestinians is not a good sign [65 words]NoaAug 7, 2002 14:181686
Israel wins only when we stop kowtowing to the Saudis [56 words]Sy SteinbergAug 7, 2002 14:051685
Israel is losing [72 words]Mark WeingradAug 7, 2002 13:591684
Israel is winning? [36 words]Steven JacobyAug 7, 2002 13:531683
Hope! [60 words]Byron LieberwitzAug 7, 2002 13:371682
Palestinians only get financial support from "Brethren Arabs" for Murders committed [467 words]Lila B. ReismanAug 7, 2002 13:131680
But Do the Palestinians Know That Their Leadership Is To Blame? [44 words]Diane HuntAug 7, 2002 13:091679
Correction: WE are winning [540 words]Peter NewtonAug 7, 2002 12:331678
A parallel [90 words]Carey StronachAug 7, 2002 12:311677
How Can Israel Win? [148 words]Steve HessAug 7, 2002 12:031676
And then what? [240 words]Ethan CoreyAug 7, 2002 12:021675
Who is winning what? [32 words]L SoczkaAug 7, 2002 04:261672
A certain view of things [386 words]TRAug 7, 2002 03:501671
This Is Winning? [259 words]Gary VinebergAug 6, 2002 23:041667
Nobody is Winning! [85 words]Michoel ZeldisAug 6, 2002 22:511666
Palestinians as Proxies [112 words]Jack AjzenbergAug 6, 2002 20:191658
It's hard to be optimistic [96 words]Lawrence ShmerelAug 6, 2002 18:231656
Only themselves to blame [79 words]Jim ClelandAug 6, 2002 18:091655
Moral Loss [113 words]Ivan M. LangAug 6, 2002 17:181654
Wonderfully written article! [73 words]YaelAug 6, 2002 16:491651
They need to get civilized [71 words]Charles SelbeAug 6, 2002 16:231650
Wishful thinking [232 words]Glenn KlotzAug 6, 2002 14:291644
Little sympathy for Palestinians [195 words]Jeff BercovitchAug 6, 2002 12:021641

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)