2 readers online now  |  69 million page views

Please stop your generalizations and grouping.

Reader comment on item: The Fatal Stabbing of Angelo Frammartino, Palestinian Apologist

Submitted by Gracie (United States), Sep 1, 2006 at 00:31

I love how people ... always like to blame the left for everything. In this article you make my point for me. You write, "..., espoused the typical anti-Israel views of a far-leftist..."

... FYI, many people on the right - the far right even - make anti-Israel comments, do not support the Jewish state, and, in fact, just don't like Jews, period. Let me give you a few examples to freshen your memory:

Pat Robertson:
"God considers this land to be his. You read the Bible and he says 'This is my land,' and for any prime minister of Israel who decides he is going to carve it up and give it away, God says, 'No, this is mine.' ... He was dividing God's land. And I would say, 'Woe unto any prime minister of Israel who takes a similar course to appease the E.U., the United Nations, or the United States of America.' God says, 'This land belongs to me. You better leave it alone.'" --Pat Robertson, on why Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon suffered a massive stroke

Patrick J. Buchanan
Subject: Buchanan aides beat up Jewish protestors Date: 20 Mar 1995 13:06:34 -0500 Organization: America Online, Inc. (1-800-827-6364) March 20, 1995 FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: Contact Judy Balint 718-884-8499. JEWISH ANTI-BUCHANAN PROTESTORS BEATEN AND KICKED AT CAMPAIGN KICK-OFF RALLY IN NEW HAMPSHIRE Three members of the Coalition for Jewish Concerns-Amcha demonstrating against Pat Buchanan's anti-Semitism and bigotry were beaten, kicked and thrown down stairs by Buchanan security guards and campaign workers in Manchester NH this morning. The three, rabbinical student David Kalb, and college students Moshe Maoz and Ronn Torossian were part of a CJC-Amcha group who jumped on the stage as Buchanan was announcing his intention to run for President on the Republican ticket in 1996. Carrying signs saying, "Pat = Duke Without the Sheets" and "Buchanan is a racist" the three were shoved, pushed to the ground and beaten while Buchanan looked on. Even after it was established that the CJC-Amcha activists were unarmed, Buchanan guards pushed and dragged the students down three flights of stairs and outside to the parking lot of the building where they continued to beat, punch and kick the three until Manchester police officers intervened and threatened to arrest Buchanan's campaign director. Kalb, Torrosian and Maoz sustained bruises, scratches, a black eye and ripped clothing in the attack. The group is pressing assault charges against the Buchanan campaign at the Manchester police department. "We hope that the rest of the campaign will not be conducted in this manner," said Judy Balint, national director of the New York-based Jewish activist group. "There must be a place for peaceful protest against anti-Semitism and bigotry without the fear of being beaten by paid goons," she asserted. "It was clear our protestors were unarmed and had no intention of causing Buchanan any physical harm--the treatment they received was completely unwarranted." "Today's protest was to expose Buchanan's record of continued support for accused Nazi war criminals including Klaus Barbie; Buchanan's "doubts about whether Jews were gassed at Treblinka," his lauding of Hitler, calling him "an individual of great courage, a soldier's soldier in the Great War" and "a leader steeped in the history of Europe." Buchanan referred to Capitol Hill as "Israel's occupied territory," and has called the American pro-Israel lobby, Israel's "amen corner in the US." Buchanan's comments raise the specter of a Jewish conspiracy and his other deplorable comments include a statement made in 1992 that "only Israel and American Jews wanted war in the Persian Gulf" and suggested that the Jews would send non-Jews to fight the war," noted Ronn Torossian and David Kalb. "Our position is that even if you agree with every one of Buchanan's programs, if he is an anti-Semite and a defender of Nazis that would make it immoral for any decent American to vote for him," said National president of the Coalition for Jewish Concerns-Amcha, Rabbi Avi Weiss. CJC-AMCHA activists followed Buchanan on the campaign trail in 1992 and were verbally and physically assaulted in New Hampshire, Georgia, Rhode Island and Massachussetts by Buchanan supporters. In Marietta, Georgia in answer to Rabbi Weiss' accusation that he is a racist, Buchanan said, "This is a rally for Americans, by American's in the good 'ole USA." The following day the American Jewish Congress and the American Jewish Committee declared the statement a clear indication of Buchanan's anti-Semitism. "As Pat Buchanan campaigns for the Republican nomination, we will campaign against his bigotry and anti-Semitism everywhere he goes," the CJC-Amcha group declared.

More Buchanan:
On Saturday, February 24, 1996, Professor Stephen Feinberg (University of Minnesota) posted the following piece to the Holocaust Discussion Group: To: Multiple recipients of list HOLOCAUS Subject: Pat Buchanan, the Jews & the Holocaust From: Stephen Feinstein PATRICK BUCHANAN: IN HIS OWN WORDS * Buchanan told Elie Wiesel that President Reagan must not surrender to "Jewish pressure" against visiting Bitburg, a German cemetery where SS men were buried. In a White House meeting with Jewish leaders, Buchanan reminded them that they were "Americans first," as fellow staffer Ed Rollins later recounted to Reagan biographer Lou Cannon. Buchanan repreatedly scrawled the phrase "Succumbing to the pressure of the Jews" on his notepad during the meeting. * In 1990 William Buckley, Buchanan's former mentor, wrote a 20,000 word essay on Buchanan that concluded: "I find it impossible to defend Pat Buchanan against the charge" of anti-Semitism. * Buchanan has called Hitler a "man of great courage" and extraordinary gifts." * On ABC Nightline, March 11, 1992, Buchanan told anchorman, Chris Wallace: "I'm one of the few people in this city, Chris, who's had the guts to stand up to the agenda of the special interests, whether it's the civil rights lobbyist or the AIPAC lobby or the gay rights lobby, and say that their agenda is not in the interest of a good society and not in the interest of my country." * In a March 13, 1991 syndicated column Buchanan called Israel "a strategic albatross draped around the neck of the United States." * In an interview in Present Tense magazine, Buchanan stated that "if my friends in the Jewish community feel Pat Buchanan, a traditionalist Catholic, owes some kind of apology for the record of the Holy Father during World War II, they can wait, because it's not going to be forthcoming." * In the Chicago Sun Times of March 1989, Buchanan criticized the West for ostracizing Kurt Waldheim. Buchanan rationalized,"like others in Hitler's army, Lt. Waldheim looked the other way." (Previously, as Secretary General of the United Nations, Waldheim had been an object of Buchanan's scorn). * On The McLaughlin Report, August 26, 1990: "There are only two groups that are beating the drums for war in the Middle East, the Israeli Defense Ministry and its amen corner in the United States." * In Newsweek, December 23, 1991, Jonathan Alter writes that in 1983 Buchanan criticized the US government for expressing regret over its postwar protection of Klaus Barbie. * In 1985 Buchanan advocated restoring citizenship of Arthur Rudolph, an ex-Nazi rocket scientist * In 1987 Buchanan lobbied to stop deportation of Karl Linnas, accused of Nazi atrocities in Estonia. * In a March 17, 1990 column, Buchanan wrote that it was impossible for 850,000 Jews to be killed by diesel exhaust fed into the gas chamber at Treblinka. "Diesel engines do not emit enough carbon monoxide to kill anybody." According to Jacob Weisberg in his article "The Heresies of Pat Buchanan," October 22, 1990, The New Republic, "Buchanan stands by his bizarre claim about the diesel engines but refuses to discuss it on the record. Suffice it to say that he embraces a bolder debunking claim than he is yet willing to endorse in print...Where did he get the anecdote ("proving" his assertion about the diesel)? 'Somebody sent it to me.' "Buchanan's source was almost certainly the July 1988 issue of a Newsletter of the German American Information and Education Association--a known Holocaust denial group which quotes extensively from a story of schoolchildren who emerged unharmed after being exposed to diesel fumes while trapped in a train tunnel. * On March 2, 1992, at a campaign rally in Marietta, Georgia, where Rabbi Avi Weiss called out, "Your anti-Semitism makes America last," Buchanan shot back, "This rally is of Americans, for Americans and for the good 'ole USA, my friends." * In the New York Post, March 17, 1990,Buchanan referred to a"so called Holocaust survivors syndrome" which he described as involving"group fantasies of martyrdom and heroics." *Buchanan was a featured columnist for The Spotlight, a patently anti-Semitic and anti-Black publication that championed David Duke. * Former Reagan press secretary Larry Speakes writes of Buchanan in his memoirs, 'Speaking Out,' "..he (Buchanan) was so blindly reactionary." * Buchanan repeatedly referred to Capitol Hill as "Israeli occupied territory." (McLaughlin Report, June 1990) * On February 4, 1987 in The Washington Post, Buchanan wrote: "Dr. Martin Luther King is one of the most divisive men in contemporary history..." In an earlier article in the Globe-Democrat, Buchanan wrote that King was "sometimes demagogic and irresponsible in his public statements." * In a January 16, 1986 column, Buchanan wrote:" But apartheid is not the worst situation facing Africans today. Not remotely. If it were, they wouldn't be pouring into South Africa from such "liberated" zones as Mozambique." * In 1990, before the Gulf War, Buchanan wrote that if the US went to war, "the fighting would be done by kids with names like McAllister, Murphy, Gonzales and Leroy Brown." The National Review (December 30, 1991) commented that "There is no way to read that sentence without concluding that Pat Buchanan was suggesting that American Jews manage to avoid personal military exposure even while advancing military policies they (uniquely?) engender."

Then we have Jerry Falwell:

I think the Moslem faith teaches hate.
Jerry Falwell

If I were president of the United States, I would include Moslems in my presidency.
Jerry Falwell
(now isn't that strange - he'd want Muslim's in his White House even after stating their faith preaches hate)

Scientology has a terrible track record of bigotry.
Jerry Falwell
*cough cough*

You know, I went a personal boycott of Hollywood about 45 years ago.
Jerry Falwell

I don't think I know a Scientologist except when I see one or two of their actors on the Hollywood screen.
Jerry Falwell

(uh, which one is it - has he boycotted Hollywood for 45 years or so or does he know a Scientologist when he sees one on the screen?)

Billy Graham, and his anti-Semitic remarks came forth in 2003 when Nixon White House tapes were released catching both President Nixon and Graham. To Graham's credit though, at least he has asked for forgiveness.

There's Mel Gibson and his anti-Semitic tirade when he was pulled over this summer.

But, he too did apologize.

In France, Jean-Marie Le Pen, known as a right wing extremist and an anti-Semite Holocaust denier was qualified to run for president in France in 2002.

We have Buchanan and Robertson, so we beat the French.

Radio Maryja, a conservative Catholic radio station in Poland was forced to apologize in April for their anti-Semitic remarks.

Now, those are just a few who come to mind. They're all right-wing extremists. Do some remarks made by the far-right mean they are "typical" of the far-right. No! Does this mean I think everyone on the right is an anti-Semite? No! Just like you should not believe all anti-Semite's are on the left or everyone on the extreme left is an anti-Semite. Portraying such a picture to your readers is dishonest, and just bad journalism. Shame Shame.


Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (64) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
1he got what he deserved. [37 words]QuazgaaApr 17, 2008 23:40126046
Like Rachel Corrie? [20 words]Dawood BenatarJul 23, 2010 14:04126046
Not so innocent [9 words]Jerry MeentsApr 15, 2011 14:34126046
I heard this as an Israeli murder in a cafe in Rome from a cook who hailed from Chicago [54 words]Abu NudnikApr 27, 2011 11:18126046
life has no value in some cultures ? [117 words]Phil GreendJun 2, 2007 13:1895786
What if, indeed, he was a Jew? [129 words]David KoralSep 14, 2006 12:5155936
1Value of a Muslim life [657 words]Thomas Justin KazeSep 6, 2006 07:1455068
I fully believe in JIHAD- against radical Islam [86 words]Seamus Dafydd Dives MacNemiApr 15, 2011 17:4655068
dislike [15 words]Aby.RiderSep 11, 2012 12:4155068
Reality Has Clearly Ben Suspended [199 words]Martin NoyesSep 1, 2006 22:4054652
Where are your friends when you need them? [61 words]MarySep 1, 2006 02:5954554
Please stop your generalizations and grouping. [1941 words]GracieSep 1, 2006 00:3154543
groupings are not exclusive [170 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDSep 2, 2006 13:0454543
What is your point? [109 words]A grateful Phil ProfSep 2, 2006 17:0254543
It Takes Two Hands To Wash The Face. [177 words]Seamus MacNemiJun 20, 2007 06:5754543
Conversion and reconversion [46 words]HariAug 31, 2006 23:3854541
Can you say irony? [64 words]JackalAug 31, 2006 06:3854452
When a man bites a dog..... [51 words]MosheSep 1, 2006 05:1054452
1He is a 'Jude'. [352 words]MarkAug 30, 2006 21:5254425
The murderous claws of the Nazi beast. [83 words]MosheSep 1, 2006 05:3954425
Parent to Parent. [92 words]maura collinsAug 30, 2006 12:2154387
2Parenting, Italian Style [174 words]MACAug 29, 2006 16:4254287
1Angelo was killed three times [157 words]ItalianAug 29, 2006 13:5454264
Terrorist?!! Oh, perish the thought!!! [64 words]J.S.Aug 29, 2006 13:0454262
Survival of the Fittest [40 words]DenDAug 29, 2006 10:0054250
Friendly Fire [156 words]CervantesAug 29, 2006 01:2454225
right about that!! [53 words]ahmadzafireAug 29, 2006 21:0554225
A blown opportunity to strike a blow for freedom and justice [181 words]Dr RJPAug 29, 2006 00:0254223
angelo frammartino [139 words]robert fusfeldAug 28, 2006 22:5354218
Looking Jewish in Israel [168 words]JayAug 28, 2006 21:4654215
Mr. Pipes comments [208 words]LorenzoAug 28, 2006 20:5954208
you misunderstand Dr Pipes [134 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDSep 2, 2006 13:1654208
In over his head [107 words]J.R. CashAug 28, 2006 20:3954207
Righteousness of Islam [7 words]PaulAug 28, 2006 19:4254201
How to Kill a Westerner, and/or Jew [432 words]Jascha KesslerAug 28, 2006 19:0154194
how to kill a westerner [95 words]rafi brownAug 29, 2006 16:4254194
Dead because he looked like a Jew [38 words]David W. LincolnAug 28, 2006 18:5254193
An excellent illustration by Mr. Pipes [106 words]MHAug 28, 2006 18:2554190
Sometimes the crocodile [7 words]Abu NudnikAug 28, 2006 18:0554189
"Gentle" Evil [258 words]Alan N.Aug 28, 2006 16:5154180
The Fatal Stabbing of Angelo Frammartino, Palestinian Apologist [43 words]Ira LevineAug 28, 2006 16:2254177
oops... [173 words]donvanAug 29, 2006 12:3654177
Berg too [88 words]neurodocAug 28, 2006 15:3454172
What if? [14 words]George BruceAug 28, 2006 14:5454169
Perfect Comments by Dr. Pipes [52 words]William Sumner Scott, J.D.Aug 28, 2006 14:4554168
Keep it simple [83 words]Jan VinkAug 29, 2006 03:2654168
Hate & Deception [58 words]Paul DavidAug 28, 2006 14:4154167
Who is to blame [181 words]Roger RickAug 28, 2006 14:2454166
What's next? [140 words]PatAug 29, 2006 14:0454160
Or would he have learned nothing and still considered it an act of legitimate self-defense [205 words]rickAug 28, 2006 12:4854158
...or would he have [95 words]rafi brownAug 29, 2006 08:1354158
The more I ponder this story the more it becomes an anti-semitic metaphor for our times [565 words]rickAug 29, 2006 17:0354158
the fatal stabbing [231 words]rafi brownAug 30, 2006 18:0154158
Respectfully, I must disagree about the parents [619 words]rickAug 31, 2006 16:3054158
You reap what you sow [94 words]Irving WeinsoffAug 28, 2006 12:3854155
Useful Idiiots [253 words]Faqi HussainAug 28, 2006 17:0254155
Angelo Murder and FOX Journalist Statement [133 words]John Randall PeacherAug 28, 2006 12:1854151
Highest respect... [11 words]DONVANAug 29, 2006 12:1654151
Remember where Centanni Was [78 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
PatAug 29, 2006 14:1454151
highest respect [108 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDSep 2, 2006 13:3154151
Victim of Italian Media [47 words]Ed HalperAug 28, 2006 11:1954144
USEFUL IDIOTS [19 words]PJMAug 28, 2006 11:1054141
I wonder... [26 words]antAug 28, 2006 17:0454141
Wonder???....Absurd! [21 words]MosheAug 31, 2006 13:5654141

Comment on this item

Mark my comment as a response to Please stop your generalizations and grouping. by Gracie

Email me if someone replies to my comment

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List
eXTReMe Tracker

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2020 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)