Latest Articles
ADVERTISEMENTS
Submitted by Steve Saaf (United States) , Jul 21, 2002 at 16:26
Your article did not mention the idea that lies at the base of western democracy - the ideal of self-government. This is most often thought of and mentioned in the context of foreign influence over one's country, but is more applicable here in the context of which you discuss. I think it's creation and history of development should be explored and then should be compared with the development of Muslim culture to see if democracy can truly be expected in a Muslim context.
Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened for relevance, substance, and tone, and in some cases edited, before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome, but comments are rejected if scurrilous, off-topic, vulgar, ad hominem , or otherwise viewed as inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the Guidelines for Comments .
Submit a comment on this article
Other reader comments on this article
Title
By
Date
khilafat is islamic style democracy [100 words]Syed Mohammad Ali Jan 20, 2005 04:16 ↔ What nonsense [8 words] Terry Feb 19, 2007 17:41 ↔ For Syaed and his bogus Arabic and he ain't no Arab and another potential tourist to Mecca I mean Makkah [125 words] dhimmi no more Feb 20, 2007 07:29 ↔ Khilafah is islamic style democracy. [47 words] Niyazi Feb 14, 2008 04:55 ↔ purpose of Khilafat [80 words] Abdul Ali May 26, 2008 14:55 ↔ One can't exclude Politics from Khilafat [104 words] Asif Shahzad Jun 7, 2008 13:33 ↔ Khilafat considered in politics [144 words] Abdul Ali Jun 9, 2008 13:23 No open society-No democracy! [150 words]Dan L. Nichols Jul 22, 2004 13:55 islam, christanity and democracy... Reply to Sam TANIOS, July 19, 2002 [483 words]fan Jul 8, 2003 10:20 ↔ A Christian's point of view [143 words] Fred Inglis May 24, 2008 23:17 Turkey , Islam and Ataism [43 words]Ronald Barlow Feb 11, 2003 09:52 Islam IS and ISN'T compatible [296 words]Waleed Shirzoi Nov 22, 2002 16:55 ↔ Christianity [157 words] Fred Inglis May 27, 2008 21:55 Ignorance is bliss [394 words]Iqbalur Rehman Nov 22, 2002 06:25 Moderation can happen, but is not natural [68 words]Henk Twerda Aug 13, 2002 17:54 Turkey: fascistic, racist, tyrannic and extremely nationalistic! [291 words]Christian Aramean Aug 5, 2002 20:14 Democracy and Islam....Hard Questions [184 words]D. Walls Jul 29, 2002 12:27 An islamic nation with democracy [w/response] [269 words]syam rudra Jul 23, 2002 20:19 Democracy and Islam [76 words]A. Ahmed Jul 23, 2002 18:28 Thank you, Dr. Pipes! [50 words]Ali Farshidi Jul 22, 2002 09:47 ⇒ The ideal of self-government [83 words]Steve Saaf Jul 21, 2002 16:26 Islam and Democratization [368 words]Kevin Donovan Jul 21, 2002 06:44 A clear and present danger [101 words]Danny Bonca Jul 20, 2002 20:57 Correction to Ericson post [117 words]Annette R. Floystrup Jul 19, 2002 21:19 ↔ reviews site [30 words] reviews site Feb 10, 2007 19:22 Muslim Countries' Lack of Democracy [219 words]Amy Mack Jul 19, 2002 13:26 Islam and democracy [101 words]Sam TANIOS Jul 19, 2002 09:12 Islam compatible with democracy? [120 words]Tom Dykhuizen Jul 19, 2002 01:08 No democrcy in Islam [173 words]F. Shawki Jul 18, 2002 21:46 ↔ read it [155 words] muslim May 13, 2006 04:39 Muslims & Democracy [217 words]Gerald Gerjekian Jul 18, 2002 20:19 Citizen of the 21st Century [141 words]F.W. Thornton Jul 18, 2002 19:55 ↔ All is confusion [116 words] Fred Inglis May 26, 2008 19:34 Democracy and Islam [279 words]James Sofko Jul 18, 2002 19:42 "Nations of Citizens" versus "Nations of Inhabitants" [83 words]David Jacob Jul 18, 2002 18:58 Ah, and history of Islam says what? [274 words]Sheerahkahn Jul 18, 2002 18:34 Are you sure there is nothing in Islam against Democracy? [544 words]Karl Ericson Jul 18, 2002 17:21 Islam NOT compatible with democracy [269 words]Tom Clear Jul 18, 2002 16:00 WOW! [44 words]Howard L. Morry Jul 18, 2002 15:43
Comment on The Citizen of the 21st Century: How Far, How Fast?
ADVERTISEMENTS