10 readers online now  |  69 million page views

Translations of this item:

Submit a comment on this item

Reader comments (249) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
There can be peace in Iraq and middle east ... if the muslims want it. [26 words]Phil GreendAug 11, 2009 23:18160076
Pipe's definition of civil war may be too broad [68 words]AndrewAug 6, 2006 13:2351801
Christian peace activist murdered by islamist [213 words]Richard Lion heartMar 11, 2006 13:3639744
once again you show your true colors...please!!! [166 words]ahmad zafireMar 22, 2006 13:2439744
Ahmad - what Arabs? [71 words]SiddaMar 23, 2006 18:0839744
sidda [82 words]ahmad zafireMar 24, 2006 18:1039744
Ahmad - What? [301 words]SiddaMar 25, 2006 10:3739744
SIDDA [120 words]AHMADZFAIREApr 7, 2006 19:0539744
I understand what Ahmad is saying [333 words]BrettDec 16, 2007 22:4139744
Disagree [105 words]Jonathan GoodmanMar 10, 2006 11:5939630
Dear Octavio- My intentions [227 words]Bader SMar 7, 2006 18:1039254
Happy about Bader's comment [37 words]Octavio JohansonMar 8, 2006 03:4839254
Propaganda-101, Today's Lesson: Bader S. [618 words]orange yonasonMar 7, 2006 15:2739224
Don't fix it, if it ain't broke. [178 words]JaladhiMar 7, 2006 16:0939224
to Jaladhi [90 words]orange yonasonMar 8, 2006 18:1739224
If you Believe America is so Squeaky clean...... [225 words]BtheREbeLJan 30, 2007 11:3639224
I am entitled to ask questions to Amir [163 words]Octavio JohansonMar 7, 2006 04:5439145
Bader's analysis on who should be on this forum [229 words]Jeremy MattilMar 6, 2006 10:0339051
To Patrick O'Brien [485 words]Mu'een Ud DeenMar 6, 2006 05:4139039
RE:To Patrick O'Brien [503 words]WeAreAllDanes!Mar 6, 2006 20:1439039
Reply [788 words]Mu'een Ud DeenMar 8, 2006 05:0039039
RE:RE:To Patrick O'Brien [480 words]WeAreAllDanes!Mar 8, 2006 23:2239039
Civil War in Iraq, art.No.3423 [45 words]S.C.PandaMar 6, 2006 03:5039033
The Koran and Democracy [451 words]Patrick O'BrianMar 4, 2006 12:0138862
Re: the Koran and Democracy [321 words]Bader SMar 4, 2006 17:0938862
RE:Koran and Democracy [215 words]WeAreAllDanes!Mar 4, 2006 17:5338862
Jizya [196 words]WeAreAllDanes!Mar 4, 2006 21:1638862
"NO funds for Hamas, the terrorists" [126 words]NicholasMar 4, 2006 23:1538862
Re: Jizya [138 words]Bader SMar 5, 2006 03:5438862
Re WeAreAllDanes 's The Koran and Democracy [208 words]Bader SMar 5, 2006 04:2438862
Christian Palestinians [48 words]yuval brandstetter MDMar 5, 2006 08:3938862
Democracy, Hamas Style [275 words]Patrick O'BrianMar 5, 2006 12:0738862
The Koran is contrary to democracy [166 words]Richard Lion heartMar 6, 2006 01:1438862
Re WeAreAllDanes 's The Koran and Democracy [254 words]WeAreAllDanes!Mar 6, 2006 01:2038862
RE: Jizya [234 words]WeAreAllDanes!Mar 6, 2006 01:2338862
Absence Of "Liberalism" In Islamic Thought, Or.... [310 words]orange yonasonMar 6, 2006 02:3738862
Re: Palestinian Christians [249 words]Bader SMar 6, 2006 03:4538862
The concerns of the founding fathers [189 words]Bader SMar 6, 2006 16:2038862
Re: Richard the Lion: The Koran is contrary to democracy [70 words]Bader SMar 6, 2006 16:3538862
Re: Re WeAreAllDanes 's The Koran and Democracy [140 words]Bader SMar 6, 2006 16:4838862
to Richard - Quran contrary to democracy [71 words]SiddaMar 6, 2006 17:0638862
Re: Re Jizya [166 words]Bader SMar 6, 2006 17:0738862
RE:Bader - The Koran and Democracy [136 words]WeAreAllDanes!Mar 7, 2006 23:1338862
RE: Bader - Jizya [311 words]WeAreAllDanes!Mar 7, 2006 23:2838862
RE: Bader - "founding fathers" [185 words]WeAreAllDanes!Mar 7, 2006 23:4338862
Re: RE:Bader - The Koran and Democracy [529 words]Bader SMar 8, 2006 03:5538862
The making of the 98% [104 words]Bader SMar 8, 2006 05:1538862
Slavery [367 words]BaderSMar 8, 2006 08:1038862
RE:Slavery [42 words]WeAreAllDanes!Mar 8, 2006 22:4338862
RE:98% [116 words]WeAreAllDanes!Mar 8, 2006 22:4538862
RE:The Koran and Democracy- Bader [217 words]WeAreAllDanes!Mar 8, 2006 22:5838862
Bader, Harrak - hello again Sidda (I see you're here too). [102 words]Hind SamyMar 28, 2006 21:4738862
Islam and Democracy [399 words]DaveMay 14, 2006 08:4238862
Comments by "PCMadness" [50 words]faqiMar 4, 2006 11:4738860
Harrak strikes.... [231 words]PCMadnessMar 3, 2006 23:2938826
To PC MADNESS....It is a living monument [36 words]ForTheWestMar 4, 2006 10:5438826
To PCmadness, (on Harrak) [62 words]NicholasMar 4, 2006 12:3038826
PCMadness, answering your questions and recommending a book relevant to your standing [333 words]HARRAKMar 4, 2006 12:3338826
Hopefully my last response to Harrak [39 words]PCMadnessMar 4, 2006 15:2738826
What are we to believe? [164 words]Bader SMar 3, 2006 16:3038800
Oil . . . Oil . . . Oil!! [158 words]S JacobsMar 3, 2006 09:2538760
S Jacobs, Oil . . . Oil . . . Oil!! [65 words]BarbaraMar 3, 2006 17:2138760
Conspiracy [207 words]Mu'een Ud DeenMar 3, 2006 05:4138748
yes! [99 words]HARRAKMar 3, 2006 18:2538748
Shrewd business really [176 words]PCMadnessMar 4, 2006 23:1138748
HARRAK ?? [23 words]TimothyMar 5, 2006 22:0738748
To Timothy: Fact that no muslim would blow up a mosque [66 words]Infidel3Mar 6, 2006 12:1938748
Is there a contradiction? [73 words]Octavio JohansonMar 3, 2006 04:1938733
Time to outsource Iraq [77 words]Jerome Mc KennaMar 2, 2006 18:5838702
... this is not a morally consistent stand [248 words]Ben ShniperMar 2, 2006 14:0038659
Ben Shniper nailing every body , how about Coca Cola! [265 words]HARRAKMar 2, 2006 20:1338659
RE:this is not a morally consistent stand [218 words]WeAreAllDanes!Mar 3, 2006 02:0538659
Re: ... this is not a morally consistent stand [97 words]Bader SMar 3, 2006 15:5138659
You flaunt your moral inconsistencies [266 words]Ben ShniperMar 6, 2006 16:1038659
Nicely put. [57 words]Ben ShniperMar 6, 2006 16:1538659
How dare I? [455 words]Bader SMar 7, 2006 06:2938659
RE: ...this is not a morally consistent stand [94 words]WeAreAllDanes!Mar 7, 2006 23:5338659
Strategic Planning [143 words]RolandMar 2, 2006 09:4438640
Well Said!!! [19 words]YovenMar 3, 2006 13:2238640
STRATEGIC IGNORANCE and Saoudi Wahabia [193 words]HARRAKMar 3, 2006 14:3138640
Harrak we can hear you but would appreciate it if you don't use holy trinity to convey a political message [48 words]LisaMar 3, 2006 22:0538640
Lisa, I hear you. Sorry for politicizing the holy trinity! [60 words]HARRAKMar 4, 2006 11:0238640
Iraq is Only One Front [284 words]William Robert JackMar 2, 2006 07:5738632
Civil War in Iraq [208 words]Martin E. WeinsteinMar 2, 2006 03:0938611
Stategic Planning [57 words]William Robert JackMar 2, 2006 18:5238611
on the brink [48 words]G. R. LoveringMar 2, 2006 01:0138607
"Povertocracy" vs Democracy [100 words]NicholasMar 1, 2006 22:4238599
Secularism not Democracy [171 words]John Anonymous SmithMar 1, 2006 17:1038561
Glory of American Foreign Policy [41 words]EMar 1, 2006 16:1238545
Democracy and Iraq [190 words]VinodguptMar 1, 2006 14:2338524
Democracy? [70 words]AmirMar 1, 2006 15:3938524
Equivocation and evasion [142 words]Terry JonesMar 1, 2006 16:3038524
India The povertocracy and bowl [118 words]HARRAKMar 1, 2006 17:2838524
Islam -democracy are not compitable [176 words]aumprakashreddyMar 1, 2006 19:0238524
2India's democracy is its strength !!!! [274 words]NicholasMar 1, 2006 22:2838524
An Imam from a "povertocracy" [83 words]Infidel3Mar 1, 2006 23:0338524
Hindus [27 words]robert aMar 1, 2006 23:3938524
Dictatorships and Islam [428 words]Bader SMar 2, 2006 04:1538524
To Harrak [64 words]VijayMar 2, 2006 05:5638524
Harrak- Democracy depends upon the character of the people, not the economy [231 words]Arvind MadhavanMar 2, 2006 10:1538524
India and China invading what!..starvomania! No democracy without Dignity [300 words]HARRAKMar 2, 2006 18:3538524
Democracy [219 words]faqiMar 2, 2006 19:1638524
India is ruled by a fanatic group. [42 words]Muhammed aliMar 2, 2006 21:3738524
Harrak- You are still mistaken [122 words]Arvind MadhavanMar 3, 2006 01:0838524
To Mohammed Ali [130 words]VijayMar 3, 2006 06:0638524
The Violent Hindus [263 words]Bader SMar 3, 2006 08:4138524
To Harrak's "INDIAN FRIENDS"….. [352 words]Infidel3Mar 3, 2006 09:5438524
"Take it cool" when you get insulted. [48 words]NicholasMar 3, 2006 10:3138524
civil war in iraq [70 words]brooklynbobMar 3, 2006 11:5538524
Thank you Arvind [41 words]YovenMar 3, 2006 13:4438524
About Bader: A "Moderate" Muslim's Bag of Tricks [149 words]sanjayMar 3, 2006 17:3638524
Sanjay [78 words]Bader SMar 4, 2006 09:0938524
Harrak and Amir [40 words]Octavio JohansonMar 4, 2006 12:4538524
1To Bader: Difference between "Terrorism" and "Rioting" [94 words]Jeremy MattilMar 4, 2006 15:3738524
3 questions for Amir [27 words]Octavio JohansonMar 4, 2006 17:2438524
Octavio's 3 questions and the spanish inquisition [156 words]Infidel3Mar 4, 2006 21:4738524
Research the "violent Hindus" (label by Bader, S) [204 words]ForTheWestMar 4, 2006 22:2938524
Fragile egos hurt ?.... To Bader [78 words]SanjayMar 4, 2006 23:2438524
Octavio Johanson and the theory of spying in this forum on Amir [113 words]HARRAKMar 5, 2006 01:0838524
To Jeremy Mattil: Check your definitions [340 words]Bader SMar 5, 2006 03:1938524
Infidel3 [29 words]Octavio JohansonMar 5, 2006 12:1838524
Good choice [27 words]Octavio JohansonMar 5, 2006 12:4838524
Re: The Violent Hindus [86 words]Octavio JohansonMar 6, 2006 10:0438524
To Harrak [129 words]Octavio JohansonMar 6, 2006 11:1038524
HARRAK's question on Octavio's questions [161 words]NicholasMar 6, 2006 12:1038524
Harrak's question on Octavio Johanson answered . [93 words]ForTheWestMar 6, 2006 12:3838524
Freedom of speech [30 words]Octavio JohansonMar 6, 2006 12:5438524
Bader's choice: Who should be on this forum [209 words]Jeremy MattilMar 6, 2006 13:3038524
Re: Re: The Violent Hindus [127 words]Bader SMar 6, 2006 17:1938524
Re: Bader's choice: Who should be on this forum [71 words]Bader SMar 6, 2006 17:5338524
1More about violent Hindus [177 words]Octavio JohansonMar 7, 2006 03:5038524
Old Italians and Greeks [35 words]Octavio JohansonMar 7, 2006 03:5338524
The problem with "Violent Hindus" [210 words]Octavio JohansonMar 7, 2006 08:5838524
Dear Bader [69 words]Octavio JohansonMar 7, 2006 09:1338524
practice what you preach!! [46 words]HarrakMar 7, 2006 10:2938524
Re: practice what you preach [41 words]Octavio JohansonMar 8, 2006 06:0938524
To Octavio Johanson [151 words]VijayMar 9, 2006 07:5638524
8Hindus burning Christians alive AND THE NAGA GENOCIDE. [346 words]ex-hindu2christianMar 23, 2009 08:5638524
Haha... [182 words]SamNov 21, 2009 18:3338524
Jesus a Yogi [88 words]Jon KongloiApr 5, 2011 06:1438524
exhindu2fool [371 words]SamDec 1, 2014 16:4438524
Iraq [277 words]YovenMar 1, 2006 14:1438522
Iraqi religion [163 words]AmirMar 1, 2006 15:5238522
Reply to Yoven [9 words]Ramsis AlMasryMar 2, 2006 04:5438522
the list is better or like India [23 words]HARRAKMar 2, 2006 20:4938522
To Harrak [43 words]VijayMar 3, 2006 07:3838522
Re: Yoven's ...list [261 words]Bader SMar 3, 2006 08:1138522
Incredible [23 words]Octavio JohansonMar 4, 2006 18:5438522
Why does Bush care so damn much? [326 words]VanessaMar 21, 2007 12:5038522
not surprised [107 words]JOHN MANITTAMar 1, 2006 12:2238511
Civil War in Iraq? [47 words]Octavio JohansonMar 1, 2006 11:5438510
Avoid "civil war in Europe"...How to [252 words]ForTheWestMar 3, 2006 11:3938510
To For the West [20 words]Octavio JohansonMar 4, 2006 07:1238510
We can't walk away from this mess in Mesopotamia [189 words]ChrisMar 1, 2006 11:1938504
The Worst Case Scenarios [545 words]Patrick O'BrianMar 1, 2006 09:2738497
India would wipe Pakistan? Sure [172 words]AmirMar 1, 2006 16:0838497
NO Pakistanis will wipe Pakistanis off the world map [47 words]Aumprakash reddyMar 1, 2006 19:1838497
Pakistani Fantasies [144 words]Jeremy MattilMar 1, 2006 22:1438497
to Amir, ref India and Pakistan [109 words]M. al-ContentMar 2, 2006 17:4638497
Amir: fair and balanced [66 words]Octavio JohansonMar 3, 2006 11:2438497
Iraq's Civil War [148 words]Leonard MarkowitzMar 1, 2006 06:5838490
Arrogance [64 words]Joe MarschallMar 1, 2006 06:4838489
تفوق القوة المضادة للقاعدة [130 words]mohamed.mMar 1, 2006 06:1638488
احترام الانجليزية respecting English [52 words]HARRAKMar 1, 2006 18:3338488
Can someone translate this ? [10 words]TimothyMar 1, 2006 21:5138488
Translation to English [348 words]YovenMar 3, 2006 09:1838488
Translation of Mohamed M. comments. [183 words]SophieMar 3, 2006 12:4438488
Sophie's translation [6 words]Bader SMar 3, 2006 15:3138488
Translation [6 words]Liam K.Jul 1, 2006 18:5438488
Translation [11 words]SophieJul 2, 2006 08:5538488
Painting a positive picture.... again [545 words]Bader SMar 1, 2006 05:4038486
Painting a positive picture.... again [6 words]ZiaMar 4, 2006 23:4538486
A super power humiliated and defeated. [190 words]Muhammad aliMar 1, 2006 03:2338480
The Tragedy [26 words]Gary NewmanMar 1, 2006 01:0738467
Division of Iraq [279 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
David GoshenMar 1, 2006 00:3838465
Why Muslims are killing and destroying themselves? [1036 words]KamekishFeb 28, 2006 23:3938460
Bravo Kamekish [8 words]YovenMar 3, 2006 15:1138460
We're still on course [75 words]Melvin A. FechterFeb 28, 2006 23:3838459
What is the value of a human life? [88 words]Gloria HoffmanFeb 28, 2006 23:1438457
Future Iranian intervention [161 words]Thomas HaidonFeb 28, 2006 22:5338454
Civil War in Iraq? [149 words]Steven LFeb 28, 2006 22:3638452
Comment for: JS , Chaim, Korstad, Joe, Donvan [409 words]HARRAKFeb 28, 2006 21:3538447
Civil War in Iraq [74 words]Jeffrey A. SupowitFeb 28, 2006 20:3438445
Where we go from here--short version [89 words]William Robert JackFeb 28, 2006 20:2938444
Overview of Iraqi Violence and US Response [322 words]William Robert JackFeb 28, 2006 19:5638443
Strategy [241 words]Shmuel HaLeviMar 1, 2006 11:3538443
Terrorist stronghold ? [48 words]Bader SMar 1, 2006 16:2738443
Terrorist Stronghold? [74 words]William Robert JackMar 2, 2006 07:3438443
Al Qaeda's mobile stronghold [236 words]Bader SMar 3, 2006 15:1738443
My Fear is... [150 words]Lee HarrisFeb 28, 2006 18:3138432
Playing into their hands? [243 words]Jane OFeb 28, 2006 18:0738426
One More Positive From an Iraqi Negative [61 words]Dan FriedmanFeb 28, 2006 17:4438418
Civil War in Iraq [388 words]D WeilFeb 28, 2006 17:3638417
Regardless of how you slice it [74 words]David W. LincolnFeb 28, 2006 17:1038412
War Period. [206 words]renchFeb 28, 2006 16:5038409
Strategic outcomes [116 words]Thomas HaidonFeb 28, 2006 16:4438407
Present Day Iraq Could Go The Way Of Former Yugoslavia [115 words]AnneMFeb 28, 2006 16:4438406
1Cause & Effect - Islam or Tyranny? [319 words]Al GordonFeb 28, 2006 16:3138400
Our leaders don't see the root cause [171 words]Robert D. KlimekFeb 28, 2006 19:2538400
Excellent Posting Al Gordon [11 words]TimothyMar 1, 2006 00:1238400
Wrong definition for Islam. [237 words]Muhammad aliMar 1, 2006 14:2338400
How do Muslims define Islam? [121 words]PatMar 1, 2006 17:0038400
Islam or Tyranny [118 words]Muhammad aliMar 1, 2006 19:4538400
RE:Muhammad ali [47 words]WeAreAllDanes!Mar 3, 2006 02:1238400
Three cheers to the "resistance" [116 words]Richard Lion heartFeb 28, 2006 16:2838399
Richard - Three Cheers [84 words]SiddaMar 1, 2006 19:0638399
What About the "Hidden Imam"? [238 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
AlexFeb 28, 2006 16:2738398
Muslim legacy [32 words]Donna SummerFeb 28, 2006 15:5938391
What an Iraqi civil war will accomplish [183 words]rickFeb 28, 2006 15:5938390
Nobody should have been surprised by this!! [178 words]Dr RJPFeb 28, 2006 15:4838388
Civil War [363 words]JohnFeb 28, 2006 15:4738387
Iraq would go back to Muslim controlled? [56 words]AmirMar 1, 2006 16:3638387
Civil War Response [388 words]JohnMar 2, 2006 01:0938387
Iraq and Europe [8 words]Octavio JohasnonMar 4, 2006 18:4938387
It will take longer than most think it will. [147 words]Edmund JamesFeb 28, 2006 15:4138386
Yes, Iraqis love you. [133 words]AmirMar 1, 2006 16:4838386
to Amir - Islam [344 words]SiddaMar 1, 2006 19:3038386
"Yes, Iraqis love you" by Amir [4 words]Octavio JohansonMar 3, 2006 08:5238386
TO Sidda, Submitted to Amir - Islam --Mar 1, 2006 at 19:30- [189 words]BarbaraMar 3, 2006 10:4938386
Guidance for Amir [31 words]Octavio JohansonMar 3, 2006 17:0938386
to Barbara [96 words]SiddaMar 3, 2006 18:2138386
The haven here on earth for Islam [43 words]Infidel3Mar 4, 2006 13:3338386
Pakistan [9 words]Octavio JohansonMar 4, 2006 18:3638386
Response to Sidda., [37 words]BarbaraMar 5, 2006 01:2938386
Fixing Iraq [287 words]Robert D. KlimekFeb 28, 2006 15:3538385
Letter to Pres. Bush. [43 words]Jacob Goldberg, MDFeb 28, 2006 15:2838383
news today from Putin [55 words]JMarFeb 10, 2007 13:0738383
Iraq's plight not a coalition responsibility nor danger to the West [356 words]Elan RubinsteinFeb 28, 2006 15:1538381
Iraq war [163 words]donvanFeb 28, 2006 17:0538381
destabilize the middle east [126 words]yuval brandstetter MDMar 4, 2006 15:5238381
What is a "strategic tragedy"? [199 words]Dick BardFeb 28, 2006 15:1438380
Is the problem deeper than Islam? [378 words]PatMar 1, 2006 12:2438380
The US Turned Iraq into Al Queda Breeding Ground [148 words]AmirMar 1, 2006 17:0438380
Excuses, excuses. [263 words]PatMar 2, 2006 14:0938380
Civil War in Iraq? [432 words]Maurice PicowFeb 28, 2006 15:1238379
1What's so bad about a Civil War, anyway? [214 words]Wes ClarkFeb 28, 2006 14:4638376
Not Sunni [7 words]SufyaanFeb 6, 2012 05:2638376
Yes! We can only hope for a protracted civil war [27 words]J.S.Feb 28, 2006 14:3338375
'Islam Fatigue' [344 words]JoeFeb 28, 2006 14:1938372
response [125 words]donvanFeb 28, 2006 17:2438372
The moral, legal and administrative responsibility of the occupier [161 words]HARRAKFeb 28, 2006 13:3738365
If...but... [82 words]Vic CoffeyMar 1, 2006 02:5338365
if...but..! [61 words]HARRAKMar 2, 2006 10:3238365
RE: The Moral, Legal and admin.... [461 words]ErikMar 2, 2006 12:2838365
Re: Erick [153 words]HARRAKMar 2, 2006 20:3338365
Speaking of intervention [80 words]Vic CoffeyMar 4, 2006 15:2538365
Lacking a Conclusion [58 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
Bill KorstadFeb 28, 2006 13:1638361
Create 3 new countries [118 words]ChaimFeb 28, 2006 13:0938360
Divide Iraq [92 words]LukeAug 16, 2006 00:1438360

Comment on this item

Name
Email Address (optional)
Title of Comments
Comments:

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

See recent outstanding comments.

ADVERTISEMENTS

eXTReMe Tracker

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2014 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum. Daniel J. Pipes