69 million page views

reply to J Schamroth

Reader comment on item: A Conspiracy Theory Spreads Polio
in response to reader comment: So what? Let them get malaria!

Submitted by Mark (United Arab Emirates), Mar 12, 2006 at 04:04

I don't think it is as sufficient to say. They don't want the vaccine so let them go without. They won't affect us..

I disagree. I am not a scientist but in my limited understanding of that sphere leads me to believe that the viral agents are continually and rapidly mutating to adapt to assaults by various drugs and pressures put on them by their hosts.

The only way to protect the general population is to irradicate the viral agents and make it impossible for them to find hosts in which to mutate.

Some factions within Islam ( I accept that this is not necessarily a pan-Islamic phenomenon) are not alone in their irrational distrust of vaccines. This mistrust is also found among the good people of Australia where a large number of non-islamic parents have chosen not to have their children vacinnated according to the regular preschool schedule due to fear of side effects including permanent deafness and even death. Apparaently there has been some evidence of these side effects in a very small number of cases.

This has greatly concerned health and community officials in Australia where this has become such a problem that there are now demands that children who have not been vaccinated be denied access to public schools until their vaccinations are up to date. The parents resist and the controversy rages..

Personally I put this down to stupidity rather than religion, for the reason I mentioned above. Though some people might argue that they are one and the same.
Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (47) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
2Still in this day and age? [89 words]steveNMay 21, 2012 22:42195769
1Uncertain. [67 words]JamesNov 27, 2009 21:10165145
1Don't blame them... [515 words]JohnOct 15, 2009 19:44163135
Help save the Tripoli Six from death and reform Libya right now! Usable e-mail included. [462 words]MelMDec 12, 2006 02:0669212
Polio wiil live long after man is gone [206 words]JimJan 29, 2006 01:1932973
Yemeni 5th anti-polio campaign launched. [63 words]SophieOct 9, 2005 13:2326744
Sophie- [161 words]steveMay 7, 2006 12:3326744
Poor, young battle Polio in Yemen [80 words]SophieOct 5, 2005 06:1226610
Massive Indonisian vaccination drive against polio resumes. [1 words]sophieSep 27, 2005 21:4226391
Indonisia make progress against Polio. Results of immunization campaign 'good but not great' UN official says [1 words]sophieSep 6, 2005 04:3525507
Most recent claim [29 words]Ramsis AlmasryJul 23, 2005 04:1423725
1Reply to: Muhammad Kabir Muhammad [3 words]Ramsis AlMasryMar 16, 2006 15:5023725
Western agenda is rarely transparent [65 words]C Ananda RaoJul 19, 2005 09:2023572
1Conspiracy [53 words]YovenJun 24, 2005 14:4622850
In response to Yldaev Suriv [58 words]Octavio JohansonJun 18, 2005 09:2222738
This has nothing to do with Islam [225 words]Hakan HekimgilJun 3, 2005 04:4022541
So what? [8 words]Muhammad Kabir MuhammadMay 31, 2005 13:2622492
Response to Octavio Johanson [100 words]Yldaed SurivMay 30, 2005 20:3522481
1Two Points... [49 words]AlexMay 30, 2005 20:2022480
"Wake Up" gets my vote [120 words]RPaineMay 30, 2005 11:4922477
1RE: Bruvha's comment on Western aid [127 words]Rony GuldmannMay 30, 2005 07:1722475
Islamic law.... [20 words]ChrisMay 29, 2005 21:0322471
1Multiculturalism has failed [85 words]Octavio JohansonMay 27, 2005 14:1122449
1jewish medicine [13 words]tomMay 26, 2005 15:1422441
1Islamism for Dummies [83 words]Funk Soul BruvhaMay 26, 2005 04:4722426
How to use a negative reputation [133 words]WernerMay 26, 2005 00:3422425
1Polio Vaccine: The First 50 Years and Beyond [347 words]Andria SpindelMay 25, 2005 23:4922424
1Polio conspiracy [165 words]lubicz, StephaneMay 25, 2005 19:0522422
1Wake Up [132 words]DeniseMay 25, 2005 15:5922419
Easy to blame Islam [286 words]Bingo MorrisJan 25, 2006 08:2322419
1Polio vaccine delusion [122 words]Elliott VizelMay 25, 2005 14:2322417
1It will hurt us, soon [98 words]PatMay 25, 2005 12:2922413
1Vaccine conspiracy theory [42 words]Robert L. DuecasterMay 25, 2005 11:1622408
Polio Vaccine Hoax [52 words]jorgenMay 25, 2005 10:5122406
1Less Developed Countries [135 words]Octavio JohansonMay 25, 2005 09:2822405
War of the Worlds [38 words]Moose ZibbyMay 25, 2005 02:3822399
1Can We Realistically Hope To Break The Cycle Of Virulence? [142 words]yonasonMay 25, 2005 01:0522398
1Deception is part of Islamic teaching [85 words]Mike RamirezMay 24, 2005 22:2322395
disinformation [276 words]Peter J. HerzMay 24, 2005 19:5922392
1Leave them alone [157 words]Ramsis AlmasryMay 24, 2005 18:5622390
1Polio [45 words]Donald W. Bales, M.D.May 24, 2005 17:2522384
What passes for information or education... [141 words]JohnMay 24, 2005 17:0422382
1Ignorance [129 words]Octavio JohansonMay 24, 2005 17:0422381
1Social Darwinism? [35 words]Charles R.L. PowerMay 24, 2005 16:4522380
1So what? Let them get malaria! [65 words]J SchamrothMay 24, 2005 15:3222378
1reply to J Schamroth [251 words]MarkMar 12, 2006 04:0422378
1Two small points that Mohammed missed [42 words]Darwin BarrettMay 24, 2005 14:5922377

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)