69 million page views

Adolf Eichmann hoped his 'Arab friends' would continue his battle against the Jews (2015 article following Bettina Stangneth' book)

Reader comment on item: Will Americans Learn What Israelis Already Know?

Submitted by Karen (United States), Dec 27, 2022 at 15:34

Douglas Murray

Adolf Eichmann hoped his 'Arab friends' would continue his battle against the Jews

27 January 2015

Over Christmas I finally got around to reading Eichmann Before Jerusalem by Bettina Stangneth. I cannot recommend this book – newly translated from the German – highly enough. It challenges and indeed changes nearly all received wisdom about the leading figure behind the genocide of European Jews during World War II.

The title of course refers to Hannah Arendt's omnipresent and over-praised account of Adolf Eichmann's 1961 trial, Eichmann in Jerusalem: a report on the banality of evil. I would say that Stangneth's book not merely surpasses but actually buries Arendt's account. Not least in showing how Arendt was fooled by Eichmann's role-play in the dock in Jerusalem. For whereas Arendt famously portrayed the man in the glass booth as a type of bureaucrat, Stangneth shows not only that Eichmann was not the man Arendt took him to be, but that she fell for a very carefully curated and prepared performance. Putting together a whole library of scattered documents from Eichmann's exile in Argentina in the 1950s, Stangneth puts the actual, unrepentant Eichmann back centre stage.

There are a number of startling discoveries in the book, not least among them being the extent to which Eichmann had kept up with the books and scholarship on the Holocaust as they came out so that by the time he was awaiting trial in Jerusalem he was fully on top of all primary and secondary material put to him. There is also the extent to which Stangneth is able to show (through accounts from various members of the South America Nazi circles) how well known the true identity of 'Ricardo Klement' actually was within the German expat community in those years.

But Stangneth's principle scholarly triumph has been her ability to piece together and make sense of the extant transcripts and recordings known as the Sassen conversations. Together with Eichmann's contemporary attempts at memoir-writing they bring a wholly new interpretation on his years in Argentina. These conversations – recorded by the journalist and Nazi Willem Sassen in the 1950s – came to light before Eichmann went on trial. But in Jerusalem Eichmann threw doubt on their authenticity and for this reason (as well as the complex dissemination and distribution of the transcripts plus disputes over ownership as well as attempts to disown them) the complete picture of these interviews has taken until now to come to light. Stangneth's work on these materials is extraordinary and the results more than reward her considerable efforts. For instance she shows that those who participated in the conversations (including Sassen himself) tried very hard to cover over exactly what had gone on after Eichmann was abducted by the Mossad. And Stangneth startlingly shows the extent to which these discussions were far from being one-on-one interviews but were in fact semi-public events.

The nature of these events, and their content, is of considerable contemporary as well as historical relevance. For two reasons in particular. The first relates to the ongoing European discussion of free speech and Holocaust denial laws. Because Stangneth shows that as an increasing amount of information on the Holocaust came to light in the 1950s the immediate reaction of the remaining Nazis and neo-Nazis in South America was denial. Some of the Argentina Nazis sincerely believed that the Federal German Republic would not last and that their belief system might yet return to save the German people. But even these remote fantasists realised that the news of the Holocaust presented problems for their rehabilitation. And so they hoped to "expose" the Holocaust. Their first attempts were not only crude but were swiftly overtaken by an unstoppable flood of information and scholarship. By the mid-1950s even the most committed remaining Nazis clearly found ignoring the weight of evidence to be an uphill struggle. And so this group of Nazis in South America, brought together by Sassen, thought that Eichmann might provide the solution to their quandary. They believed that Eichmann would be able to help them not just because he had been the person most closely involved in the Nazi programmes against the Jews, but as the man cited at Nuremberg as having first used the six million figure. The Buenos Aires Nazis assumed that if they got Eichmann on record then they could show the world that the six million figure was a lie, or at least a great exaggeration.

By this point Eichmann was also thinking of breaking his cover in some way. In 1956 he once again attempted to write a book, this time provisionally titled Die anderen sprachen, jetzt will ich sprechen [The Others Spoke, Now I Want to Speak!]. But the conversations with the Sassen circle – which came from the same instinct of his to break his silence – turned out to constitute an attempt to square an impossible circle. For Eichmann saw the Sassen circle's efforts to minimize the Holocaust as something like a spitting on his life's work. Eichmann knew that the six million figure was accurate, and seems to have only gradually realised that his audience were hoping for something quite different from him. The discussions clearly broke down under this unresolvable issue. Among the reasons why I would suggest that this has some contemporary relevance is that it is the clearest possible reminder of how in open discussion even the people most committed to trying to prove the Holocaust did not occur (former leading Nazi officials) ended up being unable to disprove the facts. On that occasion – as so often – they slunk away.

But the second reason why Stangneth's book seems relevant for more than historical reasons is because of what it tells us about a stream of poison which remains very much at the centre of current events.

In The Others Spoke, Now I Want to Speak! (the reference is to his former colleagues who – in another un-square-able moment – Eichmann believed had defamed him at Nuremberg) he had the opportunity to write about the recent Suez Crisis. Here is one passage Stangneth quotes which was new to me at least.

'And while we are considering all this – we, who are still searching for clarity on whether (and if yes, how far) we assisted in what were in fact damnable events during the war – current events knock us down and take our breath away. For Israeli bayonets are now overrunning the Egyptian people, who have been startled from their peaceful sleep. Israeli tanks and armored cars are tearing through Sinai, firing and burning, and Israeli air squadrons are bombing peaceful Egyptian villages and towns. For the second time since 1945, they are invading... Who are the aggressors here? Who are the war criminals? The victims are Egyptians, Arabs, Mohammedans. Amon and Allah, I fear that, following what was exercised on the Germans in 1945, Your Egyptian people will have to do penance, to all the people of Israel, to the main aggressor and perpetrator against humanity in the Middle East, to those responsible for the murdered Muslims, as I said, Your Egyptian people will have to do penance for having the temerity to want to live on their ancestral soil... We all know the reasons why, beginning in the Middle Ages and from then on in an unbroken sequence, a lasting discord arose between the Jews and their host nation, Germany.'

There then follows an extraordinary and important passage. For Eichmann goes on to say that if he himself were ever found guilty of any crime it would only be 'for political reasons'. He tries to argue that a guilty verdict against him would be 'an impossibility in international law' but goes on to say that he could never obtain justice 'in the so-called Western culture.' The reason for this is obvious enough: because in the Christian Bible 'to which a large part of Western thought clings, it is expressly established that everything sacred came from the Jews.' Western culture has, for Eichmann, been irrevocably Judaised. And so Eichmann looks to a different group, to the 'large circle of friends, many millions of people' to whom this manuscript is aimed:

'But you, you 360 million Mohammedans, to whom I have had a strong inner connection since the days of my association with your Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, you, who have a greater truth in the surahs of your Koran, I call upon you to pass judgment on me. You children of Allah have known the Jews longer and better than the West has. Your noble Muftis and scholars of law may sit in judgement upon me and, at least in a symbolic way, give me your verdict.' [pp 227-8]

Elsewhere Stangneth shows how open Eichmann must have been in his admiration for Israel's neighbours. After Eichmann's abduction his family apparently became concerned about his second son. According to a police report, 'As Horst was easily excitable the Eichmann family was afraid that when he heard about his father's fate, he might volunteer to fight for the Arab countries in campaigns against Israel.' As Stangneth adds, 'Eichmann had obviously told his children where his new troops were to be found.' [229]

Of course for years after the war there were rumours that Eichmann had fled to an Arab country. He might have had a better time there. Other Nazis certainly did, including Alois Brunner – Eichmann's 'best man' – who settled in Damascus after the war and who is now believed to have died in Syria as recently as 2010. Eichmann's Argentina years were certainly filled with frustration and rage. What is most interesting is how mentally caught he remained even before he was captured, principally by the impossible conundrum of how to persuade the world to accept what he had done and simultaneously boast about his role in the worst genocide in history.
https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/adolf-eichmann-hoped-his-arab-friends-would-continue-his-battle-against-the-jews/

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

Reader comments (48) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Adolf Eichmann hoped his 'Arab friends' would continue his battle against the Jews (2015 article following Bettina Stangneth' book) [1652 words]KarenDec 27, 2022 15:34290266
It took twice human rights group Honenu's appeal to get the court to Shadi Abdel Hai [شادي عبد الحي], a resident of Tira [الطـّيرة], شادي عبد الحي [410 words]NirDec 13, 2022 16:23289668
What if "the Wave of the Future" hates us? [59 words]KephaSep 12, 2022 21:24286311
Understanding Precursors to the 'Wave of the Future" - Current Hostilties Signal Coming Events If No Pressure for Peace Exerted [185 words]M ToveySep 13, 2022 12:12286311
New Lessons from Tisha B'av Come as Reminders That Old Lessons Still Need to be Observed [231 words]M ToveyAug 8, 2022 10:12284860
Time to Catch a Breath - Future Events Cycling Up to Continue the Breach of Peace the World Cannot Hope to Achieve [217 words]M ToveyAug 16, 2022 10:30284860
1This should give you an indication of what is coming [57 words]SlayhyDec 10, 2022 20:47284860
Our dear Slayhy صلى الله عليه وسلم his prophet is a "genius" امنت بالله [345 words]dhimmi no moreDec 12, 2022 06:39284860
Our dear Slayhy صلى الله عليه وسلم and the BEST NATION? Read and Laugh [428 words]dhimmi no moreDec 12, 2022 11:55284860
Mr. Coptic Egyptian [12 words]slayhyDec 12, 2022 16:06284860
Haven't we been here before? [96 words]JeffDec 12, 2022 22:50284860
1I verified DNM's description of why Muhammad's answer to the question re women's intellect [100 words]PrashantDec 12, 2022 23:39284860
Our dear Slayhy al-Tablighee issued a Fatwa [136 words]dhimmi no moreDec 13, 2022 05:59284860
Our dear Slayhy and Science in the Qur'an! Mashallah! [51 words]dhimmi no moreDec 13, 2022 06:22284860
Our dear Slayhy disagrees with his Prophet who predicted the end of Islam! Astaghfirullah! [246 words]dhimmi no moreDec 13, 2022 07:51284860
Our dear Slayhy: He also said that I'm an Arab that renounced his "origins"! [243 words]dhimmi no moreDec 13, 2022 10:15284860
very good keep it up [25 words]slayhyDec 13, 2022 11:17284860
Armageddon very soon [193 words]SlayhyDec 13, 2022 11:31284860
your disputing argument [13 words]SlayhyDec 13, 2022 11:36284860
Our dear Slayhy: al-Mahdi, Pigs, Chianti wine and More Disasters [309 words]dhimmi no moreDec 13, 2022 17:07284860
Our dear Slayhy and Islamic Embryology! And more disasters [395 words]dhimmi no moreDec 14, 2022 08:37284860
Our dear Slayhy Disagrees with His Prophet! I Smell Riots! [78 words]dhimmi no moreDec 14, 2022 08:44284860
Our dear Slayhy is not aware that his Allah is a Zionist! (GASP!) [101 words]dhimmi no moreDec 14, 2022 08:55284860
Quran, not Arabic, is at fault (message 1 of 3) [422 words]PrashantDec 14, 2022 11:40284860
Our dear Slayhy and more gobbledygook science in the Qur'an [119 words]dhimmi no moreDec 15, 2022 07:02284860
1Our dear Slayhy and Quran 62:2 and Allah sent an illiterate prophet to illiterate people like you. امنت بالله [95 words]dhimmi no moreDec 15, 2022 16:07284860
Our dear Slayhy and رضاعة الكبير or Breast Feeding of the Adult! Yes brother it is Halal [138 words]dhimmi no moreDec 16, 2022 10:20284860
1Quran, not Arabic, is a fault (message 2 of 3) [496 words]PrashantDec 18, 2022 22:26284860
He was not a prophet [40 words]PrashantDec 19, 2022 00:55284860
1Quran, not Arabic, is at fault (message 3 of 3) [645 words]PrashantDec 24, 2022 22:15284860
1The case of adult breastfeeding in Islam gets curiouser and curiouser [179 words]PrashantDec 25, 2022 01:11284860
1Prashant: Breast Feeding of the Adult and the Goat that ate the Quran, and more Disasters [395 words]dhimmi no moreDec 27, 2022 16:38284860
Prashant: Breast Feeding of the Adult and the Goat that ate the Quran, and more Disasters Part Two [324 words]dhimmi no moreDec 28, 2022 08:22284860
Desperate citizens in Iraq turn to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who will take them to Israel for political asylum [68 words]NirJul 28, 2022 22:47284276
2The anti-intellectualism of woke inhibits progress [335 words]
w/response from Daniel Pipes
DaveJul 24, 2022 18:49284121
3promoting mediocre people [117 words]mythJul 25, 2022 19:11284121
1Reader myth produced the all important truth. [190 words]PrashantJul 26, 2022 14:49284121
Ridiculous CNN describes anti-Israel 'J Street' as (supposedly) "pro Israel" [126 words]MiriJul 27, 2022 13:49284121
Collusion of Ideologies Attempting to Change the World Order - Mentality of Mediocrity [281 words]M ToveyJul 28, 2022 17:43284121
Spending Too Much Time in Consideration of Rebellious 'Woke' Rejections of Rational Intellectual Commiserations Injurious to Mental Health [145 words]M ToveyAug 1, 2022 19:42284121
America's Troubles with "Wokism' Symptomatic of Government Excesses Being Manipulated to Spite 'We the People' [158 words]M ToveyAug 16, 2022 19:11284121
From Worse to the Worst - Salvaging Remnants of a Free Society for a Revival to Freedom and Independence Appearing Impractical [280 words]M ToveyAug 29, 2022 14:41284121
Divisiveness Now Seen in American 46th Administration Chief Executive's Demeanor to the Republic Threatens Democracy; Even Israel's [266 words]M ToveySep 2, 2022 11:15284121
Failed Remembrances of the Time America Could be Counted Upon to Protect Freedom - A Cause Now Lost on Current 46th American Administrative Chief Executive [310 words]M ToveySep 13, 2022 17:40284121
Vacillations of the International Kind - Oslo Solved Nothing - Mimicking Its Failures Will Produce No Redeeming Results for Peace [155 words]M ToveySep 21, 2022 18:47284121
Religious Right In America Should Take Notice of Israel's Religious Right in Wresting Control Back From the Brink of Secularistic Apathy [273 words]M ToveyNov 7, 2022 16:07284121
1Lapse of Leadership Creditability - America Cannot Lead Israel to Its Destiny - 46th American Administration Reverts to Lost Cause [149 words]M ToveyJul 22, 2022 20:04284059
Does Israel Really Know What America May or May Not Do When the Next Hand is Dealt? [279 words]M ToveyJul 27, 2022 16:44284059

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)