69 million page views

partition

Reader comment on item: Next Steps in Israeli-Palestinian Peace Process

Submitted by Yuval Brandstetter MD (Israel), Feb 27, 2007 at 11:42

The partition was made in 1922. A Jewish state west of the Jordan, an Arab state Est of the jordan.

If this partition is illegal or unacceptable then all ohter partitions of the ME made at that time are just as illegal and unacceptable. The partition of the Land of Israel from Lebanon, the partition of Jordan from Syria, the partition of syria from Iraq. the partition of Kuwait from Iraq, the partion of Alsace from Germany, the partion of the Sudetten from Germany etc... ad infinitum.

If Palestinian aspiration for a state are legitimate, then Chechen aspiration to part ways from Moscow are legitimate, Quebec from Canada, Basque-land from spain, Catalan from spain, Wales from the UK, and the Indians need to give up on the trinkets they got for Manhattan and get it back, ploughed, with all the trees replantedm and the beavers reinstalled. Did we say all the Europeans should go back to Europe and the Africans to Africa? Oh, I forgot to mention, the Palestinians whose king is unknown, their langiage unheard of, their culture suicide and their history a complete make-up-as-you-go must go back to the Hijjazz.

Alternatively they can be settled in Jordan which is 4 times larger then Israel, and make peace with their Jewish neighbors across the Rift.

That is the only solution to the Jewish Arab conflict. All partitions of the Holy Land have consistently failed for the last 85 years.

Y Brandstetter MD

Submitting....

Note: Opinions expressed in comments are those of the authors alone and not necessarily those of Daniel Pipes. Original writing only, please. Comments are screened and in some cases edited before posting. Reasoned disagreement is welcome but not comments that are scurrilous, off-topic, commercial, disparaging religions, or otherwise inappropriate. For complete regulations, see the "Guidelines for Reader Comments".

Submit a comment on this item

<< Previous Comment      Next Comment >>

Reader comments (39) on this item

Title Commenter Date Thread
Congress--- Lord Help Us [65 words]Vince PApr 15, 2007 22:5489356
encouragement [10 words]Wanetta CombsApr 6, 2007 11:1388719
Dr Pipes Left Out The Victory Method [84 words]F DanteMar 16, 2007 14:0986511
They will, but at what pretext? [57 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDMar 31, 2007 10:3586511
Israeli-Palestinian Peace WILL NOT HAPPEN [196 words]InfidelMar 4, 2007 16:1880122
I AGREE [41 words]OliverApr 11, 2007 01:0380122
1Silesia or Cilicia? [107 words]PeterMar 1, 2007 07:4179501
Letter to Rep Gary L.Ackerman (D-NY) [1748 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDFeb 28, 2007 17:5179403
Right ON [131 words]BlackspeareFeb 28, 2007 20:0179403
partition [243 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDFeb 27, 2007 11:4279249
1Yuval Brandstetter,You Are Absolutely Right! We must all wake up! [190 words]TTSMar 1, 2007 02:3879249
Testimony [14 words]AlanFeb 27, 2007 09:1879227
an aside on minneapolis jihadists [223 words]robert aFeb 27, 2007 02:5779201
next step in the peace process [50 words]jon purizhanskyFeb 26, 2007 19:5379151
gaza is Iraq [158 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDMar 3, 2007 13:1179151
Pipes makes it clear [115 words]Vince DalyFeb 26, 2007 16:5379085
I agree [36 words]DanFeb 28, 2007 11:1879085
What About Iran? [139 words]Roger McKinneyFeb 26, 2007 15:5579072
Not backing their aspirations Roger but designing them [139 words]PeterFeb 28, 2007 10:0379072
Mecca agreement [172 words]Robert SolotFeb 26, 2007 09:1379011
There's the rub [137 words]Howard E. CookFeb 26, 2007 03:5278968
What a waste of time! [104 words]Noah WilkFeb 25, 2007 23:3978930
WOW ! That's what Ackerman said! WOW! [168 words]martin KesslerFeb 25, 2007 18:0778872
So what else is new, and private post script to the Editor. [128 words]Martin KesslerFeb 26, 2007 01:1478872
to martin kessler [27 words]jon purizhanskyFeb 26, 2007 22:5578872
Selected comments from "Samson Blinded" by Obadian Shoher--as must reading [1041 words]martin kesslerApr 4, 2009 23:5178872
Palestinian commitment to two states [201 words]Gerry MandellFeb 25, 2007 13:2778829
Two state solution - the response [235 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDMar 20, 2007 09:3278829
1the "peace process" needs a paradigm shift [3847 words]Ted BelmanMay 28, 2007 15:5878829
quite a comment [159 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDMay 29, 2007 15:3278829
Might Makes Right [122 words]BlackspeareFeb 25, 2007 11:1978808
Blackspeare is Correct - Israelis are not acting like Israelites [277 words]nabil shawarmaMar 4, 2007 11:4278808
its the diaspora [231 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDMar 6, 2007 09:3078808
PHYSICIAN , HEAL THYSELF - I respect your opinions but I disagree on your reason to mock the US [449 words]Nabil ShawarmaMar 19, 2007 08:4178808
we are working on it [326 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDMar 20, 2007 09:1778808
Re: Putting my fate in the hands of strangers - I will take them over Olmert and the Israeli-Left and Ha'aretz [266 words]Nabil ShawarmaMar 24, 2007 03:2778808
Is Bush/Blair/Prodi a better alternative? [133 words]Yuval Brandstetter MDMar 29, 2007 13:5178808
I agree with everything you said [24 words]NabilMar 29, 2007 17:1978808
registration [82 words]Y Brandstetter MDMar 30, 2007 17:1878808

Follow Daniel Pipes

Facebook   Twitter   RSS   Join Mailing List

All materials by Daniel Pipes on this site: © 1968-2024 Daniel Pipes. daniel.pipes@gmail.com and @DanielPipes

Support Daniel Pipes' work with a tax-deductible donation to the Middle East Forum.Daniel J. Pipes

(The MEF is a publicly supported, nonprofit organization under section 501(c)3 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Contributions are tax deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Tax-ID 23-774-9796, approved Apr. 27, 1998.

For more information, view our IRS letter of determination.)